Source: ECOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF AMERICA submitted to NRP
ECOLOGY AND EDUCATION SUMMIT - ENVIRONMENTAL LITERACY FOR A SUSTAINABLE WORLD
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0223285
Grant No.
2010-38832-21846
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2010-03896
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2010
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2012
Grant Year
2010
Program Code
[MG.2]- NRE-Admin. Discretionary & Cong. - Research
Recipient Organization
ECOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF AMERICA
1707 H STREET NW, SUITE 400
WASHINGTON,DC 20006
Performing Department
Education and Diversity Programs
Non Technical Summary
Society's most pressing problems range from securing sufficient food and water, to discovering future supplies of energy, keeping ourselves healthy, and ensuring a habitable climate. All these problems require pooling knowledge and tools from multiple science and mathematics disciplines and all have ecological dimensions. Yet, environmental problems need to be understood in relation to human needs. In the urgent quest for sustainable solutions, it is imperative that a solid and up-to-date understanding of ecosystem functioning and the impacts of human behaviors on multiple scales inform decision-making at various levels. Investing in environmental literacy is critical to developing a workforce and a citizenry that can engage in public discourse, research, and governance for a sustainable world. Environmental literacy can be viewed as the outcome of a process of education about the environment whereby learners are equipped to participate in decisions for the management and solution of complex environmental problems. Ecological literacy - the ability to understand ecological systems and their interface with human systems based on sound ecological concepts and principles - is a foundational part of the desired environmental knowledge and skill set of an environmentally literate person. Environmental literacy embraces both ecological literacy and environmental citizenship. An environmentally literate citizenry and a diverse workforce with the capacity and skills to assess, predict, and manage environmental risk and social resilience is the cornerstone of any successful plan to implement solutions for long-term environmental sustainability. Recent reports such as A New Biology for the 21st Century (2009) and Transitions and Tipping Points in Complex Environmental Systems (NSF Advisory Committee for Environmental Education and Research, 2009) point to the urgency of building that essential capacity, now and in future generations, to rise above our often myopic viewpoints even as our planet undergoes changes that may push us inexorably closer to the "tipping points" threatening the vitality of Earth's living systems. These reports offer new frameworks and opportunities to understand and to teach about the major ecological and environmental issues of our times. Education research has made plain that developmentally appropriate, hands-on, inquiry-based, and active student engagement around real world problems are keys to effective science learning. Additionally, for ecology and environmental education, opportunities for field-based learning and place-based learning are vitally important. The explosion of online and handheld technologies as well as analytical tools such as simulations, GIS, and data visualizations have created enormous possibilities for active learning, as well as for citizen science and multidisciplinary collaborative learning unconfined by space or time. The time has arrived to build a national dialogue towards transforming ecology and environmental education and to design a concerted national strategy for its efficient implementation.
Animal Health Component
50%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
50%
Applied
50%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
7246010302010%
7247410107010%
8036010107010%
8037410107010%
8037410302010%
8066010107010%
8066010302010%
8067410302010%
9036010302010%
9037410302010%
Goals / Objectives
Goals and Objectives The Ecological Society of America (ESA), in partnership with national organizations, propose to organize an Ecology and Education Summit on the theme, Environmental Literacy for a Sustainable World. The Summit aims to create a national dialogue to accelerate the transformation of teaching and learning among K-20+ audiences in both formal and informal settings in response to today's urgent and complex environmental and sustainability challenges. The first half of the summit will be open to participants from national/regional/state organizations. Invited participants will remain for the second half of the summit to draft a Decadal Plan of Action for 2010-2020 based on the discussions. The objectives of the Summit are to: (1) Disseminate best practices that will advance environmental literacy; (2) Reduce duplication of efforts; (3) Coordinate strategies to build capacity and pathways of support for green careers for the next generation; (4) Integrate technology in the study of earth and nature; (5) Develop strategies to increase the participation of underrepresented minorities and women into the environmental agenda, and; (6) Develop public policy and funding opportunities to advance environmental literacy. Outputs The products of the summit will include (1) a report of a pre-Summit survey of national organizations, (2) a directory of national organizations, (3) an online showcase of best practices highlighting the use of technology, multidisciplinary programs and efforts to engage diverse audiences, (4) an interactive networking site, (5) a Decadal Plan of Action and the formation of an Implementation Task Force, and (6) an article in Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, ESA's highly cited multidisciplinary journal, to be submitted as part of an education series. Outcomes The Summit will stimulate an action plan for environmental literacy that will prepare a diverse and increasingly networked citizenry to participate in a green workforce and contribute to sustainable decision-making in the next decade. Within the next three years, national organizations will prioritize the focus of their programs based on identified gaps and needs to achieve environmental literacy among the citizenry. The summit will set in motion a plan for greater integration of programs horizontally (where one cohort experiences multiple and reinforced programs) and vertically (across age groups at developmentally appropriate stages). In the longer term, effective use of new technologies and pedagogies will be incorporated and an increased national capacity will be developed to promote greater and more diverse participation in environmental monitoring, stewardship and careers.
Project Methods
The Summit will bring together leaders of diverse national ecology and environmental education organizations, scientific and social science societies as well as organizations of teachers, faith-based organizations, technology experts, and the business sector that serve the spectrum of K-gray audiences. Organizations will be strongly encouraged to include underrepresented minorities, women and persons with disabilities in their teams. ESA will also make a special effort to invite organizations with strong programs that aim to diversify the participation of people of color in environmental protection and sustainability. The summit is being planned as a combined conference (8:00 am Day 1 through 1:30 pm Day 2) and a Decadal Plan drafting session (2:30 pm Day 2 through 5:30 pm Day 3). Two keynote speakers have confirmed: Will Steger, Arctic Explorer, and Will Allen, Growing Power. Discussion topics will be introduced through panel discussions by key thought leaders, to be confirmed on: 1. Foundations of Ecological and Environmental Literacy 2. A Diverse, Sustainable, and Green Society 3. New Technologies for Environmental Education 4. Best Practices in Effective Teaching and Learning 5. Policy and Strategies for Environmental Literacy On the evening of Day 1, there will be a poster session/exhibit/demonstration kiosks. About 50 participants will be invited to draft the decadal plan based on ideas emerging from the conference. The closed session will be organized around working groups preparing drafts for action. Each group will report back to the larger planning group and discussion will be focused on major lines of strategy for pathways-building between disciplines; across audiences, settings, and among organizations. The session will then organize recommendations according to timelines and identify key decadal milestones to be reached by 2020 for each of the six groups and for the strategic pathways connecting the disciplines, and age groups and organizations. The session will end with the formation of a National Implementation Task Force to monitor progress on the decadal plan. Recognizing that our ambitious program cannot be achieved solely in three days of meeting, partner organizations are invited to participate in a working group and/or lead a forum within their own networks prior to the Summit, to bring to the surface, a vision of a forward-looking ecology education based on the experience and expertise of the networks. These forums may be held in person at partner events or through video or voice conferencing, ranging from 15-100 participants each. Summaries of these forums will inform the final agenda for the Summit. Three months before the summit, a website will be set up to enable all interested to submit ideas and reflections on the issues, allowing those who are not attending in person to also participate. Staff from partner organizations will promote and moderate these discussions and continue to generate interest through regular summaries and pose new questions.

Progress 09/01/10 to 08/31/12

Outputs
OUTPUTS: I) PRE-SUMMIT ACTIVITIES: April 30, 2010 Focus group of K12 Teachers hosted by National Education Association on Barriers and Opportunities to Incorporating Environmental Education in the Nation's Classrooms. June 3, 2010 Meeting of Education and Public Policy professionals of Scientific, Educational and Environmental organizations led by National Wildlife Federation on Public Policy Opportunities and Funding for Environmental Literacy. July 13, 2010 Meeting of Education professionals from Educational organizations led by Earth Day Coalition and National Wildlife Federation on Policy and Funding Briefing. September 8, 2010 Webinar Led by William Godsoe (NIMBioS) and Louis Gross (Univ. of Tennessee/NIMBioS) on Math, Computing, Undergraduate Ecology Education and Large Datasets: An Example from a Citizen Science Program. September 16, 2010 Co-organized by Ecological Society of America and National Education Association, with Campaign for Environmental Literacy, Earth Day Network and National Wildlife Federation on Expanding Funding, Strengthening Public Policy. September 28, 2010 Webinar organized by American Institute of Biological Sciences. Led by Susan Stafford, Alan Kay, John Moore and Meg Lowman on Advancing Environmental Literacy about Transitions and Tipping Points in Complex Environmental Systems. II) PRE-SUMMIT SURVEY: This survey was designed to learn what the current and projected priorities of the environmental education community are related to environmental literacy activities. III) OPEN FORUM OF THE ECOLOGY AND EDUCATION SUMMIT: The Summit attracted 200 participants from across the US. The Summit featured: a) Two keynote speakers: Will Steger, Arctic Explorer and Will Allen, Urban Farmer, Growing Power; b) six panel discussions with 27 panelists and moderators; c) a participant reflection on "What does it mean to be an environmentally literate person"; d) breakout sessions based on the themes of the panels; and e) a debrief of the "Sustainability Education: Citizenship and Pathways for a Green Economy" Summit, organized by the US Department of Education, Greg Henschel, US Department of Education. IV) ACTION PLAN DESIGN WORKSHOP: This is a facilitated workshop with an invited group of 62 participants representing K-16+ and included representatives from informal and formal education, media, health, community planning, scientific sectors as well as agency personnel. The Summit Decadal Action Plan is available at http://www.esa.org/eesummit/content/proceedings. V) POST-SUMMIT ACTIVITIES: a) A workshop was presented at 12th National Conference on Science, Policy, and the Environment hosted by the National Council for Science and the Environment on January 19, 2012 on "Environmental Literacy for a Secure Future"; b)a half-day workshop on October 25, 2011 that brought together organizations interested in pursuing continued coordination; c) a plan for a searchable directory of organizations engaged in environmental literacy and to expand engagement of new audiences. PARTICIPANTS: STAFF PI MOURAD, Teresa, Director, Education and Diversity Programs, Ecological Society of America (ESA). More than 160 hours. ESA Education Interns: BEETLE, Nicole; GUAN, Peggy, DAUGHERTY, Jennifer; MCAVOY, Meghan; TAYLOR, Jason; Volunteer Videographer. ADVISORY TEAM BECK, Chris, Senior Lecturer, Department of Biology, Emory University; BREWER, Carol, Associate Dean and Professor, College of Forestry and Conservation, University of Montana; GRAM, Wendy, Chief of Education and Public Engagement, NEON Inc.; MOORE, John, Director/Research Scientist Natural Resource Ecology Laboratory, Colorado State University; ORTEGA, Sonia, program Director, Division of Graduate Education, National Science Foundation; RANDLE, DC, Science Teacher St. Francis High School, MN; RISSER, Paul, Acting Director of Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History; Chair of University of Oklahoma Research Cabinet. PROGRAM TEAM BERKOWITZ, Alan, Head of Education, Plant Ecologist, Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies; BOWERS, Michael, National Program Leader - Ecology, USDA - National Institute for Food and Agriculture; CATO, Bobby, Senior Education Project Manager, National Environmental Education Foundation; DEMARIA, Rusel, The Art Institute, Seattle; ERWIN, Nathan, Director of O. Orkin Insect Zoo, Smithsonian Institution National Museum of Natural History; GRAHAM, Eric, Associate Development Engineer; Center for Embedded Networked Sensing, University of California-Los Angeles; HASEGAWA, Sheryl, Program Manager, Education Outreach, National Geographic Society; GROSS, Louis,Director, National Institute for Mathematical and Biological Synthesis (NIMBioS.org), University of Tennesse, Knoxville; KLEMOW, Ken, Professor of Biology and GeoEnvironmental Science, Wilkes University; MELENDEZ-ACKERMAN, Elvia, Institute for Tropical Ecosystem Studies University of Puerto Rico - Rio Piedras; POHLAD, Bob, Professor of Biology and Horticulture Ferrum College; SAMMAN, Safiya, Director, Conservation Education, USDA Forest Service; STEVENSON, Rob, Associate Professor, Department of Biology, University of Massachusetts - Boston; TABOLA, Jennifer; Senior Director of Education, National Environmental Education Foundation. SURVEY TEAM Berkowitz, Alan, Head of Education, Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies; Breedlove, Carolyn, Manager, NEA's Green Across America, External Partnerships and Advocacy, National Education Association; Bumpous, Sue, Program & Communications Manager, North American Association for Environmental Education; Coyle, Kevin, Vice President, Education Programs, National Wildlife Federation; Hasegawa, Sheryl, Program Manager, Education Outreach, National Geographic Society; Holifield, Quintaniay, Soil Scientist, US Forest Service Northern Research Station; Li, Helen, Senior Policy Analyst, International Relations, National Education Association; Ortega, Sonia, Program Director, Division of Graduate Education, National Science Foundation. TARGET AUDIENCES: Traget audiences were leaders of national, state, regional and local organizations involved in environmental literacy from a broad range of sectors, disciplines and settings including educators, scientists, technology experts, doctors, media experts, religious organizations, planners, farmers and social service agencies. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
The combination of pre-Summit, Summit and post-Summit events created an awareness of the need for greater coordination of programs and efforts. Given the enormity of the challenges, raising the level of environmental literacy in the nation will require us to 'get the right vocabulary, the right audience, and the right message'. To build the capacity in the citizenry to deal with complexity and change, we need to tie the messages to 'place', which involve people in their own communities, neighborhoods, churches, schools and homes. The focus is on both doing and learning, ensuring that we nurture ownership to "place". In education, it is critical that we engage stakeholders at the state level - which can in turn impact the 15,000 school districts in a non-partisan fashion. This means strong networks at the state level with particular efforts to show how environmental literacy has an existing place in the education content standards. At the local level, we saw the Green School as a hub for sustainability, where the community can live and learn about sustainability to accelerate environmental literacy. We were reminded that in teaching, the medium is sometimes, the message. Green schools and green campuses are in and of themselves, tools for learning. Bringing kids outdoors to learn conveys a different message than learning within a classroom to be successful in tests. Many participants felt ambivalence about using technology for environmental education. At the same time, the power of gaming to reach many millions at once is not trivial and we need to be more creative about developing games that kids want to play while learning about their environment. The themes of the Summit helped participants to rise above their own disciplines and settings. There is a realization that we need to vastly broaden the scope of our understanding of environmental literacy and to come together in new ways. This is guiding a lot of thought currently on an integrated environmental literacy framework that serves to communicate clearly why environmental literacy is important and what it entails especially as relates to engaging diverse audiences.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 09/01/10 to 08/31/11

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Activities associated with the Ecology and Education Summit included: I) A Series of pre-Summit events: 1) April 30, 2010 Focus group of K12 Teachers: Barriers and Opportunities to Incorporating Environmental Education in the Nation's Classrooms 2) June 3, 2010 Led by National Wildlife Federation Meeting of Education and Public Policy professionals of Scientific, Educational and Environmental organizations: Public Policy Opportunities and Funding for Environmental Literacy 3) September 8, 2010 Webinar Led by William Godsoe (NIMBioS) and Louis Gross (Univ. of Tennessee/NIMBioS: Math, Computing, Undergraduate Ecology Education and Large Datasets: An Example from a Citizen Science Program 4) September 16, 2010 Co-organized by Ecological Society of America and National Education Association, with Campaign for Environmental Literacy, Earth Day Network and National Wildlife Federation: Expanding Funding, Strengthening Public Policy 5) September 28, 2010 Webinar organized by American Institute of Biological Sciences Led by Susan Stafford, Alan Kay, John Moore and Meg Lowman: Advancing Environmental Literacy about Transitions and Tipping Points in Complex Environmental Systems II) A pre-Summit survey This survey was designed to learn what the current and projected priorities of the environmental education community are related to environmental literacy activities. The preliminary results were reported at the Summit. The full report of the survey is still in progress. III) Open forum of the Ecology and Education Summit The Summit attracted 200 participants from across the US. The Summit featured: - two keynote speakers: Will Steger, Arctic Explorer and Will Allen, Urban Farmer, Growing Power. - Five panel discussions with 27 panelists and moderators. - A participant reflection on "What does it mean to be an environmentally literate person" - Breakout sessions based on the themes of the panels - A debrief of the "Sustainability Education: Citizenship and Pathways for a Green Economy" Summit, organized by the US Department of Education, Greg Henschel, US Department of Education IV) Action Plan Design Workshop This is a facilitated workshop with an invited group of 65 participants representing K-16+ and included representatives from informal and formal education, media, health, community planning, scientific sectors as well as agency personnel. Products The project has generated the following products: a) Reports of the pre-Summit events b) Two blogs posted by ESA's Public Affairs office: Moving Environmental Literacy Forward (10/18/2010) Injecting science and nature into video games (10/21/2010). c) A Decadal Plan of Action and the formation of an Implementation Steering Committee d) Video proceedings of the Summit e) A Summit Community letter to be disseminated by participants as appropriate PARTICIPANTS: CO-CHAIRS: Margaret Lowman, ESA Vice President of Education and Human Resources,North Carolina Museum of Natural Sciences; Carolyn Breedlove, National Education Association. EVENT STAFF: Teresa Mourad, Ecological Society of America. ESA EDUCATION INTERNS: Meghan McAvoy, Jennifer Daugherty, Nicole Beetle, Peggy Guan. ADVISORS: Chris Beck, Emory University; Alan Berkowitz, Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies; David Blockstein, National Council for Science and the Environment; Michael Bowers, USDA National Institute for Food and Agriculture; Carol Brewer, University of Montana; Sue Bumpous, North American Association for Environmental Education; Bobby Cato, National Environmental Education Foundation; Kevin Coyle, National Wildlife Federation; Daniel Edelson, National Geographic Society; Rusel DeMaria, The Art Institute, Seattle; Nathan Erwin, National Museum of Natural History; Eric Graham, Center for Embedded Networked Sensing, UCLA; Wendy Gram, NEON Inc.; Louis Gross, University of Tennessee Knoxville; Sheryl Hasegawa, National Geographic Society; Quintaniay Holifield, US Forest Service Northern Research Station; Helen Li, National Education Association; Ken Klemow, Wilkes University; Elvia Melendez-Ackerman, University of Puerto Rico Rio Piedras; John Moore, Colorado State University; Sonia Ortega, National Science Foundation; Bob Pohlad, Ferrum College; DC Randle, St. Francis High School MN; Paul Risser, University of Oklahoma; Safiya Samman, USDA Forest Service; Rob Stevenson, University of Massachusetts Boston; Jennifer Tabola, National Environmental Education Foundation; Trish Silber, Aliniad Consulting Partners, Inc. 22 partner organizations including: 1. Ecological Society of America (coordinating partner) 2. National Education Association (host partner) 3. American Association for Advancement of Science 4. American Institute of Biological Sciences 5. American Meteorological Society 6. Center for Embedded Network Sensing 7. Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies 8. Earth Day Network 9. National Council for Science and the Environment 10. National Institute for Mathematical and Biological Synthesis 11. National Ecological Observatory Network 12. National Geographic Society 13. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 14. National Science Foundation 15. National Wildlife Federation 16. North American Association for Environmental Education 17. National Environmental Education Foundation 18. National Education Association Foundation 19. National Science Foundation 20. USDA Forest Service Research and Development 21. USDA Forest Service Conservation Education 22. USDA National Institute for Food and Agriculture TARGET AUDIENCES: The Summit brought together 200 participants from diverse national ecology and environmental education organizations, federal agencies, scientific and social science societies as well as organizations of teachers, faith-based organizations, comunity organizations, and technology, health and media experts that serve the spectrum K-16+ audiences. Organizations with strong programs that aim to diversify the participation of people of color in environmental protection and sustainability were also among the participants. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: The Ecology and Education Summit event as proposed has been completed. A 12-month No-cost extension from 9/1/2011 through 8/31/2012 has been approved to complete the products that were planned: 1) The report of a pre-Summit survey of national organizations; 2) An article in Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, ESA's highly cited multidisciplinary journal, to be submitted as part of an education series; 3) A prioritization of additional articles to be disseminated through other venues or presentations at strategic events; 4) A plan for a searchable directory of organizations engaged in environmental literacy; 5) An engagement plan to disseminate the Summit Action Plan; 6) Publication of the Summit proceedings.

Impacts
The Action Plan developed during the Summit will serve as a guide for coordinating national efforts around environmental literacy and sustainability education for the next decade. Twelve priority high-level action items were identified although they were not intended to be final. It is anticipated that new ones may be added as major gaps are identified. The action items were strategically developed to reduce redundancy, disseminate best practices, advance public policy to advance environmental literacy and build capacity to increase participation of underserved populations. The Decadal Action Plan has already begun to set in motion greater integration and coordination of programs and initiatives. Specific projects include: 1) Support for a Green Ribbon Schools program launched by the US Department of Education and a reinvigorated effort to promote Green Schools and communities 2) An initiative to develop a framework for K-12 that integrates knowledge of natural and human systems in order to educate citizens to make informed decisions about how people adapt to and interact with the environment. A concept paper has been drafted and meetings with several stakeholders. 3) A technology development plan to build a national database of existing environmental literacy programs and services ala Amazon.com to facilitate easier networking and integration of programming. 4) A survey on the extent to which environmental literacy is part of K-12 preservice teacher preparation. 5) A coordinated research effort on best practices in environmental education, Science education and sustainability education.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period