Source: AGRICULTURAL RESEARCH SERVICE submitted to NRP
ABATEMENT OF PHENOLIC AND INDOLIC VOC EMISSIONS FOR ODOR CONTROL AT ANIMAL FEEDING OPERATIONS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0223802
Grant No.
2007-35112-21117
Cumulative Award Amt.
$247,446.69
Proposal No.
2010-04495
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Apr 1, 2010
Project End Date
Dec 31, 2012
Grant Year
2011
Program Code
[28.0]- Air Quality1
Recipient Organization
AGRICULTURAL RESEARCH SERVICE
(N/A)
CLAY CENTER,NE 68933
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Despite years of odor abatement research, odor issues still occur near animal feeding operations (AFOs). Prior research focused on reducing all odorous compounds, a task which has thus far proven unattainable. Based on our recent research, the primary odorants several kilometers downwind of AFOs are phenolic and indolic compounds, primarily p-cresol, phenol, indole, and skatole. We describe a microbiological method we recently developed that uses genetically modified yeast to specifically target and degrade these compounds using the horseradish peroxidase (HRP) enzyme. The objective of this proposed research is to optimize the effectiveness of genetically modified yeast for abatement of odorous compounds, and evaluate a non-GMO based anaerobic bioreactor with complementary attributes, first using VOC mixtures then using actual AFO wastewater. We will conduct further experimentation to refine the methodology and bring it closer to implementation in the real world. As part of the process, we will design, build, and test a continuous-flow bioreactor using the yeast and HRP enzyme as the control mechanism. The long-term goal is to develop mitigation strategies that will increase the adoption of best management practices to reduce agricultural emissions.
Animal Health Component
25%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
25%
Applied
25%
Developmental
50%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1410410100050%
4033310202025%
4033510202025%
Goals / Objectives
The objective of this research is to develop and optimize the effectiveness of bioremediation techniques for the abatement of odorous compounds from animal manure and wastewater treatment systems at animal feeding operations, using both genetically modified organism (GMO) and non-GMO approaches. Expected outputs include data, reports, and manuscripts detailing the effectiveness, limitations, and economics of the treatment options.
Project Methods
The effectiveness of genetically modified (GMO) and non-GMO yeast for abatement of odorous compounds will be evaluated, first using VOC mixtures then using actual AFO wastewater. In step 1, we will implement liquid and gas phase quantification of phenolic and indolic odorants (phenol, p-cresol, 4-ethylphenol, indole, and skatole) for CAFO manure lagoon and bioreactor performance optimization and evaluation. Effectiveness of treatment methods will be evaluated using gas chromatography/mass spectrometry (GC/MS) and high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). In step 2,we will fabricate, optimize, and test a continuous flow bioreactor based upon genetically modified Saccharomyces cerevisiae displaying horseradish peroxidase (HRP). Critical questions to be studied for the GMO approach include bioreactor catalysis rate, yeast encapsulation and viability, hydrogen peroxide concentration and rate of addition, rate of bioreactor performance at low temperature and response to changes in temperature, hydraulic retention time, and resistance to CAFO lagoon water components. Results will be disseminated to the public and animal producers in oral and written form at meetings, conferences, and in manuscripts.

Progress 04/01/10 to 12/31/12

Outputs
Target Audience: The target audience for this grant includes animal/meat producers and nearby residents who might be impacted from odor reduction technologies. Changes/Problems: The initial grant was awarded to Dr. David Parker (PI) and Dr. Mark Olsen of West Texas A&M University. Upon Dr. Olsen’s moving to Midwestern University, and Dr. Parker accepting employment with the USDA-ARS in Clay Center, Nebraska, the grant was transferred to the USDA-ARS in Nebraska. As Dr. Olsen was no longer available to work on the grant following his move to Midwestern, Dr. Parker initiated collaborative efforts with Dr. Audrey Atkin and Dr. Ken Nickerson at the University of Nebraska to work on the genetically-modified part of the grant (Objective 2 above). Collaborative efforts were also initiated with Dr. Lingshuang Cai (post-doc research formerly at Iowa State University) for completion of the project. A similar collaborative project was also conducted with Dr. Jacek Koziel (Iowa State University) to assess the efficacy of soybean peroxidase for treating swine manure on a project funded by the National Pork Board. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? A post-doc researcher received training and professional development on this research project, as did a PhD student from the University of Nebraska. A new gas chromatograph and thermal desorber system was calibrated, and a small wind tunnel system was constructed. Several laboratory experiments were conducted to assess the efficacy of a commercially-available soybean peroxidase enzyme product for reducing odor in standard phenolic solutions and swine manure, and to optimize the amount of hydrogen peroxide addition. The project provided training opportunities for Dr. Lingshuang Cai (post-doc researcher) and for Krista Patefield(PhD student at the University of Nebraska). How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Results have been disseminated to fellow scientists and engineers through peer-reviewed publications and through oral and poster presentations at scientific conferences. Results were disseminated to animal producers at USDA field days, in one-on-one meetings, and with commodity groups. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Accomplishment 1: Odorous VOC emissions were successfully quantified using a wind tunnel system and gas chromatography instrumentation. The primary odorant from swine manure was determined to be 4-methylphenol, which accounted for 68–81% of the odor activity value. Skatole accounted for 11–13% of the odor activity value. Accomplishment 2: Two different batches of Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains were obtained: one in which the yeast display HRP on their cell surface, and one in which the yeast secrete the HRP. An enzyme assay containing a standard HRP substrate (2,2'-azino-bis(3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6-sulphonic acid)—ABTS) was used to test four different variants of the secreted HRP enzyme for optimal growth conditions, enzyme activity, shelf-life, storage conditions, and thermostability. Enzyme activity was confirmed in all four variants of the secreted HRP as determined by the ABTS assay. Early testing of the secreted HRP variants using 4-methylphenol as a substrate showed promise but complete quantifying GC analysis is still pending. Accomplishment 3: The optimum application rate of soybean peroxidase for treating swine manure slurry in a totally mixed system was determined to be 50 grams per liter. At this application rate, 4-methylphenol emissions were reduced by 62 to 98 percent. Of the two peroxides evaluated, calcium peroxide was most effective. When combined with soybean peroxidase, 4-methylphenol emissions were reduced by 62 percent with hydrogen peroxide, and by 98 percent with calcium peroxide. At an estimated treatment cost of $0.33 per liter of manure treated, and more than $100 per pig, the use of soybean peroxidase/calcium peroxide would not be feasible for most commercial swine operations. Accomplishment 4: Topical application of soybean peroxidase was equally effective as the totally mixed treatment in reducing 4-methylphenol emissions for a period of about ten days. There was little difference between the 10, 50, or 100% topical application rates, suggesting that the amount of SBP required for successful treatment could be reduced when applied topically as compared to totally mixed. However, after 14 days the 4-methylphenol emissions actually increased as compared to the control and totally mixed treatments. This suggests that, as compared to the totally mixed treatments, topical treatment may be useful for short periods of time, but could possibly cause elevated odors in the long term.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2012 Citation: Parker, D. B., L. Cai, K-H Kim, K. E. Hales, M. J. Spiehs, B. L. Woodbury, A. L. Atkin, K. W. Nickerson, K. D. Patefield. 2012. Reducing odorous VOC emissions from swine manure using soybean peroxidase and peroxides. Bioresource Technology 124:95-104.


Progress 04/01/10 to 03/31/11

Outputs
OUTPUTS: The PI, Dr. David Parker, accepted a position as Research Leader with the USDA-ARS on March 1, 2010. There has been minor progress during this last annual period, as the grant was being transferred from West Texas A&M University to the USDA-ARS Meat Animal Research Center. The transfer was completed in early 2011. Since then, a post-doc researcher was hired. A new gas chromatograph and thermal desorber system has been calibrated, and a small wind tunnel was constructed. Several laboratory experiments have been conducted to assess the efficacy of a commercially-available soybean peroxidase enzyme product for reducing odor in standard phenolic solutions and swine manure, and to optimize the amount of hydrogen peroxide addition. PARTICIPANTS: The following individuals worked on this project during the reporting period: Dr. David Parker (PI), Dr. Lingshuang Cai (post-doc researcher), Sue Wise (technician), Todd Boman (technician) TARGET AUDIENCES: The target audience for this grant includes animal/meat producers and nearby residents who might be impacted from odor reduction technologies. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
Results of the laboratory experiments conducted in early 2011 give typical p-cresol reductions in headspace of 50-75 percent for swine manure slurry and 65-85 percent for 1 mM p-cresol standard solution. The results appear promising, and further experiments are planned for the upcoming year using the genetically modified yeast.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period