Source: SENSOR DEVELOPMENT CORP submitted to NRP
A NEW NANO BASED REAL-TIME AFLATOXIN DETECTOR
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0210192
Grant No.
2007-33610-17972
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2007-00186
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jun 1, 2007
Project End Date
Jan 31, 2009
Grant Year
2007
Program Code
[8.5]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
SENSOR DEVELOPMENT CORP
12900 SNOW ROAD
PARMA,OH 44130
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Mold growth in grain can produce deadly mycotoxins. SDCAEs nanocrystalline, solid state tin dioxide gas sensor will allow detection a signature gas given off during mold growth. This high sensitivity, high selectivity sensor system will allow real-time monitoring of grain in storage bins and during transportation. The initial target is detecting the growth of Aspergillus flavus in corn which produces aflatoxin. The FDA has a 20 ppb action limit on aflatoxin to insure food/feed safety. This project will optimize SDCAEs nanocrystalline gas phase sensors system. Sol gel coating of tin dioxide on an alumina substrate will produce a large number of active sites. Combinatorial chemistry will be used to add other compounds to the sol gel to improve selectivity to the signature gas given off by Aspergillus flavus. The operating conditions of the chip will be varied to further enhance sensitivity and selectivity. Commercial data analysis software will be adapted to further refine the detection system. Initially chips will be tested in a lab scale systems using know concentrations of signature gas and typical interferent gases. A lower detection limit of 1 ppb for the signature gas will be sought. Once optimized in the lab, a prototype will be evaluated in a real world environment using corn and Aspergillus flavus. Success will lead to beta site testing and the application to other mycotoxins, such as DON and other corps such as wheat and peanuts.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
71250101102100%
Goals / Objectives
Sensor Development Corp intends to demonstrate the sensitivity and selectivity of its proprietary nanocrystalline tin oxide solid state gas phase sensor for detecting ppb levels of certain signature gases given off during mold growth in grain. The initial target mold is Aspergillus flavus which produces aflatoxin. The target grain is corn. The FDA has an action limit for aflatoxin of 20 ppb. SDC believes a signature gas for Aspergillus flavus mold growth has been identified. With the sensitivity and selectivity of our systems, it could provide real-time management of grain storage and reduce the losses. Since our sensor system measures the signature gas from mold, it does not rely on grain sampling with its inherent potential for inaccuracy and the cost/delay of the sampling process. Temperature and carbon dioxide measurements could indicate mold growth. In a later phase, we would attempt correlation of these measurements with our signature gas measurements. Selectivity for the signature gas in the presence of other gases typical in grain storage environments is necessary and SDC will test a variety of active coatings, chip operating conditions and chip signal processing software to give the optimum performance for Aspergillus flavus. SDC believes there will be a unique set of parameters for each distinct signature gas. SDC will use combinatorial chemistry to fabricate a number of active coatings using sol-gel techniques. This nanocrystalline active coating will be screened in a laboratory test system that was developed and qualified earlier for assessment of indoor air quality. This system will use simulant gases of known composition for our measurements. Initial operating conditions will be based on earlier work, while the data analysis software to be evaluated will be commercially available platforms adapted to our application. The hardware and test operating software are already in place and should require minimal modification to complete the Phase I objective of developing a sensor chip with a high sensitivity and high selectivity for the signature gas for aflatoxin production in corn, performing under optimized chip operating conditions, and successfully using commercial software adapted for this application. The second objective for the Phase I program will be to test this sensor system in a real world environment by collaborating with Purdue University. Purdue possesses expertise in mold growth in corn both at the lab scale and 500 bushel bin scale. They will grow the mold on corn in the lab scale, and measure the gases produced using the optimized sensor from our lab scale work. Following completion of this task, we will evaluate the overall sensor performance in preparation for Phase II which would involve field-testing first in pilot bins at Purdue and then at beta test sites at major grain handling firms. Successful completion of this Phase I will open up other mold based applications in grain storage, such as DON produced by Fusarium, and other food supplies such as peanuts and wheat. In fuel ethanol production, aflatoxin in the DDG would also be a serious problem.
Project Methods
Sensor Development Corp will use its platform technology, a nanocrystalline tin dioxide solid state gas phase sensor system, to detect a signature gas for the presence of aflatoxin in corn storage. The Phase I effort will start with the fabrication of a number of sensor chips. These chips will be made by spin coating an alumina substrate with tin dioxide sol gels and then calcining under controlled temperature and time conditions. This will produce a nanocrystalline surface with numerous reaction sites, hence the high sensitivity. The composition of the sol gel will be modified by adding additional active metals to enhance selectivity in the presence of interferent gases. In addition to adding these metals to the sol gel, the composition of the sol gel can be varied. A combinatorial chemistry approach will be used to optimize performance of the sensors. The chip will have a platinum heater element printed, on its backside for chip heating, and a temperature sensor on the front side to monitor chip operating temperature. Chip fabrication will be done at Case Western Reserve University, using state-of-the-art equipment and experienced personnel. For sensors optimization, the fabricated chip will be evaluated in a lab test system which will expose the chip to controlled gas concentrations and compositions. Measurements of the specific net conductance (SNC), the change of the sensor in response to exposure to a test gas, will later be used to determine the concentration of the target gases. The system uses LabVIEW (National Instruments) to control the test operation and monitor the data output. During testing, the gas concentrations and compositions are varied along with the operating conditions. The optimum performance will be established from the variables of active coating composition, operating conditions, and data analysis. Software from commercial data analysis platforms will be used to analyze the data and correct for drift and noise if present. This optimized chip will then be installed in a test device, already prototyped by FloCell and delivered to Purdue University where it will be incorporated in a laboratory scale system for measuring the signature gas from actual mold growth in corn. The sensor chip, protected from dust, will be used to measure the concentration of the gas present. Knowing the bin volume and gas exchange rate, the high sensitivity of the system will allow comparison of the diluted signature gas with that determined by conventional analysis, the latter requiring representative sampling of the corn, then sample preparation and finally, reacting the resultant analyte with mycotoxin specific antibodies. The color change indicates the mycotoxin concentration. This method, Enzyme Link Immunosorbent Assay (ELISA), is approved by (GIPSA). Depending on the results from single chip testing in Phase I, multiple chips in an array format can be used to enhance the selectivity in Phase II. Each chip will have a different active coating or operating condition. Software manipulation of the data will further enhance the selectivity.

Progress 06/01/07 to 01/31/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: The ultimate goal beyond Objective 1 was to detect Humulene in an actual crop enclosure in the presence of the gases in the headspace over corn as it is stored in the enclosure using Sensor Development Corporation's (SDC) prototype sensor. The sensor was taken to Purdue University and tested in conjunction with the 1000 bushel corn bin located on the Purdue University farm. The bin was filled approximately three fourths full with corn from their farm. The gas from the bin was pumped out of the bin with an air pump and passed over the sensors and the base line sensor response established. An amount of about 80 ppb of the MVOC was released into the bin air stream. The sensor response to the MVOC was as expected and clearly demonstrated that the MVOC could be detected in an environment commonly existing in a corn bin atmosphere. Furthermore, SDC set up a computer and radio receiver in a remote weigh house approximately 120 yards from the corn bin. The computer received the wireless signal from the SDC sensor and displayed the resistance change and the temperature of the chips simulating transferal of data in the final application. As a result of the success of the Purdue University field test both The Andersons and Cargill have agreed to be beta test sites. The results have been shared with potential customer beta test sites at trade shows followed up with individual meetings. Objective 2 relates to indentifying the gases present in the headspace above the corn. It is important to identify other components as well which would be considered interferents or background gases. Samples of the gas in the headspace of non-toxigenic corn and toxigenic corn producing aflatoxin were collected and analyzed using GC/Mass Spec for gases not common between the two types of samples. This sample collection and GC/Mass Spec work were done at Purdue University and the USDA Southern Region Research Center. The analysis of the data was done at SDC. This work confirmed the presence of sesquiterpenes in the head space. It also identifies potential interferent gases and other potential marker gases. This information has yet to be published other than in the Phase I final report. PARTICIPANTS: The Project Director for this project was Robert N. Mansfield, Jr. "Rocky" as he is known at Sensor Development Corporation (SDC) led a team of engineers and scientists from inside SDC and other contributors from various universities, research groups and other companies through to its completion. The SDC team included Dr. Robert F. Scarr, Sr. Research Chemist and Samuel F. Reichert, Sr. Product Engineer. Dr. Scarr had overall responsibility for the gas analysis portion of the project including determining potential marker, background and interferent gases that could be found in a crop enclosure. Mr. Reichert worked in the area of sensor chip testing and interfaced with Dr. Mark R. De Guire, Assistant Professor Department of Materials Science and Engineering and his PhD candidate Ling Tang at Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio, as they made the sol gels with and without catalysts for coating the sensor chips that are used in SDC's prototype and lab testing set up. The sensor chips were tested in SDC's lab for best bet combinations for detecting the marker gas. This work led to the successful field trial at Purdue University's farm. Many individuals outside of Sensor Development Corporation contributed their time and talent to this project. Their contribution is acknowledged here. At Purdue University College of Agriculture, West Lafayette, Indiana, Dr. Charles P. Woloshuk, Professor of Plant Pathology, Botany and Plant Biology Department ran many key experiments using SDC's prototype sensor in the lab to confirm the presence of susquiterpenes in toxic corn with aflatoxin growing. The susquiterpenes were not present in non-toxic corn. Dr. Johnselvakumar Lawrence, Post Doc., set up the field trial at Purdue University's farm. Dr. Dirk E. Meir, Professor and Head Department of Grain Science & Industry, Kansas State University, Manhattan, Kansas formerly of Purdue University oversaw the field trial. The Food and Feed Safety Research group at the USDA Southern Regional Research Center, New Orleans, Louisiana led by Dr. Thomas E. Cleveland, Director Southern Regional Research Center, formerly Director Food and Feed Safety Research collected samples of volatiles from agar with and without A. flavus, the mold that produces aflatoxin, for gas chromatograph - mass spectroscopy analysis. Mr. Anthony J. De Lucca, Microbologist Food and Feed Safety Research supervised the undergraduate students that ran the volatile gas samples he prepared. Dr. Stephen M. Boue, Research Chemist, Food and Feed Safety Research provide the gas chromatograph - mass spectroscopy equipment for the analysis. Edward J. Rapp, President Flocel, Cleveland, Ohio designed the electronics for SDC's prototype, built the working prototype and encoded the software used by the prototype and lab test station. TARGET AUDIENCES: Not relevant to this project. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
The ultimate goal beyond Objective 1 was to detect sesquiterpenes in an actual crop enclosure in the presence of the gases in the headspace over corn as it is stored in the enclosure using Sensor Development Corporation's prototype sensor. The prototype sensor contains four sensor chips. Some are coated with catalyst combined with the nano-crystalline tin oxide and others are without catalyst. The gases in the headspace above the corn were pumped from the corn bin at 1,500 cubic centimeters per minute into the prototype through a dual flow controller. Into the second side of the dual flow controller, a tank containing a susquiterpene was connected. The susquiterpene flow rate was set at 85 ppb and turned on and off as desired. A 1,000 bushel bin at Purdue University's Agricultural Research Farm was used for this demonstration. In order to achieve this result, Objective 1 was a necessary precursor. To coat the sensor chips with catalyzed nano-crystalline tin oxide, techniques had to be developed to add the catalysts to the tin oxide sol gel before applying it to the sensor chip. Once the catalyst was successfully added to the tin oxide sol gel, a procedure for applying the sol gel had to be developed. Eventually two procedures were settled on and tried. The combinations of application procedure to the sensor chip and catalyst were tested in SDC's lab for response to susquiterpenes and other interferent gases. The goal of Objective 2 was to substantiate volatiles from previous work by Zeringue as markers for aflatoxin and to determine if other volatiles could be used as markers for aflatoxin detection. Furthermore, it was important to identify other components as well which would be considered interferents or background gases. Samples of the gas in the headspace of non-toxigenic corn and toxigenic corn producing aflatoxin were collected and analyzed using GC/Mass Spec for gases not common between the two types of samples. This sample collection and GC/Mass Spec work were done at Purdue University and the USDA Southern Region Research Center. The analysis of the data was done at SDC. The electronic chip sensors for A. flavus-produced volatiles will detect the five compounds that are most produced by this fungus as identified by the gas analysis from the USDA and Purdue. This will reduce the need, and hence overall cost, for sensors for all identified volatiles. Since these units will be small they can be easily located in any area where grain is stored and since the units can be either "hard-wired" or battery operated for power and data (e.g., power status, volatile detection, signal strength) transmission, purchasers of this technology will have the flexibility needed to accommodate their needs. This technology will be the first to offer the corn storage industry a real-time warning of A. flavus growth and will reduce or eliminate the need for costly and time consuming analyses for aflatoxins. This real-time capability will allow the users to reduce the possibility of contaminated corn being mixed with good, wholesome corn and thereby reduce food, feed and economic losses due to a large, mixed corn batch contaminated with aflatoxin.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period