Source: CORNELL UNIVERSITY submitted to
OPPORTUNITIES FOR AND BARRIERS TO THE GROWTH OF ORGANIC AGRICULTURE IN NEW YORK STATE
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0219628
Grant No.
(N/A)
Project No.
NYC-121473
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Oct 1, 2009
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2012
Grant Year
(N/A)
Project Director
Henehan, B. M.
Recipient Organization
CORNELL UNIVERSITY
(N/A)
ITHACA,NY 14853
Performing Department
Applied Economics & Management
Non Technical Summary
Organic agriculture and food processing have grown significantly in the U.S. as well as in New York State. Cropland in organic production in the U.S. has increased from 638,500 acres in 1995 to over 1,723,271 in 2005 (USDA, NASS). Sales of organic foods have increased by double digits annually over that same time period. New York State ranked sixth in the U.S. in the number of certified organic farms in 2005 (USDA, ERS). New York has seen significant growth in certified organic agriculture. However, limited research has been conducted on the longer term outlook and opportunities for New York farmers, food processors, and marketers. The growth of organic agriculture in New York State has occurred across a mix of types of commodities and farm enterprises. Opportunities for expansion can vary across types of farms, products and market channels. Given the increased production and scope of organic agriculture and food processing in New York State, further study of the opportunities for and barriers to growth is warranted. The proposed research addresses a number of Federal, State and Institutional research priorities. The project would address the following USDA, Cooperative State Research, Education and Extension Service research goals (CSREES Strategic Plan) Goal 2: Enhance the Competitiveness and Sustainability of Rural and Farm Economies and Goal 3: Support Increased Economic Opportunities and Improved Quality of Life in Rural America. The Cornell Organic Agriculture Program Work Team, (PWT) lists the following research priorities under the category of "Marketing, Economics and Farm Business Management" Market opportunities, Economics of organic enterprises, Impacts of regional and global marketing on local production. The purpose of this project is to improve the decision making of New York farmers and agribusinesses who are currently involved in organic agriculture or those producers or firms interested in potentially marketing organically produced farm products. The collection and analysis of data on current production and processing operations should provide insight into the identification of the best opportunities for organic agriculture as well as the potential barriers to growth. The study will attempt to effectively analyze the options available New York farmers, processors, and marketers. The impact of making the right strategic decision for producers, processors or policy makers can translate into better performance in today's global marketplace, a financially stronger New York agriculture, improved profitability at the farm level, as well as a positive economic impact on the communities that are involved.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
6015010301015%
6036299301020%
6046230301015%
5026299301050%
Goals / Objectives
The overall purpose of the project is to improve the understanding of the potential opportunities to grow the organic food and agriculture industry in New York State. The study would also examine what constraints or barriers exist to increasing organic agriculture or marketing. Specific objectives include: 1. Conduct extensive review of literature that focuses on organic agriculture production, distribution, manufacturing and marketing. 2. Develop up to date database on organic agricultural production in New York State 3. Develop up to date database on organic food processing and distribution in New York State. 4. Estimate and analyze the economic impact of organic production and processing in New York State. 5. Ascertain what are the most promising opportunities for organic production and/or processing in New York State 6. Identify barriers or competitive disadvantages for organic production or processing in New York State. 7. Disseminate the results through Extension and outreach activities
Project Methods
A number of Cornell faculty, agency staff and a consultant have agreed to collaborate on the project including: Marc Smith, Dr. Anusuya Rangarajan, Fay Benson, Dr. George Abawi, Dr. Todd Schmit, Dr. Brad Rickard, Sarah Johnston, NY Dept. of Ag. and Markets, Organic Farming Coordinator, Dr. Steve Ropel, Director, NASS- New York, USDA, and Laurie Demeritt, President and Chief Operating Officer, The Hartman Group (subcontractor). The procedures that will be used to accomplish each of the objectives are described below: 1. Utilize the resources of Mann Library as well as various research search engines such as Agricola, AgEcon Search, Ag Network Information Center, and AGRIS. 2. Utilize data collected by New York NASS and certifying agencies such as NOFA to describe the scale and types of organic production in New York. 3. Utilize data collected by various New York State licensing entities and certifying agencies such as NOFA to describe the scale and types of organic food processing in New York. Previous Cornell research conducted on perishable product distribution in NY would be incorporated (Gloy et al.). This effort would also be coordinated with the current project on food and beverage manufacturing in NY (Schmit et al.) 4. Data collected in previous phases of the project would be analyzed to describe the economic impact. The economic impact of various links in the value chain would be identified such as production, processing, distribution and marketing. Previous Cornell research would provide a model to analyze inter-industry economic impact (Schmit and Bills). Utilizing technical resources such as the Dunn and Bradstreet Online Database, the New York Manufacturers Register, and national business directory databases such as the American Yellow Pages, an up-to-date inventory and profile of current plant operations will be developed. 5. Data would be analyzed to identify potential production and marketing opportunities for growth. Survey respondents will also be invited to participate in five regional focus groups across the state. At these regional meetings, food and beverage manufacturers will be asked to identify opportunities and strategic advantages they see in their businesses, as well as the most important obstacles and barriers they face in terms of retention or expansion of manufacturing activity. 6. Data would be collected through surveys and personal interviews of producers, processors, distributors, marketers and certifying agencies. Data would be analyzed to identify potential competitive advantages, disadvantages or barriers to growth. Data collected and reported by the Hartman Group would be used to better understand how organic products resonate with today's consumers. 7. Educational and outreach materials will be developed and communicated to industry stakeholders. Research findings will be communicated to aid policymakers in designing effective policy initiatives. Outreach efforts will include presentations to producer groups and industry firms through workshops or trade association meetings. Outreach efforts will be coordinated with CCE County Educators.

Progress 10/01/09 to 09/30/12

Outputs
OUTPUTS: During the first year of the project, data on the current status, scope and scale of organic agriculture in New York State were collected and published. This information proved useful as a basis for the duration of the project. The report provides useful production data benchmarks to help identify where there are opportunities for future growth or barriers to hinder expansion of organic agriculture in New York State. The project does not include any formal multi-state activities. However, related research in other states or potential inter-state marketing opportunities were examined. Food and Beverage manufacturing firms were enumerated and classified operating in New York State to provide a database for an extensive survey. Several questions included in the survey inquired about whether firms were involved in organic food and beverage processing. The data generated from that survey were collected for firms involved on organic food processing and are being analyzed in a forthcoming report during the final year of the project. Data were also collected on consumer purchasing behavior in buying organic foods in New York State. PARTICIPANTS: Several Graduate Students from the Dyson School at Cornell University including Jie Li and Amrit Singh served as research assistant in the project. A number of partner organizations were involved including: the Northeast Organic Farmer Association, NOFA, market researchers from the Hartman Group, the Organic Trade Association, OTA, the NOP group at USDA. Faculty collaborators at Cornell University and the NYS Experiment Station included: Marc Smith, Extension Associate and Assistant Director of Cornell University's New York State Agricultural Experiment Station. Provide coordination with faculty in Geneva and interaction with New York farmers and stakeholders. Dr. Anusuya Rangarajan, Director, Small Farms Program and Executive Director of the Northeast Organic Network (NEON), Department of Horticulture, Cornell http://www.smallfarms.cornell.edu . Fay Benson, Organic Dairy Program Leader, Cornell Coop. Ext.(Advisor) Provide expertise on organic dairy production, assist with project objectives, and collaborate on outreach to dairy farmers and industry. Dr. George Abawi, Geneva Experiment Station provided information on soil health research related to organic agriculture. Dr. Todd Schmit, Asst. Professor, AEM Cornell Collaborated on current research focusing on the NY food and beverage industry. Dr. Brad Rickard, Asst. Prof. AEM, Cornell collaborated on the collection and analysis of cost of production data as well as analysis of consumer preferences with respect to organic food products. A research support specialist from the Mann Library assisted in conducting a literature review, A representative from a New York State Agency. Sarah Johnston, NY Dept. of Ag. and Markets, Organic Farming Coordinator advised on data collection as well as clarifying objectives for the study. A number of representatives from private industry offered input including the following companies: Whole Foods, Wegman's. Hains Celestial Training or professional development occurred through on campus In-service events for Cornell Cooperative Extension Educators. Research results wer presented in a webinar in December, 2012 sponsored by the Cornell Cooperative Extension Organic agriculture Program Work Team, PWT. TARGET AUDIENCES: The target audience reached by the project included: CALS faculty, Cornell Cooperative Educators, organic agribusiness managers, organic farm managers and managers and staff of related businesses. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: The original NIFA grant proposal was written in 2008 at a time when the P.I. received a level of funding that supported a full-time position. From July, 2009 until September 30 2012 when the project termed, funding for the P.I.s position decreased by 50%. This cut in support resulted in a shift to a half-time position for the Principal Investigator creating a significant decrease in the time available to focus on the project and accomplish all of the proposed work plan. And so, a number of proposed goals and project outputs were not achieved due to the time constraints imposed by deceased funding for the position of the Principal Investigator.

Impacts
Reports and presentations generated from the project were utilized by Organic Trade Associations, farmers, processors and policy makers to gain a better understanding of the opportunities and barriers to the growth of organic food and agricultural production in New York State. The evidence-based results provided a useful basis for producers and agribusiness firms to make better decisions about entering or increasing organic food and agricultural production in New York State as well as he barriers to growth. Results were distributed through various media and educational distribution channels including the New York Department of Agriculture, Cornell Cooperative Extension field staff and the Cornell Program Work Team (PWT) on Organic Agriculture. Articles for the general press along with and Extension Bulletins posted on websites were utilized to distribute research results.

Publications

  • Schmit, T.M., K.Park, B.Henehan, & J.Hall. (2012) "A Study of Food and Beverage Manufacturing in New York State." E.B. 2012-07. Charles H. Dyson School of Applied Economics & Management, Cornell University.
  • Henehan, B. (2012) Smart Marketing series article "Purchasing Organic Foods in New York State" available at http://marketingpwt.dyson.cornell.edu/SmartMarketing/pdfs/SmrtMktg%20 Dec2011.pdf
  • NortheastOrganic Research Symposium Proceedings (2012) - from the 1/19/12 session in Saratoga Springs, NY- see https://www.nofany.org/?q=events/2012-winter-conference/ne-organic-re search-symposium/proceedings


Progress 10/01/10 to 09/30/11

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Over the past two years, several proposed goals for the project were accomplished including: data collection data to describe the current organic agricultural production in New York State, data were collected to assess the current situation of firms involved in organic food and beverage processing in New York State, and began an analysis of consumer purchasing of organic foods in New York State. Several publications reporting the results of various surveys are being finalized and are forthcoming. Good progress is being made towards the end objective of identifying the barriers and opportunities for organic agricultural production and food processing in New York State. PARTICIPANTS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. TARGET AUDIENCES: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
It is expected that the project will assist New York producers in identifying potential opportunities for increased organic production as well as examine the barriers to growth. By analyzing production data, data on value-added operations as well as potential consumer demand, the project should provide evidenced- based results that improve decision-making for farmers as well as food processors related to increasing organic production and/or value-added enterprises.

Publications

  • Henehan, B. (2011) Organic Agriculture in New York, April 2011, Smart Marketing Article series, Dyson School Cornell University http://marketingpwt.dyson.cornell.edu/SmartMarketing/pdfs/Smrt%20Mkgt %20Apr2011Organic.pdf


Progress 10/01/09 to 09/30/10

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Worked with research staff at the Mann library including two graduate students in the Dyson School of Applied Economics and Management to conduct an extensive review of research literature focusing on organic agricultural production as well as organic food and beverage processing. We were able to work with the New York office of USDA, NASS to obtain state level data from the Organic Ag. Production census conducted by USDA, NASS. Those results were released in March 2010. Organic production data are reported and analyzed in a published report. The publication is posted on the Charles H. Dyson School of Applied Economics and Management Outreach and Extension website. Publication has been linked to by other related websites. PARTICIPANTS: Several graduate students have been involved in the project, Jei Li and Amrit Singh both pursuing masters level studies in the Charles H. Dyson School for Applied Economics and Management, Cornell University. Staff with the Mann Library at Cornell University assisted in a literature review. Staff with the New York and national offices of NASS, USDA helped secure the data used in the initial report. Staff with the New York State Dept. of Ag. and Markets have collaborated. Other faculty in the College of Ag. and Life Science as well as the Geneva Ag. Experiment Station have collaborated. TARGET AUDIENCES: Target audiences include: current organic producers, producers considering the adoption of organic production methods, processors handling organic food products, food retailers, policy makers, Extension faculty and staff as well as the general public. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
Output from the first year includes a very useful report on the current status, scope and scale of organic agriculture in new York State. This information will prove useful to build upon during the duration of the project. The report provides useful production data benchmarks to help identify where there are opportunities for future growth or barriers to hinder expansion of organic agriculture in New York State. A presentation on the project was delivered to the Cornell Cooperative Extension educators at the Cornell Cooperative Extension Annual Food and Agriculture In-service held in Ithaca, NY on November 18, 2010. An invited presentation was given on the project at the Local Food & Fiber Fair held at Mann Library, College of Ag. and Lize Science, Cornell University on November 18, 2010.

Publications

  • Organic Agriculture in New York State, 2010. Dyson School Extension bulletin available at http://www.aem.cornell.edu/outreach/extensionpdf/2010/Cornell-Dyson-e b1013.pdf