Source: TEXAS A&M UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
SPATIAL ECONOMIC MODELING: APPLICATIONS FOR LAND USE AND WATERSHED MANAGEMENT
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0221594
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Mar 9, 2010
Project End Date
Mar 8, 2015
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
TEXAS A&M UNIVERSITY
750 AGRONOMY RD STE 2701
COLLEGE STATION,TX 77843-0001
Performing Department
Agri Economics
Non Technical Summary
Land-use change is a primary driver of the losses in biodiversity and ecosystem services at local to global scales (Foley et al. 2005). Developing spatially explicit projections of land-use change and their consequences has thus emerged as one of the eight grand challenges in environmental science (Clark et al. 2001; Harte 2001; National Research Council 2001). Yet our ability to forecast land-use change has been limited by the availability of spatial data and our understanding of nonlinear threshold responses in economic and ecological systems (Nilsson et al. 2003; Wu et al. 2000). For example, LANDSAT satellite imagery is commonly used to classify land-cover change from urban and agricultural uses; however, it does not detect low-density exurban development. This is important to consider because exurban development uses a great deal more land than both urban and suburban development (Heimlich and Anderson 2001). Exurban development therefore poses the greater challenge to farmland preservation efforts and has caused significant reductions in the survival of many native species (Hansen et al. 2005). To mitigate these impacts, it is important to understand what factors influence the spatial pattern of land-use development. In particular, it is essential to analyze the role of land-use policies and infrastructure planning on guiding future development patterns and the expected ecological outcomes. Additionally, human activities related to land use and water management have major impacts on aquatic ecosystems (Harding et al. 1998). As urban and agricultural development expands, it has caused reductions in stream flows and water quality. This has contributed to high numbers of endangered aquatic species and the decline of economically valuable fisheries, such as anadromous salmonids (Richter et al. 1997). Likewise, the federal listing of endangered species can trigger instream flow requirements that reduce water security for irrigated agriculture and other uses. Therefore, there is a need to develop spatial economic models to understand the joint decisions on land-use development and water management. This would be a first step to an integrated spatially explicit economic and hydrologic model in order to improve water supply security for rural landowners and the instream flows needed to sustain aquatic ecosystems.
Animal Health Component
30%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
70%
Applied
30%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1120320301025%
1310120301030%
6050120301025%
6050320301020%
Goals / Objectives
This research program has the following four main objectives: (1) to identify and assess the economic factors that determine spatial land-use patterns, with an emphasis on the role of land-use regulations, infrastructure planning, and conservation incentive programs; (2) to analyze the joint decision process on land use and water management for rural landowners and how these decisions vary according to geomorphic setting and other factors; (3) to improve economic models to forecast land-use change and water management and assess scenarios on the influence of various environmental policy options; and (4) to improve the economic efficiency of environmental policies by integrating spatial and dynamic aspects of ecological and hydrologic systems.
Project Methods
This research program will take advantage of geographic information systems (GIS) and spatial data to perform economic analysis, as well as multidisciplinary analysis with ecologists and hydrologists. Parcel-level models of land-use change will be used to characterize and explain the determinants of residential development (Bockstael 1996; Irwin, Bell, and Geoghegan 2003; Newburn and Berck 2006). These econometric models are able to distinguish how individual landowners respond to land-use policies. The aim is to understand how smart-growth policies, such as urban growth boundaries, have different effects on guiding future residential development at suburban and exurban densities. This modeling approach can be similarly applied to understand landowner decisions on agricultural expansion and water management. In this case, the spatially explicit approach is essential because access to surface and ground water supplies can vary tremendously across the landscape. Novel methodologies will be used to assess the spatial variation in land use and water management at a landowner level, by integrating various data sources within a GIS, including current and historic agricultural land use, water right permits, onsite reservoirs, and other physical and locational parcel characteristics. Econometric models are used to determine how landowners respond to policies that influence both land and water use. For example, instream flow requirements for protecting endangered species will affect the timing and location of water withdrawals; therefore, this analysis aims to understand which types of landowners are most affected by the policy restrictions and how they would respond if these policies were altered. The economic analysis eventually will be integrated with hydrologic and ecological models because the ultimate goal is to assess tradeoffs between water security for human uses and instream flows to sustain aquatic ecosystems.

Progress 03/09/10 to 03/08/15

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Ongoing teaching responsibilities. Analyzed farmer survey data to measure additionality from USDA conservation programs in Ohio. Submitted paper for publication on this topic and presented the results at the Annual Meeting of the Applied and Agricultural Economics Association (AAEA) in Pittsburg. Developed econometric model on land use and water management decisions before and after species listing of salmonids in Sonoma County, California. Published paper on this topic and presented the results at the inaugural meeting of the Association of Environmental and Resource Economics (AERE) in Seattle. Developed statistical models of juvenile fish survivorship as a function of stream flows and land use in the Russian River Basin, California and published paper on this topic. Analyzed data on residential development and urban growth boundaries in Sonoma County, California and published paper on this topic. Developed econometric model on spillover effects of residential development due to downzoning in Baltimore County, Maryland and presented results at the AAEA and AERE meetings. PARTICIPANTS: Richard Woodward (TAMU) worked on the Ohio project to provide data analysis and assist with writing paper. Nicholas Brozovic (University of Illinois) worked on the Sonoma County project to help with writing the model for this paper. Ted Grantham (UC Davis) and Adina Merenlender (UC Berkeley) helped analyze the fish survey data and write the paper. Charles Towe (University of Maryland) worked on the data analysis for the residential spillover paper in the Baltimore metro region and Allen Klaiber (Ohio State), Doug Wrenn (Ohio State), and Elena Irwin (Ohio State) worked on the conference paper for this project. The research in Ohio and California has also provided the opportunity for training of a doctoral student, Mariano Mezzatesta (TAMU), who made the presentation in Pittsburg. TARGET AUDIENCES: Academic environmental economists who attend the AAEA and AERE meetings are the primary target audience for this research. Furthermore, the research in Ohio is relevant to the USDA policy makers who help to design the conservation subsidy programs in the federal Farm Bill. The spillover paper in the Baltimore metro region is relevant to county and state planners at land use and environmental agencies in Maryland. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
Research results on additionality from federal conservation program in Ohio have been shared with economists at the USDA. This has helped them better understand the role of conservation subsidy program in changing adoption decisions and improve the cost effectiveness of implementation. The results on spillover effects in the Baltimore metro region were presented to local planning agency staff at the annual meeting of the Baltimore Ecosystem Study. This research provides a better understanding on how uncoordinated land use planning can lead to unintended leapfrog development.

Publications

  • Newburn, D. and R. Woodward. 2012. An ex post assessment of the Great Miami River Water Quality Trading Program. Journal of the American Water Resources Association, in press.
  • Grantham, T., D. Newburn, M. McCarthy, and A. Merenlender. 2012. The role of stream flow and land use on limiting endangered steelhead trout recruitment and survival. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society, in press.
  • Newburn, D. and P. Berck. 2011. Exurban development. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 62: 323-336.
  • Newburn, D., N. Brozovic, and M. Mezzatesta. 2011. Agricultural water security and instream flows for endangered species. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 93(4): 1212-1228.
  • Newburn, D. and P. Berck. 2011. Growth management policies for exurban and suburban development: Theory and an Application to Sonoma County, California. Agricultural and Resource Economics Review, 40(3): 375-392.


Progress 01/01/10 to 12/31/10

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Ongoing teaching responsibilities. Analyzed data from conservation programs in the federal Farm Bill and the Great Miami Water Quality Trading Program (GMWQTP) in Ohio. Presented results to program administrators in Ohio and a workshop sponsored by the USDA Economic Research Service in Washington DC. Developed econometric model on land use and water management decisions before and after species listing of salmonids in Sonoma County, California. Presented the results at the World Congress for Environmental and Resource Economics in Montreal, Canada. Analyzed data on residential development and smart growth land-use policies in Calvert County, Maryland. PARTICIPANTS: Richard Woodward (TAMU) worked on the Ohio project to provide data analysis and presentation to the program administrators. Nicholas Brozovic (University of Illinois) worked on the Sonoma County project to help with writing the research results. Elena Irwin (Ohio State) worked on the Calvert County project to provide advice on data analysis. The research in Ohio and California has also provided the opportunity for training of a doctoral student, Mariano Mezzatesta (TAMU), who made the presentation in Washington DC and Montreal. TARGET AUDIENCES: Academic environmental economists are the primary target audience for this research. Furthermore, the research in Ohio is relevant to the GMWQTP program administrators for the GMWQTP and the USDA policy makers. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
The research results on the water quality trading program in Ohio have been shared with the GMWQTP program administrators. This has helped them better understand the role of local institutions in the program and improve the cost effectiveness of the implementation. The data on water and land use in California has been shared with local stakeholders, including the Salmon Coalition and Sonoma County Water Agency. This has helped them better understand the cumulative water demand that exists in small upland watersheds that support endangered salmonids.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period