Source: TENNESSEE STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
EFFECTS OF LONG-TERM NURSERY CROP PRODUCTION SYSTEMS IN MIDDLE TENNESSEE: AN ASSESSMENT OF NUTRIENTS IN THE COLLINS RIVER BASIN
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0208544
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Oct 1, 2006
Project End Date
Dec 31, 2009
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
TENNESSEE STATE UNIVERSITY
3500 JOHN A. MERRITT BLVD
NASHVILLE,TN 37209
Performing Department
Agricultural and Environmental Sciences
Non Technical Summary
It is obvious that growers will continue to use fertilizers and other farm chemicals to improve the quality of their nursery stock. Phosphorus (P) and nitrogen (N) are essential nutrients for crop production and are the primary factors controlling eutrophication. In middle Tennessee, especially in Warren and Grundy counties, large concentrations of nursery crop production exist. The Collins River Watershed drains these counties. The need to produce ornamental and nursery crops of high aesthetic quality has caused over-reliance on fertilizers. Some of these chemicals will be detected in streams and lakes. Additionally in nursery crop production systems, non-target application of fertilizer to nursery stock has been reported in published literature; this can result in the migration of the nutrients into water resources. And, subsequently degrade the water bodies. Plowing, liming and fertilization of nursery fields can result in the runoff of tons of soil and essential crop nutrients. To our knowledge most growers are not aware of the impact of these chemicals in surface water. For this reason it is expected that the project approach will provide sound data and therefore growers will recognize problems associated with nutrient pollution from nursery fields. It is expected that the data will be used as a template to encourage growers to develop nutrient management plans for their fields and in addition, adopt BMPs to mitigate the movement of nutrients to streams and the rivers.
Animal Health Component
30%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
60%
Applied
30%
Developmental
10%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1120210200060%
1120310205010%
1330310200030%
Goals / Objectives
1)To assess the concentrations of nitrogen and phosphorus in the river basin as a function of in field nursery crop production; 2)To develop essential nutrients chemical index relative to the seasons and as a measure of in-stream water quality; 3)To develop and administer a survey instrument to growers to provide baseline data on the nature of their farm operations and management practices in the Collins River Basin.
Project Methods
A short survey instrument will be developed and administered to growers in the Collins watershed. The data collected will provide baseline information on the nature of farm operations including acreage owned, types of nursery crops grown, frequency and types of fertilizer and lime application. The instrument will also reflect questions on their management practices. The watershed will be instrumented with weather stations, and the number of stations will be based on the predominant soil types in the watershed. The assumption is that the predominant soil types will not be more than three. In addition to providing meteorological data, the weather stations will have sensors that will provide real time soil moisture status in the watershed. Grab water samples will be collected weekly during base flow and after rainstorm events from up stream, middle stream and down stream. During each field visit, water samples will be collected in one liter LDPE (low density polyethelene) sample containers placed in a cooler with ice and will be transported to lab for analysis. The sampling locations will be geo-referenced with a GPS unit. The grabbed samples will be analyzed for total nitrogen, nitrate-N, ammonium-N, total phosphorus, dissolved phosphorus and particulate phosphorus attached to sediment particles. The water samples will also be analyzed for the following cations: sodium, potassium, magnesium and calcium. Standard EPA methods for water sample analyses will be used. Water sampling frequency will be coordinated with Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation (TDEC) and will be taken during the three major seasons (Spring, Summer and Fall). TDEC currently have monitoring stations at the watershed to measure water quality parameters such as dissolved oxygen, pH, turbidity, temperature and suspended particles and is willing to share such data. The measured and calculated values of all the parameters including the nutrient parameters will be used to develop stream water quality chemical index (WQCindex) for the Collins river basin dominated by nusery rop production. The WQCindex will be calculated by normalizing and summing up the measured and /or calculated water quality parameters of the stream(s) in the sub-watershed dominated by nursery crop productions. This will be done for each of the seasons, summer, fall and spring. The water quality chemical index could range from greater than 0 to100 with 100 being extremely poor stream quality; greater or equal to zero being having excellent quality.

Progress 10/01/06 to 12/31/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Three major tributaries:Mountain creek, Charles creek, Hills creek of the Collins River were sampled for two years,2008 and 2009 during spring, summer and fall. During this period Nitrate-N, Ammonium-N, Ortho-Phosphorus, Calcium, Magnesium, Potassium and Sodium were monitored in the creeks during base flow. The following water quality parameters: pH, Temperature, Dissolved oxygen, Turbidity, Specific conductance and Total dissolved solids were also monitored. Nitrate concentrations in the creeks were low; it ranged from 0.2 to 1.4 mg/L. Ammonium -N was negligible (below detection limit). The average concentration of nitrate- N in the creeks were: Mountain creek (0.02-1.41 mg/L) Charles creek (0.7-1.22 mg/L), Hills creek (0.06-0.50 mg/L). However, during rainstorm events in 2008, the average nitrate concentration in Hills creek ranged from 1.5-15.6 mg/L. Charles creek, 0.81- 1.37mg/L; Mountain creek 0.6-1.41 mg/L. It is what noting that rainfall events were minimal during the summers of 2008 and 2009. The national background concentration of nitrate -N in streams is about 0.6 mg/L. In some instances in the study, nitrate concentration in the creeks exceeded this value. Phosphorus, during base flow and rainstorm events was also low. It ranged from 0.02 mg/L in Mountain creek and Hills creek to 0.08 mg/L in Charles creek. Total phosphorus concentration greater than 0.025 can stimulate excessive growth of algae in surface water. Excessive algae growth can result in undesirable taste and odor of water. Additionally, all the creeks at the time of sampling had relatively low concentrations of cations except calcium. Mountain creek (0.9-3.0 mg/L of Na; 0.5-8.4 mg/L of K; 4.0-9.0 mg/L of Mg and 25.1-51.32 mg/L of Ca); Charles creek (0.4-2.0 mg/L of Na; 0.76-1.27 mg/L of K; 6.0-10.30 mg/L of Mg and 38.04-55.84mg/L of Ca); Hills creek (0.33-0.89 mg/L of Na; 0.88-1.35 mg/L of K; 6.69-10.74 mg/L of Mg and 37.9-63.77 mg/L of Ca). Considering the hydro-geologic conditions of Middle Tennessee, with abundance of limestone rocks, it was expected that calcium will be relatively high. Water quality parameters data during base flow were as follows: Mountain creek (Average pH value = 7.8, water temperature = 20.550C, dissolved oxygen 6.7 mg/L, turbidity = 2.2 NTU, Specific conductance = 245 micro Siemens and total dissolved solids = 155gram/L). Charles creek (Average pH value = 8.1, water temperature = 20.120C, dissolved oxygen 7.8 mg/L, turbidity = 4.72 NTU, Specific conductance = 261 micro Siemens and total dissolved solids = 168 gram/L). Hills creek (Average pH value = 6.6, water temperature = 21.280C, dissolved oxygen 6.6 mg/L, turbidity = 5.03 NTU, Specific conductance = 356 micro Siemens and total dissolved solids = 283 gram/L). Forums such as regional nursery trade shows (Southern Nursery Association trade show) and watershed association organized meetings were used to communicate research findings to appropriate scientific and stakeholder groups. PARTICIPANTS: Sam Dennis served as the PD of the project. He was responsible for the characterization of the Collins River sub-watershed. He directed the water sampling and analysis protocols including instrument calibrations. Debbie Eskandarnia served as the research assistant. She also was involved in the collection and analysis of the water samples. She also took the lead in data entry and tabulation. Debbie also made contact with growers, regularly updating their production practices. Steve Morris is an undergraduate student who worked on the project. His role was to assist the research assistant in data entry and sample instrument calibration. Chris Ransom is an undergraduate student who worked on the project. His role was to assist the research assistant in data entry and sample instrument calibration. TARGET AUDIENCES: -Field nursery crop growers. -Watershed association's members/stakeholders -Row crop growers. -The State regulatory agency (Tennessee Department of environment and conservation) PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
Collins River is still on the State's 303(d)list of impaired water bodies. It is too soon to conclude that the in-flow creeks monitored (Mountain creek, Charles creek, Hills creek) contributed to the impairment of the water quality of the Collins River. More sampling seasons are needed to ascertain why Collins River is on the 303(d) list. Majority of the growers (98%) in the Collins River watershed had field grown nursery stock operation. They grew a mixture of trees like dogwood and shrubs like burning bushes. However, prior to the inception of the project, these growers in the watershed were not aware of the impact of their fertilizer and lime management practices on surface water. The results from the study play an integral role in educating the growers. The project targeted 10 growers per year in the watershed that will become aware of the impact of their nutrient management practices on surface water quality. We found out during the Collins River watershed association meetings that the actual number of growers who became aware of the impact ranged from 5-7 per year. We also found out that no grower developed nutrient management plans for their field operations. They also seldom do annual soil testing for fertilizer and lime requirements. There is the need to train future workforce (students) to meet the need of water resource issues, especially in the area of water quality assessment and monitoring. The project provided research and extension experiential training to two(2) undergraduate students.The students assisted in instrument(s) calibration and stream water sampling.

Publications

  • Dumenyo, C.K., Kersey, C., Dennis, S.O. and Eskandarnia, D. 2010. Survey for bacterial pathogens in creeks at the Collins River sub-watershed. In Proceedings Southern Nursery Association Research Conference Vol. 55: 000 (In Press).
  • Dennis, S. O., Eskandarnia, D., Clardy, A. and Tsegaye, T. 2009. Water quality assessment of two creeks at the Collins River sub-watershed dominated by nursery crop production. Accepted. Jour of Environmental Monitoring and Restoration. Vol 7: 000.
  • Dennis, S. O., Eskandarnia, D. and Clardy, C. 2009. Know your creek: A look at the water quality of two creeks at the Collins River sub-watershed. In Proceedings Southern Nursery Association Research Conference Vol. 54: 43-47.
  • Dennis, S. O., Eskandarnia, D. and Tsegaye, T. 2009. Assessing nutrients in two Creeks at the Collins River Sub watershed in Middle Tennessee. Abstract-CD. American Society of Agronomy Conference. Southern Branch. Atlanta GA.


Progress 01/01/08 to 12/31/08

Outputs
OUTPUTS: The possible impact of field nursery crop production on surface water continues to play an integral role in the project. Three major tributaries (Mountain creek, Charles creek, Hills creek) of the Collins River were sampled in the summer of 2008 during ten consecutive weeks. Grab water samples were taken during base flow and in some instances during rainstorm events. The water samples were analyzed for Nitrate-N, Ammonium-N, Ortho-Phosphorus, Calcium, Magnesium, Potassium and Sodium. The following water quality parameters: pH, Temperature, Dissolved oxygen, Turbidity, Specific conductance and Total dissolved solids were also monitored. While the project is still at the data acquisition stage; the PD and his research assistant attended the Collins River watershed technical stakeholders meeting in late summer of 2008. The meeting was held in McMinnville Tennessee. We used the forum to present the data collected thus far. PARTICIPANTS: Sam Dennis served as the PD of the project. He was involved in the collection and analysis of the water samples. Debbie Eskandarnia served as the research assistant. She also was involved in the collection and analysis of the water samples. She also took the lead in data entry and tabulation. TARGET AUDIENCES: -Field nursery crop growers. -Watershed association's members/stakeholders -Row crop growers. -The State regulatory agency (Tennessee Department of environment and conservation) PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: None

Impacts
The average nitrate concentrations during base flow in the creeks were low: Mountain creek (0.02-1.41 mg/L) Charles creek (0.7-1.22 mg/L), Hills creek (0.06-0.50 mg/L). However, during rainstorm events the average nitrate concentration in Hills creek ranged from 1.5-15.6 mg/L. Charles creek, 0.81- 1.37mg/L; Mountain creek 0.6-1.41 mg/L. It is worth noting that the number of times it rained was very few during the summer of 2008. Phosphorus, during base flow and rainstorm events was also low. It ranged from 0.02 mg/L in Mountain creek and Hills creek to 0.08 mg/L in Charles creek. Additionally, all the creeks at the time of sampling had relatively low concentrations of cations except calcium. Mountain creek (0.9-3.0 mg/L of Na; 0.5-8.4 mg/L of K; 4.0-9.0 mg/L of Mg and 25.1-51.32 mg/L of Ca); Charles creek (0.4-2.0 mg/L of Na; 0.76-1.27 mg/L of K; 6.0-10.30 mg/L of Mg and 38.04-55.84mg/L of Ca); Hills creek (0.33-0.89 mg/L of Na; 0.88-1.35 mg/L of K; 6.69-10.74 mg/L of Mg and 37.9-63.77 mg/L of Ca). Considering the hydro-geologic conditions of Middle Tennessee, with abundance of limestone rocks, it was expected that calcium will be relatively high. Water quality parameters data during base flow were as follows: Mountain creek (Average pH value = 7.8, water temperature = 20.550C, dissolved oxygen 6.7 mg/L, turbidity = 2.2 NTU, Specific conductance = 245 micro Siemens and total dissolved solids = 155gram/L). Charles creek (Average pH value = 8.1, water temperature = 20.120C, dissolved oxygen 7.8 mg/L, turbidity = 4.72 NTU, Specific conductance = 261 micro Siemens and total dissolved solids = 168 gram/L). Hills creek (Average pH value = 6.6, water temperature = 21.280C, dissolved oxygen 6.6 mg/L, turbidity = 5.03 NTU, Specific conductance = 356 micro Siemens and total dissolved solids = 283 gram/L). Based on the finding thus far, growers (10) present at watershed technical stakeholders meeting in late summer are aware of the possible impact of nursery crop production in the creeks especially during rainstorm events.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 01/01/07 to 12/31/07

Outputs
OUTPUTS: A short survey instrument was developed. The method of delivery was by mail. It was sent to twenty (20) randomly selected growers in the Collins River sub-watershed. There was one phone call follow-up a month after the survey was mailed out. Twelve (12) of the twenty (20) randomly selected growers in the sub-watershed returned the completed survey questionnaire. PARTICIPANTS: Dr. Sam Dennis served in the capacity of the project director. He developed the survey instrument and analyzed the questionnaires with the help of students. TARGET AUDIENCES: Nursery crop growers especially those that grew field-grown stock

Impacts
Majority of the growers (98%) had field grown nursery stock operation. They grew a mixture of trees like dogwood and shrubs like burning bushes. Two (2) percent had both field grown and container operations. The field nursery crop operators applied complete fertilizer (NPK) to their nursery fields. None of these growers had nutrient management plan for these fields. They only became aware of the importance of developing a nutrient management plan for their fields because of the results of the survey. They also seldom do annual soil testing for fertilizer and lime requirements. Four of the surveyed growers (33%) applied agricultural lime every 3-4 years to their fields.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 01/01/06 to 12/31/06

Outputs
The Collins River is a major source of public water supply and recreational source for the residents of the watershed. Possible effects of nursery crop production on the quality of inflows to the river are concern to water managers and residents that live on the watershed. The objectives of the project are: to asses the concentrations of nitrogen and phosphorus in the Collins River basin as a function of in-field nursery crop production; to develop essential nutrients chemical index relative to the seasons and as a measure of in-stream water quality; to develop and administer a survey instrument to growers to provide baseline data on the nature of their farm operations and management practices in the Collins River sub-watershed. A short survey was developed to provide baseline information on the types of nursery operations; including types of crops grown and frequency of fertilizer and lime application in the Collins River sub-water shed dominated by nursery crop production. The survey instrument will be pre-tested in late March 2007. Project personnel have attended two stakeholders' meetings held in McMinnville Tennessee; one in November 2006 (15 attendees) and the other in February 2007 (20 attendees). The Collins River watershed drains McMinnville. The forum (stakeholder meetings) was used to introduce the objectives of the project to the growers that were present. Discussions are also on going with officials of the Tennessee Department of Environment (TDEC) on how to better coordinate nutrient (nitrogen, phosphorus, sodium, potassium, magnesium, and calcium) sampling protocol and discharge data for the major tributaries of the Collins River.

Impacts
A 20% reduction in fertilizer and lime application to nursery fields by growers in the watershed. Behavior change as a result of adopting soil testing by nursery crop growers prior to fertilizer and lime application is expected to increase by 40%. A monitoring network in the sub-watershed dominated by nursery crop production that will be used to validate the State's TMDL of nutrients in the Collins River.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period