Source: UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA submitted to
THE ROLE OF INFECTED ENDOTHELIAL CELLS IN IMMUNITY TO ANAPLASMA MARGINALE
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0207145
Grant No.
2006-34135-16969
Project No.
FLA-VME-04522
Proposal No.
2006-03915
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
AH
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2006
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2009
Grant Year
2006
Project Director
Barbet, A. F.
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA
G022 MCCARTY HALL
GAINESVILLE,FL 32611
Performing Department
COLLEGE OF VETERINARY MEDICINE
Non Technical Summary
Anaplasmosis is a globally important tick-borne disease causing significant morbidity and mortality to livestock. In the south-eastern USA and Caribbean region, control of the disease is inadequate as previously marketed vaccines have been withdrawn and are no longer available to livestock producers. The reason for this is lack of efficacy of the vaccines against certain strains of the causative agent, Anaplasma marginale and resulting breakthrough infections in vaccinated animals. This project examines whether previously unrecognized stages of the infection, organisms infecting endothelial cells, are critical for developing protection in infected animals.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
75%
Applied
25%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
3113310109050%
3113410109050%
Goals / Objectives
The overall hypothesis to be tested is that infected autologous endothelial cells are capable of processing and presenting A. marginale antigen to T cells via MHC class I and II and play a vital role in protective immunity to homologous and heterologous strains of A. marginale. The specific objectives of this project are: Specific Objective 1: Determine if PBMC of infected and immunized steers recognize or are stimulated by autologous A. marginale infected endothelial cells via MHC class I and II. Evidence of activation and stimulation of T cells by autologous endothelial cells infected with the St. Maries strain of A. marginale will be measured by assaying PBMC from infected and immunized steers for 3H-thymidine uptake in proliferation assays, IFN-g secretion in ELISPOT assays, and cytotoxicity in 51chromium (51Cr)-release assays. Objective 2: Identify the responding T cell populations and their expressed cytokine profiles. Proliferation, IFN-g ELISPOT, and 51Cr-release assays using positive and negative selection and flow cytometric analysis (FACS) of CD4+, CD8+, or gamma delta T cells will be used to identify the reactive T-cell populations. T-cell lines and clones will be utilized in future studies to characterize immunogenic T-cell antigens and epitopes. Real-time PCR and ELISA where possible will be used to quantify and compare T-cell cytokine expression stimulated by exposure to infected endothelial cells. Objective 3: Compare immune responses to autologous endothelial cells infected with different strains of A. marginale to identify conserved antigens and epitopes that can be used as vaccine candidates. Autologous endothelial cell cultures will be infected with either the St. Maries or Florida strain of A. marginale. T-cell responses as measured by proliferation, IFN-g ELISPOT, 51Cr-release and cytokine profiles will be compared for the cultures infected with different Anaplasma marginale strains. Cell lines and clones derived by exposure to autologous endothelial cells infected with the heterologous strain of A. marginale will be used to identify conserved antigens and epitopes. This research should aid in understanding the immune mechanisms more fully and help to develop new vaccines against anaplasmosis. Control of anaplasmosis will improve livestock production in the southeastern U.S., Caribbean, and worldwide through biotechnology, one of the goals of the TSTAR strategic plan.
Project Methods
The approach for objective 1 is to determine whether infected endothelial cells are capable of presenting A. marginale antigen via MHC I and II resulting in stimulation of A. marginale-specific T cells. Our focus will be on identification of endothelial stage-specific responses as well as MHC class I-dependent responses resulting in T-cell activation. Utilization of the proliferation and IFN-gamma ELISPOT assays will allow us to determine if endothelial cells process and present antigen in a way that results in activation of A. marginale-specific T cells and 51Cr release assays will evaluate potential cytotoxicity. In objective 2 the approach is to define the phenotypes of the responding T cells, i.e. CD8+ cytotoxic T cells, CD4+ cytotoxic T cells, CD4+ helper T cells or gd T cells. In the case of the helper T cells, we will determine the nature of this response, i.e. polarization toward either Th1 or Th2. In objective 3 we will identify T-cell populations that recognize endothelial cell- presented antigens common to both the St. Maries and Florida strains of A. marginale. Studies on the strain-specificity of T cell responses will be carried out to provide additional evidence for the role of CD4+ and/or CD8+ T cells in protective immunity. We propose to use two strains of A. marginale for which the complete genome sequences are available, St. Maries and Florida. Availability of the genome sequences will aid in definition of cross-reactive epitopes shared between the strains or epitopes unique to each strain. A cross-reactive (as opposed to a strain-specific) T cell response is desirable for vaccines and is likely key to protection against heterologous challenge.

Progress 09/01/06 to 08/31/09

Outputs
OUTPUTS: The following projects have been carried out in the course of this study. Establishment of A. marginale in both commercial and primary endothelial cell lines. Primary bovine endothelial cell cultures were prepared from bovine testicular vein endothelial cells and verified immunochemically with factor VIII antigen antibody as endothelial cells. The Virginia strain of A. marginale was established in these primary cell lines as stable long-term cultures. In addition to the primary endothelial cell lines, we used commercial RF/6A cells from American Type Cell Culture (ATCC) for propagation of the Bacteria. Determination of infection kinetics of A. marginale in endothelial cell lines. Real-time PCR assays using the single-copy opag2 gene and live-dead fluorescence assays were developed to monitor the kinetics of infection and the production of A. marginale suitable for infection of cattle. These assays accurately determine the presence of between 102 to 108 live organisms in a sample and have shown that production of A. marginale in cultured primary bovine endothelial cell lines and RF/6A cells reaches a maximum after two-four weeks and is evident by cytopathic effect. In some cases; however, we were able to establish and propagate low-level, minimally cytopathic long-term cultures. Interestingly these cultures cycled in vitro approximately every 9-14 days. Sample DNA collected at the time of the cyclic peaks was sequenced and analyzed to see if the compliment of variants changed from peak to peak. Two predominant variants were identified in each of the peaks representing from 65 to 89% of the variants. Cytotoxic T cell assays. Cytotoxic T cell release assays were done utilizing whole, half matched, and unmatched primary bovine endothelial cell cultures as target cells and whole PBMC from immunized and infected steers as effector cells. Significant cytotoxicity was not seen in the samples assayed. However, in order to increase MHC expression on the endothelial cells we may need to add IFN-gamma to the cultures. Inoculation of cattle with endothelial cell culture derived A. marginale. In four different trials, four young steers were inoculated with endothelial cell derived A. marginale bacteria. Trial 1 used A. marginale grown in high passaged (100 plus) RF6A Rhesus macaque endothelial cells in 75 cm2 flasks. The A. marginale Virginia strain used in this study has been in culture for approximately 4 years. A cell free fraction of the bacteria was isolated via shearing (10 passages through a 25 gauge needle) the cultured cells, low speed centrifuge to pellet intact cells, and filtered with a 3 um filter. 1x108 live bacteria were inoculated into the jugular vein of a 4-month-old mixed breed steer. Trial 2 used 2.5x109 live bacteria inoculated into the jugular vein of a second 4-month-old Holstein steer. Trial 3 used A. marginale grown in low passaged (<20) primary bovine endothelial cells derived from testicular veins. The calf was inoculated with 1x107 live bacteria and endothelial cells into the jugular vein. Trial 4 used a splenectomized steer inoculated intravenously with 1.3 x 106 A. marginale-infected endothelial cells. PARTICIPANTS: Heather Wamsley, Graduate student during this project. Jeffrey Abbott, Assistant Professor Anthony F. Barbet, Professor. TARGET AUDIENCES: Not relevant to this project. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Nothing significant to report during this reporting period.

Impacts
Results of the above trials: Infection with A. marginale was not detected in any of the above trials. This suggests that A. marginale organisms (cultured Virginia strain) grown in mammalian endothelial cells are not infective to cattle. Vaccination with endothelial cell derived A. marginale and challenge with blood stabilate. To discover if vaccination with killed endothelial cell derived A. marginale organisms could protect against challenge, a pilot study was done. Two of the animals employed in the previous trials were subsequently given 3 inoculations separated over a 2 month period of time. The inoculum consisted of whole A. marginale Virginia strain cultured in RF6A Rhesus macaque fetal endothelial cells. The cultured bacteria were inactivated with beta-propriolactone in 0.5 ml and mixed with an equal volume 0.5 ml of ISA 50 (montinide) from Seppic Inc Fairfield NJ. The inoculum was 1 ml total volume injected subcutaneously in the left side of the neck/shoulder. The immune response was measured with lymphocyte proliferation before the time of each inoculation and 2 weeks following the last inoculation. Both animals showed significant responses to A. marginale antigen in a titrated manner after the second inoculation that continued after the third inoculum. Two months following the third inoculation, the steers were boosted a fourth time. The 2 inoculated steers and a naive control were simultaneously challenged 2 weeks following the fourth boost. The animals were inoculated IV with 20 ml of A. marginale infected blood stabilate estimated to contain approximately 8 x 1011 organisms (both live and dead). All three of the animals became bacteremic concurrent with fever and anemia. The control and one of the vaccinated steers peaked at 14 days post infection. The second vaccinated steer had a delayed peak of bacteremia, peaking at 29 DPI. Although the number of animals is small, there may be some potential for using cultured organisms as vaccine material to overcome limitations of blood-derived products. However, as with many other A. marginale vaccines, sterile immunity was not induced by these cultured organisms.

Publications

  • Wamsley, HL and Barbet, AF 2008. In situ detection of Anaplasma spp. by DNA target-primed rolling-circle amplification of a padlock probe and intracellular colocalization with immunofluorescently labeled host cell von Willebrand factor. J. Clinical Microbiology 46:2314-2319.


Progress 09/01/06 to 08/31/07

Outputs
We have begun this project by establishing A. marginale infected and uninfected endothelial cell lines, real-time PCR assays for monitoring infection of cultures and cattle and testing infectivity of cultured A. marginale for cattle in a pilot trial. The St. Maries and Virginia strains of A. marginale were obtained from our collaborators, growing in ISE6 tick cells (St. Maries) or RF6A endothelial cells (Virginia). Primary bovine endothelial cell cultures were also prepared from bovine testicular vein endothelial cells and verified immunochemically with factor VIII antigen antibody as endothelial cells. The Virginia strain of A. marginale established in these primary cell lines as stable long term cultures. The St. Maries strain has only established in the tick cell line. Real-time PCR assays using the single-copy opag2 gene and live-dead fluorescence assays were developed to monitor the kinetics of infection and the production of A. marginale suitable for infection of cattle. These assays accurately determine the presence of between 102 to 108 live organisms in a sample and have shown that production of A. marginale in cultured RF6A cells reaches a maximum after two-four weeks. 1 X 108 live Virginia strain A. marginale were prepared from cultures by needle disruption followed by differential centrifugation and used to intravenously inoculate a steer. Serial sampling of temperature, attitude, and blood were used to monitor the course of infection. The blood sampling included parameters of packed cell volume, fibrinogen, and total and individual leukocyte numbers. In addition to clinical monitoring microscopy of Giemsa-stained smears, real-time PCR assay of extracted DNA and seroconversion were used. Seroconversion was determined by a competitive ELISA, using sera to block reactivity of a monoclonal antibody with recombinant MSP5. Additionally, an aliquot of the inoculated organisms was used to infect new cultured endothelial cells, to verify the infectivity of cultured A. marginale.

Impacts
All blood samples from the infected steer were negative for A. marginale up to 60 days post-infection by microscopy and real-time PCR. Similarly, only one sample tested was positive for seroconversion by cELISA and this sample was very close to the cut-off value for seropositivity. Likewise, there was no reduction in packed cell volume of the blood and no clinical symptoms indicative of infection. The inoculated organisms were confirmed to be infective in culture, as A. marginale was recovered by culture of an aliquot of the inoculum with uninfected endothelial cells. We are currently intending to immunosuppress this steer to determine if the steer was not infected or had a subclinical infection.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period