Source: UNIV OF WISCONSIN submitted to NRP
BIOMASS DENSIFICATION FOR COMBUSTION
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0222159
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jun 1, 2010
Project End Date
May 31, 2012
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
UNIV OF WISCONSIN
21 N PARK ST STE 6401
MADISON,WI 53715-1218
Performing Department
Biological Systems Engineering
Non Technical Summary
Concerns of green house gas and air emissions from coal burning power plants have led many plants to retrofit their boilers to allow biomass to be a portion of the fuel. Whereas combusting biomass has many benefits over coal it also has many process drawbacks. Many types of biomass are difficult to process and handle, where coal can pulverized and easily conveyed. Coal does not deteriorate nor does it absorb appreciable amounts of water. Additionally transportation costs are minimized with the higher density of coal. To utilize biomass effectively in combustion processes developments are needed to allow biomass to be processed and handled more similarly to coal. Densification of biomass into small pellets or briquettes is believed to be a good first step. However, biomass does not easily deform and requires high binder amounts, high temperature, and high pressure to be densified. This research project seeks to improve the economics and environmental performance of biomass combustion by understanding biomass deformation fundamentals and leveraging the understanding to develop an improved process to densify biomass. Mechanic fundamentals will be combined along with material properties measurements to provide a fundamental understanding of modes of biomass densification and bonding. The deliverables of this research will be to: 1) Characterize a variety of biomass feedstocks for their chemical composition and fuel qualities. 2) Determine suitable binder materials and process conditions to create high-density biofuel materials for combustion. 3) Determine the potential energy and material yields of this process through energy calculations and modeling. 4) Determine the viability of this process for a wide variety of lignocellulose feedstocks including woody, non-woody, and residue biomass. The research results will be passed to the audience of peer researchers, farmers, extension agents and government agents in the forms of reports, presentations and publications.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
4020699200025%
4020699202025%
4021699200025%
4021699202025%
Goals / Objectives
The acceleration of bioenergy as a national imperative has created numerous processing options to create biopower, biofuels, and biomaterials from biomass feedstocks. Although many of the options are still in the research phase, there have been significant commercialization activities in biomass combustion projects in the US. These projects look to convert coal-fired heating and power plants to biomass only, or a combination of coal and biomass fuel. These early bioenergy projects represent quick wins for energy industries on three fronts. First, they increase the use of renewable energy resources by utilizing biomass instead of primarily coal. Second, they have a positive impact through decreased greenhouse gas, Hg, SO2, and NOx emissions. Finally, beyond the environmental impact it is also expected they will create a biomass supply for the energy market, which will provide economic benefits for landowners, farmers, and processors. However, creating this market quickly has the downfall that little technical development has occurred on harvesting and processing options to maximize economic and environmental utilization. Examples of the technical challenges associated with biomass combustion can include, among others, air emissions, deposit and corrosion problems, agglomeration, and ash-related issues. Fuels that provide the most assistance with regulatory compliance such as CO2 reduction, renewable portfolio standards, and other regulatory requirements will be the most valued by the consuming companies. Not all biomass will be ideal for specific combustion options, and some feedstocks will be better suited for other uses. Controlling these characteristics will enable producers and aggregators to make wise investment decisions as this industry evolves. Along with the potential technical challenges in boiler operations of biomass-to-energy combustion projects, there are additional drawbacks of the large capital expenditures required to retrofit boilers to handle high levels of biomass fuel. Therefore, identifying processing approaches that provide biomass fuels options that can be easily handled and co-fired with coal in existing boilers without heat loss would be beneficial. Densification of biomass is a means to improve the storage and handling characteristics of low bulk density biomass materials. Additionally, this processing step can provide additional consistency and increase biofuel quality for combustion. This research project seeks to improve the economics and environmental performance of biomass combustion by developing a process to densify biomass. Specific objectives include: 1) Identify the chemical and physical characteristics that allow biomass to be more easily densified as measured by fundamental mechanical properties. 2)Identify processing conditions utilizing novel binders that enable biomass fuels to be densified with minimal cost and energy. 3)Characterize the resulting densified biomass for suitability to heat and power generation, boiler operations, and air emissions. 4) Assess environmental, agricultural, and economic impact of utilizing recommended biomass fuel options for combustion technologies.
Project Methods
Biomass feedstocks for the project will include Hybrid Poplar representing a woody biomass bioenergy crop, Switchgrass representing a non-woody biomass bioenergy crop, and corn stover representing an agricultural residue biomass. Chemical characterization will be performed to insure the samples are well understood and represent typical samples. Several binder agents will be employed to represent both natural and synthetic systems. Biomass and binder mixes will be transformed into densified biomass utilizing uni-axial compression via a plunger in a cylindrical die. This method will be followed to allow a detailed analysis of the compression/relaxation behavior of the feedstock/binder composites at the laboratory scale. A steel apparatus will be constructed to fit onto a tensile/compression testing machine. The apparatus will have internal chamber to mold the biomass and be outfitted with a plunger that the compression tester will attach to. Heat tape will be utilized to provide the necessary heat and a thermocouple, connected to the outer surface of the cylinder will be used to regulate power to the tape. The compression testing equipment will be equipped with a suitably sized load cell and computer controlled to record the force-displacement data. Milled feedstock will be mixed with water and binder following an experimental design and placed into the heated die cylinder. The biomass will be compressed with preset loads by compression test at a constant rate to create the densified biomass samples. Lab testing will be performed to provide a characterization of the biomass relevant to fuel performance, and will include both proximate and elemental analysis. Proximate analysis provides fixed carbon (char), volatile, moisture and ash content in the fuel and the heating values, while elemental analysis gives elemental percentages of C, S, H, N, Cl, and O of the fuel and ash. Additionally, properties of size, density, and flow characteristics will also be performed to aid in the understanding of storage requirements, material handling, and transportation impacts. An additional discussion of these tests is provided to explain how they will be used to assess biomass fuels for combustion. The heating value of the biomass will be determined by both the higher heating value (HHV) which both measure the energy content measured on samples using a calorimeter. The moisture content of biomass fuels will be determined gravimetrically and a drying oven. Volatile and char will be measured to indicate biofuels that ignite easily, even at low temperatures. The quick release of a large fraction of biofuels as volatiles makes it necessary to have longer high temperature zones in order to achieve complete combustion at high efficiency and ensure low pollutant emissions. Ash, the inorganic incombustible part of fuel left after combustion, will be measured utilizing a muffle furnace. Elemental analysis on the ash will also be performed to provide insight into biomass and ash characteristics.

Progress 06/01/10 to 05/31/12

Outputs
OUTPUTS: As continued increases from greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuels negatively impact our environment, finding renewable forms of energy that can reduce those emissions are becoming increasingly important. Biomass is an abundant renewable resource and Wisconsin is fortunate to have a wide variety of biomass materials with land and water resources to grow more. To utilize biomass effectively in combustion processes, developments are needed to allow biomass to be processed and handled more similarly to coal. Densification of biomass into small pellets or briquettes is believed to be a good first step. However, biomass does not easily deform and requires high binder amounts, high temperature, and high pressure to be densified. This research project seeks to improve the economics and environmental performance of biomass combustion by understanding biomass deformation fundamentals and leveraging the understanding to develop an improved process to densify biomass. The first task was to characterize biomass and identify chemical and physical characteristics that allow biomass to be more easily densified. Moisture had the greatest impact with significant energy savings from proper control of this variable. A novel method of treating biomass with a mild acid treatment was found to significantly reduce size reduction energy and create improved pellets. The second task measured the deformable media mechanical properties of the biomass under densification conditions. A compression electromechanical system was created that allowed measurement of stress and strain during pellet production. This test was used to simultaneously measure the biomass mechanical properties and make pellets that could be measured for durability. As the pellets produced were small in number, new test methods were developed to measure the pellet durability. The third task identified processing conditions and binder systems to create densified biomass fuels with minimal cost and energy. Thermoplastic binders were shown to require less energy and the ability to create high quality pellets. If low cost waste plastic, such as ag bags can be sourced, the research indicated they made excellent binders. Additionally, it was found if a portion of the hemicellulose was extracted using either hot water or dilute acid solutions, the biomass was easier to size reduce and made higher density pellets. The fourth task was to characterize the resulting densified biomass for suitability to heat and power generation, boiler operations, and air emissions. Thirty solid fuels from various biomass collected from the state were tested for ultimate (C, H, N, O, S), proximate (moisture, ash, volatiles, fixed carbon), Cl, and Hg and mineral ash analysis. Woody fuels were found in general to be the best fuel for combustion, benefiting from low values in problematic elements, and herbaceous fuels were the next most desirable fuels, presenting emissions and corrosion issues related to sulfur and chlorine. Residual fuel compositions varied greatly with some indicating significant emissions or operational issues. They therefore require review on a case by case basis. PARTICIPANTS: Pamella Wipperfurth, MS Student; Jeffrey Mueller, MS Student. TARGET AUDIENCES: Our findings were presented at several conferences that included professionals doing biomass to power projects. Based on the positive feedback from the audience, it was evident that this knowledge was useful for both biomass pellet producers as well as utilities trying to utilize this solid fuel. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
The biomass characterization information was used to help guide the biomass supply chain development for bio-power installations. Information was provided during several conferences, which led to several additional invitations based on audience interest. The conferences included the following: 1. Runge, Troy, Du, Sheldon, Porter, Pam, Radloff, Gary Biomass Quality for Combustion: Not all Biomass is Equal, Heating the Midwest Conference, Eau Claire, WI (April 26, 2012). 2. Radloff, Gary, Runge, Troy, Du, Sheldon, Runge, Troy, Du, Sheldon Coupling Biomass Quality and Quantity to Create a Statewide Energy Plan International Biomass Conference, Denver, CO (April 17, 2012). 3. Runge, Troy; Value Prior to Pelletization, Transforming Biomass into High-Quality On-Spec, High-Density Feedstocks Workshop, in Idaho Falls, ID (August 23, 2011). 4. Mueller, Jeff, Runge, Troy; Fuel Survey for Solid Fuel Combustion, International Biomass Conference, in St. Louis, MO (May 3, 2011). 5. Wipperfurth, Pam, Runge, Troy, Chunhui Zhang; Simple Biorefinery: Creating an Improved Solid Fuel and Soluble Sugar Stream, TAPPI International Bioenergy & Bioproducts Conference, in Atlanta, GA (March 16, 2011). 6. Runge, Troy; Biomass for Heat and Power Midwest Renewable Energy Conference, in St. Paul, MN (March 4, 2011). 7. Runge, Troy; "Developing a Biomass Supply Chain," Midwest Biomass Conference, Dubuque, IA , November 17, 2010. 8. Runge, Troy; "Biomass Supply Development," TAPPI Management Meeting at Madison, WI on November 4, 2010. 9. Runge, Troy; "Biomass Feedstock Development for your Energy Project," International Bioenergy Days, Rockford, IL, September 28, 2010.

Publications

  • Runge, Troy; Wipperfurth, Pamella; Zhang, Chunhui; Improving biomass combustion quality using a liquid hot water treatment, Biofuels, Vol. 4, No. 1, Pages 73-83 (2013).


Progress 01/01/11 to 12/31/11

Outputs
OUTPUTS: As greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuels negatively impact our environment, renewable energy is becoming increasingly important. Biomass is a renewable resource that Wisconsin is fortunate to have an abundance of, with land and water resources to grow more. Solid fuel combustion represents a cost effective renewable resource that utilizes well developed combustion technologies, but requires further research to improve the quality of the biomass supply. To utilize biomass effectively in combustion processes, developments are needed to allow biomass to be processed and handled more similarly to coal. Densification of biomass into small pellets or briquettes is believed to be a good first step. However, biomass does not easily deform and requires high binder amounts, high temperature, and high pressure to be densified. This research project seeks to improve the economics and environmental performance of biomass combustion by understanding biomass deformation fundamentals and leveraging the understanding to develop an improved process to densify biomass. The first task was to characterize biomass and identify chemical and physical characteristics that allow biomass to be more easily densified. Several biomasses at sizes and moistures were utilized to explore densification. Moisture had the greatest impact with significant energy savings from proper control of this variable. A novel method of treating biomass with a mild acid treatment was found to significantly reduce size reduction energy and create improved pellets. The second task measured the deformable media mechanical properties of the biomass under densification conditions. A compression electromechanical system was created that allowed measurement of stress and strain during pellet production. This test was used to simultaneously measure the biomass mechanical properties and make pellets that could be measured for durability. As the pellets produced were small in number, new test methods were developed to measure the pellet durability. The third task identified processing conditions and binder systems to create densified biomass fuels with minimal cost and energy. Thermoplastic binders were shown to require less energy and the ability to create high quality pellets. If low cost waste plastic, such as ag bags can be sourced, they make excellent binders. The fourth task was to characterize the resulting densified biomass for suitability to heat and power generation, boiler operations, and air emissions. Thirty solid fuels from various biomass were collected from the state were tested for ultimate (C, H, N, O, S), proximate (moisture, ash, volatiles, fixed carbon), Cl, and Hg and mineral ash analysis. Woody fuels were found in general to be the best fuel for combustion benefiting from low values in problematic elements and herbaceous fuels were the next most desirable fuels presenting emissions and corrosion issues related to sulfur and chlorine. Residuals fuels compositions varied greatly with some indicating the ability in significant emissions or operational issues and require review on a case by case basis. PARTICIPANTS: Two graduate students were involved with this project including:Pamella Wipperfurth, Master Student; January 1, 2011 through July 31, 2011.Jeff Mueller, Master Student; January 1, 2011 through December 31, 2011. TARGET AUDIENCES: Outreach presentations were provided to reach companies interested in biomass for heat and power. Information was provided during several conferences including: Runge, Troy, "Biomass for Heat and Power,"Midwest Renewable Energy Conference, Minneapolis, MD, March 4, 2011 Runge, Troy; "Bioenergy Project Development, The Wisconsin Experience," US Department of Energy, Biomass 2011: Replace the Whole Barrel, Supply the Whole Market, National Harbor, MD , July 27, 2011. Runge, Troy; "Value Prior to Pelletization," Biomass Preconversion, Formulation, and Densification Workshop, INL, Idaho Falls, ID , August 23, 2011. Runge, Troy; "Value Prior to Pelletization," DOE sponsored webinar, August 30, 2011. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
The biomass characterization information was used to help guide the biomass supply chain development for bio-power installations.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 01/01/10 to 12/31/10

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Lab tests to be able accurately quantify biomass as solid fuels were developed to be able to quantify the solid fuel properties of various biomasses accurately. Approximately 30 different biomass samples were collected from around Wisconsin and analyzed for solid fuel properties including proximate analysis, ultimate analysis, and potential air pollution precursors of mercury and chloride. The samples represented a wide variety of woody materials, bioenergy crops, agriculture residuals, and waste products. The data is currently being analyzed and submitted for publication to provide publically available information for bioenergy projects. Additionally, this data was used along with information on biomass availability to create several presentations at bioenergy conferences including: + IBED Rockford IL (September 28, 2010) + Platts Biofuel Conference at Chicago, IL on October 5, 2010. + Midwest Biomass Conference at Dubuque, IA on November 17, 2010 PARTICIPANTS: Troy Runge, Principle Investigator; Jeff Mueller, Master Student; TARGET AUDIENCES: Companies, communities, and regions trying to commercialized biomass to energy projects. Biomass to energy projects that outreach information stemming from this project have so far included: Charter Street Heating Plant, UW Madison in Madison, WI; Efrim Energy in Sturgeon Bay, WI PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
The biomass characterization information was used to help guide the biomass supply chain development for the UW Madison Charter Street Heating Plant upgrade project. The project is currently planned to convert a coal fired boiler to a new biomass boiler. The biomass data was supplied to the project to enable planning for air emission control equipment as well as inform potential suppliers as to the suitability of their material to meet the State's desired specification. Information was shared through several public hearings to insure that both the project staff and potential future suppliers were informed.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period