Source: UNIVERSITY OF VERMONT submitted to NRP
HERBACEOUS PERENNIALS HARDINESS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0215222
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Oct 1, 2008
Project End Date
Oct 1, 2011
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF VERMONT
(N/A)
BURLINGTON,VT 05405
Performing Department
Plant & Soil Science
Non Technical Summary
There are over 460 firms in the environmental horticulture industry in Vermont (Perry and Stack, 2006), those that derive over half their income from this industry. Most of these either sell or install (landscapers) perennials. The production and sale of herbaceous perennials is still strong after two and a half decades of recent growth, and is likely to remain so in the future. This crop continues to increase in popularity and sales, and is a key income or growth area for many firms, even during recessionary times. Wholesale floriculture production figures show that even though overall sales dropped by one percent, the first time in over a dozen years, sales of herbaceous perennials were $619 for 2003 or up one percent over the previous year (Neal, 2004). With overall wholesale floriculture crop value of $5.4 billion in 2005, resulting in $19.4 billion in floriculture retail sales, herbaceous perennials ranked third with 12% of sales, compared to 17% for flowering potted plants and 47% for bedding plants (which increasingly also include some perennials). Practical answers to grower problems overwintering an increasing diversity of plants, will help make producers more competitive. This is increasingly a factor with increased global mail order and internet sales and websites. By knowing more details on how key factors influence the container plants they are overwintering, growers will be better able to manage conditions and culture to overwinter their perennials successfully and with minimal losses. Such answers from our studies thus will increase the efficiency, productivity and so profitability of those growing and using herbaceous perennials both commercially and at home. The result will be a more viable and sustainable industry. A proven history of industry support over many years attests to the value of such results to the industry, and potential for their future support. The University of Vermont is an ideal location for winter hardiness studies, given the climate for outdoor trials, protocol, and baseline results established with previous Hatch projects and industry support. With 27 years of research by the PI on perennial production, and particularly on hardiness and overwintering, a critical mass of information in this area is being developed. This is recognized in Vermont, as well as nationally and internationally in publications and invited presentations. Joint appointment of the PI in Extension has facilitated timely and effective distribution of results to the appropriate audiences. Previous results have been sought by several trade journals and groups, attesting to their usefulness (see Curriculum Vitae). A web page developed by the PI on the internet, partially supported by funds from a New England grower association (http://perrysperennials.info) is the latest method to be used for dissemination of such results.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2032120106080%
2032140106020%
Goals / Objectives
1. To determine least survival temperatures under controlled conditions of 12 groundcover perennials in containers, as chosen from field trials, results of previous studies, and selections of interest to wholesale growers. A final year is proposed and has been funded to examine a third brand of these perennials, including species not yet studied. Any species with questionable results from the previous two years (see above) also will be reexamined. Determining relative hardiness under similar controlled conditions for at least three dozen cultivars of most interest to growers and retailers will be useful to them in production and retailing. 2. To determine the effect of various mid-winter temperature deacclimation situations on subsequent hardiness and survival. An aspect of the overwintering of perennials not yet studied is the effect of increased temperatures during sunny winter days in greenhouses on deacclimation of perennials, and their subsequent ability to withstand cold temperatures. This is a common situation in production greenhouses in northern climates. Three aspects to this situation will be determined for select popular perennials to still remain hardy including the increased temperature plants can tolerate, the amount of daily cycling from cold to warm, and when unhardened the temperatures and time needed for plants to reacclimate. 3. To determine compost and fertility effects on hardiness and regrowth. A major interest to fund of the national Perennial Plant Association is the effect of media and fertility on perennial production. This recently funded study will examine the effects of two local Vermont compost products and two fertility regimes on the production growth and economics of three popular perennial cultivars, and their subsequent overwintering and regrowth. 4. To determine optimal fall acclimation temperatures. Although 4C has been generally used as a fall acclimation temperature in previous studies, whether this is optimal has not been determined. For several important perennials the cold above-freezing temperature in fall, and time at that temperature, for optimal hardening and winter survival will be determined in controlled freezing studies. 5. To determine least survival temperatures under controlled conditions of coralbells (Heuchera), and other popular cultivars, in containers, and in field trials. One of the most popular perennial general recently, and having dozens of new introductions from the U.S. and abroad, is coralbells. Hardiness of these new introductions being widely marketed has not been determined, and is of great interest to northern growers. Field trials in USDA hardiness zone 4A and in controlled freezing studies will begin to address relative hardiness of popular new introductions in this and other subsequent genera to be studied as determined through grower input. Plants are currently being provided with funding recommended by key industry leaders.
Project Methods
Relative hardiness of significant herbaceous perennial genera in the field and under controlled and uniform freezing conditions will be determined. Effects on hardiness of select significant cultivars will be determined under varying regimes of mid-winter elevated deacclimation temperatures. Optimal temperatures for fall hardiness will be determined as well as the optimum time needed for hardiness to develop. Compost and fertility effects and combinations will be studied for select perennials both for summer growth and winter hardiness. For all studies, plants will be grown in the field or nursery conditions in Vermont in USDA hardiness zone 4A, or in a greenhouse. Greenhouse temperatures will be maintained above freezing with a target of 5C. Plants will be frozen as required in temperature-controlled chest freezers using previously-determined protocol. Data will be taken, analyzed statistically as appropriate, with results reported in referred journals, journals of funding associations, on the PI website, and in presentations. Results will enable growers to manage overwintering of perennials in northern climates with better survival, to be able to predict effects of various overwintering conditions on subsequent survival, and to sell perennials with hardiness appropriate to their regions and zones.

Progress 10/01/08 to 10/01/11

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Many retail and wholesale nurseries grow herbaceous perennials, and many such growers in northern climates need to successfully overwinter plants either in production, or held from the previous year, in overwintering structures such as greenhouses. This study contributed to the knowledge of how cycling temperatures (hot and cold) in winter affect hardiness, as well as soil moisture and plant age (vigor) effects. Results will be shared with industry both in their publications and presentations, in journal articles, and on the author's Perry's Perennial Pages website. Based on these results, future studies will investigate the effect on hardiness of midwinter deacclimation temperatures. PARTICIPANTS: Sarah Kingsley-Richards is a MS graduate student in the Department of Plant and Soil Science. Dr. Leonard Perry, Extension Professor, was the PI. Supplemental funding was provided by partner organizations New England Grows, a New England conference annually funding research and education in ornamental horticulture; and the Vermont Nursery and Landscape Association. TARGET AUDIENCES: ornamental greenhouse and nursery growers PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
Perennial growers overwintering plant stock require information to assist in deciding which containerized plants are most likely to successfully overwinter. Such results will result in significant economic savings in both fuel and plant losses. Three studies on container-grown herbaceous perennials were conducted to examine the influence of plant age, soil moisture, and temperature cycling date on cold hardiness. In January, plants were exposed to controlled freezing temperatures of -2, -5, -8, -11, and -14C and then returned to a 3-5C greenhouse. In June, plants were assessed using a visual rating scale of 1-5 (1 = dead, 3-5 = increasing salable quality, varying by cultivar) and dry weights of new growth were determined. Controlled freezing in November and March were also included in the third study. In the first study, two ages of plants were exposed to controlled freezing temperatures in January. For Geranium x cantabrigiense 'Karmina', age had no effect on either rating or dry weight in one study year. In two Sedum 'Matrona' study years, age had no effect on dry weight but ratings were higher for older plants than younger plants in the first year and higher for younger plants than older plants in the second year. In two Leucanthemum x superbum 'Becky' study years, age had an effect on both rating and dry weight which were both generally higher for younger plants than older plants. In the second study, plants were maintained in pots at two different soil moisture levels prior to exposure to controlled freezing temperatures in January. Coreopsis 'Tequila Sunrise' and Carex morrowii 'Ice Dance' showed no effect on either rating or dry weight from soil moisture level. Soil moisture level had no effect on dry weight but ratings were higher for Geranium x cantabrigiense 'Cambridge' wet plants and for Heuchera 'Plum Pudding' dry plants. Carex laxiculmus 'Hobb' (Bunny Blue TM) soil moisture level had an effect where dry weight was higher for dry plants. Means at were of salable quality for Geranium and Heuchera at all temperatures and Carex laxiculmus at temperatures above -11C. The effects of soil moisture level on Carex oshimensis were inconclusive. In the third Study, during November, January, and March, plants were subjected to temperature cycling treatments prior to exposure to controlled freezing temperatures. Geranium x cantabrigiense 'Cambridge' were more tolerant of both temperature cycling and freezing temperatures in January and an increased number ofcycles in November had an advantageous effect. Sedum 'Matrona' were more tolerant of temperature cycling and freezing temperatures in January and an increased number of cycles in March had an advantageous effect. Leucanthemum x superbum 'Becky' were more tolerant of temperature cycling in January in the second year ofthe study and an increased number of cycles in November had an advantageous effect in the first year and in all months in the second year.

Publications

  • Kingsley-Richards, Sarah L. (2011) Influence of plant age, soil moisture, and temperature cycling date on container-grown herbaceous perennials. MS thesis. Department of Plant and Soil Science, University of Vermont. May.


Progress 10/01/09 to 09/30/10

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Many growers of herbaceous perennials in northern climates need to successfully overwinter plants either in production, or held from the previous year. Often this is done in greenhouses which can heat during sunny winter days. This study this past winter continued to address this effect of mid-winter possible deacclimation by warm, or cycling, temperatures. Based on outcomes, a similar study with the same Shasta daisy and a foamflower will be repeated, to get a better understanding of these effects and on a wider range of species. Results will be shared with industry both in their publications and presentations, and on the author's Perry's Perennial Pages website. PARTICIPANTS: Not relevant to this project. TARGET AUDIENCES: nursery and greenhouse growers through extension outreach in presentations and online PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
The second winter of this study examined a marginally hardy species of perennial shasta daisy (Becky) and a normally hardy selection of yarrow (Apricot Delight), both popular perennials. Result showed that in midwinter (January), even just 5 days at 16C was enough to deacclimate plants, resulting in loss in subsequent subzero soil temperatures. Returning plants to 4C during the night did not compensate for the deacclimation. There were no differences between one or two weeks held at 16C prior to subsequent freezing. Plants in a normally fluctuating greenhouse (-2 to 8C, mean 4C), continuous 4 or 2C showed no differences, all surviving similarly. This study also supported previous results that plants not sufficiently rooted had poor winter survival, so this study will be repeated one more year. Growers overwintering perennials will benefit from knowing the effect of mid-winter high temperatures and cycling on subsequent plant survival when exposed to freezing. This will enable them to save money either in plant losses, scheduling labor and covering treatments more appropriately, and saving costs and fuel in heating if not needed.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 10/01/08 to 09/30/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: This project has as its components several industry funded applied projects relating to hardiness of herbaceous perennials. These include field and controlled freezing trials, both to determine lowest minimal winter temperatures, and effects of variables such as soil type and fertility, and mid-winter deacclimation on subsequent winter survival. Specific genera such as coralbells, and groupings such as groundcovers, also will be tested. Results will be shared in presentations, articles, and on the author's Perry's Perennial Pages website. PARTICIPANTS: Dr Leonard Perry, PI, University of Vermont. Funding provided by New England Grows, Vermont Nursery and Landscape Assn., New England Floriculture, Perennial Plant Association, New Hampshire Floriculture Endowment. TARGET AUDIENCES: greenhouse and nursery perennial growers, home gardeners PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
During the winter of 2008-2009 three studies were conducted. Nine cultivars of groundcover plants were frozen under controlled conditions during midwinter to one of 5 subzero temperatures (-2,-5,-8,-11,-14C) then evaluated in spring for survival and regrowth parameters. Of these 5 were found hardy to the lowest temperature with no differences among treatments, the other 4 were moderately hardy. In the second study, 5 species of popular herbaceous perennials, grown the previous season in 6 media and fertilizer combinations were overwintered outdoors using standard overwintering fabrics as used by growers. There were no differences in survival among treatments. The third study examined midwinter deacclimation of a marginally hardy species of perennial Salvia (Rhapsody in Blue) and a normally hardy selection of Sedum (Neon), both popular perennials. Results showed that in midwinter (January), even just 5 days at 16C was enough to deacclimate plants, resulting in loss in subsequent subzero soil temperatures. The greatest loss was at lower soil temperatures on freezing, -8C and below for Sedum and -11C and below for Salvia. Returning plants to 4C during the night did not compensate for the deacclimation. There were no differences between one or two weeks held at 16C prior to subsequent freezing. Plants in a normally fluctuating greenhouse (-2 to 8C, mean 4C), continuous 4 or 2C showed no differences, all surviving similarly. Both growers and home gardeners will benefit from these studies by knowing to what temperatures, and under what conditions in winter, herbaceous perennials will withstand. Perennials are one of the most important groups of plants sold, and bought by gardeners, in the ornamental horticulture industry. Such information will lead to more success at plant selection and overwintering in northern regions. Such controlled freezing studies on perennial hardiness are not being done in other parts of northern latitudes.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period