Source: UNIVERSITY OF MAINE submitted to
GROWTH OF ASCOPHYLLUM NODOSUM AS AN INDEX OF OCEAN WARMING AND CLIMATE CHANGE IN THE NEARSHORE WATERS OF THE GULF OF MAINE.
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0210309
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jan 1, 2007
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2008
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF MAINE
(N/A)
ORONO,ME 04469
Performing Department
SCHOOL OF BIOLOGY & ECOLOGY
Non Technical Summary
This alga responds to elevated temperatures by increasing growth rate. If this can be quantified, then a index can be developed for detecting ocean warming. This project examines current and past growth rates of this perennial alga and may provide a test of whether ocean warming is occurring in the Nearshore Gulf of Maine.
Animal Health Component
50%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
50%
Applied
50%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1320430107060%
1350812106020%
1360819110320%
Goals / Objectives
1) To determine the origin of the tissues contributing to the purported annual segments (modules) that form below the new apical tip and establish whether or not the subtending apical module (SAM) represents one or more than one year of growth. In addition, observations on possible phenological and life-history changes (e.g., initiation of vegetative growth, gamete release, etc.) in Ascophyllum nodosum will be made. 2) To identify and characterize optimal habitat(s) for detecting possible changes in the growth of apical tips of Ascophyllum due to ocean warming. The rationale for this approach is that populations with higher growth rates and longer modules might detect or respond more readily to elevated temperatures. In effect, plants at fast-growing sites might provide an early-warning system for subtle changes in ocean warming. 3) To determine the spatial and temporal variation in growth of apical tips and define the limits that can be utilized in a growth model or index. Present-day growth rates of apical tips of Ascophyllum will be quantified in two regions (southwest and northeast coast) of Maine, at two wave exposure gradients (sheltered and moderately exposed) and over two or three (annual) growing seasons. 4) To determine whether the growth of Ascophyllum has responded to the purported warming of the Gulf of Maine, over the past 30-35 years. The rationale is to contrast the growth rates of recently accumulated (last 10 -15 yr) modular units with the growth rates of thalli at previously utilized sites (1970 - 1978) to evaluate the effects of thermal loading from MYAPCO. Hydrographic data will be taken at several sites (as in the 1970's) on environmental factors potentially influencing or confounding temperature effects. 5) To refine the graphical model on temperature effects on Ascophyllum nodosum (Vadas et al. 1978a) and develop an index of thermal condition for each site and wave exposure.
Project Methods
1) Shoots of Ascophyllum will be tagged and apical tips measured seasonally to determine the origin of modules. The modules are thought to represent annual growth. Experiments will be run at sheltered and moderately exposed sites to determine if current growth is confounded by growth from the subsequent year. In June and October half of the tagged modules will be cut, measured and weighed. If the weight of modules in June exceeds the weight of SAMs in March, then the increase in length of tagged modules represents new growth. 2) Optimal growth habitat(s) for Ascophyllum will be identified by the mean length of modules. Populations with higher growth rates are predicted to respond more readily to elevated temperatures. Measurements will be made at sites in the southwest and northeast at sheltered to moderately exposed shores. Observations will be made in fall on SAMs at the end of the vegetative growth phase and in March and June. The lengths of the linear series of modules will test long-term responses whereas the apical tips will test short-term (1 yr) responses. The lengths of the series of modules will test the prediction of gradual temperature change by regressing annual growth on age. The alternatives, gradual cooling or no change, will be evaluated if the warming hypothesis is rejected. 3) Patterns of variation will be quantified in two regions, two wave exposures, and two or three seasons. Temporal variation is best understood by annual replication and regression on environmental variables. High growth sites will be sampled in the southwest and northeast (4 sites/region), and 2 replicate sites/habitat. Differences in the lengths of the apical tips will test short-term (1 yr) responses to ocean warming. Regression analysis on long-term data will be used to test hypotheses of gradual change. An index(es) of regional, wave exposure, or site specific growth rates will be developed from these data. 4) To determine if growth of Ascophyllum has responded to the purported warming of the Gulf of Maine over the past 30 yr. Present-day growth rates of canopy shoots will be contrasted with rates generated from the Maine-Yankee thermal loading studies of the 1970's (Vadas et al. 1976, 1978). A Before-After-Control-Impact (BACI) design will be used, and applied at the same sites analyzed in the 1970s. Hydrographic, habitat and nutrient data will be sampled regularly to provide background data for growth patterns. Temperature and light data will be taken at representative sites fitted with Hobo sensors and data loggers. Nutrient levels in tissues will be analyzed to assess nutrient-growth relationships. 5) The graphical model on temperature effects on Ascophyllum nodosum (Vadas et al. 1978a) will be refined based on these studies. Regression analysis of apical tip length on temperature will be explored to develop an index of thermal condition. The effectiveness of the graphical model will be compared (tested) with present-day data, and updated or adjusted to account for our data and studies (Wilce 1978; Keser et al. 2005) from southern New England.

Progress 10/01/07 to 09/30/08

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Outputs _ 1/25/09 _ I modified an earlier field technique for studying the growth and survival of apical tips and shoots of Rockweed, Ascophyllum nodosum. Small color coded cable ties were used for marking individual apical tips. Large cable ties with numbered tags were fastened around the base of the alga to identify individual shoots. The small cable ties were attached snugly (not tightly) on the shoot (module) below the second vesicle (bladder). These procedures minimized girdling damage which could lead to the loss of apical and sub-apical tips. The seasonal measurement of tips allows growth rate and survival to be estimated and correlated with season, environmental, and biological variables. In addition, individual shoots are periodically returned to the laboratory for chemical analyses and measurement. These basic measurements will provide data for comparative analysis and testing possible long-term changes in growth rates. I have shared these methods and rationale with colleagues and students, as noted below. I have discussed aspects of the preliminary findings of the field growth studies on A. nodosum with biologists at the Bigelow Laboratories, the Department of Marine Resources, Suffolk University, University of New Brunswick and the University of Maine (UM). I have shared this information with colleagues at UM, the Northeast Algal Society, and the New England Estuarine Research Society. I have spoken with members of the Maine Seaweed Council (a pro-seaweed organization concerned with the growth and sustainable use of A. nodosum and other seaweeds). I regularly respond to letters and phone calls on this and other seaweed resources. I have involved colleagues and students in these studies including: Dr. Brian Beal, a marine ecologist from the University of Maine at Machias (UMM), He has assisted with sampling and tagging in the Jonesport region, and will assist with statistical analyses. He has periodically contributed undergraduates from UMM for assistance with field studies. Also, I have had assistance with tagging and growth measurements from Dennis Anderson, a UM research associate, several UM undergraduates and my son, an aquatic ecologist from the State of Washington. Lastly an honor, work study student (Shannon Alexa) is gaining valuable research experience assisting with algal measurements, salinity determinations, entering current and 1970's growth data on spreadsheets for comparative analysis. She is also starting an honors project on an aspect of growth. We may present a poster at a regional meeting in Spring 2009. Upon completion of field measurements (July, 2009), data entry and statistical analyses (Fall, 2009), the results will be presented at regional and national conferences and workshops. We will publish two or three papers from this work including: Temporal and spatial variability in the growth of A. nodosum; Influence of elevated temperatures on the phenology, growth and reproduction of A. nodosum; Climate change and the comparative growth of A. nodosum over three decades. PARTICIPANTS: Dr. Brian Bea l, Univ. of Maine at Machias, assisted with tagging studies and water sampling in the Jonesport area and will assist with statistical analyses. Dennis Anderson, Associate Scientist, Univ. of Maine, assisted with growth tagging studies in the Sheepscot area. Shannon Alexa, an Honors work-study student, assisted with laboratory measurements and data entry. My son and several undergraduates have participated in one or two sampling efforts. TARGET AUDIENCES: Marine resource and conservation managers (Department of Marine Resources: Nature Conservancy, etc.) in Maine, New Brunswick and New England; Marine and climate change ecologists and phycologists; Maine Seaweed Council, Seaweed Harvesters and informed "conservation" public. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
The results obtained in this work have been shared with the department of Maine Marine Resources and the Maine Seaweed Council. These results on the growth and survival of Rockweed will contribute to the managed growth and sustainable use of this important seaweed.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 01/01/07 to 09/30/08

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Outputs _ 1/25/09 _ I modified an earlier field technique for studying the growth and survival of apical tips and shoots of Rockweed, Ascophyllum nodosum. Small color coded cable ties were used for marking individual apical tips. Large cable ties with numbered tags were fastened around the base of the alga to identify individual shoots. The small cable ties were attached snugly (not tightly) on the shoot (module) below the second vesicle (bladder). These procedures minimized girdling damage which could lead to the loss of apical and sub-apical tips. The seasonal measurement of tips allows growth rate and survival to be estimated and correlated with season, environmental, and biological variables. In addition, individual shoots are periodically returned to the laboratory for chemical analyses and measurement. These basic measurements will provide data for comparative analysis and testing possible long-term changes in growth rates. I have shared these methods and rationale with colleagues and students, as noted below. I have discussed aspects of the preliminary findings of the field growth studies on A. nodosum with biologists at the Bigelow Laboratories, the Department of Marine Resources, Suffolk University, University of New Brunswick and the University of Maine (UM). I have shared this information with colleagues at UM, the Northeast Algal Society, and the New England Estuarine Research Society. I have spoken with members of the Maine Seaweed Council (a pro-seaweed organization concerned with the growth and sustainable use of A. nodosum and other seaweeds). I regularly respond to letters and phone calls on this and other seaweed resources. I have involved colleagues and students in these studies including: Dr. Brian Beal, a marine ecologist from the University of Maine at Machias (UMM), He has assisted with sampling and tagging in the Jonesport region, and will assist with statistical analyses. He has periodically contributed undergraduates from UMM for assistance with field studies. Also, I have had assistance with tagging and growth measurements from Dennis Anderson, a UM research associate, several UM undergraduates and my son, an aquatic ecologist from the State of Washington. Lastly an honor, work study student (Shannon Alexa) is gaining valuable research experience assisting with algal measurements, salinity determinations, entering current and 1970's growth data on spreadsheets for comparative analysis. She is also starting an honors project on an aspect of growth. We may present a poster at a regional meeting in Spring 2009. Upon completion of field measurements (July, 2009), data entry and statistical analyses (Fall, 2009), the results will be presented at regional and national conferences and workshops. We will publish two or three papers from this work including: Temporal and spatial variability in the growth of A. nodosum; Influence of elevated temperatures on the phenology, growth and reproduction of A. nodosum; Climate change and the comparative growth of A. nodosum over three decades. PARTICIPANTS: Dr. Brian Bea l, Univ. of Maine at Machias, assisted with tagging studies and water sampling in the Jonesport area and will assist with statistical analyses. Dennis Anderson, Associate Scientist, Univ. of Maine, assisted with growth tagging studies in the Sheepscot area. Shannon Alexa, an Honors work-study student, assisted with laboratory measurements and data entry. My son and several undergraduates have participated in one or two sampling efforts. TARGET AUDIENCES: Marine resource and conservation managers (Department of Marine Resources: Nature Conservancy, etc.) in Maine, New Brunswick and New England; Marine and climate change ecologists and phycologists; Maine Seaweed Council, Seaweed Harvesters and informed "conservation" public. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
The results obtained in this work have been shared with the department of Maine Marine Resources and the Maine Seaweed Council. These results on the growth and survival of Rockweed will contribute to the managed growth and sustainable use of this important seaweed.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 10/01/06 to 09/30/07

Outputs
OUTPUTS: I have discussed the objectives and preliminary results of the growth studies on Ascophyllum with marine resource managers, graduate students, colleagues (ecologists and phycologists) in Maine, New Brunswick and New England. Also, I have spoken with members of the Maine Seaweed Council (a non-governmental, pro-seaweed organization). I regularly respond to e-mails and phone calls on Ascophyllum, seaweed resources, sustainable harvest techniques, pollution problems and mariculture issues. In addition, I have involved Dr. Brian Beal, a marine ecologist from the University of Maine at Machias, with sampling and research in the Machias area. In the 1970's I developed a tagging technique (monofilament and plastic water-proof tape) for assessing growth of specific apical tips of Ascophyllum. I modified the technique in the current project by using color-coded cable ties for marking the shoots and apical tips. The cable ties are easily attached to the shoots and cause minimum damage to the alga. I have shared this methodology with colleagues and students, as noted above. Lastly, I have a work study student entering growth data from the 1970's on spreadsheets for comparative analysis. PARTICIPANTS: Dr. Brian Beal, Univ. of Maine at Machias, assisted with tagging studies and water sampling. Dennis Anderson, Associate Scientist, Univ. of Maine, assisted with tagging studies. Shannon Alexa, Work study student, assisted with laboratory measurements and data entry. TARGET AUDIENCES: marine resource managers in Maine, New Brunswick and New England, marine and climate change ecologists and phycologists, Maine Seaweed Council and informed "conservation" public. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: 1) The number of long-term sites have been reduced from eight to six. This was caused by time and resource considerations.

Impacts
The overall goals of this research are to determine if the annually produced apical tips and the subtending annual growth increments "modules" of rockweed (Ascophyllum nodosum) can be used as an expression of present-day thermal condition and provide an historical index of growth and temperature change over the last two to three decades in the Gulf of Maine. Six field sites were utilized for tagging and long-term growth studies. These sites, three in the southwest region (Montsweag Bay, Sheepscot River, Pemaquid Beach) and three in the northeast region (Great Wass Island, Jonesport, Roque Bluffs) were sampled regularly for temperature, salinity, seawater nutrients (nitrate, dissolved phosphate, total phosphate) and seasonally for growth. In addition, light extinction depth measurements were made with a secchi disk at representative stations at or near the field sites. Originally, I planned to sample four permanent sites in each region, but logistic and resource considerations limited the number of long-term sites. Additional (random) sites will also be utilized for phenological and growth (regression) analyses. Sampling of rockweed for phenological patterns was begun during the fall of 2006. Preliminary analyses suggest that growth in 2007 extends later into fall than normal (herein during the 1970's and 1980"s). If the extension of growth into mid or late fall is real, then this increase should be reflected in the lengths of the subtending (2007) modules in spring of 2008. The time of initiation of growth of new apical tips in spring, however, appears to be unchanged and similar to the 1970's. Observation of reproductive receptacles indicates that dehiscence of receptacles occurs four to six weeks earlier than normal. This suggests that gamete release is also initiated earlier in spring or that the window of release has been compressed. The net effect appears to be a shorter, narrower period of gamete release, reproductive activity and recruitment. Growth studies based on tagged shoots and tagged canopy (apical) tips showed considerable variation between sites. Generally, the lengths of canopy tips were similar within plants and within sites, except for Bar Island, which was blocked statistically, because of the apparent differences in habitat and tidal flow. Annual growth rates for the six populations tagged in 2007 ranged from 1.9% (Bar Island) to 2.4% (Ferry). The mean (annual) lengths (mm) of apical tips were: Ferry (145.2), Clough Point (104.6), Black Duck Cove (96.4), Rogue Bluffs (90.3), Pemaquid Beach (69.9), Bar Island (69.5). The higher annual growth patterns appear to reflect both reduced water movement and slightly warmer seawater temperatures. Data on the patterns of growth of subtending modules have not been completed nor analyzed. Data from the 1970's are being entered on spread sheets.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period