Source: TUFTS UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
DETERMINING VACCINATION RATES IN RABIES VECTOR WILDLIFE SPECIES ON CAPE COD POST-ORAL RABIES VACCINATION AND COMPARING VACCINATION RATES ACHIEVE
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0207191
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Mar 1, 2006
Project End Date
Feb 28, 2011
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
TUFTS UNIVERSITY
200 WESTBORO ROAD
N. GRAFTON,MA 01536
Performing Department
Infectious Disease and Global Health
Non Technical Summary
Tufts Cummings School of Veterinary Medicine (TCSVM) has been operating a vaccination program for preventing the spread of raccoon rabies since 1994. The program is run in cooperation with the Massachusetts Department of Public Health, Massachusetts Department of Fish and Game, USDA Wildlife Services, and the Center for Disease Control and Prevention. Raccoon strain rabies first entered Massachusetts in 1992 and spread rapidly across the state. In 1993 the Massachusetts legislature provided funds for TCSVM to create a barrier of vaccinated raccoons along the Cape Cod Canal to prevent the spread of rabies onto Cape Cod, one of the first wildlife rabies vaccination efforts in the United States. For 10 years we were successful in keeping raccoon rabies off Cape Cod. This program also succeeded in achieving one of the highest vaccination rates in a raccoon population in the country (60% of raccoons vaccinated in Massachusetts compared to less than 30% elsewhere). Additionally, the program established vaccination strategies for suburban landscapes that have been used nationally. In 2004 the first rabies case was detected on Cape Cod. Since then, there have been over 250 cases of rabies detected in wildlife on Cape Cod despite several attempts to halt this spread by vaccination on the Cape itself. Our challenge now is to try to reduce and then eradicate rabies from Cape Cod, and re-establish the barrier. We can best reach our eradication goal by analyzing the efficacy of the current vaccination strategy through measurement of the vaccination rate in the raccoon population.
Animal Health Component
75%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
25%
Applied
75%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
72208401090100%
Goals / Objectives
Cape Cod is a region of Massachusetts with diverse land use. Much of the landscape is rural, especially on the outer Cape, and livestock in the form of horses and small ruminants are commonly kept for small farm and backyard hobby use. Rabies is a disease with significant public health importance and the primary source of human exposure is domestic animals. Therefore control of rabies in wildlife is a vital step in protecting domestic animals and livestock from exposure to rabies, and thereby protecting the public health. An analysis of the success of the Oral Rabies Vaccine (ORV) program in achieving effective vaccination rates in raccoons and other native rabies vector species on Cape Cod is especially important at this time. After effectively preventing the spread of the rabies epizootic onto Cape Cod for over 10 years, the ORV program is currently facing new challenges due to a breach of the vaccine barrier in early 2004, and the subsequent rapid spread of rabies into naive wildlife populations on the Cape. The ORV program will be able to use the vaccination rate information generated by this project to formulate vaccine distribution plans that have maximum effectiveness in reaching target wildlife and that make the best use of available resources. Adapting vaccination plans for future vaccine distributions based on the vaccination rate data generated by this project, and using information on the comparative effectiveness of two different baiting methods will enhance the overall success of the program in protecting livestock and human health by reducing the prevalence of rabies infections in the native wildlife on Cape Cod and eventually eliminating the disease and reinstituting the vaccine barrier. This project will produce rabies titer data for raccoons and other native rabies vector species sampled in two separate regions of the vaccine zone on Cape Cod, Massachusetts. These data will be analyzed in order to assess: 1. the overall vaccination rates in the wildlife species throughout the vaccine zone; 2. the vaccination rates achieved in two areas where different baiting methods were used; 3. a comparison of the vaccination rates achieved by the two different baiting methods used. The results of the analysis will be available to the project coordinators and collaborators for use in planning for the next vaccine distribution in order to maximize the effectiveness of the ORV program.
Project Methods
Rabies vector species will be trapped in box traps within the different baiting method areas on Cape Cod. This will begin at least 3 weeks after the spring vaccine application to allow for development of titers in the vaccinated animals. Trapped wildlife will be anesthetized with an intramuscular injection of ketamine/xylazine. Anesthetized animals will have a blood sample taken, be given a general health exam, and have weight, sex, and approximate age recorded. A tag with a unique number will be placed in each ear, and the animal will be returned to the trap to recover from anesthesia, and then released at the site of capture. We plan two trapping periods, one in each of the two sample areas. For each sample area fifty traps will be placed throughout a 1 square mile grid in good raccoon habitat. The traps will be open for 4 nights, closed for 3, then opened for a final 4 nights, for a total of 400 trap nights in each area. This trapping strategy follows a mark-recapture protocol that also allows for the calculation of population density estimates, thus maximizing the information gained from the trapping effort. Blood samples will be processed, and sera will be analyzed by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention for rabies antibody developed in response to vaccination. Secondly, we will test sick or injured raccoons and other rabies vector species for rabies virus infection. Sick, injured, or dead raccoons (and other rabies vector species) will be collected by town animal control, and submitted for rabies virus testing to the Massachusetts Department of Public Health Laboratory. We plan to have the research assistant work with local animal control to collect additional samples from these specimens, such as teeth that can be analyzed for the biomarker tetracycline put in the bait, in order to assess uptake of baits. In cases where the sick animals are collected alive, the research assistant will be available to collect blood and other samples prior to euthanasia, adding another valuable source of animals to the testing pool. Once the rabies titer data is available, we will calculate vaccination rates within each baiting method area, and compare rates between the different areas. Further analysis will determine whether there are differences in vaccination rates between sex or age class of the animals. Project preparation will begin in early June. Serum sample collection will begin approximately 4 weeks after the spring 2006 baiting season and will continue through July. This will provide information on vaccination rates in the target species, including the raccoon young-of-the-year. Serum samples will be processed and submitted for laboratory analysis and archiving, as they are collected. Titer results may not be available for up to 6 months after submission.

Progress 01/01/09 to 12/31/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Although the state source of the funding for this project has been discontinued, we continue to participate in the state rabies advisory group. This group meets every quarter. Activities concerning rabies surveillance activities, control, and prevention are discussed. Currently Massachusetts Department of Health is analyzing rabies surveillance data from the last 18 years, and we are collaborating on this project to provide data on the oral rabies vaccination locations over the years. A poster describing research on the oral rabies vaccine program was presented at the World Rabies Day event held at Tufts Cummings School of Veterinary Medicine. This poster was previously presented at the Rabies in the Americas meeting in Atlanta, GA in September 2008. PARTICIPANTS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. TARGET AUDIENCES: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
The World Rabies Day event held at Tufts University in September 2009 was open to the public and members of the vet school community. There were two Tufts faculty members that spoke on the impact of rabies both in the US and developing countries. Rabies control projects undertaken by Tufts veterinary students working around the globe were presented in poster format, along with the research results poster from the Cape Cod Oral Rabies Vaccine program. World Rabies Day events take place on many Veterinary Medical School campuses around the United States (http://www.worldrabiesday.org/). The World Rabies Day committee judges these events, and selects the school with the largest participation. Based on the high participation, Tufts won the 2009 competition, and will be fully funded by the committee to host a full-day rabies symposium next year. This honor helps us provide education on rabies to a broad community, and to highlight rabies control efforts in wildlife and domestic animals on Cape Cod and beyond.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 01/01/08 to 12/31/08

Outputs
OUTPUTS: In 2008 a third year of a live-animal trapping study was conducted to continue to assess the success of the current ORV baiting strategies. Veterinary students were involved in two 10 day trapping sessions, one in each of two 3 km2 areas within the vaccination zone. This allowed an assessment of the relative effectiveness of the two different bait formulations in achieving vaccination of the target wildlife species, and bait uptake rates. In addition, raccoon population density and age structure was determined in the two different sites. Trapped rabies-vector wildlife species were anesthetized and the species, age estimate, body weight and condition were recorded and blood and a premolar tooth were collected. The animals were marked with ear tags and released when awake at the site of capture. PARTICIPANTS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. TARGET AUDIENCES: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
The trapping studies, including data from additional trapping performed by USDA Wildlife Services in the area where the bait stations are used, allow assessments of three different study sites and provide a diverse assessment of the vaccinated zone, with different habitats, and different baiting strategies in each. The results when available will be used to formulate better baiting and vaccination strategies to reduce wildlife rabies cases on Cape Cod.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 03/01/07 to 02/29/08

Outputs
OUTPUTS: In 2007 a live-animal trapping study was conducted to continue to assess the success of the current oral rabies vaccine baiting strategies on Cape Cod. Two veterinary students (with assistance from three others) conducted two 10-day trapping sessions, one in each of two 3 km2 areas within the vaccination zone. The same trap areas were used that were used the previous year to allow comparative data to be collected. This project continued to provide information on the relative effectiveness of two different bait formulations in achieving vaccination of the target wildlife species, and bait uptake rates. In addition, raccoon population density and age structure was determined in the two different sites. Trapped rabies-vector wildlife species were anesthetized and the species, age estimate, body weight and condition were recorded and blood and a premolar tooth were collected. The animals were marked with ear tags and released when awake at the site of capture. PARTICIPANTS: Two second-year veterinary students conducted the trapping study with assistance from one first-year and two other second-year veterinary students. Project oversight, training and mentoring were provided by Dr. Janet Martin, Research Assistant Professor. TARGET AUDIENCES: Massachusetts State Public Health Veterinarian, USDA-Wildlife Services National Rabies Plan project coordinators, other collaborating agencies and project participants on Cape Cod. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: None.

Impacts
The trapping studies, including data from continued additional trapping performed by USDA Wildlife Services in the area where the bait stations are used, allow assessments of three different study sites and provided a diverse assessment of the vaccinated zone, with different habitats, and different baiting strategies in each. The results when available will be used to formulate better baiting and vaccination strategies to reduce wildlife rabies cases on Cape Cod.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 03/01/06 to 02/28/07

Outputs
In 2006 a live-animal trapping study was conducted to begin to assess the success of the current baiting strategies. Three veterinary students ran conducted two 10 day trapping sessions, one in each of two 3 km2 areas within the vaccination zone. This allowed an assessment of the relative effectiveness of the two different bait formulations in achieving vaccination of the target wildlife species, and bait uptake rates. In addition, raccoon population density and age structure was determined in the two different sites. Trapped rabies-vector wildlife species were anesthetized and the species, age estimate, body weight and condition were recorded and blood and a premolar tooth were collected. The animals were marked with ear tags and released when awake at the site of capture. Results of the serology and biomarker analysis are still pending. During this study two of the raccoons were found exhibiting severe neurological signs. Both animals were submitted for a full necropsy, rabies testing and histopathological examination. Both were found to be rabies negative and canine distemper positive.

Impacts
The trapping studies, including data from additional trapping performed by USDA Wildlife Services in the area where the bait stations were used, allowed assessments of three different study sites and provided a diverse assessment of the vaccinated zone, with different habitats, and different baiting strategies in each. The results when available will be used to formulate better baiting and vaccination strategies to reduce wildlife rabies cases on Cape Cod.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period