Source: UNIVERSITY OF WYOMING submitted to NRP
CONTINUING STUDIES ON BIOMEDICAL COUNTERMEASURES AGAINST BRUCELLOSIS IN DOMESTIC AND WILD HOSTS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0221622
Grant No.
2010-38510-20778
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2010-01876
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jun 1, 2010
Project End Date
May 31, 2013
Grant Year
2010
Program Code
[EE-T]- Wildlife/Livestock Disease Research Partnership, WY
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF WYOMING
1000 E UNIVERSITY AVE DEPARTMENT 3434
LARAMIE,WY 82071-2000
Performing Department
Veterinary Sciences
Non Technical Summary
The disease produced by B. abortus in domestic livestock can be potentially devastating, thus substantiating the need for a continuing effort to development more effective vaccines. We have identified three potential new vaccine candidates, which unlike the current brucellosis vaccines on the market, are non-living. Despite demonstrating some success our candidates in a mouse model, adequate large animal models must be established to effectively test candidates against the disease in ruminants. The goat has been well characterized over 20 years ago by experimental Brucella infection, producing the same disease processes as in cattle. Thus, the goat has been proposed as a suitable model for the study of brucellosis in cattle, and is well-suited for vaccine studies. The first part of our project thus represents the evaluation of a three vaccine candidates for their ability to protect against brucellosis using the goat model. The utility of goats as a ruminant model for brucellosis includes lower cost, more manageable logistics, and a gestation period of just 150 days. If we are successful, our study in the goat may yield an effective and safe new vaccine against brucellosis. Despite a long history of infection of humans and livestock by Brucella, relatively little is known of the specific bacterial disease factors that contribute to interactions with susceptible animals. Analysis of Brucella genes have revealed only about a dozen relevant factors suggesting that many more factors remain to be discovered. Therefore, a functional screen of Brucella genes also will be conducted in parallel with the evaluation of already identified gene products in the goat. The outcome of this study may result in new vaccine candidates. Finally, although the efficacy of existing brucellosis vaccines has been well documented , little effort has been made to estimate the economic benefit of a more effective brucellosis vaccine. We will therefore calculate the benefit of how an improved vaccine would affect cattle producers' willingness to practice adult animal booster vaccination. As an outcome, we propose that an increase in the vaccine's effectiveness would induce more producers to practice such vaccination.
Animal Health Component
70%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
30%
Applied
70%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
3110830109010%
3110830110010%
3110830301010%
3113310109010%
3113310110040%
3113310301020%
Goals / Objectives
Previous studies in our laboratory have demonstrated the utility of a gene discovery methodology, known as IVIAT (In vivo-Induced Antigen Technology) for the identification of antigens of Gram negative pathogens relevant to infection, including ten virulence factors of Brucella abortus. We have further characterized several of these antigenic proteins for their ability to induce protective immunity in a murine model, and have identified three as promising vaccine candidates. Goal 1: As an extension of this preliminary work, we intend to assess the three proteins in the caprine model for their ability to protect against abortion, placentitis, and other pathologies associated with B. abortus infection in ruminants. Goal 2: In a parallel effort, a search for additional novel B. abortus virulence factors will be conducted by screening large sequence cosmid libraries of strains 2308 and S19, using a variety of in vitro assays. Transposon mutagenesis will be applied to selected clones to specifically identify virulence genes of interest. This approach complements our earlier application of IVIAT on B. abortus, and will likely yield additional vaccine candidates for testing in both our small and large animal vaccine efficacy models. Goal 3: an economic analysis will be conducted to explore the effects of an improved brucellosis vaccine on the willingness of cattle producers in the Greater Yellowstone Area to use adult-booster vaccination. If successful, these studies should advance eradication of brucellosis, not only in domestic livestock, but in wild animal hosts.
Project Methods
Project 1: Four groups of ten goats each will be vaccinated with one of 4 antigen formulations, and receive a boost on day 30 post-primary immunization. A fifth group of 10 animals will receive adjuvant alone. Thirty days after the last vaccine boost, the immunized dams will be housed with fertile billies and monitored for impregnation by ultrasound. Between 100 and 110 days gestation, the gravid, vaccinated animals will be challenged with wild-type B. abortus. All infected animals will be monitored daily for delivery. Fetuses will be collected and live kids euthanized for necropsy. Tissues will be obtained for bacteriologic and pathologic analyses. Dams will be similarly euthanized, and necropsy samples taken. The pathogen's in vivo response in the immunized and challenged animal groups will be assessed serologically using our panel of 10 IVI antigens, and comparisons made with those immune signatures in other hosts. Cytokine levels in all serum samples will also be assessed. We predict that immunization with a cocktail of IVI antigens will produce synergistic effects, and anticipate that one or a number of the formulations tested will yield a positive outcome and streamline efficiency of livestock production and management of large animal wildlife. Project 2: Rapid Virulence Annotation (RVA)is an assumption-free approach to identify virulence determinants by high-throughput genome expression screening for gain of toxicity in various hosts. After B. abortus genomic library construction, toxicity assays will employed to screen for virulence regions. These assays include a unicellular non-mammalian organism: the amoeba Acanthamoeba castellani, used successfully in the Ward lab for RVA screening. We will also employ a multicellular non-mammalian organism: the nematode C. elegans, an effective model organism for study of mammalian pathogens. To provide mammalian host backgrounds, we will use trophoblast-derived continuous cell lines and a placental fibroblast line. A future long-term goal of our work is to ultimately test candidates identified in screens of these mammalian cell lines in vivo. Project #3: Economic theory on decision-making under uncertainty will be combined with quantitative risk analysis techniques to determine the effect of an improved brucellosis vaccine on producer adoption of adult-booster vaccination. Monte Carlo simulation will be used to calculate expected profit over distributions of epidemiologic and economic parameters that represent four scenarios: 1) calfhood but not adult-booster vaccination under current vaccine efficacy, 2) calfhood and adult-booster vaccination under current vaccine efficacy, 3) calfhood but not adult-booster vaccination under improved vaccine efficacy, and 4) calfhood and adult-booster vaccination under improved vaccine efficacy. Comparison of expected profit in scenarios 1) and 2) will define a baseline of producer willingness to adopt adult-booster vaccination given current vaccine efficacy. Comparison of expected profit in scenarios 3) and 4) will indicate how producer willingness to adopt adult-booster vaccination responds to improved (but still imperfect) vaccine efficacy.

Progress 06/01/10 to 05/31/13

Outputs
Target Audience: Livestockproducers; State Department of Agriculture; State Game and Fish; wildlife managers. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Results of the goat study will be presented at the December 2013, Conference of Research Workers on Animal Diseases (CRWAD) annual meeting. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Goal 1: A pilot immunization/challenge study in the gravid caprine model for brucellosis was completed. Three sub-unit vaccine formulations adjuvanted with aluminum hydroxide (Alhydrogel were used to vaccinate 50 female mixed-breed goats in a two-dose immunization regimen. Immune take was assessedserologically by Western blot. Animals were subsequently impregnated, challenged in the third trimester with Brucella abortus 2308, and and allowed to come to full gestational term. Control groups consisted of adjuvant-only immunized animals and a group that received the RB51 vaccine. Abortion rates in the sub-unit vaccine groups were no different than the adjuvant-only negative control groups (best case, p = .084, Fisher's Extact). More remarkably, RB51 failed to protect animals, suggesting that the established live attentuated vaccine is effective at abrogating brucellosis in this host species. Bacterial loads in milk and tissues of the dams and kids were also assessed. Again, no differences were noted either in the distribution of the pathogen in different tissues (uterus, lymph nodes, lung, abomason), nor in bacterial numbers. Goal 2: Weobserved the ability of Brucella abortus to avoid amoebal predation, and consequently exploited this phenomenon as a simple, high-throughput screen of amoebal consumption preference to mine for virulence determinants based on gain-of-toxicity phenotypes in a B. abortus cosmid library. Our results show that when B. abortus RB51 is challenged with predatory Acanthamoeba castellanii, the bacteria avoid consumption and display an unusual escape phenotype. Using a previously described method, we screened a library of over 400 RB51 cosmid clones and found that none conferred the ability to avoid amoebal consumption to the E. coli host. In addition, none of the fosmids granted E. coli the ability of B. abortus to become internalized by amoebae and to survive for up to 45 minutes in a gentamicin protection assay. Our results provide evidence for a relevant interaction between Brucella spp. and free-living amoebae, and show promise for the use of A. castellanii as a model host for virulence gene discovery in Brucella.

Publications


    Progress 06/01/11 to 05/31/12

    Outputs
    OUTPUTS: Project 1: Evaluation of protective efficacy of selected B. abortus recombinant protein formulations in a caprine challenge model for brucellosis. Purified large quantities of two key brucella virulence proteins, Hia and D15, for use in the goat immunization/challenge study. Immunized 50 mixed-bred female goats with three different vaccine formulations. Immunized two control groups with RB51 live vaccine strain and adjuvant (aluminum hydroxide) respectively, in a two-dose regimen. Bred all immune animals. PARTICIPANTS: Gerard P. Andrews, PI/Project Director, University of Wyoming; Richard Bowen, co-PI, Colorado State University; Jack Leonhardt, graduate student, University of Wyoming TARGET AUDIENCES: State and regional veterinarians, epidemiologists, WY Game and Fish Department, Wyoming Department of Public Health, cattle producers in WY PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Location of off-site goat vaccine study has changed from LSU to CSU.

    Impacts
    In a related study, we demonstrated that two B. abortus proteins, Hia and D15, are able to induce clearance immunity in a BLAB/c mouse model for fully virulent B. abortus infection. In this regard, we have chosen these two proteins to evaluate in a gravid caprine model for their ability to abrogate disease (abortogenicity). If successful, one or both of these proteins, formulated with a non-toxic adjuvant, may represent a next-generation veterinary vaccine against brucellosis.

    Publications

    • Andrews, G.P., Leonhardt, J.A., Dougherty, A.M., Lowry, J.E., and R. Bowen. 2012. Brucella abortus recombinant outer membrane proteins induce clearance immunity against virulent challenge in BALB/c mice. The 93rd Annual Meeting of the Conference of Research Workers in Animal Diseases (CRWAD), Chicago, IL.


    Progress 06/01/10 to 05/31/11

    Outputs
    OUTPUTS: Project 1. Evaluation of protective efficacy of selected B. abortus recombinant protein formulations in a caprine challenge model for brucellosis. Outputs: Scaled-up production of three selected B. abortus antigenic proteins previously shown to be relevant to infection in two different susceptible hosts. Completed protocol (reviewed and approved) for immunization/challenge study using formulations of the three Brucella abortus recombinant proteins in a gravid caprine model for brucellosis. Project 2. Identification of novel candidate virulence factors from B. abortus using Rapid Virulence Annotation (RVA), a high-throughput functional genomic screen. Construct cosmid libraries from B. abortus strains. Identify candidate genomic regions by screening cosmid libraries for gain-of-toxicity against host organisms/cell lines. Identify specific genes responsible for gain-of-toxicity by transposon mutagenesis of positive cosmid clones. Outputs: Isolated and purified high molecular weight genomic DNA from B. abortus RB51. Constructed a cosmid library of RB51 genomic DNA in the Epicentre cosmid vector pWEB. Effect of an improved brucellosis vaccine on cattle producers' incentives to use adult-booster vaccination. Project 3. Determine the potential for an improved brucellosis vaccine to increase the willingness of cattle producers in the Greater Yellowstone Area to use adult-booster vaccination. Outputs: Estimated the costs and revenues of a cow-calf-yearling operation with versus without adult-booster vaccination, combined with the presence versus absence of a brucellosis-infected animal. Constructed a worksheet in Excel to calculate expected profit with and without adult-booster vaccination assuming current versus improved vaccine efficacy. Defined distributions for relevant epidemiological and economic parameters. We are now using the software program @Risk to conduct a Monte Carlo simulation of expected profit and adoption of adult-booster vaccination under current versus improved vaccine efficacy. We will then compare simulation results to determine the effect of an improved vaccine on producers' willingness to adopt adult-booster vaccination. PARTICIPANTS: Gerard P. Andrews, Department of Veterinary Sciences, UW, co-PI and project director; Phil Elzer, School of Veterinary Medicine, LSU, co-PI; Naomi Ward, Department of Molecular Biology, UW, co-PI; Chris Vassallo, Department of Molecular Biology, UW, graduate student; Dannele E. Peck, Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, UW, co-PI; Bryan A. Wilson, Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, UW, graduate student; Trenton W. Roberts, Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, UW, graduate student; John P. Ritten, Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, UW, collaborator; Roger H. Coupal, Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, UW, collaborator. TARGET AUDIENCES: State and regional veterinarians and epidemiologists; Wyoming Game and Fish Department; Wyoming Department of Public Health; cattle producers in the Greater Yellowstone Area. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

    Impacts
    Project 1. Our previous work in the murine model strongly suggest the potential for use of B. abortus malate dehydrogenase, as a recombinant subunit vaccine candidate for brucellosis. AfuA and D15 may also represent promising subunit vaccine candidates when used in combination with Mdh. In this regard, it is quite possible that immunization with a cocktail of these antigens will produce synergistic effects. To test this hypothesis, we have scaled up four B. abortus proteins for use in an ungulate model for evaluation of their ability to induce protective immunity against wild-type Brucella challenge. Project 2. Successful construction of a cosmid library requires availability of high-quality, high molecular weight genomic DNA. Thus we have expended considerable effort in obtaining such DNA from B. abortus strains. We began work with strain RB51, with the goal of optimizing DNA isolation and purification protocols in this strain, and subsequently applying them to a second B. abortus strain. The Andrews lab has successfully optimized protocols to obtain DNA of the requisite quality and quantity from strain RB51. This DNA has been used to generate a cosmid library. A library of over four hundred cosmid clones has been generated and preserved by preparation of glycerol freezer stocks. Production of this resource has been quite time-consuming, principally due to problems experienced with early attempts at cosmid cloning, and the troubleshooting required to resolve these problems. We are currently involved in end-sequencing the library to verify genome coverage. Other short-term goals include characterization of representative cosmid inserts by determination of insert size by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis, and testing for protein expression by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of E. coli culture supernatants. project 3. Our economic analysis reveals that if a 400-head herd contracts brucellosis, and is quarantined for one year without compensation, the owner will incur $134,000 in additional costs (feed and labor ). The total cost of administering adult-booster vaccination to all adult cows once in their ten-year useful life, and to incoming two-year old heifers each year over a ten-year period, is roughly $16,500. When this total cost is annualized over a 10-year period, adult-booster vaccination costs $1,695 per year. The producer incurs just $854 of this annual cost because of cost-shares with the Wyoming Livestock Board, which pays the remaining $841. We have constructed spreadsheets in Excel to calculate expected profit with and without adult-booster vaccination assuming current versus improved vaccine efficacy. The spreadsheets accommodate a range of values for the probability of a cow being exposed to brucellosis, and the effectiveness of calfhood and adult-booster vaccinations. The spreadsheets track sexually-intact cows through one year, during which time each individual cow has a given probability of contracting brucellosis. This probability depends on whether their calfhood vaccination was effective, whether they received an adult-booster vaccination, and whether the adult-booster vaccination was effective.

    Publications

    • Lowry, J.E., Isaak, D.D., Leonhardt, J., Vernati, G., Fluegel, A.M., Pate, J., and Andrews, G.P. 2011. Vaccination with recombinant antigens reduces Brucella abortus strain-19 colonization in a mouse model for infection. Plos ONE. March 11; 6(3): e17425.
    • Roberts, T.W. 2011. Master's Thesis: Costs and Expected Benefits to Cattle Producers of Brucellosis Management Strategies in the Greater Yellowstone Area of Wyoming. Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, University of Wyoming.