Source: UNIVERSITY OF NEBRASKA submitted to NRP
ALLIANCE FOR FOOD PROTECTION-NEBRASKA
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0214090
Grant No.
2008-34352-19287
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2008-03464
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Aug 1, 2008
Project End Date
Jul 31, 2010
Grant Year
2008
Program Code
[KY]- Alliance for Food Protection, NE
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF NEBRASKA
(N/A)
LINCOLN,NE 68583
Performing Department
FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
Non Technical Summary
This project has two major aspects related to food allergy. The first objective is to develop detection methods for residues of two commonly allergenic foods - buckwheat and pistachio. This group has previously develop detection methods for peanut, milk, egg, other tree nuts, soybeans, shrimp, clam, mustard, and lupine so these two additional methods help to complete the set needed by the food industry. The industry can uses to determine if its cleaning practices are sufficient or whether the use of shared equipment presents potential hazards to allergic consumers. The new buckwheat and pistachio assays will give food processors sensitive and specific techniques to detect inadvertent contamination of their raw materials and finished products with residues of either of these allergenic foods. Ultimately, the antibodies used in the pistachio detection method may be useful in the development of a multi-plex tree nut ELISA as we already have antibodies for walnut, almond, hazelnut, pecan, and cashew (but Brazil nut, macadamia nut, and pine nut are also missing). The second objective relates to the refinement of methods for the assessment of the potential allergenicity of genetically modified or other novel foods. These methods are needed to assess the potential risk and prevent the unintended introduction of a major allergen or protein that would likely cause allergic cross-reactions in some consumers. Bioinformatics approaches (computer assisted sequence comparison analysis) have been developed as one of the most important tools to identify potentially allergenic proteins. AllergenOnline is a public database created through the efforts of the Food Allergy Research and Resource Program (FARRP) at the University of Nebraska. The database provides a publicly available, searchable list of protein sequences of known allergens and bioinformatics strategies useful in comparing these sequences to those of novel proteins. FARRP will continue to screen the literature to identify new allergens so that the list can be annually updated. This database is used by academic and government scientists developing genetically engineered and other novel foods, by regulatory officials in many countries, and by the agricultural biotechnology industry in a key step in the overall allergenicity assessment process. As part of this project, we will assess the validity of the search criteria of 35% identity over any 80 amino acid segment as a predictor of allergenicity through serum testing of legume allergic subjects, using allergic sera. IgE-binding proteins will be separated, identified, and compared to known allergens in the database.
Animal Health Component
25%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
75%
Applied
25%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2012299100020%
2012299109020%
7121219109015%
7121219115015%
7121599109015%
7121599115015%
Goals / Objectives
This project has several goals and objectives: (1) To develop quick test methods for the detection of residues of buckwheat and pistachio in other foods; these residues can cause severe, life-threatening reactions in allergic individuals. (2) To use the developed buckwheat and pistachio detection methods to survey retail and other commercial food products and assess contamination levels. This will determine if products that are potentially hazardous to buckwheat- and pistachio-allergic consumers are present in the marketplace. (3) To evaluate and summarize the published scientific evidence that is used to assess the potential allergenicity of novel proteins that may occur in genetically modified and other novel foods. Specifically, that will involve comparisons of several ways to assess the structural similarity of proteins using bioinformatics. Additionally, this project will provide partial support to allow the development of version 9 of the AllergenOnline database, a publicly available database of known allergen sequences. The outputs of the project will include the development of test methods for pistachio and buckwheat residues and the publication of these methods in scientific journals, the release of the AllergenOnline, version 9 allergen sequence database on the AllergenOnline web site, and the publication of a manuscript that will compare various ways of assessing the structural similarity of proteins to predict allergenicity.
Project Methods
Antisera will be made against buckwheat and pistachio using standard procedures in rabbits, goats, and sheep. Two formats, a competition ELISA and a double antibody, sandwich-type ELISA will be tried. Sandwich-type ELISAs have been developed successfully for the detection of undeclared peanut, casein, egg, almond, walnut, hazelnut, cashew, sesame seed, shrimp, clam, lupine, and mustard proteins in food products in our laboratory. The sensitivity of the ELISAs will be determined using standard curves prepared with protein extracts from the specific foods with targeted detection limit of 1-2 ppm in various food systems. Regression analysis will be performed in the interpretation of the ELISA results. Once an assay with suitable sensitivity has been developed, the recovery of buckwheat spiked into wheat flour will be assessed, while the recovery of pistachio spiked into a cake mix will be assessed to determine if the presence of other food components will affect the sensitivity of the assay. The specificity of the ELISAs will be assessed by subjecting numerous components and ingredients of food and food products to rigorous testing in the ELISAs to evaluate any cross-reactions or non-specific interference using a broad assortment of foods and food ingredients. Since food processing operations (heat, acidity, etc.) can affect the extractability of food proteins or their detectability in immunoassays, buckwheat and pistachio, respectively, will be incorporated into foods at various levels, processed according to typical industry standards, and analyzed by the ELISAs to determine if processing will affect the utility of the ELISAs. The structural criteria to identify novel proteins as potential allergens will be assessed. The validity of the search criteria of 35% identity over any 80 amino acid segment will be evaluated for predictive value by serum testing of legume allergic subjects, using sera from the US, EU and India. IgE binding proteins will be identified. Cross-reactive proteins identified by either overall sequence homology or by the 35% identity over any 80 amino acid segment criteria will be compared among legumes based on IgE binding. Cross-reactive proteins from legumes will be evaluated for sequence identity by separating proteins using 2-dimensional gel electrophoresis and sending them for peptide sequencing by Liquid Chromatography and Maldi MS/MS. Further analysis will be performed by matching sequences to the NCBI website and comparing to known allergens. The current version of AllergenOnline allergen sequence database will be updated with the anticipated January 2009 release of version 9.0. The criteria for the inclusion of proteins as allergens in the database are: Protein (gene) isolated from a documented allergenic source, study subjects with described allergic symptoms consistent with exposure, specific IgE testing included controls and characterized test materials. Details of relevant allergenicity assessment data will also be retained in an archive e.g., the number of allergic subjects that tested positive to the protein, type of testing (qualitative or quantitative IgE binding, challenge tests).

Progress 08/01/08 to 07/31/10

Outputs
OUTPUTS: The development of an immunoassay (ELISA) for detection of buckwheat residue in processed foods has been completed. Polyclonal anti-buckwheat sera were successfully developed in rabbits and goats. Pooled anti-sera from both species were used to develop a sandwich ELISA with a limit of quantitation (LOQ) of 2 ppm in complex food matrices (muffins and noodles). No cross-reactivity was observed to the 80 food ingredients tested in the buckwheat ELISA indicating that the ELISA is highly specific for buckwheat. The detection efficiency of buckwheat in the assay was evaluated in laboratory prepared model foods (muffins and noodles). The developed ELISA is able to detect buckwheat in muffins and noodles with greater than 60% and 90% efficiency, respectively. Results of this research were presented at the 2009 American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology (AAAAI) and Instititute of Food Technologists (IFT) annual meetings to disseminate this work to both clinical and food industry audiences. The development of an immunoassay for detection of pistachio residue in processed foods has been completed. Polyclonal anti-pistachio sera were successfully developed in rabbits and sheep. Pooled anti-sera from both species were used to develop a sandwich ELISA with a limit of quantitation (LOQ) of 1 ppm in complex food matrices (sugar cookies and ice cream). Minor cross-reactivity was observed to cashew but none of the other 101 food ingredients tested in the pistachio ELISA. The detection efficiency of pistachio in the assay was evaluated in laboratory prepared model foods (sugar cookies and ice cream). The developed ELISA is able to detect pistachio in these matrices with greater than 50% and 94% efficiency, respectively. The AllergenOnline database was updated to version 9.0 in January 2009. Version 9.0 contains a comprehensive list (1386 sequence entries) of unique proteins of known and putative allergenic proteins (food, airway, venom/salivary and contact). This version replaces version 8.0 with 1313 sequences, which was posted in January 2008. Sequences and other reference information for version 9.0 were downloaded in May 2008 and compared with all sequences contained in version 8.0 including those listed as allergens and putative allergens and those that were not listed as they were judged to have insufficient evidence to be defined as allergens in version 8.0. Duplicate entries and corrections due to updates in NCBI entries were entered. The result was a unique list of 2256 sequences. The 2256 sequences were divided into groups based on taxonomic identity (genus and species) and sequence comparison to classify the sequences into homologues similar to the concept of isoallergens of IUIS (International Union of Immunological Societies). Source and sequence information as well as data from allergy studies were gleaned from AllergenOnline version 8.0, IUIS, Allergome, PubMed and individual publications. The resulting database includes 1386 sequences from 236 species that are clustered into 502 protein groups with sufficient evidence judged by the panel to be called allergens or putative allergens. PARTICIPANTS: Rahki Panda is a Ph.D. student in Food Science & Technology at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln and the development of an immunoassay for the detection of buckwheat residue in processed foods was her Masters research project. Pei Wen Lim is a Masters student in Food Science & Technology at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln and the development of an immunoassay for the detection of pistachio residue in processed food products is her graduate research project. Dr. Joseph Baumert, a Post-Doc with the Food Allergy Research and Resource Program and Afua Ofori-Anti, a Ph.D. student in Food Science & Technology at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln, assisted in the development, management and quality control of the research projects conducted by the aforementioned graduate students working on the development of ELISA methods. Dr. Steve Taylor is the principle investigator of this grant and he, along with Dr. Rick Goodman supervised the overall research conducted by the personnel previously mentioned. John Wise is a bioinformatics specialist with the Food Allergy Research and Resource Program (FARRP) at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln. John compiled the initial list of proteins for assessment and identified key supporting documentation, developed the new version of AllergenOnline and made the new version publically available on the AllergenOnline website. Dr. Rick Goodman is the director of AllergenOnline and supervised the work conducted by John Wise as well as organized the peer review team consisting of allergen experts from around the world. Pat Gergen is the Project Manager for the Food Allergy Research and Resource Program who provided assistance in drafting, editing and preparation of reports; provided resources and assisted with coordination of the grant preparation; and assisted with budget and grant oversight. TARGET AUDIENCES: Two target audiences exist for the development of immunoassays for the detection of buckwheat and pistachio residues in processed foods. Food processors that may process products on shared equipment with products that do not contain these foods will be very interested in using sensitive and specific method to detect inadvertent contamination of their raw materials and finished products and to evaluate the effectiveness of their sanitation program. Regulatory agencies will be interested in these immunoassays to ensure that processed food products on the market are in compliance. Scientists in academia, government, and private industry will be interested in the new version of AllergenOnline for risk assessment of potential allergenicity of the genetically engineered or novel food proteins that they are researching. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: No modifications were been made to this project.

Impacts
The development of immunoassays for the detection of buckwheat and pistachio residues in processed foods will now provide food processors with sensitive and specific techniques to detect inadvertent contamination of their raw materials and finished products with residues of either of these allergenic foods. These immunoassays can also be used by food processors to assess the effectiveness of their sanitation protocols. Regulatory agencies will be able to use these immunoassays to ensure that processed food products on the market are in compliance and do not contain undeclared food residues. Ultimately, buckwheat- and pistachio-allergic consumers will benefit from increased safety of these foods as a result of the development of rapid and sensitive methods for detection. The AllergenOnline database can be used by academic and government scientists that are developing genetically engineered and other novel foods, by regulatory officials in many countries, and by the agricultural biotechnology industry to evaluate the sequence identity of the novel protein to known allergens. This is a key step in overall allergenicity assessment process.

Publications

  • Panda, R., Taylor, S.L., and Goodman, R.E. 2010. Development of a sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for detection of buckwheat residues in food. J. Food Sci. 75:T110-T117.


Progress 08/01/08 to 07/31/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: The development of an immunoassay (ELISA) for detection of buckwheat residue in processed foods has been completed. Polyclonal anti-buckwheat sera were successfully developed in rabbits and goats. Pooled anti-sera from both species were used to develop a sandwich ELISA with a limit of quantitation (LOQ) of 2 ppm in complex food matrices (muffins and noodles). No cross-reactivity was observed to the 80 food ingredients tested in the buckwheat ELISA indicating that the ELISA is highly specific for buckwheat. The detection efficiency of buckwheat in the assay was evaluated in laboratory prepared model foods (muffins and noodles). The developed ELISA is able to detect buckwheat in muffins and noodles with greater than 60% and 90% efficiency, respectively. The development of an immunoassay for detection of pistachio residue in processed foods is ongoing. Polyclonal anti-pistachio sera were successfully developed in rabbits, sheep, and goats and are being used to develop a sandwich ELISA Food matrix interference studies are currently being conducted to determine the effects of ice cream and cookie matrices on the LOQ of the assay. Capture and detector antibody levels will be optimized to achieve an assay LOQ of 1-2 ppm. Cross-reactivity and detection efficiency will be evaluated in the final stages of the assay development. The target completion date of the development of this assay is May of 2010. The AllergenOnline database was updated to version 9.0 in January, 2009. Version 9.0 contains a comprehensive list (1386 sequence entries) of unique proteins of known and putative allergenic proteins (food, airway, venom/salivary and contact). A number of the allergenic wheat gliadins or glutenins may also cause celiac disease and those are listed if there is evidence of IgE binding. This version replaces version 8.0 with 1313 sequences, which was posted in January, 2008. Sequences and other reference information for version 9.0 were downloaded in May, 2008 and compared with all sequences contained in version 8.0 including those listed as allergens and putative allergens and those that were not listed as they were judged to have insufficient evidence to be defined as allergens in version 8.0. Duplicate entries and corrections due to updates in NCBI entries were entered. The result was a unique list of 2256 sequences. The 2256 sequences were divided into groups based on taxonomic identity (genus and species) and sequence comparison to classify the sequences into homologues similar to the concept of isoallergens of IUIS (International Union of Immunological Societies). Source and sequence information as well as data from allergy studies were gleaned from AllergenOnline version 8.0, IUIS, Allergome, PubMed and individual publications. The resulting database includes 1386 sequences from 236 species that are clustered into 502 protein groups with sufficient evidence judged by the panel to be called allergens or putative allergens. PARTICIPANTS: Rahki Panda is a Ph.D. student in Food Science & Technology at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln and the development of an immunoassay for the detection of buckwheat residue in processed foods was her Masters research project. Pei Wen Lim is a Masters student in Food Science & Technology at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln and the development of an immunoassay for the detection of pistachio residue in processed food products is her graduate research project. Dr. Steve Taylor is the principle investigator of this grant and supervisor of the graduate students previously mentioned. John Wise is a bioinformatics specialist with the Food Allergy Research and Resource Program (FARRP) at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln. John compiles the initial list of proteins for assessment and identifies key supporting documentation, develops the new version of AllergenOnline and makes the new version publically available on the AllergenOnline website. Dr. Rick Goodman is the director of AllergenOnline and leads the peer review team consisting of allergen experts from around the world. TARGET AUDIENCES: Two target audiences exist for the development of immunoassays for the detection of buckwheat and pistachio residues in processed foods. Food processors that may process products on shared equipment with products that do not contain these foods will be very interested in using sensitive and specific method to detect inadvertent contamination of their raw materials and finished products and to evaluate the effectiveness of their sanitation program. Regulatory agencies will be interested in these immunoassays to ensure that processed food products on the market are in compliance. Scientists in academia, government, and private industry will be interested in the new version of AllergenOnline for risk assessment of potential allergenicity of the genetically engineered or novel food proteins that they are researching. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
The development of immunoassays for the detection of buckwheat and pistachio residues in processed foods will provide food processors with sensitive and specific techniques to detect inadvertent contamination of their raw materials and finished products with residues of either of these allergenic foods. These immunoassays can also be used by food processors to assess the effectiveness of their sanitation protocols. Regulatory agencies will be able to use these immunoassays to ensure that processed food products on the market are in compliance and do not contain undeclared food residues. Ultimately, buckwheat- and pistachio-allergic consumers will benefit from increased safety of these foods as a result of the development of rapid and sensitive methods for detection. The AllergenOnline database can be used by academic and government scientists that are developing genetically engineered and other novel foods, by regulatory officials in many countries, and by the agricultural biotechnology industry to evaluate the sequence identity of the novel protein to known allergens. This is a key step in overall allergenicity assessment process.

Publications

  • Panda, R., Taylor, S.L., Goodman, R.E. 2009. Development of a Sandwich Enzyme Linked Immunosorbent Assay (ELISA) for Detection of Buckwheat Residues in Food. [in preparation].