Source: UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA submitted to NRP
PRODUCING ORNAMENTAL AROIDS WITH REDUCED CALCIUM OXALATE CRYSTALS.
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0210614
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
May 1, 2007
Project End Date
Apr 30, 2012
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA
G022 MCCARTY HALL
GAINESVILLE,FL 32611
Performing Department
AGRI RES & ED CENTER, APOPKA
Non Technical Summary
Florida is the leading state in the nation in production of container-grown tropical ornamental foliage plants. Aroids represent one third of the wholesale value of commercially grown foliage plants. Most of the aroids are native to Central and South America and stock plantings are grown throughout the Caribbean Basin in large nurseries. Although the ornamental value of aroids is widely recognized, an important issue concerning their mammalian toxicity nature has not been addressed. This group of plants produces calcium oxalate crystals (COC), which cause dermal and gastric irritations, varying from mild to severe. Dieffenbachia is the most toxic of the aroids and reports of severe and painful dermatitis, swelling of internal tissues, paralysis, and painful gastritis after the exposure to Dieffenbachia sap have appeared in the medical literatures for over a hundred years. Nursery workers frequently report rashes after handling these plants, particularly if the sap makes contact with their skin as commonly occurs when they are taking cuttings from stock plantings. Other commonly grown aroids can cause similar but less severe problems. This project will identify COC types, densities, and distribution in Dieffenbachia cultivars and other aroids, isolate cultivars that have low levels of COC, and develop appropriate guidlines for using the low COC cultivars in commercial production.
Animal Health Component
40%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
60%
Applied
40%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2032122108040%
2042121102060%
Goals / Objectives
The objectives of this project are to (1) develop methods of studying the occurrence, type, and distribution of calcium oxalate crystals (COC) in the aroid genus Dieffenbachia; (2) quantitatively study COC numbers in stems and leaves of 42 representative Dieffenbachia cultivars to determine if genetic variation exists among cultivars; (3) survey nine other aroid genera to compare similarities and differences of their COC types, quantities, and distribution patterns with those of Dieffenbachia and determine if their mammalian toxicity or lack thereof is related to the types, quantities and/or distribution of COC they develop; (4) evaluate if cultural practices, specifically Ca and Mg fertilization programs and light intensity levels affect COC formation; and (5) summarize these research findings to develop methods of producing plants less toxic to nursery workers in the Caribbean Basin and elsewhere as well as produce safer plants for the ultimate consumer.
Project Methods
(1) We will use Dieffenbachia maculata var. Carina, a popular cultivar in the industry, to develop methods of identifying types of COC and determining distribution of different COC types in different plant organs. (2) Based on the methods established, we will study if differences exist in the type, density, and distribution of COC among 42 Dieffenbachia cultivars that have different genetic backgrounds. These differences will be analyzed in terms of genetic relationships established by our previous AFLP analysis to determine if detected differences can be related to certain species relationships or correlated with hybridization schemes of developed hybrids. The categorization of species and cultivars based on their COC density will provide information as to which species or cultivars have lower COC levels or fewer defensive COC per tissue unit. (3)We will also compare the occurrence of the type, quantity, and distribution of COC in other aroids including Aglaonema, Alocasia, Anthurium, Dieffenbachia, Epipremnum, Monstera, Philodendron, Spathiphyllum, Syngonium, and Zamioculcas with those in Dieffenbachia. Although they all belong to the aroid family, distinct mammalian toxicities differences may exist. Comparing types, quantity, and locations of COC in these aroids with those in Dieffenbachia will provide additional information concerning the relationship between COC and mammalian toxicity. (4) We will also investigate if light intensity and varied levels of Ca and Mg during production will alter the quantity or type of COC in leaves and stems of representative Dieffenbachia cultivars. Continuous-flow hydroponic culture will be used in this study. If cultural practices do alter the quantity and type of COC formed in plants, guidelines regarding the light intensity and Ca and Mg concentrations for producing plants with lower levels of COC will be developed and introduced into the ornamental plant industry for the production and propagation of Dieffenbachia. (5) The results will be summarized and published in scientific and popular greenhouse production journals to inform growers, nurserymen, interior plantscapers, and general consumers about the following information: (a) the occurrence, type, and distribution of COC in Dieffenbachia and other genera studied; (b) the categorization of 42 Dieffenbachia cultivars based on the COC density in different organs; (c) recommended cultivars that have lower COC levels and the best cultural practices (Ca and Mg concentrations and light intensity) for their production;. (d) the potential to develop new cultivars with much lower COC levels by using cultivars with low COC levels as parents for hybridization; (e) a data analysis on the type, distribution, and density of COC in plant organs of Dieffenbachia that may explain why it is more toxic than other members of the aroid family; (f) a ranking of COC density based on types of the nine other genera in the aroid family; and (7) the potential of converting the current toxic Dieffenbachia cultivars into safer plants for nursery workers and the people who buy them.

Progress 05/01/07 to 04/30/12

Outputs
OUTPUTS: (1) Developed methods for studying the occurrence, type, and distribution of calcium oxalate crystals (COC) in aroids. (2) Identified that raphides and druses occurred in stems, leaves, roots, and spadices, and crystal sands in stems of Dieffenbachia. (3) Quantified the density of raphides and druses in leaves of 37 Dieffenbachia cultivars and found that more druses occurred than raphides regardless of the location in the leaf. The druse densities were 7- to 76-fold greater than those of raphides depending on the cultivar. In addition, two lines of evidence indicate that COC density is under genetic control. (a) The COC densities in tetraploid cultivars were at least 34% less than their corresponding diploid cultivars. (b) Cultivar Star White, a triploid hybrid developed from a cross between 39301 and tetraploid Memoria Corsii, had one of the lowest densities of COC, partially due to the fact that Memoria Corsii had low COC density. We also identified a cultivar having a total druse and raphide density of 137 per mm2 compared to some cultivars having over 481 per mm2. (4) Surveyed 10 other aroid genera to compare similarities and differences of their COC types, quantities, and distribution patterns. Results suggested (a) only druses and raphides were found in the leaves of these aroids and (b) the density of druses was higher than raphides, which are the similar results found in Dieffenbachia. However, (c) the COC density in the other aroids studied was generally lower than that of Dieffenbachia. (5) Studied the effects of different concentrations and combinations of Ca and Mg on COC formation. Significantly less COCs were formed when plants were cultured in solutions containing zero Ca and Mg, or zero Ca with increased Mg. In addition, the formation of raphides and druses varied with Ca and Mg concentrations. Plants cultured with zero Ca had no druse idioblasts, while plants cultured with 1.0 mM Ca or higher had 4-8 druses per mm2, indicating that druses did not form until Ca in the culture attained a level of 1 mM. Thus, druses may serve as storage for Ca. (6) Determined light effects on COC formation. Results showed that raphide densities of Exotic Perfection and Snowflake produced indoors decreased by 58% and 64%, respectively, compared to those of plants produced in the shaded greenhouse. (7) Studied the type, density, and distribution of COC in three types of philodendrons: vining type, self-heading type, and tree type. Results showed that (a) only druses and raphides occurred in the studied philodendrons; (b) druses were the dominant type of COCs in philodendrons with the ratio of druses to raphides ranging from 12:1 to 300:1 in leaves, 3:1 to 30:1 in petioles, and 2:1 to 12:1 in stems; and (c) the type of philodendrons or cultivars differed significantly in the density and distribution of COCs. In leaf tissue, the vining type philodendron had the highest the density of COCs (both druses and raphides), followed by the self-heading type, and then the tree type. PARTICIPANTS: Not relevant to this project TARGET AUDIENCES: Foliage plant growers, interior plantscapers, and homeowners PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period

Impacts
Aroids are important ornamental foliage plants produced in Florida and used widely for interiorscaping. However, all aroids produce COCs, which are associated with mammalian toxicity, such as dermal and gastric irritations, varying from mild to severe. Reports in medical journals document that several children have had to have tracheotomies to breathe after ingesting a small part of a leaf. Nursery workers frequently report rashes after handling these plants, particularly if the sap makes contact with their skin as commonly occurs when they are taking cuttings from stock plants. Additionally, aroids are produced for use inside homes and other building interiors, people, particularly children and pets may inadvertently make dermal contact with the plants or ingest parts of them. This study was the first attempt to determine the occurrence, types, and distribution of COCs in aroids. The results showed that more druses in leaves, which may suggest that it could be druses not raphides that act as vehicles to carry proteolytic enzymes to mammalian skin. We have identified significant genetic differences among cultivars of Dieffenbachia and Philodendron in the distribution, type, and density of COCs. The density of druses varied from 126 to 481 per mm2; and the density of raphides differed from 5 to 45 per mm2 among cultivars. We also found that environmental and cultural factors, such as light levels, fertilizer regimes particularly Ca and Mg, also affect the density of COC in aroids. Our findings strongly suggest that the reduction of COC densities is possible through breeding using cultivars with low COC density as parents or chromosomal doubling to develop polyploid cultivars.

Publications

  • Cao, H., J. Chen, and D.B. McConnell. 2005. Dieffenbachia calcium oxalate crystal formation affected by cultivars, nitrogen rates, light intensity. HortScience 40:1086 (abstract).


Progress 10/01/08 to 09/30/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Research effort on this project in 2009 has been focused on Philodendron cultivars. The type, density, and distribution of calcium oxalate crystals (COC) in three types of philodendrons were studied. Vining type: Philodendron scandens and P. micans; self-heading type: P. x Imperial Red and P. x Imperial Green; and tree type: and P. Selloum (Yellow Selloum) were grown in the same shaded greenhouse with an identical fertilization and irrigation management program. After three months of plant growth, leaf samples were prepared using the clear leaf method, and sections were prepared from leaf, petiole, and stem samples using a microtome. The type, density, and distribution of COCs were determined using a Nikon OPTIPHOT microscope. Results from this study are as follows: (1) only druses and raphides occurred in the studied philodendrons. Most raphides were distributed in the upper epidermal cells or the Palisade parenchyma adjacent to the epidermal layer. Druses were located mainly in both the palisade parenchyma adjacent to upper epidermal layer and the spongy parenchyma next to the lower epidermal layer. In both petioles and stems, the cortex area has more druses and raphides than the central ground tissue where the vascular bundles were scattered. (2) Druses were the dominant type of COCs in philodendrons with the ratio of druses to raphides ranging from 12:1 to 300:1 in leaves, 3:1 to 30:1 in petioles, and 2:1 to 12:1 in stems. (3) The type of philodendrons or cultivars differed significantly in the density and distribution of COCs. In leaf tissue, the vining type philodendron had the highest the density of COCs (both druses and raphides), followed by the self-heading type, and then the tree type. The density of COCs in the petioles of vining types of philodendron was one fourth of that both in self-heading and tree types of philodendron. In stem tissue, COC density differed significantly between the two self-heading cultivars. On the other hand, the ree type of philodendron had significantly higher density than the vining type. PARTICIPANTS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. TARGET AUDIENCES: Foliage plant growers, interior plantscapers, homeowners PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
The genus Philodendron has more than 700 species, which makes it the second largest genus in the family Araceae. Philodendrons differ widely in growth habits from climbing to arborescent, leaf sizes vary from small (10 cm long and 6 cm wide) to gigantic (120 cm long and 40 cm wide), leaf shapes differ from heartleaf to palm-like, and leaf colors vary from light yellow to burgundy. Thus, many philodendrons have been produced as ornamental foliage plants. Although the ornamental value of Philodendron is widely recognized, an important issue concerning their mammalian toxicity has not been. Philodendron, like Dieffenbachia, produces COCs, which cause dermal and gastric irritations, varying from mild to severe. The general public has considered Dieffenbachia the most toxic aroid. However, the American Association of Poison Control Centers ranked Philodendron number one among the top 20 most frequently ingested poisonous plants in 1989 (www.kidsource.com/kidsource/content/Ingested.html). Reports in medical journals document that several children have had to have tracheotomies to breathe after ingesting a small part of a leaf. Nursery workers frequently report rashes after handling these plants, particularly if the sap makes contact with their skin as commonly occurs when they are taking cuttings from stock plants. Additionally, philodendrons are produced for use inside homes and other building interiors, people, particularly children and pets may inadvertently make dermal contact with the plants or ingest parts of them. This study was the first attempt to determine the occurrence, types, and distribution of COCs in philodendrons. The identified differences among cultivars in the distribution, type, and density of COCs in philodendron organs may suggest that the reduction of COC densities is possible through breeding.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 10/01/07 to 09/30/08

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Research accomplishments 2008: (1) Studied the effects of different concentrations and combinations of Ca and Mg on calcium oxalate crystal (COC) formation. Dieffenbachia Rebecca were grown in hydroponic culture and Vergo Container Mix A. Nutrient solutions containing 3.0 mM KNO, 0.25 mM NH4H2PO4, 20 micromole FeSO4, 12.5 micromole H3BO3, 2.5 micromole MnSO4, 1.0 micromole ZnSO4, 0.25 micromole CuSO4, 0.0075 micromole (NH4) Mo7O24, and 40 micromole free-acid EDTA-chelated FeSO4 with variable concentrations and combinations of Ca and Mg were used for hydroponic production of the plants and for irrigating the plants grown in the container substrate. Leaf transections of 2 mm by 5 mm from leaf margin in the middle of lamina were taken from the first unfurled leaf 10 weeks after transplanting and examined for COC density. Results from hydroponic culture showed that plant growth was stunted when cultured in solutions containing either Ca or Mg only or zero Ca and Mg. There was no difference in dry weights among plants cultured in solutions containing 1 mM Ca and 4 mM Mg, 2.5 mM Ca and 2.5 mM Mg, or 4 mM Ca and 1 mM Mg. Raphide and druse idioblasts were two predominant types of COCs in leaves. Significantly less COCs were formed when plants were cultured in solutions containing zero Ca and Mg, or zero Ca with increased Mg. In addition, the formation of raphids and druses varied with Ca and Mg concentrations. Plants cultured with zero Ca had no druse idioblasts, while plants cultured with 1.0 mM Ca or higher had 4-8 druses/mm2, indicating that druses did not form until Ca in the culture attained a level of 1 mM. Thus, druses may serve as storage for Ca. Furthermore, both raphide and druse densities in leaves of plants cultured in solution containing 1 mM Ca and 4 mM Mg were significantly lower than those cultured in solutions containing 2.5 mM Ca and 2.5 mM Mg or 4 mM Ca and 1 mM Mg, indicating that lowering Ca and increasing Mg concentrations can reduce COC density. However, plants grown in the container substrate irrigated with the same solutions did not show apparent changes in density of raphides and druses, suggesting that the container substrate had enough Ca and Mg initially, and fertigation with different concentrations of Ca and Mg had little effect on COC densities. (2) Determined light effects on COC formation. Dieffenbachia Exotic Perfection, and Snowflake were grown in Vergo Container Mix A and fertilized with N at 200 mg/L using an ebb-and-flow system in a shaded greenhouse under the maximum photosynthetic radiation of 285 micromole/m2/s. Eight months after planting, leaf sections were taken from the first unfurled leaf. The same plants were then moved to interior evaluation rooms and grown under a light intensity of 8 micromole/m2/s for eight months. Leaf sections were taken from the first unfurled leaf as well. COC types and densities were determined from the leaves produced under two light intensities. Results showed that raphide densities of Exotic Perfection and Snowflake produced indoors decreased by 58% and 64%, respectively, compared to those of plants produced in the shaded greenhouse. PARTICIPANTS: Not relevant to this project. TARGET AUDIENCES: Foliage plant growers, interior plantscapers, homeowners PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
Results from the hydroponic culture showed that lowering Ca and increasing Mg concentrations can significantly reduce COC density without detrimental effects on plant growth. However, such effects became diminished when Dieffenbachia were produced in container substrate. This finding suggests that COC density in Dieffenbachia would not be reduced in commercial production unless plants are produced in hydroponic system. Results from the light intensity experiments showed that high quality plants produced under the optimal light level contained high COC density, but COC density was significantly reduced after plants were placed indoors. Both nutritional and light experiments showed that the manipulation of environmental and cultural factors may have a limited opportunity for reducing COC densities in commercial Dieffenbachia production. As documented in our previous reports, COC formation is under genetic control, and genetic manipulation may be the ultimate solution to the COC reduction. Dieffenbachia is an important ornamental foliage plant used widely as a living specimen for interior decoration, but it contains some proteolytic enzymes contributing to the irritant effects to mammalians. COCs have been blamed as vehicles for delivering the enzymes. The identified differences among cultivars in distribution of the type and density of COCs in Dieffenbachia organs in our previous studies as well as the cultural practices altering COC density may suggest that reduction of COC densities is possible through breeding in combination with proper cultural practices, which may result in cultivars with less skin irritation.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period