Source: WASHINGTON STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to
ORGANIC CROPPING, WA
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0213939
Grant No.
2008-34618-18981
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2008-03177
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jun 1, 2008
Project End Date
May 31, 2010
Grant Year
2008
Program Code
[VF]- Organic Cropping, OR
Recipient Organization
WASHINGTON STATE UNIVERSITY
240 FRENCH ADMINISTRATION BLDG
PULLMAN,WA 99164-0001
Performing Department
CTR FOR SUSTAINING AGRIC & NATURAL RESOURCES (CSANR)
Non Technical Summary
The organic food industry has been growing at a rate of 20-30% per year for the past decade (Organic Trade Association, unpublished data) in the US, with a commensurate increase in land farmed under certified organic management and an increased need for research and education on organic farming practices and systems. In Washington State, farmgate sales of organic products were valued at over $101 million in 2006-07, an annual increase of 31%; and there has been a 39% increase in organic acreage from 2006 to 2007 (WSDA). Organic farming offers growers a form of production and market diversification and the potential for increased returns, all of which are needed in light of current economic conditions. In addition, organic systems generally lead to improved environmental performance (Reganold et al., 2001) and farm worker safety, thus lessening the need for the public sector to bear these costs. Conventional growers also benefit from the development of organic practices because they are increasingly adopting these practices to deal with pesticide resistance and regulatory constraints and because adoption of these methods may lead to reduced costs, improved biological performance, and enhanced environmental protection (A. McErlich, pers. comm.). The WSU CSANR has developed an organic and biologically intensive farming research program to better enable growers to produce high-quality organic crops. Initial research and education priorities have been identified by an Organic Advisory Committee and include the following: organic weed control methods for annual crops and vineyards; managing plants and soil underneath fruit trees and vines to integrate nutrient management and biological and cultural control of pests; assessing the economic trends of organic production in the region; and testing the efficacy of organic pest management materials and fertilizers. This special research grant project will enable Washington State University to begin to address these issues and assist organic growers to improve their profitability, agronomic performance, and environmental stewardship. This will provide economic benefits to growers and their rural communities, fulfill consumer demand for organic products that bring environmental benefits to the farm and watershed, and develop techniques that conventional farmers can use to meet the regulatory challenges of the federal Food Quality Protection Act and other public environmental initiatives. The region's climatic diversity provides biophysical characteristics that favor organic production, especially in the semi-arid zones where there is high-quality irrigation water. Additionally, the region has a high level of consumer awareness and demand for organic products as well as support for organic and sustainable production systems, especially in the urbanized maritime region. This special grant will help the agricultural sector to capitalize on these advantages.
Animal Health Component
34%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
33%
Applied
34%
Developmental
33%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1021419106010%
2021549106015%
2051599106020%
2111115106014%
2121499104016%
2131131114015%
6012410301010%
Goals / Objectives
The proposed project will enable growers and agricultural industries to comply with the new federal organic standards and become more competitive in domestic and international markets. We will investigate organic seed inputs, weed management techniques, fruit understory management strategies, food quality, and integration of sustainable grain and livestock production that will better enable growers to produce high-quality food crops effectively and efficiently. We will also assess the economic trends associated with organic production and marketing to enable growers and the organic industry to make information-based decisions regarding future organic production and marketing. Beginning on page 3, the objectives, procedures, and justifications are listed for each of the subprojects. The key five-year objectives of this special research grant are: (1) Research nutrient and soil management: affordable nitrogen sources, soil phosphorus balance, managing biological N, maintaining soil quality, perennial crop understory management. (2) Research integrating livestock into organic cropping systems: grazing systems, organic animal feeds, organic livestock health maintenance, enterprise integration and rotation. (3) Research pest management: agroecosystem design, biological and mechanical control methods, efficacy of new products and tools. (4) Research organic seed production, seed protection, and variety development specific for organic systems. (5) Study the effects of farming practices and crop varieties on food quality; tests for nutritive and health properties. (6) Research economic aspects: industry structure and trends, market assessment, enterprise budgeting, input and risk evaluation.
Project Methods
This special research grant proposal is organized by a collaborative team of research scientists and extension specialists that cuts across numerous disciplines. The proposal is being submitted through the Center for Sustaining Agriculture and Natural Resources (CSANR) at Washington State University (WSU). An organic advisory group identified priority research and education needs, and project directors solicited proposals from WSU scientists to address these priorities. The full proposal was reviewed by the Advisory Group and scientific review was provided by faculty in the Washington State University College of Agricultural, Human, and Natural Resource Sciences. Detailed project procedures are contained in the subproject descriptions below. The proposed work will include testing organic pest management strategies to minimize seed-borne diseases of seed crops. We will develop and evaluate methods for integrating sustainable organic grain with livestock production systems. Field trials will be used to investigate techniques for improved weed control in organic orchard and vineyard crops and enhanced pest management and nutrition in orchards. And finally, the organic industry trend analysis will rely on data collected by the dominant organic certifiers in the region.

Progress 06/01/08 to 05/31/10

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Four different legume species interplanted in an apple orchard were tested for a second year. Legume biomass, tissue N, tree leaf N, soil nitrate (biweekly sampling), and stand composition were monitored. Dissemination included two field tours, consultations with NRCS, and presentations at 3 grower meetings. A second year of comparing alfalfa in drive alleys versus grass was conducted in 3 commercial organic pear orchards and 1 experimental orchard to monitor effects on pear psylla and its predators. Results were presented at two grower meetings. An organic vineyard was established for conducting weed control research under western Washington conditions, comparing rototilling/ mowing (control); Wonder Weeder tillage; and 3 grain/legume cover crop treatments. Local growers and wine makers prioritized the management strategies to be tested. First year results were presented at grower meetings. Reduced tillage in organic dryland systems was explored with an undercutter blade and direct seeding. Crop trials were established at 4 locations to test more diversified rotations, included soybean, chickpea, spring pea, lentil, early-seeded winter wheat, proso millet, Japanese millet, milo, June-seeded winter canola, and June-seeded winter wheat. A survey of organic vegetable producers was conducted in western and central Washington to determine their major seed-borne and seedling disease challenges. Results are being used to design the next round of experiments on seed treatments. Soil samples were taken from 37 certified organic fields across the Columbia Basin in organic pea and sweet corn production, and are being used to bait, isolate, and identify (morphological and molecular methods) the key Pythium species. The sampled fields planted to pea crops in spring 2010 will be monitored for damping-off; plant/soil samples will be collected to compare with Pythium isolates obtained from the fall 2009 soil samples. Historical wheat cultivars, advanced breeding lines and modern varieties were evaluated in multiple locations in western Washington to provide organic growers with a grain option in rotation to meet regional demand for organic grains. The 2009 trials focused on evaluating grain yield, protein, test weight, lodging, resistance to stripe rust, mineral nutrient concentrations (Ca, Cu, Fe, Mg, Mn, P, Se, Zn), and preliminary milling and baking tests. We planted, evaluated and harvested 18 spring wheat cultivars on 3 organic farms and planted over 150 winter wheat varieties and breeding lines at the WSU Mt. Vernon research center. Detailed data on the farm gate value and acres of organic crops in Washington and Oregon were compiled for 2008. Reports for each state were written and put on-line. A separate report on organic tree fruit production was written, which included national data as well. The 2007 data from this project were compared with the limited results from the 2007 Census of Agriculture to better understand what farms were not included in certifier databases. Results were presented at multiple grower and industry meetings in the region and nationally. PARTICIPANTS: Project director: David Granatstein Co-project directors: Chad Kruger, Carol Miles Principal investigators for sub-projects: Dr. Steven Jones, Crop and Soil Science Dr. Joan Davenport, Crop and Soil Science Dr. Lindsey DuToit, Plant Pathology Dr. Vince Jones, Entomology Dr. Lynne Carpenter-Boggs, Crop and Soil Science Partners: Warren Morgan Orchards BMR Ranch G&L Ranch Zakarison Ranch Thundering Hooves Ranch USDA-ARS YARL, Wapato, WA USDA-ARS, LMWC, Pullman, WA USDA-ARS, WGQPD, Pullman, WA Organic Seed Alliance Jubilee Farm, Carnation, WA Camas Creek Ranch Acapella Vineyards Lopez Island Vineyards Collaborators: Dr. David Horton, USDA-ARS Dr. Tom Unruh, USDA-ARS Dr. David Huggins, USDA-ARS Dr. Kevin Murphy, Crop and Soil Science Mr. Gary Moulton, Horticulture Dr. Tim Miller, Crop and Soil Science Dr. Xianming Chen, USDA-ARS Dr. Lyndon Porter, USDA ARS Dr. Tim Paulitz, USDA ARS Mr. Alec McErlich, Small Planet Foods Mr. Todd Crosby, Mercer Canyon Farms. Mr. Brian Anderson Mr. Brad Baillie Mr. Joe Bennett Mr. Dave Hedlin Mr. Gilbert Hintz Mr. Nash Huber Mr. Chris Hyer Ms. Anne Schwartz Ms. Micaela Colley, Organic Seed Alliance Training: Two graduate students completed their programs during the special grant: Dan Ter-Avest and Kevin Murphy. Other graduate students involved included Avi Acala (seed pathology), Lukas Patzek (wheat varieties), Grant Morton (reduced till dryland), and Heather Ireton (reduced till dryland). Two students from ENITAB, France, were interns on project funding (Wenatchee, Mt. Vernon) during summer 2009 as part of their undergraduate degree requirements. TARGET AUDIENCES: Organic and conventional commercial farmers are the primary target audiences of the information that will be produced from research studies and Extension publications that will result from this research program. University colleagues and other agricultural professionals are the primary target audience for journal publications and conference presentations/abstracts that will result from this research program. Target audiences were reached through field tours, presentations at industry and professional meetings, popular publications, and resources added to web sites. Organic statistics were conveyed in Spanish to a Latino audience during the Washington State Horticulture Association annual meeting Latino session. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
Alfalfa planted in orchard alleys produced greatest seasonal contribution (48 kg N/ha) and release of N, with ladino clover and trefoil the next highest, kura clover the lowest of the legumes, but all showing more N release than the grass treatment. Additional plantings of legumes have been made on other orchard blocks based on these findings. NRCS is using these results in developing organic EQIP guidance. However, there was no effect of alfalfa on pear psylla pest or predator densities in the tree canopy. Tree nitrogen was slightly higher in the cover crop plots than control plots. Initial insect movement data show that tree-collected predators likely visited orchard floor vegetation; no striking differences were noted between alfalfa and control plots. In the reduced tillage dryland studies, milo performed reasonably well, and proso millet survived in some of the wetter plots and could be considered for low-lying fields. Either could provide options for grazing and/or seed production. Edamame and tofu-type soybeans both survived and yielded beans, but edamame-type soybeans were harvested too late for market use due to unfamiliarity with proper timing. The fact that they all yielded without irrigation was encouraging. Early-seeded winter wheat did survive, and has potential for providing late-season grazing. Economic analyses have been completed but not yet published for two of the farms. Results were very encouraging regarding the possibility of growing high quality wheat in western WA. Where there was sufficient nitrogen in the soil, grain proteins were very high. Grain yield followed suit, and big differences were found among the varieties for yield. 'Westbred Express', 'Kelse', 'Scarlet' and 'Canus' were the top yielders in the hard red market class; 'Louise' and 'Alpowa' in the soft white market class. As expected, these varieties shifted slightly depending on the farm/environment. Many of the varieties exceeded the minimum test weight of 60 lb per bushel. Organic growers are already planting these varieties in commercial quantities for markets in the region. The organic statistics data continue to be widely used and requested by the industry, media, and policymakers. The predicted spike in organic apple acres and consequent fall in prices did occur for the 2008/09 marketing year. The number of organic farms and acres did grow substantially in both states in 2008 compared to 2007.

Publications

  • Granatstein, D. and E. Kirby. 2009. Organic farming sector grows in Washington State. Sustaining the Pacific Northwest 7(2):6-7.
  • Granatstein, D. 2009. Nitrogen, a necessity for life. Good Point column, Good Fruit Grower, April 15, 2009; p. 6.
  • Granatstein, D. and E. Kirby. 2009. Current trends in organic tree fruit production. Proceedings 104th Annual Meeting, Wash. St. Hort. Assoc., Yakima, Dec. 1-3, 2008. WA. p. 155-157.
  • Miles, C., T. Miller, G.A. Moulton, M. Olmstead, J. Roozen and T. Thornton. 2009. Weed Management in Establishing an Organic Wine Grape Vineyard. Tilth Producers Quarterly, January 2009, Vol. 19(1):4-6.
  • Murphy, K., S. Jones, and C. Miles. 2009. Wheat variety trials in Western Washington. Tilth Producers Quarterly, Spring, 2009.
  • Alcala, A.C., and du Toit, L.J. 2009. Management of damping-off in organic vegetable crops in the Pacific Northwest. Sustaining the Pacific Northwest 7(4):5-7. http://csanr.wsu.edu/publications/SPNW/SPNW-v7-n4.pdf.
  • Cummings, J.A., Miles, C.A., and du Toit, L.J. 2009. Greenhouse evaluation of seed and drench treatments for organic management of soilborne pathogens of spinach. Plant Dis. 93:1281-1292.
  • Davenport, J. R., K. Bair and R. G. Stevens. 2010. The Relationship Between Soil Temperature and N Release in Organic and Conventionally Managed Vineyards. Comm. Soil Sci Plant Anal: In Press.
  • Granatstein, D. and E. Sanchez. 2009. Research knowledge and needs for orchard floor management in organic tree fruit systems. Intl. J. Fruit Science 9:257-281. Granatstein, D., E. Kirby, and H. Willer. 2009. Current World Status of Organic Temperate Fruits. Acta Hort. In press.
  • Miles, C., S. Jones, J. Roozen, K. Murphy, and X. Chen. 2009. Growing Wheat in Western Washington, EM 022E, Washington State University, December 2009, 18 pp.
  • Wiman, M.R., E.M. Kirby, D.M. Granatstein, and T.P. Sullivan. 2009. Cover crops influence meadow vole presence in organic orchards. HortTech 19:558-562.


Progress 06/01/08 to 05/31/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: An advisory group of organic growers, consumers, suppliers, and researchers was convened to identify research priorities in the region. Seven research studies are now underway. 1) Economic trends in organic production - profiles of the organic acres (certified and transition) in Washington and Oregon were developed for 2007. Certified area grew 27% in Washington and 41% in Oregon from the previous year, with a total value of farmgate sales exceeding $250 million. 2) Integrating organic grain and livestock production in dryland farming areas - trials on 2 farms showed that organic grains after alfalfa take-out yielded similarly to the conventional local average when the alfalfa was thoroughly controlled by intensive tillage or by overlapping subsoilers. Any remaining alfalfa significantly reduced grain yield, so more conservative take-out methods were not successful. Integration of organic crops with livestock was economically successful in 2008 both for livestock producers adding a grain component and for grain producers adding a livestock component. 3) Evaluating and developing wheat varieties for organic systems in western Washington - variety trials have been planted at WSU Mount Vernon NWREC and on 3 on-farm sites in Skagit, King and Clallam Counties. Entries include common regional varieties and advanced breeding lines from the organic wheat breeding program. A Ph.D. student has been recruited. Two grower workshops were organized in Skagit and San Juan Counties and were attended by 50 growers and agricultural professionals, and a workshop was presented at the kneading conference in Skowhegan, Maine July 30 and 31, 2008. 4) Seed treatments for organic vegetable production - a Ph.D. student has been recruited and started at WSU in spring semester of 2009. Treatments for field research studies are being identified, and interested stakeholders consulted for grower-cooperator field sites in western and central WA, crops to select for the PhD project, and primary pathogens of concern. 5) Growing nitrogen in the organic orchard - two on-farm trials were established to explore the potential contribution of legume cover crops to tree nitrogen needs. One trial used 4 different perennial legumes that were successfully planted in the drive alley with direct seeding and produced a modest amount of biomass in the first year. The other trial used annual legumes planted in the tree row, but they did not establish well and could not compete with weeds. 6) Assessing effects of an alfalfa cover crop in organic pear orchards - plots were established at an established experimental orchard and in 3 commercial orchards in April 2008. At the experimental orchard, the study has 4 plots per treatment, and arthropod densities, predator movement, predator feeding, and pear leaf nitrogen was assessed during the 2008 season. At the commercial orchards, at each site plots measure 0.2 to 0.5 acres each with 3 plots including a 0.5 meter-wide strip of alfalfa, each paired with a control grass understory plot. Arthropod densities and leaf nitrogen sampling will begin in spring 2009. 7) Weed management in establishing an organic wine grape vineyard - a grower ad. PARTICIPANTS: Primary participants in this research program are WSU research scientists and Extension agents, USDA-ARS scientists, organic farmers, and other agricultural professionals. TARGET AUDIENCES: Organic and conventional commercial farmers are the primary target audiences of the information that will be produced from research studies and Extension publications that will result from this research program. University colleagues and other agricultural professionals are the primary target audience for journal publications and conference presentations/abstracts that will result from this research program. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
This 5-year research program was just initiated in 2008 and so as yet there are no research results from subproject studies and only limited information has been available for dissemination to growers and industry. Most organic pest-control materials and fertilizers currently are manufactured by small businesses that lack resources to research and register their products. Several studies will provide field testing and unbiased evaluation for new organic products, which will aid both manufacturers and users of these products. The systems, methods, and products evaluated by this program are used not only by certified organic and transitional organic farmers but also increasingly by conventional producers as economic, environmental, safety, and market pressures increase. Several of these subprojects have the potential to advance sustainable agriculture on a national scale. New wheat varieties will be developed and selected in organic systems and will be available to wheat growers throughout the United States. Organic vineyard management techniques will be relevant to growers in other regions of the country with similar wet growing conditions. Organic seed treatment results will be relevant to all growers regardless of location. Orchard management for nitrogen and cover crops will be relevant to orchard growers with similar dry growing conditions.

Publications

  • Hoagland, L.A., L.A.Carpenter-Boggs, D.M.Granatstein, M.Mazzola, J.L.Smith, F.Peryea, and J.P.Reganold. 2008. Orchard floor management effects on nitrogen fertility and biological soil quality in a newly established organic apple orcha. Biology and Fertility of Soils. 45:11-18.
  • Granatstein, D.M., and E.M.Kupferman. 2008. Sustainable horticulture in fruit production. Acta Horticulturae. 767:295-308.
  • Granatstein, D.M., and K.Mullinix. 2008. Mulching options for Northwest organic and conventional orchards.. HortScience : A Publication of the American Society for Horticultural Science. 43(1):45-50.