Source: MAYATERIALS, INC. submitted to NRP
CONVERSION OF AGRICULTURAL WASTE INTO HIGH QUALITY INSULATION FOR ENERGY CONVERSION
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0222860
Grant No.
2010-33610-21483
Cumulative Award Amt.
$398,972.00
Proposal No.
2010-02172
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2010
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2013
Grant Year
2010
Program Code
[8.8]- Biofuels and Biobased Products
Recipient Organization
MAYATERIALS, INC.
661 AIRPORT BLVD., SUITE1
ANN ARBOR,MI 48108
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
The United States particularly through DOE and USDA has very strong and often integrated programs targeting the development of new energy sources (e.g. biofuels, wind energy, geothermal, etc) and improvements to sustainable energy sources especially solar power. Billions of dollars have been invested in diverse programs. In contrast, similar integrated efforts at similar scales directed towards new approaches to energy conservation (aside from lighting) have not received the same emphasis despite the fact that this should be of equal National importance. The byproducts of biofuels and direct burning processes (of agricultural wastes for example) will always contain a major inorganic fraction likely to be primarily silica because plants selectively extract and concentrate silica from the environment excluding heavy metals. Thus, the resulting silica is relatively pure compared with natural silica sources (e.g. sand), amorphous and high surface area allowing it to be chemically extracted at low temperatures with minimal costs. Mayaterials' researchers have developed a low temperature, green and inexpensive process to extract this silica from agricultural wastes, rice hull ash in particular. Using the various products of this process, Mayaterials is proposing to develop a new type of inexpensive vacuum insulation panels (VIPs). The use of VIPs in refrigeration and housing is currently limited in the USA due to their very high cost. By using agricultural waste as the raw ingredient and getting rid of the complex and expensive processes currently used to make good quality VIPs, Mayaterials plans to decrease the cost of VIPs several fold. This would allow for a more widespread use of VIP insulation which has the potential for tremendous energy savings if widely adopted. Just in the home refrigerator market, use of VIPs has the potential to save up to 76 Twh each year (50% higher than the USA total wind power electricity generated in 2008).
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
51115302000100%
Knowledge Area
511 - New and Improved Non-Food Products and Processes;

Subject Of Investigation
1530 - Rice;

Field Of Science
2000 - Chemistry;
Goals / Objectives
This project address preservation of energy by developing a new type of highly efficient thermal insulation for refrigerator and housing applications from agricultural waste, e.g. rice hull ash. Our target materials are silica based cores for vacuum insulation panels (VIPs), the state of the art in thermal insulation, offering R values of 20-50 where traditional insulation offers R ≈ 3. Adoption of VIPs in housing and refrigeration is currently limited by their very high costs and limited lifetimes. Our objectives are: (1) To increase the thermal resistance of our VIP systems to R >30. (2) Produce 60 cm square by 2.5 cm VIPs at 15/week sufficient for widespread testing by potential partners/customers in refrigerator applications; (3) keep projected costs below $25/m2 and (4) optimize mechanical properties for use as structural elements.
Project Methods
Vacuum insulation panels (VIP) consist of: (1) A core which holds the shape of the panel and limits gas movement; and (2) an envelope that maintains the vacuum while also preventing moisture and air permeation into the VIP. Most high cost of commercially VIPs come from shaping the core under vacuum while hot-pressing the envelope around the core. In contrast we use a uniquely developed castable silica composite to form our core. All composite components are derived from rice hull ash using an inexpensive green processes (also all chemicals used are recycled/regenerated in the process). The cores we produce have the added advantage over conventional cores of having high mechanical properties. Not only does this allow our VIPs to be used as structural elements (impossible with conventional VIPs), it further lower the cost by simplifying the assembly of the VIP from the cores.

Progress 09/01/10 to 08/31/13

Outputs
Target Audience: During this period, Mayaterials has worked with several rubber companies to develop new applications for the silica produced as part of our process. In addition both our vacuum insulation panels(VIP) cores and silica were tested byinsulation for integration in their current VIP production.Refrigeration companies have been contacted and production of prototypes for consumer refrigeration is underway. Finally Mayaterials was approached to develop prototypes and scale production for the insulation of cold boxes for long range transportation oftemperature sensitive pharmaceuticals andbiologics products. Changes/Problems: (1) Mayaterials developed an even less costly method of extracting silica from biogenic silica using only catalitic amount of base. Compared to our initial approach of extracting silica from biogenic silica in the form of octaanions our new method extract silica in the form of glycoxysilane, allowing much higher recycling and overall costs are less than a third of our projected cost for our original process. (2) We investigated spray drying to remove bottlenecks caused by the drying of precipitated silica drying. Once a suitable system was provided by one of our strategic partners it considerably decreased drying time and improved both silica and core batch consistency. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Our processhas been presented at several chemical and materials scientific conferences.This resulted in several contacts with large companies that have now become strategic partners and are investing in the technology to replaceconventional silica used in their applicationsby our biogenic derived silica. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Through this project we have developed the extraction of silica from rice hull ashes and other biogenic silica in the form of glycoxy-silane. We have scaled this reaction several time and currently process 20 kg batches. This scale-up was used to start the design of both a 900 tons/year and a 20k tons/year plant with the help of an engineering firm hired by our partners. We have also developed and scale-up the controlled precipitation of silica from glycoxysilane. We have used this silica to generate further interests and funding as well as for the production of silica/silica gel composite cores for vacuum insulation panels. Mayaterials has developed several techniques for producing a wide range of precipitated silica from glycoxy-silane, with varied specific surface area, total porosity volume and distribution, aggregate size and surface chemistries. Several companies have investigated these silica powders as an additive to rubber, to use as a biogenic stand-in replacement for current source of precipitated silicas or to improve current products. Drying of these silica powders has also been scaled-up with the use of spray drying, with the added benefits of a tighter control of the powders aggregate size. This wide-range of silica powders were used to produce very low density silica/silica gel composite cores. We mixed the precipitated silica powder (with/without the addition of PEG) with glycoxy-silane and started the gelation of the glycoxysilane, casted the resulting slurry and carefully dried the resulting green bodies. By varying the properties of the silica powders, the gelation conditions, the ratio of gel to silica powder and the drying conditions, we have been able to produce silica/silica gel composite cores with densities (0.23 g/cc) close to 10% of the density of bulk silica (in other words our cores are close to 90% pores). This very low density limits the heat transfer by conduction through the core. Surprisingly despite their low densities and in sharp contrast with traditional vacuum insulation cores, the cores we produced show unusual mechanical toughness and can be used as part of the structural component of the structure being insulated. Testing of the thermal conductivity of these cores showed that their thermal insulation (R=40/inch) was equivalent to commercially available silica based vacuum insulation but for a fraction of the costs. Based on our economic model and a third party evaluation of our process, we have been able to precisely determine the various costs of our process. Our project cost for fully assembled vacuum insulation panels (60-90 cm sides) is estimated at $0.66-1.37/ft2 ($495/m3 of insulation depending on thickness). Mayaterials is continuing development of this process with funding from strategic partners whose interest was initially sparked by the use of our biogenic derived precipitated silica as an additive to rubber. Further development of this project involves further scaling of the dissolution and precipitation at several 100s kg scale. In addition the casting of the silica powder /silica gel needs to be automated and scaled-up to deliver the amounts needed for beta-testing of our vacuum insulation panels. Further scale-up is planned to produce enough insulation for both the refrigeration market and the medical temperature-sensitive cold box market. To summarize of our 4 objectives: (1) We have succesfully increased the insolation properties of our VIP to R=40/inch by controlling the core porosity and low density. (2) Scale-up was longer than initially planed and production scale-up has not reached the quantities ( equivalentto 150 kg batches) deemed optimal for widespread testing. Funds from strategic partnerswill be usedto reach and surpass this scale. (3) Projected costs (as evaluated by third party) are $7.1-14.2/m2 well below our initial cost objectives. (4) mechanical properties are unlike any VIP commercially available. Cores are sturdy enough to be used in construction by themselves and have gathered interest for these properties.

Publications


    Progress 09/01/11 to 08/31/12

    Outputs
    OUTPUTS: This project goal is to develop and commercialize vacuum insulation panels (VIP), a form of high quality insulation produced from rice hull ash (RHA) an agricultural waste produced in kilotons quantity for a fraction of the costs of current VIP technologies. RHA is produced in kilotons quantities in the US for various applications (additive in cement, steel manufacturing...) including energy production such as our partner Wadham Energy's power plant (producing 40 kTons/year of RHA). The RHA is more than 90% amorphous silica and much more reactive than crystalline silica. The overall process is to: 1-dissolve the amorphous silica in the RHA, 2-re-precipitate the silica under controlled conditions to obtain a slurry with controlled silica particle size and porosity, 3-cast the slurry into the shape of the VIP core, 4-drie the core while avoiding shrinkage and pore collapse, 5-package the core into a metalized polymer film to form the final VIP products. Mayaterials has developed several paths to extracting the silica in the RHA into a liquid form using low temperature process using non-toxic, easily recycled chemicals. During Phase II of this project Mayaterials has perfected and scaled (20 kg of RHA reacted per batch) an inexpensive route to silica dissolution at low temperature. All chemicals used in this process are recycled above 93%. Scale up of this process has been used to precisely design a commercial plant with the 900-tons/year capacity required to reach 5 % market penetration of the high-end house refrigerator market as well as a larger plant. From these design and the data gathered in the laboratory we have also crafted more precise estimates of the various costs of this project The slurries thus formed have been cast and resulted in very low core densities once dried (as low as 0.2-0.25 g/cc, less than 10% of the density of bulk silica). These cores have much higher mechanical properties than traditional cores used in VIP and have comparable insulation properties (R=27/inch) to commercial VIP, for a small fraction of the costs: total production costs are $0.66/ft for the final VIP products ($495/m3 of insulation). Note that these cost were externally confirmed by an engineering consulting firm. During this period we have sent additional samples of our precipitated silica to several companies for evaluation. PARTICIPANTS: Julien Marchal worked as the PI of this project. He was assisted by Vera Popova (senior chemist) and David Krug (R&D engineer), who helped with improving the process. David Krug also worked on improving and scaling the casting of the VIP cores. He was assisted in this task by Garret Huff(laboratory assistant). Wadham Energy LLC and Empower Corp. provided in-kind and financial support during this project, in particular hiring an engineering consulting firm for evaluating the cost of full commercial plant. This work was done by the Harris Group. TARGET AUDIENCES: In addition to offering better/less expensive insulation to refrigerator manufacturers, this project has the potential to offer a new source of revenue for companies producing RHA. BY increasing the value of RHA, a large adoption of this process should increase the value of rice hulls and thus offer an additional revenue stream to rice producers. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Due to an unforeseen change of location of our company and the rebuilding of our laboratories, the project as been significantly delayed and a request for a one year no-cost expansion was sent to USDA and approved.

    Impacts
    Continuing scale-up of the reactions was a major effort during this period and will continue to be in the foreseeable future: Based on the small pilot scale reactor we designed in the latest period we have doubled our production capacity. Further scale-up will be necessary to supply the demand of early prototypes. Our current scale process was used by an engineering consulting firm to further design a full size commercial plant. External evaluation of the process has allowed for further refinement of our cost models: $0.66/ft for the final VIP products ($495/m3 of insulation) still orders of magnitudes below comparable silica based VIP currently available. Larger samples have been requested by several companies that have positively evaluated our earlier samples and we are currently working to supply these.

    Publications

    • No publications reported this period


    Progress 09/01/10 to 08/31/11

    Outputs
    OUTPUTS: The goal of this project is to develop high quality insulation made by a low temperature/low energy process from agricultural byproducts. Mayaterials currently uses rice hulls ashes (RHA) that are the byproduct of burning rice hulls to produce electricity by our partner (using 200,000 tons of rice hulls to power a 30 MW generator). Using a proprietary low temperature process, Mayaterials produces all components to form vacuum insulation panel (VIP) cores. Of these components precipitated silica is the most important as a) it represent most of the weight of the final silica core, and b) can be sold as-is offering potential for financing faster scale-up of the project. To accomplish these goals we have produced several prototype panels and sent samples of the insulation materials to two multi-billion dollars companies for evaluation. VIPs made with our process are also under evaluation by a building company, with discussions underway for testing in prototype housing. In addition to presenting our new project on our website, we have issued a press release to over a thousand contacts. Mayaterials also presented this project to the Accelerate Michigan Innovation Competition. PARTICIPANTS: During this period Mayaterials has finalized an agreement with Wadham Energy, LP for further scale-up of this project and the development of a full-scale production plant. TARGET AUDIENCES: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Mayaterials had to relocate to a new location, after our old location was scheduled for demolition by our landlord. Our new location needed considerable upgrading, which took much more time than we had anticipated. As such works and expenditure was considerably slowed for several months.

    Impacts
    Scale-up of the synthesis reactions was the major effort during this period, which has allowed us to produce large quantities of core materials needed for outside evaluation. We were able to successfully scale up the reactions to 10 kg batches after designing a small pilot scale reactor. The increased availability of materials has also allowed Mayaterials to lower the core density (lowering weight and increasing thermal insulation) while keeping high mechanical strength. In addition to supplying the materials for outside evaluation, this scale up has allowed us to refine our cost analysis and develop the needed energy/time data and detailed process diagrams for planning the construction of a full-scale plant for this process. This confirms our earlier cost estimate for the final VIP cores at $0.40/kg, which is orders of magnitudes below comparable silica based VIP currently available.

    Publications

    • No publications reported this period