Source: UNIVERSITY OF WYOMING submitted to NRP
WYOMING WILDLIFE/LIVESTOCK DISEASE RESEARCH PARTNERSHIP 2006: PASTEURELLOSIS, CWD AND BRUCELLOSIS IN WILDLIFE AND LIVESTOCK
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0208149
Grant No.
2006-34494-17598
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2006-06014
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2006
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2009
Grant Year
2006
Program Code
[VR]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF WYOMING
1000 E UNIVERSITY AVE DEPARTMENT 3434
LARAMIE,WY 82071-2000
Performing Department
VETERINARY SCIENCES
Non Technical Summary
This partnership grant tackles three wildlife-livestock diseases of concern to wildlife managers and livestock producers in Wyoming. One study will attempt to establish whether a group of domesticated sheep can induce pneumonia complex in bighorn sheep, and the infectious agent(s) that are involved. The second involves laboratory examination of the ease of which different types of normal prion protein from deer are converted in vitro to pathological prion proteins. The third study examines the merits of Wyoming's Game and Fish Department's ongoing test and kill program to reduce the proportion of elk infected with brucellosis on one feedground in western Wyoming.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
3113899110334%
3113310110333%
3113610110033%
Goals / Objectives
To study the physicochemical nature of genetic variants of cervid prion proteins (PrP) associated with differential susceptibility to CWD, using in vitro conversion assays of recombinant proteins and UV spectra circular dichroism. This is to test whether the mechanism by which these naturally occurring variants exert their effects is related to an increased energy of activation for conversion to the disease-associated isoform. A second study, to be conducted at Washington State University in collaboration with a pathologist at the University of Wyoming, will test the controversial hypothesis that pneumonia complex in bighorn sheep is directly transmissible from healthy domestic sheep to bighorns. The third component of the proposal addresses brucellosis in elk in the Greater Yellowstone Area. It will test the hypothesis that test-and-slaughter of infected free-ranging elk will significantly reduce overall number of infected elk on selected WGFD feedgrounds in western Wyoming. The test and slaughter program is due to run for 5 years (first year was 2006). This study will encompass years 2-4. Specific objectives are: - To determine changes in brucellosis seroprevalence rate in adult female elk on Muddy Creek feedground annually for 3 successive years of the test-and-slaughter pilot program - To determine and validate the minimum positive reaction titers for each of the Brucella serological tests (alone and/or in combination as necessary) to accurately identify culture-positive elk for removal - To determine abortion and parturition rates and spatial abortion/parturition ranges of feedground elk, both to correlate with serological titers and to assess the effects rates and ranges have on the test-and-removal program.
Project Methods
Study 1: examination of physicochemical properties of prion proteins from cervids of differing genotypes. The study will involve cloning normal prion protein from multiple cervid species and examining the ease with which they are converted into abnormal configurations of prion proteins. Study 2: attempted induction of respiratory disease complex in bighorn sheep following exposure to domestic sheep. This study will be done by defining the respiratory pathogens, particularly bacteria in the genus Pasteurella/Mannheimia, in the respiratory tract of a group of sheep using pulsed field gel electrophoresis and PCR analysis. The sheep will then be allowed come into contact with bighorn sheep in three stages: penned at a distance of ten feet apart for three months, followed by fence-line contact for and finally, co-mingling. Animals will be monitored for signs of pneumonia. Those which develop pneumonia will be examined post-mortem. Bacteria and viruses isolated from animals will be compared with those that were present in the sheep prior to exposure to each other, by means of pulse field gel electrophoresis and PCR analysis. This comparison should reveal whether the bighorn sheep developed pneumonia as a result of transmission of pathogens from the domestic sheep, following exposure to them. Study 3: reduction in seroprevalence in elk following a test and slaughter program in the Greater Yellowstone area: Elk trapping, testing, and removal for slaughter will be performed on a WGFD feedground in 2007 and 2008. Serum collected from adult females will be tested for antibodies to B. abortus. Elk with titers above previously established WGFD cutoffs will be transported to a packing plant and killed humanely. For each elk, culture results and serological titers will be compared using a paired t-test to determine cutoffs for the serological tests. Analyses will begin following the completion of bacterial cultures in year 1 (2006), and repeated in years 2 and 3 (2007 and 2008). Results may be incorporated into the WGFD algorithm for determining serological status in the following year of the test-and-slaughter program. Abortion rates and ranges will be investigated on one feedground. Approximately 40 female elk will be immobilized and an ultrasound unit be used to determine pregnancy. Vaginally implanted transmitters containing VHF signaling devices will be placed in 30 pregnant cows. Elk will be ear tagged, aged, and fitted with a vinyl visibility collar. Fifteen ml of blood will be collected v for subsequent serological testing for brucellosis. Vaginal transmitter signals will be monitored on a daily basis from implantation through the end of the feeding season with radio telemetry equipment. Universal transverse mercator coordinates of aborted fetuses will be recorded using a GPS unit to determine spatial range of abortion. Aborted fetuses will be recovered when possible and tissues will be collected for Brucella culture. Culture data from expelled transmitters will be combined with range information to establish the risk of transmission during feeding season and calving.

Progress 09/01/06 to 08/31/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Bighorn sheep-domestic sheep in-contact study: Results from the contact study were presented to scientific audiences (e.g., Conference of Research Workers in Animal Diseases, Chicago, IL, December 6-8, 2009; Schwabe Symposium, Chicago, IL, December 4, 2012). The study's results inform field investigations of natural outbreaks of bighorn sheep pneumonia, with increased focus on the potential importance of Mycoplasma ovipneumoniae as a co-factor. Historically, primacy was accorded Pasteurella multocida and Bibersteinia trehalosi as major etiological agents in BHS pneumonia complex. A recent investigation of 8 BHS pneumonia epizootics in the western United States concluded that M. ovipneumoniae was commonly present in pneumonic lungs. Brucellosis in GYA elk: Test-and-slaughter over five years significantly reduced elk brucellosis seroprevalence. Such an approach could serve as a management tool in a combined arsenal to reduce brucellosis transmission risks amongst elk, and between elk and other wildlife and domestic species (cattle). Identifying elk parturition ranges (and thereby abortion ranges) provided management information for more effective, seasonally relevant segregation of elk and cattle during the brucellosis transmission risk period (February-June). Results were disseminated via peer reviewed publications, meetings with Wyoming Game and Fish department wildlife managers, and WGFD annual reports. PrP in cervid species: Purified protein as well as plasmid-bearing bacterial stocks were disseminated to collaborators for collateral projects including the use of MALDI-MS to analyze alleles present in disease-associated prion from CWD-infected deer and elk. Protein and plasmids were also donated for projects to develop the in vitro conversion assay of Caughey et al (QUIC) using cervid recPrP as template material to allow the investigation of a wide range of tissue and environmental samples for infectious prion, and the compatibility of genetic variants to conversion by homologous and heterologous infectious prions. PARTICIPANTS: Individuals working on project: Dr. Subramaniam Srikumaran; Dr. Todd Cornish; Dr. Jean Jewell. Partner organizations: University of Wyoming; Washington State University. Training or professional development: Master's thesis, University of Wyoming--Ms. Laura Linn. TARGET AUDIENCES: Wildlife managers; veterinarians; diagnosticians; hunters; livestock producers. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
A significant finding was majority survival of bighorn sheep over >100 days of commingling with domestic sheep in the absence of M. ovipneumoniae. The high survival rate is consistent with M. ovipneumoniae being an important component in epidemic pneumonia of bighorn sheep. If correct, the risk of bighorn sheep pneumonia following contact with domestic sheep could be reduced if in-contact sheep are managed to eliminate carriage and shedding of M. ovipneumoniae. Related field studies of bighorn sheep pneumonia suggest that M. ovipneumoniae is the only agent for which data consistently met the criteria for a primary etiologic role in multiple outbreaks. Identification of M. ovipneumoniae as the epizootic agent of bighorn sheep pneumonia may prove a useful focus for control measures. The WGFD elk brucellosis test-and-slaughter program was performed on three elk winter feedgrounds in one elk herd unit (2006 to 2010). Elk from one feedground were trapped and tested for brucellosis twice each winter during this time period. 107 seropositive elk from the feedground were sent to slaughter. Brucellosis seroprevalence decreased significantly on the feedground from 2006 (39%) to 2010 (5%). All slaughtered elk were tested by bacterial culture. 60% were culture-positive for Brucella abortus [57% of pregnant elk (n=83), 71% of non-pregnant elk (n=24), 100% of yearling elk (n=5)]. The serological test panel with highest sensitivity and specificity for predicting culture positive animals was the card test, rivanol, SPT, and FPA (sensitivity = 100%, specificity = 88%). Results of the pilot test-and-slaughter program suggest that this approach may have value in lowering elk brucellosis seroprevalence (and, by proxy, risk of brucellosis transmission to cattle) in select applications. The program was labor intensive and costly (total cost in excess of $1.25 million). We foresee this option as a useful tool when combined with other disease control applications. The associated project using vaginal implant transmitters on pregnant elk that delineated new parturition (and potential abortion) ranges for elk. These data are incorporated into the WGFD elk brucellosis management plans, They resulted in improved segregation of elk and domestic cattle during the brucellosis transmission season (February to June). Physicochemical properties of prion proteins in cervid species: Mule deer cellular prion protein gene (PrP) alleles encoding serine at amino acid position 225 (225S) or phenylalanine at position 225 (225F) were cloned into expression-inducible plasmid vectors, expressed in E coli cultures and purified from inclusion body pellets using metal affinity column liquid chromatography under renaturing conditions. The 209I (isoleucine at codon 209) allele of moose (Alces alces shirasi) cellular prion protein gene was also cloned. Monoclonal antibodies were developed that would be immunoreactive for 225S or 225F. 25 MAbs from the F peptide mice and 19 from the S peptide mice were isolated and screened for allelic specificity. Efforts to secure further funding to continue the project beyond the expiration of the grant were unsuccessful.

Publications

  • Maichak, EJ, Scurlock, BM, Rogerson, JD, Meadows, LL, Barbknecht, AE, Edwards, WH, Cross, PC. 2009. Effects of management, behavior, and scavenging on risk of brucellosis transmission in elk of western Wyoming. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 45:398-410.
  • Scurlock, BM, Edwards WH, Meadows LL, Cornish, TE. 2011. Using Test and Slaughter to Reduce Prevalence of Brucellosis in Elk Attending Feedgrounds in the Pinedale Elk Herd Unit of Wyoming; Results of a 5 Year Pilot Project. Wyoming Game and Fish Department Annual Report 2011.
  • Besser TE, Cassirer EF, Yamada C, Potter KA, Herndon C, Foreyt WJ, Knowles DP, Srikumaran S. 2012. Survival of bighorn sheep (Ovis canadensis) commingled with domestic sheep (Ovis aries) in the absence of Mycoplasma ovipneumoniae. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 48(1):168-72.
  • Meadows, LL, Scurlock, BM, Edwards, WH, Tate, CM, Rogerson, JD, Maichak, EJ, Henningsen, JC, Randall, J, Robinson, TJ, and Cornish, TE. 2012. Evaluation of an Elk Brucellosis Test-and-Slaughter Program in Wyoming. Journal of Wildlife Diseases(submitted).
  • Meadows, LL. 2011. Evaluation of the Elk Brucellosis Test-and-Slaughter Program and Comparison of Bacteriologic and Serologic Tests for Brucellosis in Elk. Masters Thesis, Animal and Veterinary Sciences, University of Wyoming, Laramie, Wyoming.
  • Nichols, TA, Pulford, B, Wyckoff, AC, Meyerett, C, Michel, B, Gertig, K, Hoover, EA, Jewell, JE, Telling, GC, and Zabel, MD. 2009. Detection of protease-resistant cervid prion protein in water from a CWD-endemic area. Prion 3:171-183.


Progress 09/01/06 to 08/31/07

Outputs
The purposes of these three studies are 1. definitively test the hypothesis that bighorn sheep cannot cohabit with domestic sheep without transmission of pneumonia complex developing in the former, and to confirm that the causative agent is Mannheimia/Pasteurella in the upper respiratory tract of healthy sheep ; 2. determine changes in brucellosis seroprevalence rates in elk on winter feedgrounds in western Wyoming in the second year (2007) of the Wyoming Game and Fish Department's test and slaughter program, and to validate the use of minimum positive reaction titers to identify and cull high risk infected elk; 3. characterize the biochemical properties of PrP protein genetic variants from mule deer, elk and other cervid species. 1. Pneumonia complex in bighorn sheep cohabiting with domestic sheep: this study has just begun. A post-doctoral research associate is now recruited, and equipment and supplies are ordered. 2. Brucellosis study: In 2007, brucellosis seroprevalence on the study feedground was 16.5%; 13 elk went to slaughter. Tissues collected from slaughtered elk are being cultured for Brucella abortus to allow evaluation of a panel of brucellosis serological tests to improve the ability to detect actively-infected animals. 3. CWD study: Copies of one mule deer cellular prion protein gene (genotype 225SF) were cloned into bacterial plasmid pET30a in preparation for transfer to E coli BL21 (DE3) bacterial cultures for expression of the PrP protein, followed by purification and analysis by circular dichroism. Remaining clones from four other cervid species will be produced and analyzed similarly.

Impacts
1. Assuming that domestic sheep transmit pneumonia complex to bighorn sheep, this study will determine the strains of Mannheimia/Pasteurella that are involved, and whether it can be established that they match strains present in the nasal passages of healthy domestic sheep. We will attempt to establish whether other infectious agents are also involved. 2. Test and slaughter of Brucella-infected elk is being undertaken over five years (2006 - 2011). The current study will help establish whether this results in a consistent decline in prevalence rates of brucellosis in elk. 3. There are currently no effective strategies to control chronic wasting disease among susceptible cervids in the endemic area in WY and CO. The current study will provide basic information about 10 different prion proteins of cervid origin, such as the activation energy needed to convert normal PrP to disease-associated forms.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period