Source: HARMON BROOK FARM (MAINE SMELT HATCHERY submitted to NRP
ESTABLISH EFFECTIVE FEEDING AND HARVEST PROTOCOL FOR RAINBOW SMELT
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0206461
Grant No.
2006-33610-16788
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2006-00412
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
May 1, 2006
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2007
Grant Year
2006
Program Code
[8.7]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
HARMON BROOK FARM (MAINE SMELT HATCHERY
PO BOX 373
CANAAN,ME 04924
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Present supplies of rainbow smelt, both for live bait and human consumption, are provided, almost exclusively, by commercial harvest of wild populations. This project will develop alternative sources of rainbow smelt for the market and eventually reduce the harvest of wild populations. This project will shift the focus from commercial fishing of wild public resources to commercial fish culture techniques and aquaculture production.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
3023719101060%
3073719106040%
Goals / Objectives
The principle goal of this project is to discover and perfect methods for the commercial production of rainbow smelt in the Northeast. Previous private and public funding has developed methods for mass production of day old smelt larvae. This research will establish the best method to entrain smelt to commercial diets and in the process, develop a new aquaculture species for cultivation. Smelt are phototaxic and the intended research effort is to capitalize on that behavior and induce feeding habits to boost production, survival, and growth rates. Present supply of market demands come almost exclusively from commercial harvest of wild smelt populations and present market demands exceed wild resources. Successful culture of rainbow smelt will eventually replace harvest of wild smelt, stabilize availability, could increase marketability, and stabilize market prices. Developing cost effective and reasonable culture techniques is required to launch this fish into an aquaculture business. We believe these goals are obtainable in this project.
Project Methods
Both intensive and extensive methods will be explored to determine which method will prove most productive. Intensive culture will include a feed trial starting in late March to determine a viable feed that will be used in a subsequence experiment. The second experiment will involve 50,000 larvae, in 3- 800-liter tanks (150,000 total) to be entrained onto a commercial diet. This portion of the experiment will include use of live feed and a commercial diet. Multiple feedings will be applied, the use of lights to utilize the phototaxic response and the presence of feed. At 75 days post hatch, the entrained smelt will be transferred to three one quarter acre ponds and the light stimulated feedings will continue until experiment competition. Extensive culture will involve stocking of three one quarter-acre ponds with 3 to 5 day old larvae. They will graze the natural wild feed in the ponds for about 63 days and then an automatic feeding system will present a commercial diet in multiple feedings. Lights are to be used to stimulate the phototaxic response while feed is presented. Evaluation of growth, survival, and cost factors at the conclusion of the experiments will determine which is most successful. The final experiment is an evaluation of capturing the market size smelt by the use of lights and vertical lift nets. All ponds will be harvested for 10 consecutive nights using the light system and vertical nets. All ponds will then be drained and all remaining smelt harvested. Harvest method numbers are to be evaluated to determine the effectiveness of the phototaxic harvest method.

Progress 05/01/06 to 06/30/07

Outputs
Freshwater pond culture of commercially valuable species is an underutilized resource in the Northeast. High real estate and labor costs discourage construction of new ponds and existing farm ponds are often unsuitable for traditional aquaculture species because depths and obstructions limit the ability to seine-harvest fish. The use of existing ponds for the production of baitfish in the Northeast offers new opportunities for interested parties to "test the waters" of aquaculture without the enormous initial expenditures. Most baitfish are sold for recreational ice fishing in Northern New England and estimates from the 1990s place the value of baitfish in Maine in excess of $5 million (Maine Aquaculture Innovation Center). One species with considerable potential for pond culture is the rainbow smelt, (Osmerus mordax). Rainbow smelt is the preferred prey of predacious game species and for this reason rainbow smelt is often the preferred bait of anglers. Previously, we developed methods for smelt spawning and intensive larviculture. For commercial-scale production, however, methodologies for feed entrainment and harvest needed to be developed. We were successful in developing these methodologies during this Phase I research. Wild rainbow smelt were captured during their spawning migration and manually spawned to produce over a million viable embryos. The resulting larvae were successfully feed-entrained in both intensive (tank) and extensive (pond) culture. In hatchery/laboratory studies examining feed entrainment, three commercially available diets were compared during weaning experiments. Larvae were initially fed live prey (rotifers and artemia) and systematically weaned to formulated diets. Survival through weaning ranged from 9.9-15.3% and did not differ among diet treatments. Mean growth rate during this study was high but not significantly different among treatments. In extensive studies, 10,000 larvae were stocked in 6- 0.25 acre ponds at both 5 and 75 days post hatch (DPH) and feed-entrained with the use of phototaxia. Larval survival was extremely high and significantly greater with larvae stocked at 5 DPH (38-55%), likely due to lower water temperature at the time of stocking. Fish from both stocking groups were harvested by automated mechanical harvesting devices and marketed as baitfish. Two iterations of automated mechanical harvesting devices were designed and tested. The initial design consisted of a lighted feed station that utilized timers that triggered the lift of the nets. The concept was to operate the feed station for several hours and then trigger the automated lift net to rise from the bottom of the pond and capture the feeding smelt concentrated at the lighted station. Capture results from 4 ponds ranged from 16-50% using this design. The harvester was modified by the addition of a plastic "leader" that directed the fish into a continuously-acting lighted collection chamber. Harvest results from a single pond using the modified collector were 87%. All project goals were achieved and unexpected additional findings during this research project indicate that full-scale intensive/extensive smelt culture is eminent.

Impacts
Feed entrainment and capture methods are vital to future rainbow smelt culture. Without development of these methods, smelt culture would be virtually impossible. Our research has developed and utilized both feed entrainment and capture methods that have proven successful. Mounting concerns about movement of live wild fish and associated diseases like VHS have many consumers searching for alternative sources for rainbow smelt. Utilizing state-of-the-art fish health procedures and testing, cultured rainbow smelt can be certified disease free. Continued research effort will expand on this successful project and continue the development of rainbow smelt culture. Present smelt market demands exceed commercial wild harvest production and seasonal harvest limits year-round availability, future rainbow smelt producers could expect a significant expansion of existing markets once culture operations come on line. Redirecting rainbow smelt production from commercial fishing (wild harvest) to aquaculture will have a significant positive environmental benefit also.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 05/01/06 to 05/01/07

Outputs
The objectives of this project were to 1) develop methodologies for feed entrainment of larval rainbow smelt and 2) investigate the use of phototaxia as a tool to harvest market size rainbow smelt. The 10-day harvest experiment, using lift nets, has been completed on all project ponds, but the final draining and population assessment has not been completed. Inclement weather (rain/snow/sleet) slowed the harvest activities and conditions encountered during drawdown of the ponds, silt and ice formation, caused elevated mortalities during capture. Therefore, the harvest was suspended we are requesting a project extension with plans to complete the final drawdown and evaluations in the spring. Thousands of smelt have been harvested to date and are being held at Maine Smelt Hatchery for evaluation and trial sales to specific markets. Overall, the project has proceeded well and any problems encountered have been handled without significant interruption to the whole project. Extending the project for an additional 6 months will be very beneficial for completing the remaining objective .

Impacts
Results of this research will assist in the development and implementation of a new aquaculture fish. Present supply is harvested from wild populations and cannot meet market demands. In many areas, rainbow smelt are approaching threatened status; therefore, developing methods of aquaculture production are desirable. Our research has shown that cultivating rainbow smelt is possible.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period