Source: CORNELL UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
DEVELOPMENT OF AN EFFICIENT SEMIOCHEMICAL MONITORING TOOL FOR BED BUGS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0211642
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Oct 1, 2007
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2009
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
CORNELL UNIVERSITY
(N/A)
ITHACA,NY 14853
Performing Department
ENTOMOLOGY
Non Technical Summary
Bed bugs are an increasing problem in many human habitats, including homes, apartments, hotels, cruise ships, dormitories and homeless shelters. They are difficult to scout for, difficult to control and people are often embarrassed to admit to their presence. Bed bug populations in poultry facilities are an emerging problem with huge potential impacts on poultry health and productivity. There is a great need for a good monitoring tool to assess their presence. This project will investigate possible attractants for bedbugs to be used in developing a monitoring trap. Sex pheromones possibly used by the bedbugs for mating, as well as host attractants of humans and chickens, will be isolated for characterization.
Animal Health Component
30%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
70%
Applied
30%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
7213110100040%
7213110113040%
7213210100010%
7213210113010%
Goals / Objectives
There is paucity of information on pheromones or other semiochemicals that are involved in mate-finding or host-finding by bed bugs. At Cornell University, we have in place right now the components that are necessary to address the problem successfully. These essential components include an already thriving bed bug colony, the expertise to identify volatile attractants, and the extension personnel who can conduct field assays. The objectives, therefore, are (1) to characterize biologically active materials that attract bed bugs either to each other for mating or to their hosts, and (2) to test these chemicals in the field to develop an efficient monitoring trap for bed bugs in both poultry rearing and human habitats.
Project Methods
The bed bugs used in the study will be reared at the Schwardt Veterinary Entomology Laboratory in Ithaca. A colony was established in May 2006 with bed bugs collected from a poultry egg production facility in New England. Artificial feeding methods have not been successful for bed bugs in colony; therefore, chickens will serve as the blood source for the bugs. The bed bug colony will be maintained under the Animal Use Protocol #01-56-04, previously approved by the Cornell University Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee. Bed bugs will be provided as needed for the studies at Geneva. These studies will include: 1. Collecting volatiles compounds from virgin male and female bed bugs using the well-tested techniques of aeration, adsorption, and solvent elution as well as solid phase micro-extraction (SPME). A protocol has been devised to obtain adult virgin male and female bed bugs. 2. Volatiles from poultry hosts will also be collected, using the techniques outlined above in 1, 3. Using the bed bugs own living antenna, a coupled gas chromatograph-electroantennogram detector (GC-EAD) will be utilized to determine compounds of interest. Compounds collected from female bed bugs will be tested against both male and female antennae and vice versa. 4. Identify the antennally active chemicals using a coupled gas chromatograph-mass spectrometer (GC-MS). 5. Purchase or synthesize all characterized active chemicals for use in field assays with collaborator/stakeholders to determine the optimum release rates, blend ratios, trap design, etc. needed to efficiently trap bed bugs.

Progress 10/01/07 to 09/30/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: The objectives of this project are (1) to characterize biologically active materials that attract bed bugs either to each other for mating or to their hosts, and (2) to test these chemicals in the field to develop an efficient monitoring trap for bed bugs in both poultry production facilities and human habitats. Initially, it was important to establish a bed bug colony that could be used for volatile collections. This was accomplished and volatiles were collected by various methods, including solid phase microextraction (SPME). Research then was conducted to determine if a coupled gas chromatograph-electroantennogram (GC-EAD) system could be used for indicating chemicals that are potentially biologically active. GC-EAD is employed extensively on a world-wide basis to identify the sex pheromones or plant volatiles involved in these behaviors. Previous researchers have reported that recording from the bed bug antenna is not good. A large effort was spent in developing an EAD system that would work for the bed bug. A behavioral assay system also was constructed of four still-air olfactometers for use in choice tests involving bed bugs to evaluate any compounds and blends indicated to have biological activity. Additionally, a previously reported bed bug aggregation pheromone was formulated and assayed in still-air olfactometers. Headspace volatiles were then collected from live chicks and chickens and assayed with an improved GC-EAD technique. Compounds eliciting an EAD response will be assayed for attractant activity in poultry production facilities. PARTICIPANTS: This was a joint project between Geneva and Ithaca. The Ithaca team consisted of Dr. Rutz, A. Taisey and C. Strong were responsible for maintaining the bed bug colony, providing live chickens for volatile collections, and conducting behavioral assays in the laboratory and chicken houses with compounds exhibiting EAD activity. The Geneva team consisted of Drs. Roelofs, Robbins and Cha were responsible for volatile collections and assaying the extracts with bedbug antennae by GC-EAD. Paul S. Robbins, Ph.D. electrophysiology and chemistry; Dong Cha, Ph.D. electrophysiology and chemistry; Allison Taisey, M.S. bed bug information specialist and trainer; Wendell L. Roelofs, Ph.D chemist; co-PI Donald Rutz, Ph.D. veterinary entomology and co-PI Colleen Strong, Technician. TARGET AUDIENCES: The goal of this project is to develop an attractant for bed bugs for use in poultry production facilities. This targets stakeholders who are involved in chicken egg or meat production. Organic or sustainable practices may preclude the use of any pesticides or pesticides with the residual properties necessary for long-term control of bed bugs. A working chemical attractant would be extremely useful in poultry production facilities in monitoring, disrupting or trapping bed bugs. In a very real sense, the target audiences are both those who produce and those who buy because both will benefit from the use of less reliance on chemical pesticides. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
A bed bug colony was established from a poultry production facility and live chickens were then used as hosts for bed bug feeding in the lab. Research with volatiles collected from bed bugs was not successful in defining compounds not already published mainly due the inability to obtain EAD responses from the bed bug antenna. A large effort was made to get the EAD technique to work on this species. Our trials included the use of various individual saline solutions and mixtures, the testing of different antennal preparations (whole head with both antennae, whole head with one antenna, excised antenna with tip in place, excised antenna with cut tip) and the testing of several signal amplifiers that were designed for several insect groups. Finally, sensitive antennal responses were obtained from bed bug antennae with the use of a new amplifier design. Research was then focused on volatiles from chicks and chickens. Volatiles were collected for 3 hrs. in glass or plastic containers fitted with charcoal filters using live chickens. The filters were extracted with methylene chloride and the extract assayed with bed bug antennae and GC-EAD. The improved amplifier design made it possible to identify 8 potential biologically active compounds that elicited antennal responses at concentrations below 5 ng. The compounds are all related to meaty fatty chicken odor. Behavioral assays with various combinations of these compounds are needed before development of a monitoring trap for chicken houses.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 10/01/07 to 09/30/08

Outputs
OUTPUTS: The objectives of this project are (1) to characterize biologically active materials that attract bed bugs either to each other for mating or to their hosts, and (2) to test these chemicals in the field to develop an efficient monitoring trap for bed bugs in both poultry rearing and human habitats. In this first year it was important to establish a bedbug colony that could be used for volatile collections. This was accomplished and volatiles were collected by various methods, including SPME. Research then was conducted to determine if a coupled gas chromatograph-electroantennogram (GC-EAD) system could be used for indicating chemicals that are potentially biologically active. GC-EAD is employed extensively on a world-wide basis to identify the sex pheromones or plant volatiles involved in these behaviors. To date, GC-EAD techniques have not proved useful in identifying semiochemicals (either sex pheromones or aggregation pheromones) important to the bedbug, Cimex lectularius. Our trials included the use of various individual saline solutions and mixtures, the testing of different antennal preparations (whole head with both antennae, whole head with one antenna, excised antenna with tip in place, excised antenna with cut tip) and the testing of several signal amplifiers that were designed for several insect groups. Our GC-EAD experiences mirror those of researchers in two other universities researching this insect with negative results using this technique. A behavioral assay system was constructed of four still-air olfactometers for use in choice tests involving bedbugs. A previously reported bedbug aggregation pheromone was formulated and assayed in still-air olfactometers. Headspace volatiles were then collected from live chickens and will be assayed with bedbugs in choice tests using the aggregation pheromone both with and without the chicken volatiles to determine if host volatiles play a role in host finding. PARTICIPANTS: Paul S. Robbins, Ph.D. electrophysiology and chemistry; Allison Taisey, M.S. bedbug information specialist and trainer; Wendell L. Roelofs, Ph.D chemist;and co-PI Donald A. Rutz, Ph.D. veterinary entomology and co-PI TARGET AUDIENCES: Our work here at Cornell targets stakeholders who are involved in poultry egg or meat production. Organic or sustainable practices may preclude the use of any pesticides or pesticides with the residual properties necessary for long-term control of bed bugs. A working chemical attractant would be extremely useful in poultry production facilities in monitoring, disrupting or trapping bed bugs. In a very real sense, the target audiences are both those who produce and those who buy because both will benefit from the use of less reliance on chemical pesticides. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
To provide efficacy information on products being used by cooperating poultry farmers, organic pesticides were tested in the lab. The following products were tested: Ecotrol EC, Beauveria bassiana fungus, Kleen Free, Pyganic Pro, Powder Guard. None of the products tested had the residual effect that would make them a viable option in a farming system. In the coming year, further beauveria tests will be done in cooperation with the supplier. Using a bed bug-specific fungus would provide a killing method with minimal risk to people, livestock, and the environment.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period