Source: LOUISIANA STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
DURABILE WOOD-BASED PRODUCTS/COMPOSITES FROM RECYCLED WOOD AND PLASTIC MATERIALS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0214198
Grant No.
2008-34158-19400
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2008-03507
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2008
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2010
Grant Year
2008
Program Code
[BB]- Wood Utilization (AK, ID, ME, MI, MN, MS, NC, OR, TN, WV)
Recipient Organization
LOUISIANA STATE UNIVERSITY
202 HIMES HALL
BATON ROUGE,LA 70803-0100
Performing Department
School of Renewable Natural Resources
Non Technical Summary
Wood is the world's most sustainable building material. Nearly all of the 1.5 million homes constructed in the United States each year have light frames made of wood. Wood and wood-based composites are being utilized in both interior and exterior applications and frequently are the principal structural elements in buildings. Unless protected, wood is naturally degraded by combinations of heat, moisture, insects, decay, mold and intermittent catastrophic forces such as hurricanes and floods. New generation wood-based composites offer enhanced long-term durability for structures typically constructed with natural-wood products. Among the composite products, wood-plastic composites are being developed for both structural and non-structural uses. The mechanical properties of these composites depend largely on fiber quality, fiber-matrix interface, and fiber-polymer mixing ratios. Combining plastics with wood fibers to produce high quality industrial products provides a prospective solution for value-added utilization of the biomass resources. Currently, chemically-treated wood is widely used in residential and industrial wood structures for improved durability. Concerns regarding the disposal of chromated copper arsenate (CCA)-treated wood have heightened in recent years as a result of greater public awareness of potential dangers of environmental arsenic. Consequently, a large quantity of decommissioned treated wood flows into the waste stream each year with most sent to landfills. Disposal of treated wood presents particular long-term problems for landfills, and burning is unacceptable, except in certified incinerators, due to the release of gases and ash containing toxic compounds. A substantial amount of decommissioned wood could be reused to produce value-added, structural engineering components. The development of a recycling system to reuse and recycle decommissioned treated wood and preservative chemicals would alleviate these challenges.
Animal Health Component
80%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
80%
Developmental
20%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
4030650200050%
5110650202050%
Goals / Objectives
The proposed project consists of two major components: 1) development of technoligically feasible and economically acceptable solutions for using wood fibers and commingled plastics to manufacture durable building materials; and 2) development of a recycling system to reuse and recycle decommissioned treated wood and preservative chemicals. The specific aims for each of the two components are outlined below. Wood Fiber plastics composites: 1) Study the effects of multifunctional coupling agents and reactive chain extenders and micro-crosslinkers on in situ fiber-plastics compatibility and the properties of obtained composites; 2) Investigate process variables for manufacturing wood and natural fiber reinforced commingled plastic composites; 3) Develop and optimize extrusion technology for manufacturing the composite material at the production scale, and 4) Optimize long-term durability performance of the composites for building industrial applications. Special emphasis will be placed on long-term durability performance of the composites during the funding period. Treated wood recycling: 1) Evaluate cradle-to-grave flow, and physical and mechanical properties of decommissioned, treated wood as affected by location (residential, exterior, and underground), service age, and preservative type; 2) Determine the effects of preservative retention rate on the bonding of decommissioned wood treated with CCA, creosote, or penta; 3) Develop finite element models for design optimization and performance assessment, and 4) Develop a multi-product closed loop recycling system featuring novel engineered wood products and chemical extraction methods. Special emphasis will be placed on the development of an econmically viable and environmentally friendly closed loop recycling system during the funding period.
Project Methods
Nearly all of the 1.5 million homes constructed in the United States each year have light frames made of wood. Wood and wood-based composites are being utilized in both interior and exterior applications and frequently are the principal structural elements in buildings. These applications include sheathing, floor, I-beams, door and window components, joists, and molded wall panels as both skin and structural elements. Wood, unless protected, is naturally degraded by combinations of heat, moisture, insects, decay, mold and other forces such as hurricanes and floods. All of these are common to the southern states, including Alabama, California, Florida, Louisiana, Georgia, Mississippi, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, and Hawaii. For example, the most common destructive element currently at the forefront is the Formosan subterranean termite (Coptotermes Formosanus). Formosan subterranean termites are recognized as the most destructive insect in Louisiana, costing an estimated $500 million per year to homeowners in structure damage, repair and treatment, with approximately $350 million of that in New Orleans alone. The high humidity and heat in the region also provide a fertile atmosphere for growth of decay and mold inside walls and attics. New generation wood-based composites (e.g., wood plastic composites) and chemically treated wood offer enhanced long-term durability for wood-based structures. Technological feasibility to manufacture the composite materials from treated wood and recycled plastics must be quantified. The proposed project consists of two major components: 1) development of technologically feasible and economically acceptable solutions of using wood fibers and commingled plastics for manufacturing durable building materials; and 2) development of a recycling system to reuse and recycle decommissioned treated wood and preservative chemicals. Special emphasis will be placed on long-term durability performance of the composites, and on evaluating cradle-to-grave flow, and physical and mechanical properties of decommissioned, treated wood as affected by location (residential, exterior, and underground), service age, and preservative type during the funding period. The proposed investigation is consistent with national interests in developing high-value biobased products as a substitute for petroleum-based feedstocks and products. The technology developed can lead to improved energy efficiency, significant rural economic development, and great environmental benefits.

Progress 09/01/08 to 08/31/10

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Based on a novel two-step reactive extrusion technology, we were able to produce poly(ethylene terephthalate) PET/high density polyethylene (HDPE) microfibrillar blends and subsequently to introduce wood fibers into the blends created wood plastic composite with improved mechanical performances. A US patent has been applied for that describes a process that separates chromated copper arsenate (CCA) from spent CCA-treated wood. Copper, chromium, and arsenic components as well as a detoxified wood product are recovered for recycling. The process covers not only the separation of CCA from wood but also the recycling of both CCA and a detoxified wood product that results from the process. It is based on the use of microwave heating, wood liquefaction, and wastewater treatment and, therefore it offers numerous technical options for improvements to the constituting process in both technique and processing equipment. The microwave reactor and liquefaction temperature is much lower than the releasing point of arsenic, and the process is easily controlled. PARTICIPANTS: Qinglin Wu, Professor, School of Renewable Natural Resources, LSU AgCenter; Yong Lei, Postdoc Researcher, School of Renewable Natural Resources, LSU AgCenter; C Piao, Assistant Professor, Calhoun Research Station, LSU AgCenter; CJ Monlezun, Professor, Department of Experimental Statistics, LSU AgCenter; TF Shupe, Professor, School of Renewable Natural Resources, LSU AgCenter TARGET AUDIENCES: wood plastic composite manufacturers, plastics recycler, general public wood preservation industry, treated wood recycling industry, utility industry PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
High-melting-temperature poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) was successfully introduced into wood plastic composites through a two-step reactive extrusion technology. Wood flour was added into pre-prepared PET/high density polyethylene (HDPE) microfibrillar blends (MFBs) in the second extrusion at the temperature for processing HDPE. Addition of 25% in situ formed PET microfibers obviously increased the mechanical properties of HDPE, and more significant enhancement by the in situ-formed recycled PET microfibers was observed for the recycled HDPE. Adding 2% E-GMA improved the compatibility between matrix and microfibers in MFBs, resulting in further enhanced mechanical properties. The subsequent addition of 40% wood flour did not influence the size and morphology of PET microfibers and improved the comprehensive mechanical properties of MFBs. The wood flour increased the crystallinity level of HDPE in the compatibilized MFB in which PET phase did not crystallize. The storage modulus of MFB was greatly improved by wood flour. The technology provides a way for using recycled engineering plastics for wood plastic composite manufacturing. CCA-treated wood is first extracted in a microwave reactor in the presence of acid solutions (i.e., acetic acid, oxalic acid, and phosphoric acid) and the combination of these acids at a temperature of 70 - 160 C (step1). This treatment solvates or dissolves CCA into an acid solution and this acid-extracted CCA solution can then be easily drained off through a filter and separated from the wood (step 2). To this solution, precipitants or complex agents for the hazardous elements (Cr, Cu and As), such as Ca(OH)2 or phosphoric acid (in the case where it was not used in the acid extraction), are added and the solution is agitated and then allowed to form sedimentation (step 3). The sediment, which contains Cr, Cu, and As, is then separated from the solution by centrifugation or filtration. By this process, more than 99% of the Cu, Cr, and As are removed. As the fourth step, the CCA-bearing sediment is regenerated by adding a concentrated inorganic acid such as sulfuric, nitric, or phosphoric acid, and can be reused as recycled CCA. For the fifth step, the recovered acid solution can be reused in the process without further treatment. As the sixth step, the wood liquefaction reagents are added to the microwave reactor containing the CCA-free-wood and reacts at 120 - 150 0C to convert the spent wood into a thick liquid with molecular weights ranging from several hundreds to several thousands. Finally, the liquefied wood solution is concentrated to a desirable concentration to be used as a bio-based raw material for the preparation of polymer materials, such as polyurethanes and phenolic adhesives. In this study, a dual acid system was found to be optimal, consisting of phosphoric acid from 0.5-3.5 (wt.%) and acetic acid (0.5-2.0) (wt.%). The metal recovery rate of As, Cr, and Cu was over 99% for most of the various experimental variables combinations.

Publications

  • Lei, Y., and Q. Wu. 2010. Wood plastic composites based on recycled high density polyethylene and poly(ethylene terephthalate) microfibillar blends. Bioresource Technology, 101:3665-3671.
  • Piao, C. C. J. Monlezun, T.F. Shupe. 2009. Glueline bonding performance of decommissioned CCA-treated wood. Part I: Without retreatment. Forest Products Journal. 59(7/8):36-42.


Progress 09/01/08 to 08/31/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Research in wood plastics composites focused on introducing high-melting-temperature poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) into wood plastic composites through a two-step reactive extrusion technology. Wood flour was added into pre-prepared PET/high density polyethylene (HDPE) microfibrillar blends (MFBs) in the second extrusion at the temperature for processing HDPE. Addition of 25% PET microfibers obviously increased the mechanical properties of HDPE, especially the tensile modulus which was increased by about 134%. Adding 2% E-GMA improved the compatibility between matrix and microfiber in MFBs, resulting increased mechanical properties. The subsequent addition of 40% wood flour did not influence the size and morphology of PET microfibers, and improved the comprehensive mechanical properties of MFBs. The wood flour increased the crystallinity level of HDPE in the compatibilized MFB in which PET phase did not crystallize. The storage modulus of MFB was greatly improved by wood flour. Research for the treated wood recycling project has focused on development of novel chemical means to detoxify and/or recover mixed preservative-treated wood waste and development of value-added engineered wood products from decommissioned CCA-treated wood. Regarding wood preservative detoxification/recycling, past work has focused on chromated copper arsenate (CCA), oil-borne pentachlorophenol (penta), and creosote. Hydrothermal treatment (HT) was applied to samples treated with these three wood preservatives on an equal mass basis. During HT treatment, creosote-derived hydrocarbon residues in the decommissioned treated wood were recovered and of the wood mass itself was transformed (95%) into a mixture of hydrocarbons including substituted benzenes, phenolics, and light PAHs. The metals from the CCA-treated wood were partially recovered (up to 48-88%) either in an acidified aqueous phase or as scale on the internal walls of the reactor. Some arsenic was likely transformed to arsine gas, which could be trapped and recovered under basic conditions. Penta was dechlorinated and removed to below detection limits. The HT process also resulted in the generation of industrially useful mixed hydrocarbons with substantial reduction in substrate mass. Thus, the preservative-treated wood as a hazardous waste was transformed into a complimentary mixture of liquid products. Creosote and CCA were recovered, and penta was degraded. Research on the development value-added engineered wood products from decommissioned CCA-treated wood included an investigation of the gluability of CCA treated utility pole wood plies cut from decommissioned southern pine (Pinus spp.) utility poles. Two surface treatment methods (priming and incising) were evaluated for their efficacy in improving the bonding performance of decommissioned utility pole wood and untreated virgin wood. Effects of CCA retention and distribution on glue-line shear strength and delamination were investigated. Results showed that CCA reduced glue-line shear strength. Incising had a marginally positive effect on glue-line shear strength and delamination. PARTICIPANTS: Qinglin Wu Todd Shupe TARGET AUDIENCES: wood composite industry/treated pole industry PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: none

Impacts
PET and HDPE are used extensively in packaging materials, and their annual rates of growth of production and consumption steadily increase. Combining PET and PE can yield unusual properties. With the price of petroleum soaring, plastic wastes are becoming of more interest as an inexpensive source of raw materials. The developed technology of making in-situ HDPE/PET microfibrillar blends through reactive extrusion at the processing temperature for PET, and then combining them with wood flour through the second extrusion at the processing temperature for HDPE led to a strong composite building material. The treated wood project is still underway and the true impact has yet to be realized. However, the potential economic and environmental impacts of this project are substantial. Disposal is generally considered the "Achilles heel" of the preservative-treated wood industry. Since approximately half of all southern pine lumber is preservative-treated, a strong wood preservation industry is vital for the overall wood industry as well as forest landowners. Processes that economically and environmentally recycle spent treated wood waste, have the potential to strengthen the wood preservation industry, enhance rural economic development, and enhance environmental stewardship by extending the service life of wood in service, reducing the demand for timber, and lessening the amount of treated wood sent to landfills. One Louisiana wood preservation facility has estimated the potential impact of this research to his facility to be between $1-$5 million per year.

Publications

  • Lei, Y., and Q. Wu. 2009. Wood plastic composites based on recycled high density polyethylene and poly(ethylene terephthalate) co-blend matrix. Bioresource Technology, Accepted. (IF=4.45) Catallo, W.J. and T.F. Shupe. 2008. Hydrothermal treatment of mixed preservative-treated wood waste. Holzforschung. 62(1):119-122.
  • Pan, H., C.Y. Hse, R.P. Gambrell, and T.F. Shupe. 2009. Fractionation of heavy metals in liquefied chromated copper arsenate (CCA)-treated wood sludge using a modified BCR-sequential extraction procedure. Chemosphere. 77:201-206. Piao, C. Charles J. Monlezun, T.F. Shupe. 2009. Glueline bonding performance of decommissioned CCA-treated wood. Part I: Without retreatment. Forest Products Journal. 59(7/8): in press.
  • Lei, Y., Q. Wu, and Q., Zhang. 2009. Microfibrillar composites based on recycled high density polyethylene and poly(ethylene terephthalate): morphological and mechanical properties. Composite Part A 40:904-912.