Source: UNIV OF HAWAII submitted to NRP
EVALUATING NON-GMO RESISTANCE TO PAPAYA RINGSPOT VIRUS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0222997
Grant No.
2010-34135-21377
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2010-03384
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2010
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2013
Grant Year
2010
Program Code
[AH]- Tropical & Subtropical Research/T STAR
Recipient Organization
UNIV OF HAWAII
3190 MAILE WAY
HONOLULU,HI 96822
Performing Department
Tropical Plant & Soil Science
Non Technical Summary
Papaya sales in Japan have been critical for profitability of Hawaii's papaya industry, because Japanese buyers have always paid premium prices for high quality products. Papaya production peaked in Hawaii in the decade ending in the early 1990's, partly because of the appearance of Papaya ringspot virus (PRSV) in the most important production area in the State. When conventional breeding methods were found to be inadequate, genetically engineered (GMO) papayas were developed to provide protection from PRSV. The GMO cultivars are horticulturally successful, but ideological, economic, and ethical biases limit their acceptability among organic growers, as well as among consumers in Japan. Organic growers must grow non-GMO cultivars due to National Organic Production (NOP) guidelines prohibiting production and sale of GMOs as organic. Consequently, for the last decade, the Hawaii papaya industry and organic growers have been caught between the horns of a dilemma: 1) needing sales in lucrative Japanese or organic markets and 2) being unable to supply either non-GMO fruit (because of crippling losses due to PRSV) or GMO fruit (because of Japanese import restrictions or NOP Standards). Recent success in transferring resistance from wild relatives into papaya presents an opportunity to develop an alternative to GMO cultivars. Our research cooperators, Drs. Rod Drew of Griffith University in Brisbane, Australia, and Simeona Siar of the University of the Philippines at Los Banos, have introduced virus resistance genes into papaya from a wild relative, Vasconcellea quercifolia. Drew and Siar have selected plants that are fertile and have a useful level of resistance to PRSV strains in Australia and the Philippines. However, the new resistance has not been tested against Hawaii PRSV strains. Now that the sterility barrier has been lowered by the work of Drew and Siar, we are in a position to capitalize on their achievement and test the potential of resistance genes from V. quercifolia in a Hawaii papaya genetic background, using Hawaii PRSV strains as challenge inoculum. In cooperation with Drs. Drew and Siar, we propose to introduce seed from their program into Hawaii, assess resistance characteristics in greenhouse and field tests, identify and select the most resistant individuals, make appropriate self- and sib-pollinations to concentrate the resistance genes, and begin transferring the resistance into commercial Hawaii papaya cultivars. The project will provide a genetic model for PRSV resistance derived from V. quercifolia, as well as breeding materials that will give Hawaii papaya growers an alternative to GMO-based resistance.
Animal Health Component
60%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
20%
Applied
60%
Developmental
20%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2121030108060%
2121030110140%
Knowledge Area
212 - Pathogens and Nematodes Affecting Plants;

Subject Of Investigation
1030 - Papaya;

Field Of Science
1101 - Virology; 1080 - Genetics;
Goals / Objectives
The goal of the project is to evaluate new papaya breeding materials for non-genetically engineered resistance to papaya ringspot virus (PRSV). Our objectives are 1) to determine the level and type of resistance to Hawaii strains of PRSV operating in papaya BC3 and BC4 populations derived by inter-generic hybridization from PRSV-resistant Vasconcellea quercifolia, and 2) to initiate the introduction of the genes conferring resistance into non-transgenic Hawaii cultivars. Outputs include field experiments to determine resistance characteristics, data sets resulting from such experiments, and research collaborations fostered with our international cooperators
Project Methods
Our project will test the new papaya lines derived from inter-generic hybrids for resistance to Hawaii strains of PRSV by 1) direct manual inoculation of seedlings in the greenhouse and by 2) aphid inoculation via natural populations in a field trial. Initial screening will take place in greenhouse trials, utilizing mechanical inoculation. Disease reactions will be assessed for the following parameters: Time to initial symptoms and severity of reactions, assessing both the degree of chlorotic mosaic response, and degree of leaf distortion that occurs. PRSV resistance will also be evaluated by ELISA. Lines from the greenhouse trials will be advanced to field testing in two locations. In order to assure relatively uniform time of challenge, important for making relative comparisons between lines, the field plots will be planted between alternate rows of a mechanically inoculated susceptible line, so that all test plants face a uniform inoculum challenge. In both sets of experiments, we will use appropriate plant controls, including PRSV-susceptible non-GMO solo lines, the recurrent parent used for backcrossing in the Philippines, resistant GMO SunUp and Rainbow cultivars, and the resistant wild Vasconcellea quercifolia parent. Inter-generic derivatives that show either high-level virus resistance to manual inoculation or "field resistance" under natural conditions in the field trial will be crossed with breeding materials from Hawaii to begin the process of transferring the virus resistance gene(s) into commercial non-GMO solo cultivars.

Progress 09/01/10 to 08/31/13

Outputs
Target Audience: Presentations of project objectives and preliminary results were offered to local Hawaii growers at the annual meeting of the Hawaii Tropical Fruit Growers Association in Kona, Hawaii, on September 10, 2011. More complete information was presented to research peers at the 3rd International Symposium on Papaya in Chiang Mai, Thailand, December 19-21, 2011, and at the annual meeting of the Hawaii Tropical Fruit Growers Association at the University of Hawaii Manoa Campus on September 15, 2012. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? In October 2011, our Australian collaborator, Dr. Roderick Drew, visited the experimental field trial at Waimanalo, Oahu, in Hawaii and was given an update on progress in evaluating PRSV resistance in his plant materials. Two days of discussions involving Dr. Drew, the PI, and Co-PIs produced a plan of action for the completion of the project. In November 2011, the experimental field trial was used by the PI to demonstrate papaya breeding techniques to 8 students in TPSS453 Plant Breeding and Genetics. Subjects included pollination techniques, evaluation of virus disease symptomology, ELISA assays for PRSV detection, and fruit quality evaluation. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Field tour and project overview for Society of American Foresters, November 2011. Field tour and project overview for Joint Meeting of the Second International Soil Sensing Technology Conference, the Soil Physics Technical Committee Annual Meeting, and the ASA Sensor-based Water Management Community, January 3-7, 2012. Presentations of project objectives and preliminary results were offered to local Hawaii growers at the annual meeting of the Hawaii Tropical Fruit Growers Association in Kona, Hawaii, on September 10, 2011. More complete information was presented to research peers at the 3rd International Symposium on Papaya in Chiang Mai, Thailand, and at the annual meeting of the Hawaii Tropical Fruit Growers' Association in Honolulu on September 15, 2012. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? The major findings included 1) plants inoculated at 5 mo. develop PRSV symptoms faster than those inoculated at 9 mo., 2) Hawaiian solo genotypes become infected more quickly and more severely than inter-generic BC progenies, and 3) no important differences were noted between mean ratings for inter-generic BCs and papaya recurrent parent line 5648 with regard to days to symptom expression, symptom severity, ELISA Abs. @ 405nm, or percentage of symptomless plants 4 mo. or 1 year after first inoculation.At the end of the project, all test plants had PRSV symptoms. Thus, while the test materials displayed generally good tolerance to PRSV relative to Hawaiian solo papayas, and remained productive throughout the trial, there was no evidence that BC lines that were presumed to have inherited the inter-generic resistance from Vasconcellea quercifolia were any more resistant than the negative control (recurrent parent line 5648) lacking those genes.

Publications


    Progress 09/01/11 to 08/31/12

    Outputs
    OUTPUTS: The field trial established at Waimanalo Experiment Station in May 2011 was manually inoculated with PRSV at monthly intervals in August, September, and October, when seedlings in the two blocks were 5 or 9 months old, respectively. Date of disease symptom onset and rating of symptom severity were recorded for each of the 354 plants, starting in September 2011. Objectives and early progress in the field trial were reported at the annual meeting of the Hawaii Tropical Fruit Growers Association, September 10, 2011, in Kona, Hawaii. Symptom development was documented with canopy photos in October and November 2011. In October, our Australian collaborator, Dr. Roderick Drew, visited the field trial and was given an update on progress in evaluating PRSV resistance in his plant materials. By late October 2011, with about 25 to 50% of the test plants showing PRSV symptoms, we began making crosses between symptomless selections and solo papayas. Crossing with solo varieties and some sibbed crosses continued throughout the reporting period. The 162 test plants in the first block were assayed by ELISA in November and December 2011 to confirm PRSV resistance or susceptibility and in an attempt to use the ELISA value as a quantitative estimate of virus titer and disease resistance. The results of evaluations conducted through 2011 were presented at the 3rd International Symposium on Papaya in Chiang Mai, Thailand, December 19-22, 2011. From March to May 2012, further ELISA were conducted, but results were found to be somewhat unreliable, with both false positives and false negatives appearing. Changing the extraction buffer did not correct these problems, so ELISA was discontinued as either qualitative or quantitative indicator of PRSV infection. By the end of the reporting period in August 2012, all but two test plants had developed at least mild PRSV symptoms. One of the symptomless plants was an individual of the backcross recurrent parent line (5648) used in these experiments as negative control for the Vasconcellea-derived PRSV-resistance. Seeds from a total of 49 fruits of selected symptomless or mildly symptomatic plants crossed with solo parents Sunset, Kapoho, or KpL8 were harvested and cleaned for storage. Three sib-crosses of the dioecious BC lines were also harvested for seed during the reporting period. PARTICIPANTS: Not relevant to this project. TARGET AUDIENCES: Presentations of project objectives and preliminary results were offered to local Hawaii growers at the annual meeting of the Hawaii Tropical Fruit Growers Association in Kona, Hawaii, on September 10, 2011. More complete information was presented to research peers at the 3rd International Symposium on Papaya in Chiang Mai, Thailand, December 19-21, 2011. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

    Impacts
    The major findings included 1) plants inoculated at 5 mo. develop PRSV symptoms faster than those inoculated at 9 mo., 2) solo genotypes become infected more quickly and more severely than inter-generic BC progenies, and 3) no important differences were noted between mean ratings for inter-generic BCs and papaya recurrent parent line 5648 with regard to days to symptom expression, symptom severity, ELISA Abs. @ 405nm, or percentage of symptomless plants 4 mo. after first inoculation. Thus, while the test materials displayed generally good tolerance to PRSV relative to solo papayas and remained productive throughout the trial, there was no evidence that BC lines that were presumed to have inherited the inter-generic resistance from Vasconcellea quercifolia were any more resistant than the negative control (recurrent parent line 5648) lacking those genes.

    Publications

    • No publications reported this period


    Progress 09/01/10 to 08/31/11

    Outputs
    OUTPUTS: During this initial reporting period, we addressed Objective 1: To determine the level and type of resistance to Hawaii strains of papaya ringspot virus (PRSV) operating in papaya plants from four segregating BC3 and BC4 populations derived by inter-generic hybridization with PRSV-resistant Vasconcellea quercifolia. Test seed was germinated in two equal batches temporally offset by four months (Dec 2010 and March 2011), and all potentially resistant materials were placed in tissue culture from shoot-tip explants to ensure protection of the unique germplasm. The seed had excellent germination, but because the first batch of seedlings had poor growth due to a toxic reaction to fungicide treatment (Ridomil Gold), we decided not to inoculate with PRSV in the greenhouse, but instead to move plants to the field before challenging with virus. The first batch of seedlings was planted in the field in a randomized complete block design in May 2010, five months after germination, together with susceptible controls (Kapoho and Davao Solo), a transgenic resistant control, and the backcross recurrent parent (5648). Each genotype was replicated three times with six plants per replication. The second batch followed into the field in July 2010, three months after germination, with a similar experimental design, except that each rep contained eight plants and the transgenic control was replaced with a third susceptible control, Sunset. Border rows included PRSV-susceptible solo cultivars Kapoho, Sunset, and KpL8 for use as crossing parents to achieve Objective 2: To make hybrids between the resistant BC3 and BC4 selections and non-transgenic Hawaii cultivars to begin transferring PRSV resistance to a solo genetic background. The first of three manual inoculations of the test materials with PRSV, made at one-month intervals, was accomplished in mid-August, using inoculum prepared by grinding leaf tissue of papayas infected with a local virus isolate in a mortar and pestle with 20 mM phosphate buffer (~1 : 30, wt./vol.). Two recently expanded leaves on each plant were lightly dusted with Carborundum and carefully rubbed with the pestle dipped in inoculum. PARTICIPANTS: Dr. Richard Manshardt, fruit crops breeder at the University of Hawaii at Manoa, is responsible for overall management of the project. He, Karen Pitz, and Steve Ferreira are executing the papaya ringspot virus resistance screening project at Waimanalo on Oahu. Dr. Steve Ferreira is a plant pathologist in the Plant and Environmental Protection Services Dept. at the University of Hawaii. He is responsible for overseeing the evaluation of the test plants for virus resistance. Karen Pitz, Junior Researcher in the Plant and Environmental Protection Services Dept. at the University of Hawaii, is responsible for assisting the PIs in inoculating and evaluating virus resistance in the test materials. Dr Maureen Fitch, consultant plant physiologist at the Hawaii Agriculture Research Center, is responsible for establishing and maintaining tissue cultures for safekeeping of irreplacable germplasm obtained from Drs. Drew and Siar, our collaborators in Australia and the Philippines, respectively. Dr. Rod Drew is a horticulturist in the School of Biomolecular and Physical Sciences at Griffith University in Brisbane, Australia and is a cooperator in our project as the developer of the intergeneric hybrid papayas. Dr. Simeona Siar is a plant breeder at Institute for Plant Breeding at the University of the Philippines in Los Banos, Philippines, and is a collaborator with Dr. Drew on the development of the PRSV-resistant backcrosses from the intergeneric hybrids. TARGET AUDIENCES: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

    Impacts
    There are no outcomes to report at this point.

    Publications

    • No publications reported this period