Source: UNIVERSITY OF PUERTO RICO AT MAYAGUEZ submitted to NRP
BIOLOGICALLY-BASED MANAGEMENT OF THE CITRUS LEAFMINER, AND OTHER KEY CITRUS NURSERY PESTS IN PUERTO RICO: A RESEARCH AND EDUCATION PROJECT
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0207350
Grant No.
2006-34103-17136
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2006-03547
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 15, 2006
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2009
Grant Year
2006
Program Code
[QQ]- Integrated Pest Management/Biological Control
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF PUERTO RICO AT MAYAGUEZ
P. O. BOX 9000
MAYAGUEZ,PR 00681
Performing Department
Crops and Agroenvironmental Sciences
Non Technical Summary
The current application is for a joint research-extension project. This activity seeks to validate pest management systems in citrus nurseries against the citrus leafminer in Puerto Rico. These systems are new to the local production system, but well researched elsewhere. The proposed project also delivers these systems to producers through demonstrations, training, and education programs. The project's key personnel include two researchers and an extension educator with appointments in research and extension, respectively.
Animal Health Component
60%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
40%
Applied
60%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2110930113020%
2150930113030%
2160930113050%
Goals / Objectives
Objectives for this Project are : (1) to conduct validation research for CLM bio-based management tactics in citrus nurseries, using commercially available Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) formulations, and other biologically-based pesticides (i.e., abamectin, rosemary oil, and azadirachtin); (2) to determine the effects of these tactics on CLM natural enemies, and those of other pests (e.g., aphids, other lepidoptera.) ; and (3) to prepare demonstration nurseries at two locations that will be used as a platform for farmer's training through presentations, displays, and educational materials.
Project Methods
Validation of bio-based CLM management options: Our study seeks to verify the effectiveness of different bio-based products in managing CLM (and other pests) on young flush in experimental nurseries. Two locations ecologically different locations will be chosen to conduct validation testing. Five bio-based pesticides, Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki, B.t. subsp. aizawai, abamectin, rosemary oil, and azadirachtin (all as formulated plus and an organosilicate surfactant), and a water check will serve as treatments. [Bt will be applied at 2 lb/a, abamectin at 1 lb/a, rosemary oil at label indications, and azadirachtin at 1% solution]. Four replicates of 15 one-year old plastic-bagged nursery stock trees (grafted to 'Cleopatra' tangerine rootstock) will be arranged in a randomized complete block design, will be placed on the ground at 8 inch spacing between trees and 36 inches between blocks. Separate tests will be simultaneously conducted on 'Encore' tangerines and 'Tahiti' lemons at each of the locations, and the entire experiment will be replicated 3 times. Efficacy will be determined using Abbott's formula (Abbott 1925), and results compared using ANOVA with randomized complete block design Identification and importance of natural enemies attacking CLM: Presence of natural enemies will be determined by collecting 10 developing new shoots containing different stages of the CLM each week. Shoots will be placed in plastic bags and brought to the laboratory for examination. Leafminer density (larvae/leaf/flush) will be determined. Immature parasitoids found in the mines will be isolated in glass vials and placed in climate controlled chambers (25 plus or minus 2 Celsius degree) at 50-60% RH and LD 14:10). Parasitoids will be allowed to develop to adult stage for identification. Other common predators will be collected from these plots after a 10 minute inspection of each plot. Predators will be tallied, and samples collected and sent for identification.

Progress 09/15/06 to 08/31/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Field and laboratory experiments have shown excellent promise in the use of reduced risk and biological pesticides to control the citrus leaf miner (CLM) (Phyllocnistis citrella), and the Asian citrus butterfly (Papilio demoleus). The latter is an invasive pest expected to have moderate economic impact on the citrus industry, especially on new plantings. Laboratory experiments with third instar larvae showed that excellent control could be achieved with the use of the biological pesticide Bacillus thuringiensis subs. kurstaki, and of the reduced risk pesticide spinosad, as compared with the control. Other pesticides such as, azadirachtin and rosemary oil were not better controlling the pest than the control (surfactant alone). We also determined and published relevant life history parameters for this papilionid butterfly. Finally we reported the generalist predator Zelus longipes (Homoptera: Reduviidae) as an important source of larval mortality. Our research also provides information to producers on effective biological and reduced-risk alternatives to CLM control. Field-testing of six biological and reduced risk pesticides in two Tahiti lemon nurseries have demonstrated that some of them are effective against the CLM, even under high pest population pressures. We applied pesticides using CO2-powered sprayers at 100 psi; each product was sprayed in conjunction with an organo-silicate surfactant. We applied sham control plants with surfactant at the same spray pressure. We found that spinosad, azadirachtin, and abamectin are capable of suppressing CLM well below economic injury levels (one larva per leaf per growing tip). Other pesticides tested [i.e., B. t. subsp azawai, B.t. subsp. kurstaki, and Ecotrol (Rosemary oil)] did not perform better than the controls. In limited samplings collected from both nurseries sampled, Pnigalio sp. was the most common parasitoid found attacking CLM. Another finding was the confirmation of anecdotal observations that characterize CLM attack intensity higher at lower elevation. CLM attack to nursery stock at Lajas AES (100 ft elev.) was 4-5 times greater than that observed at Adjuntas AES (2,500 ft. elev.). One factor that may explain this finding is the much higher levels of parasitism of Pnigalio sp. at Adjuntas (73.3% n=60 larvae) than at Lajas (6.7% n=60 larvae). A survey of coccinellid predators in over ninety sites in the citrus growing municipalities in western and central Puerto Rico was conducted Several species are commonly collected including: Coelophora inaequalis, Chilocorus cacti, Psorolyma maxillosa, Coleomegilla innotata, Cycloneda sanguinea, Olla v-nigrum, Procula ferruginea, Cryptolaemus montrouzieri, Decadiumus pictus, Decadioumus sp., Pentilia discors, Zilus gilvifrons, Z. variipenis, Delphastus nebulosus, and Stethorus caribus; Diomus ochroderus, and D. roseicollis. Preparation of pest prey profiles and immature identifications are under way. Based on this effort a review of ladybeetles of Puerto Rico is in preparation, and also the writing of an educational book for schools and general public. PARTICIPANTS: Alex Segarra (PI) and Fernando Gallardo (Co-PI) Department of Crops and Agroenvironmental Sciences TARGET AUDIENCES: Extension Agents Extension Specialists Citrus Producers Citrus Researchers General Public PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
Results from this research will help demonstrate, to producers in Puerto Rico, the feasibility of using biologically-based and reduced risk pesticides to manage key insect pests of citrus nurseries and of new citrus plantings. In addition, producers can now fully appreciate the importance of natural enemy conservation through the use of reduced risk pesticides. In some cases, the use of our results by producers may allow an easier transition into organic production, and in other cases could lead them to use pest control alternatives that are both safer to the applicator and gentler on the environment. In addition, a survey and assessment of common natural enemies will allow further work to be carried out on the effects of management practices on their populations. Finally, information gathered under this project has advanced our knowledge of the Asian citrus butterfly life cycle and reproduction.

Publications

  • Segarra-Carmona, A.E., L. E. Flores-Lopez, and L. Morales-Collado. 2008. Ciclo de vida y control de la mariposa asiatica de los citricos, Papilio demoleus (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae), una nueva plaga invasiva en Puerto Rico. (Life cycle and control of the Asian citrus butterfly, Papilio demoleus (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae). In Press, Journal of Agriculture of the University of Puerto Rico.
  • Segarra Carmona, A.E. 2010. The Coccinellidae of Puerto Rico: A review. J. Agric. UPR. In preparation for submission.


Progress 09/15/07 to 09/14/08

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Field and laboratory experiments have shown excellent promise in the use of reduced risk and biological pesticides to control the citrus leaf miner (CLM) (Phyllocnistis citrella) and the Asian citrus butterfly (Papilio demoleus). The latter is an invasive pest and it is expected to have moderate economic impact on the citrus industry, especially on new plantings. Laboratory experiments with third instar larvae showed that excellent control could be achieved with the use of the biological pesticide Bacillus thuringiensis subs. kurstaki, and with use of the reduced risk pesticide spinosad, as compared with the control. Other pesticides, such as azadirachtin and rosemary oil, were no better at controlling the pest than the control surfactant alone. We also determined and published relevant life history parameters for this papilionid butterfly. Finally we report the generalist predator Zelus longipes (Homoptera: Reduviidae) as an important cause of larval mortality. Our research also provides information to producers on effective biological and reduced-risk alternatives to CLM control. Field-testing of six biological and reduced-risk pesticides in two Tahiti lemon nurseries has demonstrated that some are effective against the CLM, even under high pest population pressures. We applied pesticides by using CO2-powered sprayers @ 100 psi, each product sprayed in conjunction with an organo-silicate surfactant. We applied sham control plants with surfactant at the same spray pressure. We found that spinosad, azadirachtin, and abamectin are capable of suppressing CLM well below economic injury levels (one larva per leaf per growing tip) as compared to the control. Other pesticides tested (i.e., B. t. subsp azawai, B.t. subsp. kurstaki, and Ecotrol (Rosemary oil) did not perform better than controls. Pnigalio sp., was the most common parasitoid found attacking CLM, in limited samplings collected from both nurseries sampled. Another finding was the confirmation of anecdotal observations that characterize CLM attack intensity higher at lower elevations. CLM attack on nursery stock at Lajas AES (100-ft elev.) was four to five times greater than that observed at Adjuntas AES (2,500 ft. elev.). One factor that may explain this finding is the much higher levels of parasitism of Pnigalio sp. at Adjuntas (73.3% n=60 larvae) than at Lajas (6.7% n=60 larvae). Survey of coccinellid predators has been underway for the past nine months. Over 90 sites have been used for collection in the citrus-growing municipalities of western and central Puerto Rico. Several species commonly collected include Coelophora inaequalis, Chilocorus cacti, Psorolyma maxillosa, Coleomegilla innotata, Cycloneda sanguinea, Olla v-nigrum, Procula ferruginea, Cryptolaemus montrouzieri, Decadiumus pictus, Decadioumus sp., Pentilia discors, Zilus gilvifrons, Z. variipenis, Delphastus nebulosus, and Stethorus sp., Scymnus thoracicus, and S. roseicollis. Preparation of pest prey profiles and immature identifications are underway. PARTICIPANTS: Not relevant to this project. TARGET AUDIENCES: Not relevant to this project. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
Results from this research will demonstrate to producers in Puerto Rico the feasibility of using biologically-based and reduced-risk pesticides to manage key insect pests of citrus nurseries and of new citrus plantings. In some cases, the use of our results by producers may allow an easier transition into organic production, and in other cases could lead them to use pest control alternatives that are both safer to the applicator and gentler on the environment. In addition, a survey and assessment of common natural enemies is underway, investigation which will allow further work to be carried out on population management practices. Finally, information gathered under this project has advanced our knowledge of the Asian citrus butterfly life cycle and reproduction.

Publications

  • Segarra-Carmona, A.E., L. E. Flores-Lopez, and L. Morales-Collado. 2008. Ciclo de vida y control de la mariposa asiatica de los citricos, Papilio demoleus (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae), una nueva plaga invasiva en Puerto Rico. [Life cycle and control of the Asian citrus butterfly, Papilio demoleus (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae)]. In Press, Journal of Agriculture of the University of Puerto Rico.


Progress 09/15/06 to 09/14/07

Outputs
Our field and laboratory experiments show excellent promise in the use of reduced risk and biological pesticides to control the citrus leaf miner (CLM) (Phyllocnistis citrella) and the Asian citrus butterfly (Papilio demoleus). The latter is an invasive pest recently reported from Puerto Rico in 2006, and it is expected to have moderate economic impact on the citrus industry, especially on new plantings. Our laboratory experiments with third instar larvae showed that excellent control of the Asian citrus butterfly could be achieved with the use of the biological pesticide Bacillus thuringiensis subs. kurstaki, and of the reduced risk pesticide spinosad, as compared with the control. Other pesticides such as azadirachtin and rosemary oil were no better controlling the pest than the control (surfactant alone). We also determined relevant life history parameters for this papilionid butterfly, finding that development from egg to adult takes about thirty days (shorter in males). In addition, head capsule measurements are now available for each instar and stadia. Finally, we report the generalist predator Zelus longipes (Homoptera: Reduviidae) as an important source for larval mortality. Further work is now concentrated in determining sub-lethal effects of pesticides on the butterfly. Our research also provides information to producers on effective biological reduced-risk alternatives to CLM control. Field testing of six biological reduced risk pesticides in two Tahiti lemon nurseries has demonstrated that many are effective against the CLM, even under high pest population pressures. We applied pesticides using CO2-powered sprayers @ 100 psi, each product sprayed in conjunction with an organo-silicate surfactant. We applied sham control plants with surfactant at the same spray pressure. We found that spinosad, azadirachtin and abamectin are capable of suppressing CLM well below economic injury levels (one larva per leaf per growing tip) as compared to those of the control. Other pesticides tested [i.e., B. t. subsp azawai, B.t. subsp. kurstaki, and Ecotrol-registered trademark (Rosemary oil)] did not perform better than the controls. Pnigalio sp was the most common parasitoid found attacking CLM in limited samplings collected from both nurseries sampled. Another finding was the confirmation of anecdotal observations that characterize CLM attack intensity higher at lower elevation. CLM attack on nursery stock at Lajas AES (100 ft elev.) was four to five times greater than that observed at Adjuntas AES (2,500 ft. elev.). One factor that may explain this finding is the much higher levels of parasitism of Pnigalio sp. at Adjuntas (73.3% n=60 larvae) than at Lajas (6.7% n=60 larvae). Further pesticide work is now being conducted at the young planting stage (< 1 year seedlings), and to document effects on other pests common in drier cooler months [e.g., citrus aphids (Toxoptera spp.), spirea aphids (Aphis spiraecola), citrus psyllids (Diaphorina citri), and broad mites (Poligophagotarsonemus latus)].

Impacts
Results from this research will demonstrate to producers in Puerto Rico the feasibility of using biologically-based reduced risk pesticides to manage key insect pests of citrus nurseries and of new citrus plantings. In some cases, the application of our results may allow some producers to more easily transition into organic production, and in other cases could lead them to use pest control alternatives that are both safer to the applicator and gentler on the environment. Finally, information gathered under this project has advanced our knowledge of the Asian citrus butterfly life cycle and reproduction.

Publications

  • Segarra-Carmona, A. E., L. E. Flores-Lopez, and L. Morales-Collado. 2008. Ciclo de vida y control de la mariposa asiatica de los citricos, Papilio demoleus (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae), una nueva plaga invasiva en Puerto Rico. [Life cycle and control of the Asian citrus butterfly, Papilio demoleus (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae), A new invasive pest in Puerto Rico. Submitted to the Journal of Agriculture of the University of Puerto Rico' Editorial Board].