Source: OREGON STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to
INTEGRATING WEED MANAGEMENT AND FERTILITY IN ORGANIC HIGHBUSH BLUEBERRY PRODUCTION SYSTEMS TO OPTIMIZE PLANT GROWTH, YIELD AND GROWER RETURN
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0213611
Grant No.
2008-51300-04443
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2008-01237
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Aug 15, 2008
Project End Date
Aug 14, 2011
Grant Year
2008
Program Code
[113]- Integrated Organic Program
Recipient Organization
OREGON STATE UNIVERSITY
(N/A)
CORVALLIS,OR 97331
Performing Department
HORTICULTURE
Non Technical Summary
The goal of this project is to develop an organic production system for highbush blueberry that maximizes plant growth and yield; facilitates weed, water, and nutrient management; and provides the greatest economic benefit to growers. This proposal responds to research needs identified by growers and university personnel. To achieve our goals, the following objectives were developed: 1) evaluate effectiveness and impacts of organic weed management, fertility, and production systems; 2) develop a ocustomo compost; 3) develop economic enterprise budgets; 4) disseminate research findings to industry; 5) use eOrganic to facilitate clientele involvement and package our findings for a national audience; and 6) assess changes in grower knowledge, intentions, and practices resulting from the project. Our advisory committee (industry and research members) has been involved in selecting the site, developing objectives and treatments, and management. This project seeks to add greater scientific depth to our knowledge of best practices for organic blueberry production. Treatments consist of 2 cultivars (Duke and Liberty), 2 production methods (raised bed or flat ground), 3 weed management practices, and 2 types and rates of organic fertilizer. From 1995 to 2005, worldwide highbush blueberry acreage increased by 90%. The market for organic blueberries is very strong. However, there were only an estimated 194 ha of organic blueberries in North America in 2003, less than 1% of total. Even with record prices for blueberries in 2006 and 2007, organic prices were 20-50% higher than conventional. In 2003, a survey we conducted indicated that weed management was one of the top challenges nationwide. Organic mulches have been shown to be effective at controlling many annual weeds. However, using organic mulches, particularly those with a high C:N ratio, complicates management of plant fertility. Our research has shown that in plantings on raised beds, irrigation management and mechanical weed control is more difficult. Research is needed on the impact of raised and flat ground plantings on weed management and blueberry plant growth and yield. We have looked at the impact of mulch on nutrient uptake and have provided growers with revised fertilizer recommendations. However, we have not assessed whether these findings can be extrapolated to organic production systems. Can we use similar rates of organic sources of N? What are the best timings of application to ensure the fertilizer N is available when the plant needs it? How will mulch type impact fertilizer availability? Will the compost we apply provide any measurable advantage in this production system? After this study, we will have science-based information on how growers might be able to establish and manage organic blueberries. We will have concrete information on the effectiveness of organic weed management techniques and fertilization methods. We will also be able to provide advice on the irrigation requirements of flat ground and raised bed planting systems as affected by mulching or weed mat. We will maintain detailed records in order to be able to provide some economic cost/benefit analyses.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1021120101010%
1021120102015%
2051120101020%
2051120102020%
2161120101015%
2161120102010%
6011120102010%
Goals / Objectives
The long-term goal of this project is to develop organic production systems for highbush blueberry that maximize plant growth, yield, and fruit quality; facilitate weed, water and nutrient management; and provide economic benefit to growers. Research objectives of this project are: 1) Evaluate organic weed management, fertility, and production systems for effectiveness and impacts on shoot growth and production, root distribution, and availability of water and nutrients; and 2) Develop a compost specifically designed for blueberry that will provide a long-term boost in soil N mineralization potential without causing damage to plants due to high pH and/or high salts. Extension and outreach objectives of the project are to: 1) Develop economic enterprise budgets for establishment and management of organic blueberries as affected by production method. 2) Produce workshops, field days, publications and web-based tools to effectively disseminate research findings to industry. 3) Use eOrganic to facilitate involvement of clientele during the project, and to package our research findings and traditional Extension activities into products that are useful to a national audience; and 4) Assess changes in grower knowledge, intentions, and practices resulting from the project. Measurable research outcomes for the Integrated Systems Trial will be in the form of answers to these questions: 1) What is the most effective way to control weeds? 2) Can we use weed mat to substitute for sawdust mulch (industry standard practice) for weed control? 3) What fertility inputs can be used to supply the crop with adequate nitrogen? 4) Can compost be used as a fertility source in organic production? 5) Do blueberries need to be grown on raised beds? 6) What impact will altered production practices have on long-term plant health and sustainability? and 7) Can blueberries be grown economically using the recommended sustainable organic production systems? Each year, the project advisory group will meet and conduct a group assessment of project progress. Specifically, the advisory group will review project outcomes to date, and discuss future project opportunities and obstacles. Based on advisory committee inputs, our plan of work will be adjusted for the next year, as necessary. Measurable short-term and medium-term outcomes of this project have been discussed with the project advisory committee, and have been considered in the planning process. Short-term outcomes will include changes in knowledge, skills, attitude, motivation, awareness. Medium-term outcomes will include changes in behaviors, practices, policies, procedures. Short and medium term outcomes will be assessed by participant surveys at outreach events. In the final year of the project, blueberry industry participants will be surveyed to assess short and medium term project outcomes.
Project Methods
Integrated Systems Trial: Treatments consist of 2 cultivars (Duke and Liberty), 2 production methods (raised bed or flat ground), 3 weed management practices [sawdust mulch+hand weed removal; compost+sawdust mulch+acetic acid; and weed mat], and 2 types and rates of fertilizer (feather meal and liquid fish emulsion at 28 or 55kgN/ha). Plants are drip irrigated. Design is a split-split plot with 5 reps and 240 plots. Each sub-subplot is 4.6-m long with 6 plants at 0.76 m apart, planted Oct. 2006. Soil samples will be collected annually and bulk density 2x per year. Weed pressure as coverage will be recorded every 3 weeks. One plant/plot will be destructively harvested and dry weight determined and shoot growth will be evaluated each season. Root samples will be collected periodically by using root in-growth cores to estimate standing root biomass and vitality. Images of roots that grow along the surface of minirhizotron tubes will be recorded and analyzed for root production and root longevity. Soil temperature will be measured. Soil water dynamics will be measured using a time-domain reflectometry (TDR) system. To determine the distribution of mineral nutrients in each treatment, soil solution samplers (Rhizon Samplers, Soilmoisture Equipment Corp.) will be installed near each TDR probe. Soil solutions will be collected weekly and analyzed. We will use ion-exchange membranes [Plant-Root Simulator probes (PRS), Western Ag Innovations, Saskatchewan] to assess treatment effects on nutrient supply rates to plant roots. The water and nutrient status of the plants will be monitored seasonally using tissue analyses and a pressure chamber. Yield, berry weight, and firmness will be obtained by hand harvesting. We have collected accurate data on the costs of establishment and are recording labor requirements and products throughout for an economic analysis by treatment. At the completion of this project, we will produce an organic blueberry enterprise budget and interactive spreadsheet for the A Grower's TEAM software program. Custom Compost Trials: We will use combinations of locally-available byproducts to create a suitable compost. In a screening study, compost feedstock mixtures will be enclosed in porous nylon mesh bags, placed within a large hot compost pile, and harvested periodically to determine compost chemical characteristics. We will leach selected finished composts with water and use the leachate to irrigate containerized blueberry plants, evaluating survival and root health. We will conduct lab incubations with soil to determine compost decomposition rate and plant-available N release. Finished composts will be incubated in soil to determine decomposition rate and release of plant-available N, and incubated and leached repeatedly to determine nutrient concentration, pH, and salts in the leachate. Select compost mixtures will be evaluated in the field by planting blueberries in compost-amended soil or soil mulched with the compost. The data for this split-split plot design will be analyzed using Proc Mixed, analysis of variance or repeated measures, as appropriate.

Progress 08/15/08 to 08/14/11

Outputs
OUTPUTS: We established a 0.4 ha planting in Oct. 2006 to evaluate the effects of cultivar (Duke; Liberty), bed type (flat; raised), weed management (sawdust mulch and hand-weeding; compost topped with sawdust with acetic acid, lemongrass oil and hand weeding; weed mat), and fertilizer (feather meal and fish emulsion at 29 and 57 kg of N/ha (2007-2009) and 57 and 102 kg/ha (2010-11). The site was certified organic in 2008. Research: 1. Evaluate organic weed management, fertility, and production systems. Weeds never exceeded 20-25% coverage in 2007-2010; weed mat resulted in the fewest weeds and compost plus sawdust had the most. Acetic acid or lemongrass oil applied every 3 wks in summer was effective on small weeds. Hand-weeding was required in all treatments. Plants grown on raised beds were larger and had 48% greater cumulative yield than those on flat ground (years 1-4). Raised beds with weed mat required double the irrigation volume than flat plantings in years 1-3, but not in year 4. In 2010, yield averaged 1.8 kg/plant. Fertilization with the low rate of fish emulsion or the high rate of feather meal resulted in high yields in 2009 and 2010. Yield was higher with weed mat or sawdust plus compost than with only sawdust. Weed mat reduced fruit firmness compared to organic mulches in all years except 2010. Plant-available N was greater under weed mat than sawdust but availability of Ca and K was lower. Soil pH was lowest under weed mat and highest under sawdust plus compost. 2. Develop a compost for blueberry. Compost feedstocks evaluated included animal manure solids + bedding (horse or dairy), urban yard debris, and farm by-products (grass seed screenings, spent hops, or peppermint distillation residue). Elemental S required to acidify compost to below pH 6 ranged from 3 to 12 kg S per metric ton dry compost. Plants grew better in plant-derived composts than in manure-derived composts, and compost acidification increased growth. Compost pH limited growth more than soluble salts. Composts for blueberry typically have a low to medium pH buffering capacity, requiring addition of 3 to 6 kg S per metric ton dry compost to reduce pH to less than 5.5. Extension: 1. Develop economic enterprise budgets. Inputs were documented and organic fruit sold throughout the project to document costs/returns. An extension cost of establishment publication was developed with information shared with peers at conferences. 2. Produce workshops, field days, publications and web-based tools. We have given the following presentations, 2008-11: field days for growers (17); grower meetings (6); webinars (3); scientific meetings (7); and international invited (4). 3. eOrganic. We used eOrganic to enhance project outreach. Three webinars were conducted describing the ongoing project and providing research-based information to clientele. The webinar outreach included participation from all 3 project PIs, 1 graduate research assistant and 1 postdoctoral research associate (webinars reached more than 158 listeners from 32 states and 2 countries). Peer-reviewed, online materials (pages in eOrganic) were developed describing the project. PARTICIPANTS: Participants: Bernadine C. Strik, Professor of Horticulture, Oregon State University David Bryla, Research Horticulturist, USDA-ARS, HCRL, Corvallis Dan Sullivan, Assoc. Professor of Crop and Soil Science, Oregon State University Clark Seavert, Professor, NWREC, Oregon State University, Aurora Gil Buller, Senior Research Assistant, NWREC, Oregon State University Handell Larco, M.S. graduate student, Dept. Horticulture, OSU Ryan Costello, M.S. graduate student, Dept. Crop and Soil Sci, OSU Luis Valenzuela, post-doctoral associate, USDA-ARS, HCRL and Dept. Hort., OSU James Julian, Research Assistant, NWREC, OSU, Wei Yang, Assoc. Professor, NWREC, OSU Nick Andrews, Small Farms Agent, NWREC, OSU Eric Pond, Riverbend Farms, Jefferson, Ore. Adam Wagner, Fall Creek Farm and Nursery, Lowell, Ore. Steve Erickson, Pan-American Berry Growers, Salem, Ore. Chrislyn Particka, Sakuma Bros. research, Wash. Joe Bennett, Small Planet Foods, Wash. Partner organizations: Oregon Blueberry Commission Washington Blueberry Commission Northwest Center for Small Fruits Research USDA-ARS, HCRL, Corvallis Growers in Oregon and Washington TARGET AUDIENCES: Commercial berry crop growers Organic growers Crop consultants Academic peers PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
The following questions were listed as research outcome goals: 1. What is the most effective way to control weeds Weed mat has been the most effective mulch for weed control. Propane flaming and acetic acid have been effective contact weed control methods provided weeds are small and environmental conditions are favorable. Lemongrass oil was an effective contact herbicide against small weeds in 2010-11. 2. Can we use weed mat to substitute for sawdust mulch (industry standard practice) for weed control Weed mat is effective for weed control, but the impact of higher soil temperature on plant growth needs more assessment. Root production was lower under weed mat than under organic mulches, and raised beds with weed mat required more irrigation than flat beds or beds covered with sawdust. 3. What fertility inputs can be used to supply the crop with adequate N Fish emulsion was equal or superior to feather meal for plant growth and was most effectively applied by fertigation. Soil N availability was relatively consistent with fish but higher under weed mat than under sawdust mulch. Higher N availability under weed mat was associated with higher soil temperatures and thus a more rapid conversion of organic N (fish and organic matter) to ammonium- and nitrate-N. The use of fish resulted in stable or a slight decrease in soil pH over the course of the study while soil EC remained very low and therefore had little to no impact on plant growth. The lower rate of fish fertilizer has resulted in the highest yields. 4. Can compost be used as a fertility source in organic production Plant-derived composts show promise to enhance organic blueberry production. Compost pH, not salt content, has been the major obstacle to compost use for blueberry. Our research shows that compost can be acidified via elemental S addition, and that plants grow better in acidified compost. We have developed and verified a quick test to determine how much S needs to be added to acidify compost to pH 5 to 5.5 (ideal for blueberry). 5. Do blueberries need to be grown on raised beds Growth and production were greater in plants grown on raised beds than in those grown on flat ground. Raised beds reduced soil water holding capacity but increased root growth and rooting depth to enable plants to acquire more water and nutrients. 6. What impact will altered production practices have on long-term plant health and sustainability Plant rooting differed among production practices. The low rate of fish fertilizer, for example, produced deeper and 30% more roots than the higher rate of fish fertilizer, while plants on raised beds produced deeper and 45% more roots than on flat ground. Plants with sawdust mulch produced more roots than with weed mat. Such practices increase the ability of blueberry to acquire water and nutrients and therefore reduce the need for irrigation and fertilizers. 7. Can blueberries be grown economically using the recommended sustainable organic production systems Cumulative net production costs (years 0-3) varied as much as 65% among treatments, ranging from -$32,690/ha to -$54,050/ha (net loss), similar to costs expected for conventional production.

Publications

  • Strik, B.C., D. Bryla, H. Larco, and J. Julian. 2011. Organic Highbush Blueberry Production Systems Research - Management of Plant Nutrition, Irrigation Requirements, Weeds, and Economic Sustainability. Intern. Hort. Congress, Lisbon, Portugal. Acta Hort. (in press)
  • Julian, J., B. Strik, E. Pond., and W. Yang. 2011. Blueberry economics: The Costs of Establishing and Producing Organic Blueberries in the Willamette Valley, Oregon. AEB 0023, July
  • Valenzuela-Estrada, L.R., D.R. Bryla, D.M. Sullivan, and B.C. Strik. 2011. Influence of weed mat and surface sawdust mulch on soil nutrient availability and soil chemical properties under organic blueberry production. 2011 ASHS Annual Conference, Hilo, Hawaii, 25-28 September 2011 (abstract).
  • Costello, Ryan C., Shannon B. Andrews and Dan M. Sullivan. 2011. Laboratory titration to predict S required for compost acidification. SSSA Annual Meeting. San Antonio, TX. 16-20 Oct. 2011. http://a-c-s.confex.com/crops/2011am/webprogram/Paper66759.html
  • Costello, R.C., D.M. Sullivan, D.R. Bryla, B.C. Strik and J. Owen. Highbush blueberry response to compost and sulfur. p. 67-72. In: Proc. Western Nutrient Mgmt. Conf. 3-4 Mar 2011. Reno, NV. Online at: https://sites.google.com/site/westernregion103/committee-output/confe rence-proceedings-2011
  • Strik, B.C., D. Bryla, and D. Sullivan. 2010. Organic Blueberry Production Research Project. Available at: http://www.extension.org/article/31680
  • Valenzuela, L., D. Bryla, D. Sullivan, and B.C. Strik. 2011. Organic Blueberry Production Research Project: Roots. Available at: http://www.extension.org/article/32763
  • Strik, B., Vollmer, E., Buller, G., Bryla, D. and Sullivan, D. 2011. Organic blueberry production reseach project. Oregon Blueberry Update, spring, 2011
  • Costello, R. and D. Sullivan. 2010. Development of Custom Compost for Highbush Blueberry. Soil Science Soc. Am. annual meeting, Long Beach, CA. Available at: http://a-c-s.confex.com/crops/2010am/webprogram/Paper60079.html
  • Larco, Handell O. 2010. Effect of planting method, weed management, and fertilizer on plant growth and yield of newly established organic highbush blueberries. M.S. thesis. Oregon State University. http://hdl.handle.net/1957/18065
  • Sullivan, Dan M. and Ryan Costello. 2010. Breaking it down: Growers can get the most value from their compost by having it analyzed first. Digger (Oregon Association of Nurseries). 54 (10): 42-46.
  • Valenzuela-Estrada, L., O.L. Vargas, D.R. Bryla, D.M. Sullivan, and B.C. Strik. 2010. Blueberry root dynamics and nutrient management under organic and conventional production. HortScience 45:S34 (Abstr.).
  • Strik, B. and D. Bryla. 2010. Weed, water, and nutrient management practices for organic blackberry production. Proc. Northwest Center for Small Fruits Research, Dec., 2010, Boise, ID 19:92-93
  • Larco, H., D.M. Sullivan, B. Strik, and D. Bryla. 2011. Mulch effects on highbush blueberry under organic management. p. 53 In: Abstracts, ISHS Intl. Symposium Organic Matter & Compost Use in Horticulture. Apr. 2011. Adelaide, AU. Acta Hort.(in press)


Progress 08/15/09 to 08/14/10

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Outputs are described under each objective Research: 1. Evaluate organic weed management, fertility, and production systems. Weeds never exceeded 20-25% coverage in 2007-2009; weed mat resulted in the fewest weeds and compost plus sawdust had the most. Flaming in spring and acetic acid applied every 3 wks in summer was effective on small weeds. Hand-weeding was required in all treatments. Plants grown on raised beds were larger and had 63% greater cumulative yield than those on flat ground (years 1-3). Raised beds, particularly with weed mat, required up to 269 L/plant/season more irrigation than flat ground plantings. In 2009, yield averaged 1.7 kg/plant and was highest with 29 kg/ha N of fish or 57 kg/ha of feather meal and lowest with 57 kg/ha of fish. Yield was higher with weed mat or sawdust plus compost than with only sawdust. Weed mat reduced fruit firmness compared to organic mulches. Plant-available N was greater under weed mat than sawdust but availability of Ca and K was lower. Soil pH was lowest under weed mat and highest under sawdust plus compost. 2. Develop a compost for blueberry. Two plant growth trials evaluated compost effects on root and above-ground growth. Composts were added to soil at a high rate (30% v/v). Controls were soil alone and soil + sawdust (industry standard). Trials were done in winter in greenhouse (1-gal pots; Jan-May) and outdoors in summer (5-gal pots; May-Sept). In the greenhouse, plant growth was limited when composts having pH above 7.5 and EC above 4 mS/cm were incorporated into soil. Plant-derived composts performed better than manure-derived. Acidification of composts with elemental S increased plant growth. Compost pH was a greater limiting factor to plant growth than soluble salts. Elemental S addition increased compost EC, but also increased plant growth. When grown at low levels of N addition (winter trial), compost increased plant growth above that observed with sawdust addition. At higher rates of fish fertilizer (summer trial), plant growth with compost was equal to, or less than growth with sawdust. Extension: 1. Develop economic enterprise budgets. Costs have been documented to date. Certified organic fruit were sold in 2009-10 to document returns. Development of an extension cost of establishment publication is in progress. 2. Produce workshops, field days, publications and web-based tools. We have given the following presentations: field days (11); grower meetings (6); scientific meetings (4); and international invited (4). This project was highlighted at the Blueberry Field Day at the NWREC in 2008-10. 3. eOrganic. We used eOrganic to enhance project outreach. Two webinars were conducted describing the ongoing project and providing research-based information to clientele. The webinar outreach included participation from all 3 project PIs, 1 graduate research assistant and 1 postdoctoral research associate (webinars reached more than 158 listeners from 32 states and 2 countries). Online materials (pages in eOrganic) were developed describing the project. These are under review. Video recorded at the OSU Blueberry Field Day (July 2010) is being edited for release via eOrganic. PARTICIPANTS: Participants: Bernadine C. Strik, Professor of Horticulture, Oregon State University David Bryla, Research Horticulturist, USDA-ARS, HCRL, Corvallis Dan Sullivan, Assoc. Professor of Crop and Soil Science, Oregon State University Clark Seavert, Professor, NWREC, Oregon State University, Aurora Gil Buller, Senior Research Assistant, NWREC, Oregon State University Handell Larco, M.S. graduate student, Dept. Horticulture, OSU Ryan Costello, M.S. graduate student, Dept. Crop and Soil Sci, OSU Luis Valenzuela, post-doctoral associate, USDA-ARS, HCRL and Dept. Hort., OSU James Julian, Research Assistant, NWREC, OSU, Wei Yang, Assoc. Professor, NWREC, OSU Nick Andrews, Small Farms Agent, NWREC, OSU Eric Pond, Riverbend Farms, Jefferson, Ore. Adam Wagner, Fall Creek Farm and Nursery, Lowell, Ore. Steve Erickson, Pan-American Berry Growers, Salem, Ore. Chrislyn Particka, Sakuma Bros. research, Wash. Joe Bennett, Small Planet Foods, Wash. Partner organizations: Oregon Blueberry Commission Washington Blueberry Commission Northwest Center for Small Fruits Research USDA-ARS, HCRL, Corvallis Growers in Oregon and Washington TARGET AUDIENCES: Target audiences: Commercial berry crop growers, Organic growers, Crop consultants, Academic peers PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
The following questions were listed as research outcome goals: 1. What is the most effective way to control weeds Weed mat has been the most effective mulch for weed control. Propane flaming and acetic acid have been effective contact weed control methods provided weeds are small and environmental conditions are favorable. 2. Can we use weed mat to substitute for sawdust mulch (industry standard practice) for weed control Weed mat is effective for weed control, but the impact of higher soil temperature on plant growth needs more assessment. Root DW was lower under weed mat than under organic mulches and raised beds with weed mat required extra irrigation in year 2. 3. What fertility inputs can be used to supply the crop with adequate N Fish emulsion was equal or superior to feather meal for plant growth. Inorganic N availability was relatively consistent with fish over a 14-wk period (late Apr thru July) for weed mat and sawdust mulches. Soil N, nitrate, and ammonium were higher with weed mat than with sawdust and higher near the soil surface in flat than in raised beds. Soil pH was higher with sawdust than with weed mat and lower as more N fertilizer was applied, while EC increased as more N was applied but only on raised beds; pH and EC were within the range considered "safe" for blueberry. 4. Can compost be used as a fertility source in organic production Plant-derived composts show promise to enhance organic blueberry production. Compost pH, not salt content, has been the major obstacle to compost use for blueberry. Our research shows that compost can be acidified via elemental S addition, and that plants grow better in acidified compost. We have developed and verified a quick test to determine how much S needs to be added to acidify compost to pH 5 to 5.5 (ideal for blueberry). 5. Do blueberries need to be grown on raised beds After the second growing season, total plant DW was greater in raised beds than on flat. Soil water content was lower in raised beds than in flat ground with sawdust but was higher in raised beds than in flat ground with weed mat. Soil N was lower at 15 cm than at 35 cm in raised beds, but more roots were located at the 35 cm depth. 6. What impact will altered production practices have on long-term plant health and sustainability Root production was monitored starting in 2009 using 90 minirhizotron tubes. More than 8,000 digital images were captured bi-weekly throughout the last two growing seasons. So far, most roots were produced shortly after harvest, implying root production is C-source limited and will differ depending on pruning and fruit set. In general, the low rate of fish fertilizer produced deeper and 1.3 times as many roots as the high rate of fish fertilizer, while raised beds produced deeper and 45% more roots than flat beds, and sawdust mulch produced more roots than weed mat. 7. Can blueberries be grown economically using the recommended sustainable organic production systems Cumulative net production costs (years 0-3) varied as much as 60% among treatments, ranging from -$32,690/ha to -$51,990/ha (net loss), similar to costs expected for conventional production.

Publications

  • Strik, B., D. Bryla, and H. Larco. Organic Blueberry Production Webinar. Presented March, 2010 via eOrganic. Available at: http://www.extension.org/article/26115
  • Sullivan, D., L. Valenzuela, and R. Costello. 2010. Undercover Nutrient Investigation: The Effects of Mulch on Nutrients for Blueberry Webinar. Presented Jan, 2010 via eOrganic. Available at: http://www.extension.org/article/25232.
  • Costello, R. and D. Sullivan. 2010. Development of Custom Compost for Highbush Blueberry. Soil Science Soc. Am. annual meeting, Long Beach, CA. Available at: http://a-c-s.confex.com/crops/2010am/webprogram/Paper60079.html
  • Larco, Handell O. 2010. Effect of planting method, weed management, and fertilizer on plant growth and yield of newly established organic highbush blueberries. M.S. thesis. Oregon State University. http://hdl.handle.net/1957/18065
  • Valenzuela-Estrada, L., O.L. Vargas, D.R. Bryla, D.M. Sullivan, and B.C. Strik. 2010. Blueberry root dynamics and nutrient management under organic and conventional production. HortScience 45:S34 (Abstr.).
  • Costello, Ryan. Composting and Blueberry Production. p. 15-16. In: Small Farm News. OSU Extension. Fall, 2009.


Progress 08/15/08 to 08/14/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Outputs are described under each objective Research: 1. Evaluate organic weed management, fertility, and production systems. A research assistant maintained weed management and fertility treatments. Data were collected on weed presence, plant growth, and yield. Records on all costs were maintained. We hired and trained a postdoc to monitor root growth and measure availability of soil water and nutrients. In 2008, the sawdust+compost mulch had more weeds than the sawdust or weed mat and required hand pulling of weeds plus one application of 20% acetic acid and 2 propane flaming treatments. Weed mat had the fewest weeds, although hand pulling was required around the plants. Plant-available N was greater under weed mat than sawdust but availability of Mg was lower. The weed mat also had greater availability of P, S, Mn and Zn later in the season (July) compared to sawdust. In Oct. 2008, total plant dry weight (DW) was greater in Liberty, on raised beds, and at a N rate of 29 kg/ha of fish in Duke and 57 kg/ha of fish in Liberty. Root DW was greater with organic mulches fertilized with 29 kg/ha N of fish. Yield in 2008 (second growing season) was greater in Liberty than Duke, on raised beds, and on plants fertilized with fish. Weed mat reduced fruit firmness compared to organic mulches. 2. Develop a compost for blueberry. A graduate student (Costello) began work in Apr. 2009. Ten composts were produced from locally-available organic materials in preparation for blueberry growth trials. Feedstocks for compost production included separated dairy solids, ground yard debris, bean and corn cannery byproducts, spent peppermint hay, horse manure+sawdust bedding, spent hops from a brewery, and grass clippings from urban landscaping. Composting was performed in small produce bins. Compost temperatures during the first 4-6 wks exceeded 50C for most mixtures, simulating realistic composting-process conditions. Most composts met NOP time/temperature standards for human pathogen elimination. We measured compost pH and electrical conductivity (EC) in 1:10 compost:water extracts. After 10-wk of composting, pH and EC for the composts were greater than desired for blueberry (pH< 6.5 and EC<1.5). The most promising composts were made from separated dairy solids and peppermint hay. We conducted 3-d laboratory incubations to determine the quantity of acid required to decrease compost pH to the desired range. For the 5 composts evaluated so far, we estimate that addition of 1-2 kg fine elemental S per m3 would be required to decrease compost pH to below 6. Extension: 1. Develop economic enterprise budgets. Costs have been documented to date. Certified organic fruit were sold in 2009 with documentation of returns. Development of an extension cost of establishment publication is in progress. 2. Produce workshops, field days, publications and web-based tools. We have given the following presentations: field days (4); grower meetings (5); scientific meetings (2); and international invited (3). This project was highlighted at the Blueberry Field Day at the NWREC in 2008 and 2009. 3. eOrganic. We developed an eOrganic community of practice related to this project PARTICIPANTS: Bernadine C. Strik, Professor of Horticulture, Oregon State University David Bryla, Research Horticulturist, USDA-ARS, HCRL, Corvallis Dan Sullivan, Assoc. Professor of Crop and Soil Science, Oregon State University Clark Seavert, Professor, NWREC, Oregon State University, Aurora Gil Buller, Senior Research Assistant, NWREC, Oregon State University Handell Larco, M.S. graduate student, Dept. Horticulture, OSU Ryan Costello, M.S. graduate student, Dept. Crop and Soil Sci, OSU Luis Valenzuela, post-doctoral associate, USDA-ARS, HCRL and Dept. Hort., OSU James Julian, Research Assistant, NWREC, OSU, Wei Yang, Assoc. Professor, NWREC, OSU Nick Andrews, Small Farms Agent, NWREC, OSU Eric Pond, Riverbend Farms, Jefferson, Ore. Adam Wagner, Fall Creek Farm and Nursery, Lowell, Ore. Steve Erickson, Pan-American Berry Growers, Salem, Ore. Chrislyn Particka, Sakuma Bros. research, Wash. Joe Bennett, Small Planet Foods, Wash. Partner organizations: Oregon Blueberry Commission Washington Blueberry Commission Northwest Center for Small Fruits Research USDA-ARS, HCRL, Corvallis Growers in Oregon and Washington TARGET AUDIENCES: Target audiences: Commercial berry crop growers Organic growers Crop consultants Academic peers PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
The following questions were listed as research outcome goals: 1. What is the most effective way to control weeds Weed mat has been the most effective mulch for weed control. Propane flaming and acetic acid have been effective contact weed control methods provided weeds are small and environmental conditions are favorable. 2. Can we use weed mat to substitute for sawdust mulch (industry standard practice) for weed control Weed mat is effective for weed control, but the impact of higher soil temperature under weed mat on plant growth needs more assessment. Root DW was lower under weed mat than under organic mulches. Raised beds with weed mat required 300 L/plant of extra irrigation in year 2. 3. What fertility inputs can be used to supply the crop with adequate N Fish emulsion was equal or superior to feather meal for total plant growth. Inorganic N availability was relatively consistent with fish over a 14-wk period (late Apr thru July) for weed mat and sawdust mulches. In general, pH was higher with sawdust than with weed mat and lower as more N fertilizer was applied, while EC increased as more N was applied but only on raised beds; neither pH or EC were unusual for blueberry, and both were within the range considered "safe". 4. Can compost be used as a fertility source in organic production Yard debris compost+sawdust mulch at planting gave 25% more yield, but increased labor cost for controlling weeds by 63% compared to sawdust mulch alone. Produced novel composts from locally-available feedstocks, all of which had pH>6 (require elemental S or other acidifying agent to reduce pH for blueberry). Developed a "quick test" to estimate the amount of acidifying agent needed to overcome high pH. Composted dairy solids and peppermint hay best fit target pH and salt levels for blueberry. 5. Do blueberries need to be grown on raised beds After the second growing season, total plant DW was greater in raised beds than on flat ground. Soil water content was lower in raised beds than in flat ground with sawdust but was higher in raised beds than in flat ground with weed mat. Raised beds required 190 L/plant more irrigation water than flat ground in year 2. 6. What impact will altered production practices have on long-term plant health and sustainability Root production was monitored starting in 2009 using 90 minirhizotron tubes. A total of 3,960 digital images were captured bi-weekly throughout the growing season. So far, we determined that most roots were produced shortly after harvest, implying root production is carbon-source limited and will differ depending on pruning and fruit set. 7. Can blueberries be grown economically using the recommended sustainable organic production systems The total costs of land preparation, planting establishment, and maintenance after year 1 ranged from $30,311 to $35,534/ha depending on treatment. Raised beds increased costs $1,263, on average, compared to planting on flat ground. Adding compost to the mulch increased costs $976 in flat ground and $1,156 in raised beds for materials and labor, but also increased weed management costs by $1,519 due to higher weed pressure and use of acetic acid.

Publications

  • Strik, B. 2009. Weed and fertility management of a newly established organic blueberry field. eOrganic Updates!, May 2009:3.
  • Strik, B. 2009. Weed and fertility management of a newly established organic blueberry field. Proc. Northwest Center for Small Fruits Research, Dec., 2008, Corvallis, OR 17:43-45
  • Strik, B. and H. Larco. 2008. Weed and fertility management of a newly established organic blueberry field. Proc. Northwest Center for Small Fruits Research, Nov. 29, Boise, ID. 16:55-57
  • Costello, Ryan. Composting and Blueberry Production. p. 15-16. In: Small Farm News. OSU Extension. Fall, 2009.
  • Strik, B.C., G. Buller, H. Larco, and J. Julian. 2009. The economics of establishing blueberries for organic production in Oregon. A comparison of weed management systems. Acta Hort. 810:457-464
  • Larco, H., B.C. Strik, D. Bryla, and D. Sullivan. 2009. Establishing Organic Highbush Blueberry Production Systems. The Effect of Raised Beds, Weed Management, Fertility, and Cultivar. HortScience (abstr.), 44:1120-21.
  • Strik, B.C. 2009. Organic blueberry production: is it viable in the Northwest Proc. Lower Mainland Hort. Improvement Assoc., Abbotsford, B.C., Feb. 19-21: 135-136