Source: CORNELL UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
GREEN PARKING LOTS: COMBINING VEGETATION, POROUS PAVEMENT AND STRUCTURAL SOIL TO REDUCE RUNOFF AND COOL THE AIR
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0220121
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Oct 1, 2009
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2012
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
CORNELL UNIVERSITY
(N/A)
ITHACA,NY 14853
Performing Department
Horticulture
Non Technical Summary
One only needs to visit any `big box' store on the urban strip to view acres of asphalt covering soil that had previously allowed rain and snow to replenish the water table and support vegetation that cooled the air. These large asphalt parking lots are ubiquitous in every community and there is every reason to believe that they will only increase in number as commercial development occurs. Concomitant with large expanses of asphalt comes tremendous heating of the air (more than 10C warmer in the parking lot), a reduction of water filtration and recharge into the water table and the added expense of putting in storm drainage to carry precipitation into storm sewers. It may be possible, however, to combine the use of porous asphalt, structural soil, grass and trees to create parking lots that absorb rainwater, cool the urban core and are less expensive to build than conventional parking lots with storm drainage. This new green technology will address environmental problems caused by development by reducing flooding and the need for costly drainage infrastructure, purifying water as it recharges the water table and cooling the air while absorbing carbon dioxide. This will provide new business opportunities and change the way development is carried out by both public and private agencies. Structural soil is a medium developed at Cornell University's Urban Horticulture Institute to meet engineers' specifications for a compacted, load-bearing surface beneath pavement while simultaneously allowing tree roots to grow through it. Prior to the development of structural soil, soil compaction was so severe under pavement that tree roots were often restricted in their growth resulting in a stunted tree and early tree mortality. By combining structural soil with porous asphalt, the requirements of a drivable surface can be met while allowing trees to grow under the pavement. Wear-tolerant grasses have also been shown to grow in structural soil. It may be possible to plant certain wear tolerant grasses on structural soil to handle less frequently used areas of the parking lot that receive moderate traffic while using trees planted in structural soil with a porous asphalt surface in higher use areas. The city of Ithaca, NY is interested in testing the combined features of structural soil, porous asphalt, grass and trees to develop a thoroughly green parking lot that significantly reduces storm drainage and cools the environment. The first phase of the research will be to design and test variations of a green parking lot using different depths and configurations of structural soil under grass and porous asphalt with trees planted directly into the structural soil. Different species of grasses will be tested for wear tolerance under car traffic. The parking lots will be designed to accommodate the 100 year storm and tested with instruments that measure the water table and rate of draw down. Much of this can be done in field plots. Subsequently the best design will be constructed in Ithaca. Environmental effects and economic costs will be compared between traditional and new green parking lot models.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1120530311130%
1240530106050%
1320530207020%
Goals / Objectives
Structural soil is a medium developed at Cornell to meet engineers' specifications for a compacted, load-bearing surface beneath pavement while simultaneously allowing tree roots to grow through it. By combining structural soil with porous asphalt, the requirements of a drivable surface can be met while allowing trees to grow under the pavement. Wear-tolerant grasses have also been shown to grow in structural soil. It may be possible to plant certain wear-tolerant grasses on structural soil to handle less frequently used areas of the parking lot while using trees planted in structural soil with a porous asphalt surface in higher use areas. If successful, the development of this project will reduce the need for costly storm drainage infrastructure, reduce flooding, provide water purification and recharge into the water table, cool the urban heat island and increase carbon sequestration. The goals of the proposed research are to combine the technologies of structural soil with porous asphalt in parking lots to decrease air temperature and allow water recharge and filtering. Specifically we plan to measure the growth and transpiration of trees and turf as a substitution for asphalt in porous parking lots to determine the effect they have on water table draw down, to compare the effects of grass as a substitute for asphalt and its impact on the reduction of heat generated by asphalt, to determine the best spacing and design of trees in porous parking lots to optimize pavement and car shading and to test the growth and wear tolerance of different turf grasses grown in structural soil under simulated vehicular traffic. In addition, we will compare hydroseeding vs. sod establishment by cost, timing and weed control as a substitution for asphalt, to compare regular vs. infrequent mowing effects on wear tolerance and to compare carbon sequestration and carbon emitted using grass, trees and pavement both during establishment and maintenance of the site. We intend to partner with a municipality or state agency to implement porous parking lot technology in New York. Specifically we want to work with municipal and state agency engineers to develop guidelines and designs and to develop a manual detailing how to design and construct a porous, green parking lot as a guide for other communities and developers.
Project Methods
The city of Ithaca, NY is interested in testing the combined features of structural soil, porous asphalt, trees and turf to develop a thoroughly green parking lot that significantly reduces storm drainage and cools the environment. We intend to test these features in combination and evaluate their effects and costs. The first year of the research will be to design and test variations of a green parking lot using different depths and configurations of structural soil under grass and porous asphalt with trees planted directly into the structural soil in field plots that have already been developed for this purpose. Different species of grasses will be tested for wear tolerance under car traffic. Turf-type tall fescue (Festuca arundinacea) is a wear-tolerant cool season turf grass species that is widely used in high traffic sports turf situations, including horse track surfaces and is able to tolerate the abrasion and compaction associated with weight-bearing stress. Preliminary research has demonstrated the success of using turf-type tall fescue sod transplanted directly on the surface of the structural soil. However, contractors might find the use of sod to be cost prohibitive in the short term and therefore an alternative means of establishing tall fescue is required. The process of hydraulic seeding consists of mixing mulch, seed, fertilizer, soil activators and glues, and then spraying these onto the soil creating a seeding mat which, when watered several times a day, keeps moisture next to the seed for quick germination. We will investigate two establishment methods using hydraulic seeding and two seeding rates of tall fescue. 1. Hydraulic seeding directly on the surface of the structural soil. 2. Apply a 0.5cm layer of sandy loam soil and hydraulic seeding on the surface of the soil. In addition, two seeding rates of tall fescue will be used to determine which develops the most rapid wear -tolerant turf. 1. Normal lawn seeding rate of 250 kg ha-1. 2. High seeding rate 500 kg ha-1. Sod establishment will be compared to hydroseeding as an establishment method on top of structural soil. The parking lot plots will be designed to accommodate the 100 year storm of 6 inches of rain in 24 hours, and tested with instruments that measure the water table level and rates of transpiration of trees and turf. Subsequently, during the next year, the best turf and tree establishment practices will be constructed by the City of Ithaca and a design manual documenting best practices will be created. During the subsequent 2 years, the durability of turf and porous asphalt with trees planted into structural soil will be evaluated. Growth, water uptake, turf wear resilience will be measured periodically over the year. Environmental effects on temperature and storm water runoff and storm water filtration will simultaneously be measured. The economic costs of establishment and maintenance will be compared between traditional and new green parking lot models.

Progress 10/01/09 to 09/30/12

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Several test sites were constructed to test the combination of CU structural soil and turf grass on the growth of turf and trees over three years. Twelve plots were constructed with tall fescue sod or seed-established tall fescue turf growing on top of structural soil. Two different seeding rates were tested for the direct seeding test and a cushion of a half inch of soil was or was not added to the structural soil base before seeding. Turf was allowed to grow with minimal maintenance except occasional mowing. PARTICIPANTS: Not relevant to this project. TARGET AUDIENCES: Turf on CU-Structural Soil has been successfully used at a Mercedes dealership in Georgia. At this installation, the soil in an entire median was excavated and replaced with CU-Structural Soil and then sod was placed on top. After installation, the entire median can now properly withstand the compaction from the weight of the cars and serves as a flexible open space for the dealership, providing impromptu space to display inventory, or as overflow parking for the dealership. After three years, this installation is maintenance free and as healthy as the day it was installed. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
Cornell University has combined turf with structural soil to create a healthy growing medium for the grass that withstands traffic, is designed to be very low maintenance and can be used in areas that receive high levels of both pedestrian and vehicular traffic. Structural soil has two benefits. The first is that structural soil is designed to be compacted, and will therefore withstand heavy amounts of traffic. In addition, the system can allow water to infiltrate the turf surface and hold it in a reservoir underneath the grass.Working with turf and structural soil requires a change in the way that designers and contractors go about their work. Rather than just installing sod or seeding grass directly onto existing soil, entire areas will need to be excavated to a depth of at least 12" to 24", depending on the desired reservoir depth, and filled with structural soil. Once compacted, the sod or seed should be installed directly onto the structural soil and then irrigated until established. Direct seeding of tall fescue turfgrass was installed at two seeding rates with and without a half inch of silt loam soil on top of the structural soil base. Sod was installed with no cushion of soil. Installations were allowed to grow for three years with no other maintenance than occasional mowing. In order to properly mitigate any storm, exact rainfall data must be obtained from local sources. This information is based on the known void space for compacted CU-Structural Soil of 26 percent. It is important to note that while depths less than 24" will both support sod and mitigate a storm event up to 4.0" in 24 hours, it will not support adjacent large tree growth because the reservoir will be too shallow to accommodate healthy tree root growth. Important tips to keep in mind when designing with turf and CU-Structural Soil are:Minimize vehicular wear on the turf as much as possible.Angle parking stalls to minimize turning from automobile wheels. Excessive turning causes the turf grass leaf blades to tear and can create bare patches in the turf. Use turf only in overflow parking areas on the outskirts of large lots.Carefully research local stormwater data to set the proper depth CU-Structural Soil reservoir. Although CU-Structural Soil is highly porous, flooding will occur if the rate of groundwater recharge is slower than the rate that the reservoir receives both the rain and runoff. Mowing ever 10 days is necessary.Never snow plow a turf portion of the lot. The blades from the plow will damage the turf surface, removing the turf and necessitating costly replacement. Tall fescue sod covered structural soil has a total quality index of between 5.5 and 6.8. Control sod on gravel had a total quality index of 1.0 to 2.5. Tall fescue direct seeding provided 75 to 88 percent cover after 2 years at either seeding rate with and without a half-inch soil base. The double seeding rate produced a thicker turf in the first year, but all treatments were identical by the second year. Turf can be grown successfully on a base of structural soil. Such a surface will cool the air and allow storm water recharge in contrast to traditional asphalt.

Publications

  • Bassuk, NL, Grabosky, J, Mucciardi, A and Raffel, G. 2011 July. Ground Penetrating Radar Accurately Locates Tree Roots in Two Soil Media Under Pavement. Journal of Arboriculture and Urban Forestry. 37(4) 160-166


Progress 10/01/10 to 09/30/11

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Evaluations of several installations of wear resistant turf were established on experimental plots at Cornell University's Department of Horticulture Bluegrass Lane and in the City of Ithaca. In spring, 2010, the sod was removed and a CU-Structural Soil base was re-laid in each of 12, 8 feet square plots. Wear resistant tall fescue grass was hydroseeded at two rates on bare structural soil or structural soil with 2cm of soil on top of it. Plots were well watered and the turf left to grow. Turf color and density data were measured after 4 months growth. At that point, in August 2010, the grass was removed and the same installation was repeated and evaluated in the spring and summer of 2011. In August 2010, the City of Ithaca expanded an existing parking lot and 60cm of CU-Structural Soil was laid under four new parking lanes. These parking areas were hydroseeded at the high rate without extra soil on top of the structural soil. City of Ithaca crews watered the area several times during the month of August. Turf was evaluated in the spring and summer of 2011. PARTICIPANTS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. TARGET AUDIENCES: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
High seeding rates without extra soil added to the surface of the structural soil was the best treatment. Irrigation was essential for establishment. Although we already knew that sod grew well on CU-Structural Soil, hydroseeding also was successful, although there is more weed pressure. Sigma Plot data on turf cover over bare soil was taken. Final data will be taken on all sites including wear studies and water infiltration studies will commence. A bulletin is in progress describing the installation of such a grass covered parking lot.

Publications

  • Contributing author in: Day, S.D, and S.B. Dickinson (Eds.) 2008. Managing Stormwater for Urban Sustainability using Trees and Structural Soils. Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, VA.


Progress 10/01/09 to 09/30/10

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Several installations of wear resistant turf were established on experimental plots at Cornell University's Department of Horticulture Bluegrass Lane and in the City of Ithaca. Data was taken on the final year of turf that was established using sod at Bluegrass Lane in fall of 2009. In spring, 2010, the sod was removed and a CU-Structural Soil base was re-laid in each of 12, 8 feet square plots. Wear resistant tall fescue grass was hydroseeded at two rates on bare structural soil or structural soil with 2cm of soil on top of it. Plots were well watered and the turf left to grow. Turf color and density data were measured after 4 months growth. At that point, in August 2010, the grass was removed, the base re-laid again and the same spring establishment treatments repeated. Overwintering and growth will be evaluated in the spring and summer of 2011. In August 2010, the City of Ithaca expanded an existing parking lot and 60cm of CU-Structural Soil was laid under four new parking lanes. These parking areas were hydroseeded at the high rate without extra soil on top of the structural soil. City of Ithaca crews watered the area several times during the month of August. Turf will be evaluated in the spring of 2011. PARTICIPANTS: City of Ithaca forestry crews assisted with mixing and installing the structural soil at the city parking lot. Department of Horticulture technicians re-laid the structural soil on the research plots and supervised hydroseeding. Cayuga Landscape company provided the hydroseeding equipment. TARGET AUDIENCES: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
It appears that the high rate of seeding without extra soil added to the surface of the structural soil was the best treatment. Irrigation was essential for establishment. Although we already knew that sod grew well on CU-Structural Soil, hydroseeding also was successful. Data is still being analyzed. Intermittent watering by the City of Ithaca slowed the rate of establishment of grass on that parking lot and allowed more weeds to grow. Next year data will be taken on all sites and wear studies and water infiltration studies will commence.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period