Source: UNIVERSITY OF NEBRASKA submitted to NRP
ALLIANCE FOR FOOD PROTECTION, NE
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0218449
Grant No.
2009-34352-19745
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2009-03342
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Aug 1, 2009
Project End Date
Jul 31, 2011
Grant Year
2009
Program Code
[KY]- Alliance for Food Protection, NE
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF NEBRASKA
(N/A)
LINCOLN,NE 68583
Performing Department
Food Science & Technology
Non Technical Summary
This project has four main aspects related to food allergy. The first objective is to examine the digestive stability of food allergens and identify key structural components that may aid in their stability. Resistance to gastrointestinal digestion is believed to be a key characteristic of many food allergens due to the preservation of the protein structure. Knowledge of common structural characteristics of digestion-resistant food allergens may help to gain insight into the molecular basis of allergenicity of proteins. The second objective is to evaluate the major fish allergen, parvalbumin, by investigating the effects of species, calcium, thermal processing, and Maillard reactions on the antibody binding characteristics. The stability of parvalbumin and its IgE-binding ability under heating conditions will allow us to determine if cooked or heat-processed fish is as hazardous as raw fish. Ultimately, these results will allow better advice to be given to fish-allergic consumers regarding the hazards posed by various species of fish and fish processed in various ways. The third objective is to evaluate and improve methods for the assessment of the allergenicity of novel proteins and to build and curate version 10 of AllergenOnline which is a public database created through the efforts of the Food Allergy Research and Resource Program (FARRP) at the University of Nebraska. AllergenOnline has been very successful in recent years, providing the only peer-reviewed list of allergen sequences. We have a panel of internationally recognized allergy experts who set the criteria and will review the final list of allergens for possible inclusion in version 10 of AllergenOnline. Continuing to refine the criteria and reviewing the data supporting entries greatly enhances the quality and utility of the allergen database to help ensure a minimal risk of unnecessary allergenicity in future food products. The fourth objective is to continue the development and maintenance of research support databases. The Food Allergy Research & Resource Program currently maintains the published literature databases containing nearly 15,000 entries. The information in these databases can be accessed by food industry researchers and worldwide researchers as well as the FARRP research team. Development of an improved web site could enhance scholarly reviews, industry advice and other useful features that are created primarily from the publications databases.
Animal Health Component
25%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
75%
Applied
25%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2012299100025%
2012410100015%
7122410109015%
7122410115015%
7120810109015%
7120810115015%
Goals / Objectives
This project has several goals and objectives. (1) To examine the digestion stability of food allergens including to (a) identify intact allergens and digestion-resistant peptides/fragments after in vitro digestion, and (b) determine and compare the structure of intact allergens and digestion-resistant fragments after in vitro digestion. (2) To assess the allergenicity of fish and ingredients derived from fish including to (a) evaluate the comparative content and antigenicity of parvalbumin (major fish allergen) from various species of fish, and (b) determine the effects of thermal processing on the structure and antigenicity of parvalbumin. (3) To evaluate and improve various approaches used to assess the potential allergenicity of novel proteins that may occur in genetically modified and other novel foods. Specifically, this project will provide partial support to allow the development of version 10 of the AllergenOnline database, a publicly available database of known allergen sequences. (4) To develop and maintain research support databases containing over 15,000 published journal articles on food allergy which provide food industry and worldwide researchers, and the FARRP research team with over critical information on food allergen research. The outputs of this project will include the publication of critical information on the allergenicity of various fish species and fish-derived ingredients widely used in foods, the publication of critical information on the digestion stability of intact allergens and digestion-resistant fragments and characterization of structural properties that aid in their stability and allergenicity, the release of AllergenOnline version 10 allergen sequence database on the AllergenOnline web site.
Project Methods
This project will expand the current knowledge related to four major aspects related to food allergy. (1) The digestion stability of known food allergens will be assessed. Protein from raw or roasted seed or tree nuts will be extracted then isolated and purified using ammonia sulfate precipitation and a series of size exclusion, ion exchange, and hydrophobic interaction chromatography utilizing FPLC or HPLC. Protein fractions will be monitored using SDS-PAGE and sequence analysis will be conducted using liquid chromatography and tandem mass spectroscopy (LC/MS/MS). Purified allergens will undergo tryptic digestion at 37C for up to four hours. Digestion stability of these allergens will be monitored using SDS-PAGE, and LC/MS/MS will be used to identify the sequence of resistant proteins and peptides. The secondary structural characteristics and differences of purified native proteins and digestion-resistant proteins and peptides will be assessed using circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. (2) The allergenicity of fish and ingredients derived from fish will be assessed by examining antibody binding characteristics of the major fish allergen, parvalbumin, using SDS-PAGE and immunoblotting techniques to investigate if the parvalbumin content and isotypes contribute to the differences in antibody binding. Parvalbumin isotypes will be identified with 2D gel electrophoresis and LC/MS/MS. The effects of thermal processing treatments, calcium concentration, and Maillard reactions on reactivity of parvalbumin-specific IgG and IgE will be evaluated using indirect ELISA methods. (3) Bioinformatics approaches (computer assisted sequence comparison analysis) used to assess the potential allergenicity of novel proteins that may occur in genetically modified and other novel foods will continue to be developed and improved with the release of version 10 of the AllergenOnline database, a publicly available database of known allergen sequences. Proteins identified as allergens in scientific publications will be evaluated by a panel of allergy experts for inclusion in AllergenOnline. Criteria for inclusion of proteins as allergens include: Protein (gene) isolated from a documented allergenic source, study subjects with described allergic symptoms consistent with exposure, specific IgE testing included controls and characterized test materials. The current version of AllergenOnline will be updated with the anticipated January 2010 release of version 10. (4) The literature on food and other allergens is pivotal to the identification of proteins that should be evaluated for possible inclusion in the AllergenOnline database. Various library databases (e.g. Medline, Toxline, etc.) and Current Contents are screened continuously for publications that merit inclusion into the research support publications database. Each publication is then reviewed and key words are assigned to allow its retrieval during searches on specific topics. The publication is entered into the database which is maintained by the ProCite software package. Literature in this database is used to develop review articles, web site reviews and other materials on food allergens.

Progress 08/01/09 to 07/31/11

Outputs
OUTPUTS: The digestion stability of tree nut proteins may contribute to the intrinsic allergenicity of these foods. The digestion of soluble walnut and pecan proteins was carried out in simulated gastric fluid (SGF) and simulated intestinal fluid (SIF) using different ratios of protease to substrate. High molecular weight proteins of both tree nuts were found to be labile to digestion in SGF and SIF compared to low molecular weight proteins, especially the 2S albumins. These digestion-resistant proteins and peptides retain IgE binding despite extensive proteolytic digestion. Parvalbumin is recognized as an important pan-allergen in fish and frog that is capable of triggering IgE-mediated reactions in fish-allergic individuals. The reactivity of the polyclonal anti-cod parvalbumin antibody, and the commercially-available, monoclonal antifrog and anti-carp parvalbumin antibodies against raw muscle extracts of 25 fish species were determined using an indirect ELISA and IgG immunoblotting. The polyclonal anti-cod parvalbumin antibody showed reactivity to a wider range of fish species, whereas the monoclonal anti-frog parvalbumin antibody showed the least cross-reactivity. Additionally, the expression of parvalbumins in carp, catfish, and albacore tuna were evaluated using the indirect ELISA and SDS-PAGE. The parvalbumin content decreased from the anterior to the posterior positions of these fish species. These results suggested that the anti-cod parvalbumin antibody appeared to be more suitable for the detection of fish parvalbumin in foods, although limitations still exist regarding to the inconsistent binding to different species of fish. Various library databases and Current Contents are being screened continuously for publications on food allergens and clinical reports of food allergies to update the Food Allergy Research and Resource Program (FARRP) allergen database. This database has aided our bioinformatics expert in compiling a list of proteins for assessment and identification of key supporting documentation needed by the panel of allergy experts for inclusion of the allergen in the AllergenOnline database. The AllergenOnline database was updated twice during the granting period to its current version of 11.0 in February 2011. Version 11.0 contains a comprehensive list (1491 sequence entries from 265 species that are clustered into 553 protein groups) of unique proteins of known and putative allergenic proteins (food, airway, venom/salivary and contact) with sufficient evidence judged by the panel to be called allergens or putative allergens. The updates replace version 9.0 with 1386 sequences. Sequences and other reference information for version 11.0 were downloaded in May 2010 and compared with all sequences contained in version 9.0 and 10.0 including those listed as allergens and putative allergens and those that were not listed as they were judged to have insufficient evidence to be defined as allergens in version 10.0. Source and sequence information from NCBI as well as data from allergy studies were gleaned from AllergenOnline version 10.0, IUIS, Allergome, PubMed and individual publications. PARTICIPANTS: Jelena Spiric is a Masters student in the Department of Food Science and Technology at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln. The examination of the digestive stability of pecan and walnut allergens and characterization of intact protein and digestion-resistant fragments is her Masters research project. Poi-Wah Lee is a Ph.D. student in Department of Food Science and Technology at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln and the assessment of the allergenicity of fish and ingredients derived from fish is part of her Ph.D. dissertation research. Dr. Steve Taylor and Dr. Joseph Baumert are the principal investigators of this grant and supervise the graduate students previously mentioned. Jamie Kabourek (M.S., R.D.) is the Resource Manager with the Food Allergy Research and Resource Program (FARRP) at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln. Jamie manages the continuous update of the FARRP allergen database. John Wise is a bioinformatics specialist with FARRP at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln. John compiles the initial list of proteins for assessment and identifies key supporting documentation, develops the new version of AllergenOnline and makes the new version publically available on the AllergenOnline website. Dr. Rick Goodman is the director of AllergenOnline and supervises the work conducted by John Wise as well as leads the peer review team consisting of allergen experts from around the world. TARGET AUDIENCES: Three target audiences exist for the research being conducted to characterize the digestive stability of food allergens and assessment of the allergenicity of fish and ingredients derived from fish. Scientific researchers will benefit from the additional characterization of additional tree nut and fish allergens and evaluation of their relative stability under proteolytic and thermal processing conditions as this information may provide insight into additional research avenues that examine techniques that could be used to decrease the immunoreactivity of these allergenic proteins. Examination of the stability of food allergens may also aid in the improvement of immunoassays for detection of allergenic residues as the stable proteins identified in this research may be utilized in the immunoassays for improved detection in highly processed foods. Food processors may be interested in the characterization of fish allergens as this research could lead to the development of an immunoassay capable of detecting multiple fish species. Currently there are no immunoassays capable of detecting fish residue from multiple species so reliable detection is limited. Regulatory agencies may also be interested in these immunoassays to ensure that processed food products on the market are in compliance. Scientists in academia, government, and private industry will be interested in the new version of AllergenOnline for risk assessment of potential allergenicity of the genetically engineered or novel food proteins that they are researching. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
The prevalence of walnut and pecan allergies is common among allergic consumers with tree nut allergies. Allergic reactions to walnut and pecan can be severe and occasionally life threatening. There is limited information available on characterizing the stability of walnut and pecan allergens. The 2S albumins from walnut and pecan remain stable despite extensive in vitro gastrointestinal digestion. The digestion stability of the 2S albumins may contribute to allergic sensitization to walnut and pecan. Identification of digestion resistant peptides is an important factor contributing to assessment on food protein allergenicity. The presence of undeclared fish parvalbumin in foods can pose serious health risks among fish-allergic consumers and present liability issues for the food industry. However, current methods present shortcomings in consistently detecting the allergenic residues from all species of fish. Monoclonal antifrog and anti-carp parvalbumin antibodies are commercially available, however, the anti-cod parvalbumin antibody developed by the Food Allergy Research and Resource Program (FARRP) appeared to be more suitable for the detection of fish parvalbumin in foods, although limitations still exist regarding to the inconsistent binding to different species of fish. The variation of the parvalbumin content in muscle tissues located in different parts of the fish could affect the ability of these anti-parvalbumin antibodies to detect undeclared fish residues in foods, depending on which parts of fish muscles that are incorporated in the foods. The up-to-date literature in the FARRP allergen database has been used to develop scholarly review articles, website reviews, and other scholarly materials that benefit the broader research community on food allergens. The literature database has also been instrumental for the development of the new version of AllergenOnline which can be utilized by academic scientists, government regulators, and private industry for risk assessment of potential allergenicity of the genetically engineered or novel food proteins.

Publications

  • Lee P, Nordlee JA, Koppelman SJ, Baumert JL, Taylor SL. 2011. Evaluation and comparison of the species-specificity of 3anti-parvalbumin IgG antibodies. J Agri Food Chem. (Accepted for publication).
  • Lee P, Nordlee JA, Koppelman SJ, Baumert JL, Taylor SL. 2011. Characterization of IgG and IgE binding to parvalbumin derived from commercially important fish species. J Allergy Clinical Immunol. 127: AB32.
  • Spiric J, Knulst A, Nordlee JA, Koppelman SJ, Taylor SL, Baumert JL. 2011. Identification and characterization of digestion-resistant allergens in walnut and pecan species. Allergy. 66(Suppl. 94):532.
  • Lee P, Nordlee JA, Koppelman SJ, Baumert JL, Taylor SL. 2010. Binding characteristics of anti-parvalbumin antibodies to the muscle extracts derived from various fish species and distribution with whole fish. Allergy. 65(Suppl. 92):324.


Progress 08/01/09 to 07/31/10

Outputs
OUTPUTS: This project was recently funded, starting in August of 2009. Good progress has already been made toward the four main goals and objectives outlined in this project. Objective 1: Pepsin digestion experiments are underway to examine the stability of 2S albumins from peanut and tree nuts under reducing and non-reducing conditions. Identification and characterization of digestion-resistant proteins and peptide fragments will follow. Objective 2: The immunoreactivity of parvalbumin from 15 different species of fish has been evaluated using 3 anti-parvalbumin antibodies (anti-frog parvalbumin, anti-cod parvalbumin, and anti-carp parvalbumin). Differences in parvalbumin content across the longitudinal position of carp and catfish using indirect ELISA and SDS-PAGE techniques are currently being evaluated to determine if sub-sampling from different areas of the fish will affect detectable parvalbumin content. Objectives 3 and 4: Various library databases and Current Contents are being screened continuously for publications on food allergens and clinical reports of food allergies to update the Food Allergy Research and Resource Program (FARRP) allergen database. This database has aided our bioinformatics expert in compiling a list of proteins for assessment and identification of key supporting documentation needed by the panel of allergy experts for inclusion of the allergen in the AllergenOnline database. The expert panel is currently reviewing the list of potential allergenic proteins and the version 10 of AllergenOnline will be developed in the coming months with a public release anticipated in January 2010. PARTICIPANTS: Jelena Spiric is a Masters student in Food Science and Technology at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln. The examination of the digestive stability of food allergens and characterization of intact protein and digestion-resistant fragments is her Masters research project. Poi-Wah Lee is a Ph.D. student in Food Science & Technology at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln and the assessment of the allergenicity of fish and ingredients derived from fish is part of her Ph.D. dissertation research. Dr. Steve Taylor and Dr. Joe Baumert are the principle investigators of this grant and supervise of the graduate students previously mentioned. Jamie Kabourek (M.S., R.D.) is the Resource Manager with the Food Allergy Research and Resource Program (FARRP) at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln. Jamie manages the continuous update of the FARRP allergen database. John Wise is a bioinformatics specialist with FARRP at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln. John compiles the initial list of proteins for assessment and identifies key supporting documentation, develops the new version of AllergenOnline and makes the new version publically available on the AllergenOnline website. Dr. Rick Goodman is the director of AllergenOnline and leads the peer review team consisting of allergen experts from around the world. TARGET AUDIENCES: Three target audiences exist for the research being conducted to characterize the digestive stability of food allergens and assessment of the allergenicity of fish and ingredients derived from fish. Scientific researchers will benefit from the additional characterization of peanut, tree nut, and fish allergens and evaluation of their relative stability under proteolytic and thermal processing conditions as this information may provide insight into additional research avenues that examine techniques that could be used to decrease the immunoreactivity of these allergenic proteins. Examination of the stability of food allergens may also aid in the improvement of immunoassays for detection of allergenic residues as the stable proteins identified in this research may be utilized in the immunoassays for improved detection in highly processed foods. Food processors may be interested in the characterization of fish allergens as this research could lead to the development of an immunoassay capable of detecting multiple fish species. Currently there are no immunoassays capable of detecting fish residue from multiple species so reliable detection is limited. Regulatory agencies may also be interested in these immunoassays to ensure that processed food products on the market are in compliance. Scientists in academia, government, and private industry will be interested in the new version of AllergenOnline for risk assessment of potential allergenicity of the genetically engineered or novel food proteins that they are researching. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
The outcomes/impacts of this research cannot be accurately measured at this time as the research data is just beginning to be analyzed. The up-to-date literature in the FARRP allergen database has been used to develop scholarly review articles, website reviews, and other scholarly materials that benefit the broader research community on food allergens. The literature database has also been instrumental for the development of the new version of AllergenOnline.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period