Source: TEXAS COOPERATIVE EXTENSION submitted to
TALLER MIP (IPM WORKSHOP)- A BILINGUAL WORKER EDUCATION PROGRAM ON INTEGRATED PEST MANAGEMENT FOR THE SOUTHERN NURSERY AND FLORICULTURE INDU
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0210770
Grant No.
2007-41530-03829
Project No.
TEXN0X022
Proposal No.
2007-03618
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
QQ.S
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2007
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2010
Grant Year
2007
Project Director
Bogran, C. E.
Recipient Organization
TEXAS COOPERATIVE EXTENSION
(N/A)
COLLEGE STATION,TX 77843
Performing Department
Texas AgriLife Extension Service
Non Technical Summary
Ornamental growers in Texas use almost four times as much active ingredient than cotton growers on a per acre basis. This creates great pest-associated risks including insecticide resistance, environmental contamination and worker exposure. Ornamental plants are grown under labor-intensive production systems. High labor input is required in all stages of production from propagation to plant shipment. The average US floriculture grower employs more than 15 workers. The majority of field workers in the industry are of Hispanic origin, have little formal education, and lack simple yet essential technical knowledge required in plant health maintenance efforts. Pest problems often go unnoticed and untreated until they reach levels which trigger frequent and intensive pesticide applications that could be avoided by early pest detection and regular sanitation practices within IPM programs. This project will develop a series of educational videos for field workers. Armed with basic knowledge of plant health and insect/ disease symptom identification, field workers will be in the position to 1) understand their role in the successful implementation of integrated pest management, 2) actively participate in sanitation, pest detection and monitoring practices, and 3) directly contribute to plant quality assurance efforts that increase profitability and reduce worker pesticide exposure and pesticide resistance development risks.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
100%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
21621991130100%
Goals / Objectives
The objectives of this proposal are to develop and publish a series of 3 educational videos (and their audio/video components) to be used for IPM worker training in the nursery and floriculture industry. The specific objectives are:1)Develop a bilingual IPM worker training curriculum for floriculture and nursery growers in the southern region; 2)Develop a video clip library of IPM related concepts and practices, to be posted in current IPM program websites in the southern region; and 3)Produce and publish the educational video products using the above curriculum and video library, to be widely distributed to interested growers in the southern region.
Project Methods
1) Develop a bilingual IPM worker training curriculum. To develop a region-wide appropriate curriculum we will field test and evaluate the current Taller MIP-IPM Workshop curriculum with growers in Florida, North Carolina and Texas. Collaborators from University of Florida Extension and North Carolina State University Extension will organize at least three worker-training sessions in their states. Currently available, narrated power point presentations will be used to conduct pilot training sessions. During and after each training session, participants will be surveyed to evaluate content and delivery. A post-pre evaluation instrument will be used to measure any change in the level of understanding of topics by participants. This evaluation data along with a critical review by the collaborating extension specialists will be used to modify the current curriculum and develop one that is appropriate for and tailored to worker training across the region. 2)Develop a video clip library. Footage will be captured at commercial greenhouse and nursery operations and during current Taller MIP-IPM Workshop program delivery sessions using digital video technology. The footage will be captured with the help of a video communication specialist. If needed, the audio for each video will be recorded at the TAMUS Agricultural Communications audio recording studio. The audio will then be overlaid onto the video to form the final product. We expect that at least 15 video clips (approximately 3-5 minutes in duration) will be developed including descriptions of key pests/diseases, visual descriptions of how to and where to look for key plant health issues and visual descriptions of specific yet simple IPM practices. Video footage will be edited using available software and compressed into different formats/resolutions to facilitate publication and user access/download. 3) Produce and publish educational video products. Using the enhanced curriculum (objective 1) and edited audio/video footage (objective 2) the final version of the videos will be edited by combining the text and audio with edited footage using commercially available hardware (DVCAM Player/Recorder) and computer software. Based on the current curriculum we expect to develop 3 videos of up to 1 hour duration including: 1) IPM concepts, definition, justification, challenges, IPM components;, 2) plant health, growth requirements, insect damage, pathogen damage, impact of crop management practices; 3) insect and pathogen biology, life cycles, population growth, disease triangle, basic pest and disease management; 4) basic pesticide toxicology, pesticide safety, formulations and labels and resistance management, and 5) integration of IPM tools using current examples. These subjects may be modified or changed as input and feedback is received from growers and specialists (objective 1). The final digital product will be published in DVD format and made available as a whole or in parts (individual video clips) via the World Wide Web to be downloaded into personal computers or audio/video portable players.

Progress 07/01/07 to 06/30/10

Outputs
OUTPUTS: To facilitate adoption of IPM strategies that reduce pest control-associated risks, we have developed an IPM education program targeted at Hispanic (in Spanish) and other field workers (in English). This training program (Taller MIP-IPM Workshop) teaches basic concepts and their application, at an audience-appropriate level which considers the socioeconomic, cultural and educational background of participants. The program subjects include basic plant growth and health, basic biology and ecology of plants, arthropods and pathogens, pest/disease avoidance, prevention, identification and monitoring, pesticide safety and application effectiveness and the integration of pest management tools. Twenty five educational programs (3 to 4 hours in duration) were delivered in Texas, Florida, North Carolina, Oklahoma, Washington, Ohio, Indiana and New York to more than 450 participants representing 56 commercial operations. The curriculum for the educational program was validated and evaluated with the help of collaborators in Florida and North Carolina and was the basis for a on-line course. PARTICIPANTS: Not relevant to this project. TARGET AUDIENCES: Workers in the nursery and greenhouse industry PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
An audience appropriate curriculum on crop health management was developed and delivered to workers in the greenhouse/nursery industry. The impact of the program include changes in behavior: better selection and timing of pesticide applications; increased use of pest monitoring practices and significant increase in worker morale. One grower indicated that knowledge obtained on new pests and monitoring techniques produced cost savings estimated at $250,000.00 including cost of unnecessary applications and plant losses prevented based on the information provided. Program has grown to obtain nation wide recognition and has served as model for similar efforts in other regions

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 07/01/08 to 06/30/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: The network of project participants and cooperators continued to expand and now includes workers and extension personnel in eastern Oklahoma, central North Carolina and central and south Florida in addition to north east and southeast Texas. The IPM workshop curriculum has been validated in 22 operations across the southern region. Two short videos on insect monitoring techniques were shot at a grower operation in Texas. Script for two additional videos was completed. Presentations describing the program and its impact were given at the Entomological Society of America annual meeting and the annual Society of American Florists Pest Management conference in 2008 and 2009 respectively. Comments from Supervisory Personnel Follow up communications with worker-supervisors at participating nursery operations have revealed some of the early benefits of the educational program. These include an increased work-satisfaction by workers and better understanding of their role in pest management and crop quality assurance. The following is a response from a head-grower: "Sustainable practices have reduced some costs over the past year as a result of employees being more conscious of water and pest levels, therefore reducing costs of chemicals and their application and costs of labor throwing out dead material." Catherine Cherry Head Grower Seville Farms, Mansfield TX Bilingual Worker- Training Program helps Texas grower become Certified-Sustainable. Relevance: Current market and consumer trends have increased demand for agricultural products that are grown using environmentally and socially sustainable practices. Some retailers of landscape ornamental plants, such as Wal-Mart, have begun requesting their grower-suppliers to participate in certification programs aimed at increase environmental and social accountability. Such certification is currently provided by Veriflora (http://www.veriflora.com/) under its sustainability certification program for potted plants. The Veriflora program establishes criteria in three key areas, environmental sustainability (including sustainable crop production), social and economic sustainability (including worker access to services such as professional training), and product integrity. . Response: Worker training on Integrated Pest and Disease Management provided by Texas AgriLife Extension Service has aided growers in obtaining Veriflora certification. An extension education program, Taller MIP (Spanish for IPM workshop) provides workers with essential knowledge and skills to better manage pests and reduce environmental and heath risks. Results: Seville Farms of Mansfield Texas, a wholesale grower of ornamental landscape plants was among the first US floriculture and nursery growers to become certified by Veriflora. PARTICIPANTS: Described in previous section. TARGET AUDIENCES: Workers (mostly of Hispanic origin) in the floriculure/nursery industry in the southern region of the U.S. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
Participants A total of 8 educational programs were delivered in 2008 including 135 participants and representing a total of 994 contact hours. Most participants were originally from Mexico but a minority was from other Latin American countries. On average, participants had 7 years (range 0-12) of formal education and 5 years of experience in the ornamental industry. Previous program evaluation results have demonstrated that the initial level of formal education and years of experience do not determine by themselves the success of the program. Test Scores Tests were given after each training module in 4 of the educational programs. Each module represents 2-4 hours of instruction. Average test score (+/- 1SD, n=99) for all participants were 60.0 +/- 15.7%. The average test score for those participants passing the tests (≥60%), were 72 +/- 9.1%. Level of Understanding A post-pre evaluation instrument was used to assess participant's level of understanding of the concepts covered in the training program in one of sessions. Participants were asked to describe their level of understanding (low, medium, high, excellent) before and after the program. Topics were grouped into 6 categories as follows: 1. Basic IPM concepts 2. Sanitation and cultural practices 3. Basic biology and ecology of pests and pathogens 4. Insect pest management 5. Disease management 6. Basic pesticide toxicology On average, for the 17 questions included in the instrument, the percentage of participants with high or excellent understanding of the topic increased from 7% before the program to 75% after the program (range from 0 to 100%). Table 1 shows average responses and change in participants the responses as a result of the training program. On average the self-described level of understanding increased 1.6 points (in a 1-4 scale), indicating a positive impact of the training program. Table 1: Average of the self-described level of understanding of topics covered before and after the training program (1=low, 2=medium, 3= high, 4=excellent). No.Topic description, Before, After, Change 1. IPM concept,1.8,3.0,+1.2 2. Pest and disease prevention tactics, 1.6,3.0, +1.4 3. The importance of monitoring,1.8, 3.4, +1.6 4. Importance of good diagnosis of pest and diseases,1.2, 3.0, +1.8 5. How a pest population increases, 1.2,3.2, +2.0 6. Insect development and metamorphosis,1.0, 3.0 +2.0 7. Basic requirements for plant growth,1.6, 2.8, +1.2 8. When plants need water, 1.6, 3.2, +1.6 9. Importance of sanitation, 1.2, 3.0, +1.8 10. Use of yellow sticky cards to detect pests, 1.8, 3.2, +1.4 11. Difference between chewing and sucking insects, 1.4, 3.4, +2.0 12. Aphids life cycle, 1.0, 2.8, +1.8 13. Mealybugs life cycle, 1.0, 2.8, +1.8 14. Disease cycle concept, 1.4, 3.0, +1.6 15. Disease triangle concept, 1.0, 2.4, +1.4 16. Conditions that favor diseases, 1.2, 2.6 +1.4 17. Causes of plant diseases, 1.4, 3.2, +1.8

Publications

  • 1. Carlos Bogran talks about Spanish IPM workshops. Wednesday, 31 October 2007; Green Beam Pro, Branch/Smith Publishing. Published on the web at: http://www.greenbeampro.com/content/view/1067/46/


Progress 07/01/07 to 06/30/08

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Activities: Video has been captured at grower operation during training program; development of on-line distance education course has begun to make certification program available via internet. Events: Educational programs in Spanish have taken place in Florida (2), Oklahoma (1), North Carolina (2) and Texas (6). A program was also conducted in Washington State. The objective of these programs have been to validate curriculum and obtain program evaluation data from participants. PARTICIPANTS: Workers and supervisors in the greenhouse/nursery industry TARGET AUDIENCES: Workers and supervisors in the greenhouse/nursery industry PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: An online course is being developed to deliver program via distance education

Impacts
Evaluation is ongoing.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period