Source: KANSAS STATE UNIV submitted to
CLEANING UP ORGANIC ENVIRONMENTAL CONTAMINANTS USING PHYTOREMEDIATION
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0211924
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Oct 1, 2007
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2013
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
KANSAS STATE UNIV
(N/A)
MANHATTAN,KS 66506
Performing Department
Biochemistry and Molecular Biophysics
Non Technical Summary
Maintaining drinkable, safe water supplies for future generations is a high priority in conserving our natural resources. Phytoremediation, the use of plants to clean up contaminants, can have a major impact on water quality. In this proposal two examples are given where plants are highly effective and economically justified as means to clean up difficult contaminants. While remediation is important, in the long run prevention is more cost effective. By having a good understanding of the capabilities of plants, it should be possible to design much more efficient ways to contain contaminants so that they do not adversely impact ground or surface water supplies.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1020110100065%
1332499100035%
Goals / Objectives
Project 1 Objectives 1. Determine the rate of decolorization of several diazo textile dyes in hydroponic systems with sunflowers and then do comparable experiments with hydroponically grown Arabidopsis. 2. Using selective inhibitors, and laccase mediators, try to identify the enzyme system that is responsible for the degradation and attempt to isolate the enzyme activity if it is an exo enzyme. 3. Take advantage of genomics work done in Arabidopsis to identify specific isoenzymes that are active in the degradation process knowing that for many peroxidase and laccase genes, where specific Ti insertion mutants are identified. Tentative timetable- Objective 1. years 1 & 2 Objective 2. years 2-4 Objective 3. years 3-5 Completion of stages in objectives, and publication. years 2-5 Project 2 Objectives 1. Develop a highly sensitive but low cost method for determination of dioxane in water and plant extracts 2. Use the new dioxane assay method to monitor natural attenuation at a field site, preferably the former KSU isotope disposal site on Kimball Ave. Tentative timetable Objective 1. year 1 Objective 2. year 2 and 3 Completion of stages in objectives and publication. years 2-5
Project Methods
Proj 1: Identify dyes decolorized by plant roots, pinpoint the enzyme systems that carry out the reactions and use genomic techniques to identify specific genes that control production of those enzymes. Sunflower plants will be germinated and grown hydroponically. Previous work shows Evans blue is decolorized within 1 wk at 80 mg/L when a plant of several grams fresh wt is present in a bottle with 250 mL medium. Treatments will be done in triplicate and rates determined at intervals to allow normalization of activity to the relative ratio of root tissue per unit volume of water. Other similar azo dyes will be tested at comparable molar concentrations to determine specificity of the degradation process. Large polar molecules do not readily pass through the cell membrane. Reaction must occur at the cell surface. Less polar and smaller molecules can react internally to the root. Polymeric dyes will be tested to verify the activity of interest is on the root surface or in the culture medium rather than in the root. Further studies will use Arabidopsis thaliana. When reactivity of dyes is verified, mutants of Arabidopsis will be used to determine which enzymes cause the reaction. This is a key to establishing whether surface or secreted enzymes of plants are responsible for degradation of xenobiotics and allelochemicals in the roots. Laccase secretion and efficacy at degrading trichlorophenol and allelochemicals has been reported for a gene from cotton transformed into Arabidopsis. Proj 2: Develop an improved assay for dioxane and to apply it to a field site. Sunflower and poplar will be grown hydroponically. For the trees, 1/4 strength Hoaglands solution provides optimum growth. Plants grown in brown bottles with dilute solution will have specified levels of dioxane added to the culture medium. A tight fitting rubber stopper with a notch for the stem will be fitted to the bollte and plasticine used to seal the space around the stem. After the plant water has equilibrated with the solution, leaves, petioles or small shoots will be removed and placed in sealed containers and transferred to a French press and the crushed material collected in a tube with a septum-closable cap. Following centrifugation at 10,000 x g for 15 min, the clear yellowish aqueous phase will be withdrawn and added to a vial with a mininert valve and containing potassium carbonate to drive the dioxane from solution. Headspace analysis by gas chromatography allows determination of the concentration in the plant water. Comparison to the input solution will determine the partitioning of the dioxane as it passes into the plant. Sampling different portions of the plant allows one to determine the losses inherent to the transfer process. We have results showing that levels below 1 mg/L are measurable in the plant. Lower levels can be monitored in ground water. For field studies, to determine dioxane migration through plants, we can sample leaves, petioles and small shoots of trees growing at a contaminated site located north of Kimball Ave. Sampling will require coordination with the contractors in charge of the site, because the site is regulated by KDHE as a RCRA site.

Progress 10/01/07 to 09/30/13

Outputs
Target Audience: Target Audience: Researchers, and engineers attempting to clean up contaminants. Effort: Research to determine in chemical detail how plant roots degrade dyes. Target Audience: students of grades 8-12 and in college Effort: Outreach and education activities directed to students, use textile dyes as examples of how plants are able to degrade contaminants in the environment. Changes/Problems: We had hope to identify plants with altered enzyme activities in root systems. Functional redundancy if isoenzymes in the plant roots prevented us from attaining that goal. We did characterize the behavior of dye molecules in the root zone of plants and showed that dyes are degraded and irreversibly sorbed to plant roots. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? graduate student Rohit Kamat, completing dissertation now and undergraduates Joni Mengarelli and Mauri Zumalt. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest? Results were reported as posters at several local and national meetings. One article was submitted for publication. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? This was the sixth and final year of a multi-year project focused on using plants to help clean up environmental contamination. The main laboratory focus is plant roots and the enzymes secreted from or contained therein, specifically laccase and peroxidase. Plants irreversibly bind or degrade some diazo dyes that are banned (by the US and EU) because degradation in the environment yields intermediates that are carcinogenic. The dyes are still widely used in many parts of the world Laccase and peroxidase enzymes in/on plant roots degrade two simple model diazo dyes, methyl red and methyl orange. Addition of a mediator (free radical carrier) such as hydroxybenzotriazole enhances degradation of these dyes and extends the reactivity to several other dyes, including those of other classes which may also be carcinogens (e.g. malachite green which is widely used in some countries but banned in the U.S. for food uses). Phenol red, also implicated as a carcinogen, has been developed as a model for this class of dyes (triphenylmethanes). We have tested almost all of ~90 available Ti insertion mutants of arabidopsis, in both the laccase and peroxidase genes. Thus far no striking differences in capacity have been identified in the root systems. This indicates a high functional redundancy in the plant defenses against xenobiotics. Sunflowers respond differently from arabidopsis to some dyes. For both systems, and most dyes, peroxidase, not laccase, is the main, more active enzyme. That is shown by the need to add exogenous peroxide to get high rates of degradation. Phenol red can be degraded without added peroxide, but at a rate about 50 times slower than with its addition. This indicates that the peroxidase enzymes are present at levels giving a much greater capacity for degradation of xenobiotics, than is the key chemical essential for the reaction, namely peroxide. Efforts were made to demonstrate that dyes are no longer available in the environment after reaction. Mass spectrometry and UV/visible specrophotometry confirmed their disappearance from the solution. They were also shown to be unextractable from roots with solutions that will remove non-covalently bound dyes from the same roots. No evidence was obtained for partial break-down products being released to the environment. No oxidation products were identified by mass specrometry. The root systems of plants possess enzymes that can effectively decolorize diazo and other dyes. This can potentially provide a cost-effective means to treat water from facilities such as textile dying factories. It is also indicative of the versatility of plant roots in degrading aromatic compounds in their environment.

Publications

  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2013 Citation: Sathishkumar Santharum, L.C. Davis, L.E. Erickson, Biodegradation of carbon tetrachloride in simulated groundwater flow channels, Environmental Progress and Sustainable Energy (2013) doi: 10.1002/ep.11808
  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2013 Citation: M.T. Albahttiti, H.A. Rasheed, D. Peric, L. Davis (2013) The IES Journal Part A: Civil and Structural Engineering, Assessment of wheat fibre reinforced cementitious matrix, 11 pp, http://dx.doi/10.1080/19373260.2013.795503
  • Type: Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2013 Citation: Kelly Hudek, L.C. Davis, J. Ibbini, L.E.Erickson, Commercial products from algae, in Algal Biorefineries edited by R. Bajpai et al Springer, Dordrecht, pp 275-295 DOI 10.1007/978-94-007-7494-0_11


Progress 01/01/12 to 12/31/12

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Results were reported at several local and regional meetings. One article was submitted for publication. Another book chapter is accepted and should appear in print during 2013. PARTICIPANTS: L.C.Davis, principle investigator, Collaborators: Larry E. Erickson, Stacy L. Hutchinson, Training: graduate student Rohit Kamat, and undergraduates in student laboratories. TARGET AUDIENCES: Primarily other researchers, also engineers attempting to clean up contaminants. Some outreach and education activities use textile dyes as examples of how plants are able to degrade contaminants in the environment. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
This was the fifth year of a multi-year project focused on using plants to help clean up environmental contamination. The main laboratory focus is plant roots and the enzymes secreted from or contained therein, specifically laccase and peroxidase. Plants irreversibly bind or degrade some diazo dyes that are banned (by the EU) because degradation in the environment yields intermediates that are carcinogenic. But the dyes are still widely used in many parts of the world Laccase and peroxidase enzymes in/on plant roots degrade two simple model diazo dyes, methyl red and methyl orange. Addition of a mediator (free radical carrier) such as hydroxybenzotriazole enhances degradation of these dyes and extends the reactivity to several other dyes, including those of other classes which may also be carcinogens (e.g. malachite green which is widely used in some countries but banned in the U.S. for food uses). We have tested almost all of aproximately 90 available Ti insertion mutants of arabidopsis, in both the laccase and peroxidase genes. Thus far no striking differences in capacity have been identified in the root systems. This indicates a high functional redundancy in the plant defenses against xenobiotics. Sunflowers respond differently from arabidopsis to some dyes. For both systems, and most dyes, peroxidase, not laccase, is the active enzyme. That is shown by the need to add exogenous peroxide to get high rates of degradation. The root systems of plants possess enzymes that can effectively decolorize diazo and other dyes. This can potentially provide a cost-effective means to treat water from facilities such as textile dying factories.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 01/01/11 to 12/31/11

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Results were reported at several local and regional meetings. An article published on-line last year appeared in print early in 2011, in J. Env. Qual. Another was published in Bioremediation. PARTICIPANTS: L.C.Davis, principle investigator, Collaborators: Larry E. Erickson, Stacy L. Hutchinson, Ganga Hettiarachchi, with Westar Energy, Burns & McDonnell, Mango Remediation as companies collaborating. Training: graduate student Rohit Kamat, and undergraduates in student laboratories. TARGET AUDIENCES: Primarily other researchers, also engineers attempting to clean up contaminants. Presentations have been made to the corporate managers of our collaborating companies. Some outreach and education activities use textile dyes as examples of how plants are able to degrade contaminants in the environment. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
This was the fourth year of a multi-year project focused on using plants to help clean up environmental contamination. The main laboratory focus is plant roots and the enzymes secreted from or contained therein, specifically laccase and peroxidase. Plants irreversibly bind or degrade diazo dyes banned (by the EU) because degradation in the environment yields intermediates that are carcinogenic. But the dyes are still widely used in many parts of the world The compound ABTS was used to detect the activity of the laccase and peroxidase enzymes. Two simple model diazo dyes, methyl red and methyl orange have been studied with the use of "mediator" compounds ABTS and hydroxybenzotriazole. We have tested more than 50 (of ~90 available) Ti insertion mutants of arabidopsis, in both the laccase and peroxidase genes. Thus far no striking differences in capacity have been identified in the root systems. A published method was used to extract active enzyme(s) from intact plants which survive the treatment. The pH dependence of the mediated decolorization of blue dyes including Evans blue, trypan blue and direct blue was determined. For this system, peroxidase, not laccase, is the active enzyme. The root systems of plants possess enzymes that can effectively decolorize diazo dyes, and some other classes of dyes. This provides a cost-effective means to treat water from production facilities. Last year we began a collaboration to examine the abilities of wetlands to uptake and immobilize various elements, including selenium and boron, found in the flue gas desulfurization (FGD) water from a large coal-fired energy center. The wetland was established in late 1010 and sampling has continued through 2011. Toxicity of the FGD water was also determined in lab studies with sunflower. Efforts were continued to perfect formulas for biostimulation of anaerobic microbes to dechlorinate tetrachloroethene.

Publications

  • Dokken, K.M. and Davis, L.C. (2011) Infrared Monitoring of Dinitrotoluenes in Sunflower and Maize Roots. J. Environ. Qual. 40:719-730.
  • Santharam, S., Ibbini, J., Davis, L. C., and Erickson, L. E. (2011) Field Study of Biostimulation and Bioaugmentation for Remediation of Tetrachloroethene in Groundwater. REMEDIATION Spring 2011 51-68.


Progress 01/01/10 to 12/31/10

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Results were reported at a regional ACS meeting of researchers. An article was accepted in the Journal of Environmental Quality and published on-line. It will appear in print early in 2011. Our efforts for educational uses of the research are implemented here in a teaching laboratory, and published in a laboratory manual. One student continued work toward the PhD degree this year. One undergraduate was supported for summer research. PARTICIPANTS: L.C.Davis, principle investigator, Collaborators: Larry E. Erickson, Stacy L. Hutchinson, Ganga Hettiarachchi, with Westar Energy, Mango Remediation as companies collaborating. Training: graduate student Rohit Kamat, and undergraduates in student laboratories. TARGET AUDIENCES: Primarily other researchers, also engineers attempting to clean up contaminants. Some outreach and education activities use textile dyes as examples of how plants are able to degrade contaminants in the environment. A publication on educational uses has appeared, for educators, and is incorporated into a newly published laboratory manual. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
This is the third year of a multi-year project focused on using plants to help clean up environmental contamination. The specific laboratory focus is on the role of plant roots and the enzymes secreted from or contained therein. Plants rapidly absorb and irreversibly bind or degrade certain diazo dyes commonly used in textile or other dying applications. These dyes yield banned (by the EU) intermediates during anaerobic degradation, but are still widely used in many parts of the world. Rates of dye removal and degradation were determined using intact plants of sunflower, and arabidopsis (a model organism in the cabbage family). The compound ABTS was used to detect the activity of the laccase and peroxidase enzyme activity in intact plants with and without exposure to the azo dye. We have begun a search for the actual enzyme(s) responsible for decolorizing azo dyes, using genetic strategies. For this we obtained more than 100 Ti insertion mutants of arabidopsis, in both the laccase and peroxidase genes. The root systems of plants possess enzymes that can effectively decolorize diazo dyes, and some other classes of dyes. This provides a cost-effective means to treat water from production facilities. Recently we have begun a collaboration to examine the abilities of wetlands to uptake and immobilize various metallic elements from a large coal-fired energy center. The wetland is in place and sampling will begin early in 2011.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 01/01/09 to 12/31/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Results were reported in two papers at an international meeting of researchers in phytoremediation. Related work was also presented at a conference on green energy. Our efforts for educational uses of the research are implemented here in a teaching laboratory. One student began work toward the PhD degree this year. One undergraduate was supported for summer research. PARTICIPANTS: L.C.Davis, principle investigator, Collaborators: Larry E. Erickson, Training: graduate student Rohit Kamat, and undergraduates in student laboratories TARGET AUDIENCES: Primarily other researchers, also engineers attempting to clean up contaminants. Some outreach and education activities use textile dyes as examples of how plants are able to degrade contaminants in the environment. A publication on educational uses has appeared, for educators PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
This is the second year of a multi-year project using plants as tools to help clean up environmental contamination. It is a continuation of work done under a previous project, primarily focused on the role of plant roots and the enzymes secreted from or contained therein. A new student has joined the laboratory late fall of 2008 and has been workng on textile dyes. Plants rapidly degrade certain diazo dyes commonly used in textile or other dying applications. These dyes yield banned (by the EU) intermediates during anaerobic degradation, but are still widely used in many parts of the world. Rates of dye removal and degradation were determined using intact plants of sunflower, and arabidopsis (a model organism in the cabbage family). We also tested whether a specific compound that enhances the function of one enzyme, laccase, could increase the rate of dye removal. The same compound (ABTS) was used to detect the activity of the laccase and peroxidase enzyme activity in intact plants not exposed to the azo dye. We can now search for the actual enzyme(s) responsible for decolorizing azo dyes, using genetic strategies. The root systems of plants possess enzymes that can effectively decolorize diazo dyes, and some other classes of dyes. This provides a cost-effective means to treat water from production facilities.

Publications

  • Ibbini, J. H., Davis, L.C., Erickson, L.E. 2009. Phytoremediation in education: textile dye teaching experiments. Int. J. Phytoremed. 11:451-462
  • Ibbini, H.H., Santharam, S., Davis, L.C. and Erickson, L.E. 2009. Laboratory and field scale bioremediation of tetrachloroethene (PCE) contaminated groundwater. International Conference and Exhibition on Green Energy & Sustainability for Arid Regions & Mediterranean Countries., access at http://www.greenenergy-jo.com/Spaper/55.pdf


Progress 01/01/08 to 12/31/08

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Results were reported at an international meeting of researchers in phytoremediation. Our efforts for educational uses of the research were given to a faculty member at another institution and also implemented here. One student completed the PhD degree this year. PARTICIPANTS: L.C.Davis, principle investigator, Collaborators: Larry E. Erickson, Training: graduate students, Jwan Ibbini and Rohit Kamat, undergraduates in student laboratories. TARGET AUDIENCES: Primarily other researchers, also engineers attempting to clean up contaminants. Some outreach and education activities use textile dyes as examples of how plants are able to degrade contaminants in the environment. A publication on educational uses is in the press, for educators. Another publication on mechanistic aspects is in preparation, for researchers. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
This is the first full year of a multi-year project using plants as tools to help clean up environmental contamination. It is a continuation of work done under a previous project, redirected to focus on the role of plant roots and the enzymes contained therein. A new student has joined the laboratory and has been workng on the new area of textile dyes in the current semester. During this year we have focused on the ability of plants, to rapidly degrade certain diazo dyes commonly used in textile or other dying applications. These dyes yield banned (by the EU) intermediates during anaerobic degradation, but are still widely used in many parts of the world Rates of dye removal and degradation were determined using intact plants of sunflower, water hyacinth and papyrus. All three species show comparable responses to dyes. We also tested whether a specific compound that enhances the function of one enzyme, laccase, could increase the rate of dye removal. It did not increase it and indeed in some cases made the dye more toxic. We can now search for the actual enzyme(s) responsible for decolorizing azo dyes, using genetic strategies. For this new area we have begun cultivation of the model system of Arabidopsis. The root systems of plants possess enzymes that can effectively decolorize diazo dyes, and some other classes of dyes. This provides a cost-effective means to treat water from production facilities.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 01/01/07 to 12/31/07

Outputs
OUTPUTS: This is the first portion of a multi-year project using plants as tools to help clean up environmental contamination, and a continuation of work done under a previous project. One graduate student, has been workng on it in the previous quarter of a year. During this last time period we have focused on one specific ability of plants, to degrade certain diazo dyes commonly used in textile or other dying applications. We screened a large number of dyes and identified several that can be effectively degraded by sunflower root systems and water hyacinth in hydroponic culture. Rates of dye removal and degradation were determined using intact plants. Then similar studies were done for select dyes using the severed roots of the same species to verify that the degradation process depends solely on contact between the root system and the water, and not upon translocation of water into the plant. We can now search for the actual enzyme that is able to decolorize azo dyes, using genetic strategies. PARTICIPANTS: Participants: L.C.Davis, principle investigator, Collaborators: Larry E. Erickson, Training: a graduate student, Jwan Ibbini, undergraduates in student laborotories, high school students participating in GROW project. TARGET AUDIENCES: Primarily other researchers, also engineers attempting to clean up contaminants. Some outreach and education activities use textile dyes as examples of how plants are able to degrade contaminants in the environment.

Impacts
The root systems of plants possess enzymes that can effectively decolorize diazo dyes, and some other classes of dyes. This provides a cost-effective means to treat water from production facilities.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period