Source: SYSTEM SCIENCE APPLICATIONS, INC submitted to NRP
AQUAMODEL: SOFTWARE FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT OF OPEN OCEAN FISH FARMS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0211418
Grant No.
2007-33610-18532
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2007-02556
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2007
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2011
Grant Year
2007
Program Code
[8.7]- Aquaculture
Recipient Organization
SYSTEM SCIENCE APPLICATIONS, INC
3 TROVITA PL.
IRVINE,CA null
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
The development of open ocean marine aquaculture farms within the United States Exclusive Economic Zone offers the promise of profitable commercialization with low risk to the environment and wild fish stocks. Seafood imports are the third largest category of the U.S. imbalance of trade, averaging over ten billion dollars annually, third only behind petroleum and automobiles. Unfortunately, the United States is being left behind in the worldwide development of marine fish and shellfish culture. Mariculture development has been inhibited in the U.S. because of environmental concerns. AquaModel provides a mapping and computational tool to address these concerns by providing dynamic maps of the distribution and concentration of dissolved wastes that are transported by currents and taken up by plankton. AquaModel also simulates the distribution and concentration of particulate wastes, uneaten food and feces that settle towards the surrounding seabed sediments and are eventually assimilated into the marine food web. Such information is used to assess the ecological effects of proposed farms, to choose sites where these wastes will have minimal impact, and to determine the capacity of the environment to receive wastes from farms of varying sizes. AquaModel includes a physiological submodel of the cultured fish that provides predictions of the growth rate, respiration rate, and egestion and excretion rate of the fish stock within a pen over a range of conditions. These calculations can benefit farm operators since feed is the largest cost of finfish aquaculture operations.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
30737192080100%
Goals / Objectives
When completed AquaModel Hawaii will provide mapping and modeling tools required by regulators and farm operators to manage sustainable mariculture development in coastal and offshore waters. We will apply our technology to develop for the Hawaii Department of Agriculture a mariculture information system for the south coast of Oahu, Hawaii. This is a region where the growth of open water mariculture is imminent. In order to achieve this goal, we must achieve the following objectives. This list also defines our Phase II tasks. 1. Provide a more advanced visualization of a broad-scale (entire coastline), 3-dimensional coastal flow and build a interface to link this visualization in AquaModel to outputs from coastal circulation models 2. Add a contouring and statistics routines into AquaModel in order to better summarize the environmental impact of farm operations. 3. Provide computer code to accelerate simulations in order to improve our ability to analyze the impact of sediment waste deposition in waters where waste accumulation and the response of the benthic community is slow. 4. Complete testing of newly completed benthic dynamics subroutine and incorporate it into AquaModel. 5. Conduct physiological studies of newly species of priority species of marine fish needed to complete calibration of the model for these species. Specifically, we will measure in a laboratory under controlled conditions rates of growth, respiration, and waste production by moi, Hawaiian yellow tail, and cobia. 6. Use the up-dated version of AquaModel to develop the Oahu south coast (Mamala Bay and approaches) mariculture information system.
Project Methods
Our work plan consists of three tasks. First, we will also measure key physiological parameters needed to properly model fish farms in tropical areas of the U.S. Juvenile fish will be obtained without charge from cooperating growers and research academics and shipped to Seattle for culture and testing in the heated, circulating, seawater system at the NOAA Northwest Fisheries Science Center (NWFSC). We will measure respiratory oxygen demand at differing current velocities and for resting conditions for two key Hawaiian aquaculture fish species: moi (Polydactylus sexfilis) and Kona Kampachi Hawaiian yellowtail (Seriola rivoliana). We will also measure the rates of nitrogen excretion by these speices at different ages, juveniles to subadult fish. Finally, we will measure the size and sinking rates of particulate wastes, consisting of both feces and uneaten feed. Second, we will enhance the current AquaModel capacity to provide both an accurate and comprehensive description of the fate of waste materials produced by farms culturing different species of fish and operating in different regions. This work will include tuning AquaModel calculations for the two species listed above to the physiological data described above. We will use the Levenberg-Marquardt, multi-variable, search routine to obtain optimal values for coefficients of the model. We will also enable AquaModel to more quickly provide information on the environmental conditions at a farm after it has been operating for several years. Currently, a typical AquaModel simulation of several years requires many hours of computations. We will explore 2 solutions to overcome this limitation. One solution involves creating an algorithm that will provide AquaModel with the capability of running a simulation by sharing the processing among several linked computers. The second solution is separate AquaModel code into two components, one describing the 3 dimensional dynamics within the water column and the other describing the transport of waste particles to the bottom (including cycles of suspension and deposition) and its subsequent biochemical transformation by the benthic community. Since the latter component does not require computations throughout the 3 dimensional array of cells it runs between 10 and 100 times faster than the former. Third, in cooperation with the Hawaii Department of Agriculture and the University of Hawaii, we will create a comprehensive mapping and computational system that will be used by the Department and possibly farmers and investors to assist in planning and permitting of new farms. The Hawaiian Department of Agriculture and the University have electronic maps, images, and GIS databases of Oahu coastal waters that we will import into EASy-AquaModel. The Aquaculture Development Program has asked us to help them create an information system that will support sustainable open water mariculture in state waters. (See letter of support from Manager Leonard Young). The project will be an application of AquaModel Hawaii that will address the environmental and operational issues of development along the southern coast of Oahu, where successful farms are presently located.

Progress 09/01/07 to 08/31/11

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Presentation to the Geographic System in Fisheries meeting in New Zealand in August 2011 by Dr. Dale Kiefer: demonstration of model real time before the audience Invited Plenary presentation to the annual Aquaculture Canada Meeting in Quebec City Canada, April 2011 by Dr. Jack Rensel. Hour long keynote address that featured AquaModel and our SBIR project as an example of the future for aquaculture planning Presentation to World Aquaculture Society in March 2010 by Dr. Jack Rensel as invited speaker in the open ocean aquaculture session to report progress in our SBIR sponsored fish physiology and modeling work. PARTICIPANTS: Dr. Dale Kiefer, President of System Science Applications and Professor at University of Southern California. Mr. Frank O'Brien, Software engineer for System Science Applications Dr. Jack Rensel, Senior Scientist for System Science Applications TARGET AUDIENCES: Government resource management agencies worldwide Seafood Industry Aquaculture Industry Non Governmental Organizations PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
We have been actively discussing the use of our software with leaders of the U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Aquaculture Division. We anticipate being invited to Washington D.C. for a meeting soon to demonstrate the software's capability. We are also actively discussing the use of the model for Canada's Department of Fisheries and Oceans with leaders. There is also growing awareness of our software's capability that we feel can be marketed to environmental NGOs and we have made recent contacts in that regard. The advances made in our software allowed us to develop a regional-wide, multiple fish farm modeling system that is attractive to the agencies as an ocean management tool. With support from the U.S. Department of Agriculture, we have helped to advance this industry by completing development of AquaModel, software that accurately predicts the environmental impacts and operations of fish farms both nearshore and in the open ocean. AquaModel is now available to assist industry and government to predict and meet proposed rules and performance standards and to provide quick access to information needed for permitting and planning. AquaModel provides a home for data used in these and related pursuits, the tools to visualize and communicate this information, and a comprehensive model to simulate operations and environmental impact of operations. Presently, there are no other comprehensive software systems to accomplish all these tasks. The updated version of AquaModel provides mapping and modeling tools required by regulators and farm operators to manage sustainable mariculture development in coastal and offshore waters. Using this technology we have developed a mariculture information system for Hawai'i's Department of Agriculture that focuses on the main island. This is a region where the growth of open water mariculture is imminent. During this project we have completed all six of the tasks we identified in our Phase II proposal. 1. We developed an advanced visualization of a broad-scale (entire coastline), 3-dimensional coastal flow and built an interface to link this visualization in AquaModel to outputs from coastal circulation models. 2. We added contouring and statistics routines into AquaModel in order to better summarize the environmental impact of farm operations. 3. We wrote computer code to accelerate simulations in order to improve our ability to analyze the impact of sediment waste deposition in waters where waste accumulation and the response of the benthic community are slow. 4. We completed a greatly improved benthic dynamics subroutine and incorporated it into AquaModel. 5. We completed physiological studies of a culturally and commercially important species (moi, Polydactylus sexfilis) that has been the principal species cultivated in Hawai'ian net pens. We also conducted similar studies with cobia (Rachycentron canadum) as this species is growing in importance worldwide in tropical seas. 6. We created an updated version of AquaModel and incorporated the Hawai'i Department of Agriculture GIS information system into our software.

Publications

  • Two publications in manuscript form, not complete yet. 2011


Progress 09/01/07 to 08/31/08

Outputs
OUTPUTS: The development of open ocean marine aquaculture (mariculture) farms within the United States Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) offers the promise of profitable commercialization with low risk to the environment and wild fish stocks. With support from the Department of Agriculture, we will help advance this industry by completing development of AquaModel, software that will accurately predict the environmental impacts and operations of fish farms both onshore and in the open ocean. AquaModel can assist both the industry and government to predict and meet proposed rules or performance standards and provide quick access to information needed for permitting and planning. Aquamodel provides a home for data, the tools to visualize and communicate this information, and a comprehensive model to simulate operations and environmental impact of operations. Presently, there are no other comprehensive software systems to accomplish all these tasks. When completed AquaModel will provide mapping and modeling tools required by regulators and farm operators to manage sustainable mariculture development in coastal and offshore waters. We will apply our technology to develop for Hawaii's Department of Agriculture a mariculture information system for the south coast of Oahu, Hawaii. This is a region where the growth of open water mariculture is imminent. During the first year of our project we have completed 4 and nearly completed a 5th task of the 6 tasks we identified in our Phase II proposal. 1. We developed an advanced visualization of a broad-scale (entire coastline), 3-dimensional coastal flow and built a interface to link this visualization in AquaModel to outputs from coastal circulation models 2. We added contouring and statistics routines into AquaModel in order to better summarize the environmental impact of farm operations. 3. We wrote computer code to accelerate simulations in order to improve our ability to analyze the impact of sediment waste deposition in waters where waste accumulation and the response of the benthic community is slow. 4. We have completed a benthic dynamics subroutine and incorporated it into AquaModel. 5. We have completed about a third of the physiological studies of new commercial species (moi, Hawaiian yellow tail, and cobia) that are or will soon be under cultivation in Hawaii, 6. Use the up-dated version of AquaModel to develop the O'ahu south coast (Mamala Bay and approaches) mariculture information system. We have encountered few problems with this work, and foresee no new problems. PARTICIPANTS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. TARGET AUDIENCES: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
1. We have built an interface to incorporate output from complex coastal circulation models into AquaModel, drive the AquaModel simulations, and display the results. In order to simulate operations and environmental impact we have linked AquaModel to output from NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory's model of circulation in this region. The output is a continuous, 3-dimensional flow field that is output at a time step of 6 hours. Outputs include current velocity, temperature, and salinity. 2. We have added the capability to contour in user-selected bins any of the variables that are calculated during simulations. This provides the user the ability to view patterns in the distribution of farm wastes by false color raster images, or in the case of overlaying maps of two variable, view maps containing both contours and images. 3. We have increased the speed of computations by re-designing AquaModel to run three types of simulations, transport and ecological transformations of both dissolved and particulate wastes, transport and ecological fate of the dissolved wastes alone, and ecological fate within the sediments of the particulate wastes. 4. The benthic routine has been completed, and now provides the most detailed and comprehensive description of the fate of uneaten feed and fish feces deposited in the sediments beneath the farms. This new routine greatly expands this description to include changes in the relative abundance of aerobic and anaerobic organisms, the remineralization of waste carbon by anaerobic organisms that respire sulfate, and the production of hydrogen sulfide by the anaerobes. Hydrogen sulfide is of course toxic, and it is a key indicator of excess loading by farms. 5. We have begun laboratory studies on the growth and metabolic activity of three species that are candidates for large open water commercial farming in Hawaii. These species are new to American Mariculture and thus little is know about their physiology and will provide information necessary to run simulations of operations and environmental impact for the growing mariculture industry in Hawaii. The focus of this work is determination of basal (resting) and active respiration, excretion rates of ammonia, urea and total N, fecal settling rates and N and C digestibility and composition of fecal matter. 6. We will soon meet with marine scientists, developers, and regulators to define user needs for setting standards for licensing new farms. These meetings will then direct our development of an offshore information system for fish farms that will be delivered to the Hawaiian Department of Agriculture. Critical information on the growth and metabolic characteristics of the three of the most commercially promising species will allow us to calibrate the model and apply it to broad regions of the U.S. and overseas. The model will allow assessment of cumulative effects of many farms within a broad area by both Government agencies and farmers.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period