Source: UNIVERSITY OF PUERTO RICO AT MAYAGUEZ submitted to NRP
CHARACTERIZATION OF ALTERNARIA SPP. OCCURRING IN ONION FIELDS AND THEIR INTERACTION WITH BACTERIAL PATHOGENS AND INSECTS PESTS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0204189
Grant No.
2005-34135-15947
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2005-04615
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2005
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2007
Grant Year
2005
Program Code
[AH]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF PUERTO RICO AT MAYAGUEZ
P. O. BOX 9000
MAYAGUEZ,PR 00681
Performing Department
Crops and Agroenvironmental Sciences
Non Technical Summary
Since 1994, onion production has increased 67.4% in the Caribbean. In Puerto Rico, onion production has a great potential for increase due to its demand and markets for exportation. For decades, pathogens significantly reduced onion production in the fields. However, little research work has been done concerning onion pathogens or insect pests in the island since 1920's. Recent research at the UPR confirmed Alternaria spp. causing foliage lesions and that thrips attack seriously undermined production. To determine the importance of fungal, bacterial pathogens and insect pest of onions, various objectives were delimited: 1) Morphological, pathological and molecular characterization of Alternaria spp. occurring in onions in Puerto Rico, 2) Characterization of bacterial pathogens affecting onion foliage under field conditions and 3) Study the interactions of Alternaria sp. and selected bacterial pathogens with Thrips tabaci under greenhouse and field conditions.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2113110113025%
2124010100025%
2124020104025%
2124020110225%
Goals / Objectives
Continue working on the development of test protocols and the assessment of the effectiveness of molecular techniques, such as RAPD-PCR, DNA of ITS sequences of rRNA and AFLP's as complimentary or as substitute diagnostic tools for distinguishing Alternaria spp. causing leaf spots in onions. Study the interactions of Alternaria spp. of economic importance in onion with bacterial pathogens and insect pests, such as Thrips tabaci, under greenhouse and field conditions.
Project Methods
Assessment of the effectiveness of molecular techniques in Alternaria spp. identification: PCR products of Alternaria spp. rDNA ITS region will be sequenced and aligned by clustal method (www.ebi.ac.uk/clustalw). Dendograms will be constructed including sequences of ITS region obtained from the GeneBank data base. In addition, RFLP's and AFLP's will be used to differentiate among Alternaria spp. Interactions of Alternaria with bacterial pathogens and T. tabaci: A. Greenhouse experiments - Onion plants will be maintained in the greenhouse at 27 Celsius degrees. Plants at 7-8 leaves stage will be covered with cages made from polyclorovinyl tubes and polyester cloth (11 cm. long x and 18 cm. wide) to prevent the movement of Thrips tabaci. Treatments will included: 1) uninjured control, 2) Alternaria sp. selected based on importance as onion pathogen, 3)T. tabaci, 4) T. tabaci and Alternaria inoculation, 5) bacterial pathogen selected during these studies, 6) bacterial pathogen and Alternaria sp., 7) T. tabaci and bacterial pathogen, 8) combination of Alternaria sp., T tabaci and bacterial pathogen. Plant receiving T. tabaci injury will be initially infested with 15 thrips per plant. Ten days after initial T. tabaci infested plants receiving Alternaria sp. treatment will be inoculated with 105 spore suspension. Plants receiving bacterial treatment will be inoculated with 106 cfu/ml. Control plants will be sprayed with sterile distilled water. Alternaria sp. and bacterial treatments will be sprayed until leaves were thoroughly covered to run off. Plants will be observed daily for symptoms development. Samples will be collected from leaves of all treatments for examination under microscope and pathogen isolation and identification. Alternaria sp. lesions will be measure (length by width), total number of lesions and number of leaves killed will be counted. Thrips injury will be rated based on Mackenzie scale. Analysis of variance will be used to analyze the interactions. Regression analysis (y = a + bx) will be used to determine relationships between thrips damage, Alternaria and bacterial infections. B. Field experiments: Onion plots measured 5 x 10 will be planted at the Agricultural Experiment Station located in Juana Diaz, Puerto Rico. Each plot will consist of 4 beds with 4 rows of onions spaced 2 cm apart and will be fertilized according to the technological packed recommend by the Agricultural Experiment Station. Weed control will be applied according to extension agent recommendations. Different treatments will be applied to one of each plot as described for greenhouse experiments. Plots will be sampled for Alternaria spp. leaf spot, T. tabaci infestations and bacterial pathogens. Ten plants from each plot will be examined for typical Alternaria and bacterial lesions. Lesions will be counted only on non-senescent leaves every two weeks. Pathogens will be isolated and identify from collected leaves showing lesions. Thrips infestation will be monitored weekly. Number of lesions caused by Alternaria and bacterial pathogens will be correlated with T. tabaci infestations from sprayed and unsprayed plots. Data will be analyzed statistically.

Progress 09/01/05 to 09/30/07

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Alternaria species occurring in onion foliage from Puerto Rico were characterized on the basis of morphology, pathogenicity and DNA analysis. A total of 280 isolates were obtained, from which 34 were selected as morphotypes belonging to Alternaria destruens, A. tenuissima, A. palandui and A. porri (A. allii) species group. Alternaria palandui and A. destruens are new records for Puerto Rico and the Caribbean. Sixty two percent of selected isolates were placed within a taxonomically undescribed Alternaria sp. group with a "semi-arborescent" sporulation pattern. Pathogenicity tests, showed that A. porri (A. allii), A. tenuissima and Alternaria sp. ("semi-arborescent") were pathogenic to onions, been A. porri (A. allii) the most virulent. DNA of the various Alternaria spp. was analyzed using RAPD-PCR, and PCR amplification and sequencing of the nuclear ITS region of rDNA gene. RAPD-PCR technique did not differentiate between species. Phylogenetic relationships based on rDNA ITS sequences from Alternaria isolates and other Pleosporaceae were analyzed by neighbor-joining and by Kimura distance methods. Three clades were distinguished with strong bootstrap. A first clade with large filiform-beaked spores including A. porri (A. allii), was positioned as a monophyletic group, discrete from other members of the genus. A second clade, including a diverse group of small-spore Alternaria, and a third clade that includes Stemphyllium spp. Experiments in progress using AFLP's will provide additional evidence to discriminate among species. Bacterial diversity associated with onion foliage was also examined. A total of 39 bacterial strains were isolated. Of these, 92% were Gram negative, 49% hold plant pathogenic potential and 51% were putative endophytes. Pathogenicity tests showed that Acidovorax avenae subsp. citrulli, Burkholderia glumae, Pantoea agglomerans, P. dispersa, Pseudomonas sp., Xanthomonas sp. and Xanthomonas-like sp. caused symptoms to onion foliage under field conditions. Seed-borne bacteria from three commercial onion cultivars were also studied. Fifteen different pathogenic, endophytic, plant growth promoters and biocontrol bacteria species were isolated and identified. Two field experiments were conducted to determine the effects of thrips populations in the severity of A. porri (A. allii) and A. avenae subsp. citrulli in onion foliage (cv. Mercedes). Disease severity and thrips damage were evaluated for both pathogens inoculated together and individually. Frankliniella fusca was the most abundant thrips species during both experiments. Also, F. occidentalis and F. shultzei were collected from onion tissues. A greater disease severity was observed either with A. porri (A. allii) inoculation by itself, controlling thrips populations, and with A. porri (A. allii) with natural thrips populations. Plants inoculated with A. avenae subsp. citrulli did not show symptoms. A suitable management of thrips populations in the field is necessary to reduce the impact of Alternaria diseases. PARTICIPANTS: Lydia I. Rivera, PI/Plant Pathologist, Dept.Crop Protection, UPR-Mayaguez; Irma Cabrera, Co-PI/Entomologist,Dept. Crop Protection, UPR-Mayaguez; Myrna Almeda, Collaborator/Microbiologist, Dept. Agronomy, UPR-Mayaguez; Juan Calle, Former Graduate Student, Dept. Agronomy, UPR-Mayaguez; Jessie Fernandez, Former Graduate Student,Dept.Crop Protection,UPR-Mayaguez; Merari Feliciano, Former Graduate Student,Dept.Crop Protection,UPR-Mayaguez; Lesly Colon, Graduate StudentDept.Crop Protection, UPR-Mayaguez; Mario Rodriguez, Undergraduate, Dept. Agronomy, UPR-Mayaguez; Robert McPhail, Undergraduate, Dept.Crop Protection, UPR-Mayaguez; Emory G. Simmons, Advisor, Alternaria Taxonomist, Indiana; David Straney, Advisor, Molecular Biology & Genetics, University of Maryland TARGET AUDIENCES: Target audiences: Hispanic onion farmers will benefit from findings. Efforts: Transfer of science-based knowledge to undergraduate and graduate students through laboratory and field experiences, seminars on research findings and experiential learning opportunities (RAPD-PCR, AFLP's, data base management such as GenBank).

Impacts
We characterized various fungal and bacterial diseases and insect pests occurring in onion fields at the southern region of Puerto Rico. A better understanding of the relationships between diseases and insect pests in the tropics will allow us to develop effective control management practices in onion fields.

Publications

  • Alameda, M. and L.I. Rivera-Vargas. 2007. Endophytic and pathogenic bacteria isolated from onions seeds in Puerto Rico. Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the Puerto Rican Society of Agricultural Sciences (SOPCA), Catano, P.R. (Abstract)
  • Feliciano Rivera, M. 2007. Efecto de los danos causados por tripidos (Thysanoptera: Tripidae) en la severidad de Alternaria allii y Acidovorax avenae subsp. citrulli en el cultivo de cebolla (Allium cepa L.) en Puerto Rico. M.S. Thesis, University of Puerto Rico, Mayaguez, P.R. 126 pp.
  • Fernandez J. and L.I. Rivera-Vargas. 2007. Alternaria spp. occurring in onion foliage: Morphology, Pathogenicity and DNA analysis. Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the Puerto Rican Society of Agricultural Sciences (SOPCA), Catano, P.R. (Abstract)


Progress 09/01/05 to 08/31/06

Outputs
The following Alternaria species were identified associated to leaf spots in onions: Alternaria destruens, A. tenuissima, A. palandui, A. alli and Pleospora eturmiuna (Stemphylium eturmiunum). Sixty two percent of selected isolates were placed within a 'semi-arborescent' group, non-previously described taxonomically. Alternaria palandui, A. destruens and P. eturmiuna (Stemphylium eturmiunum) are new records for Puerto Rico and the Caribbean. Pathogenicity tests conducted in vitro and under field conditions with 60-day-old plants showed that Alternaria alli, A. tenuissima, Alternaria sp. ('semi-arborescent') and Pleospora eturmiuna were pathogenic to onion foliage, being A. alli the most virulent. Studies using AFLP's and minisatellites of Alternaria spp. are in progress to develop molecular markers to differentiate Alternaria species occurring in onions in Puerto Rico. Bacterial pathogens such as: Pseudomonas sp., Xanthomonas sp., Acidovorax avenae subs. citrulli and Burkholderia glumae produced symptoms on foliage during pathogenicity tests conducted under field conditions with 52-day-old onion plants. In addition, a group of putative endophytic bacteria were isolated from onion foliage. To examine thrips species associated to onions (cv. 'Mercedes') two field experiments were conducted during Fall 2005 and Spring 2006 at southern Puerto Rico. Thrips were collected using two methods: 1) a direct method using a moist camel's-hair brush to collect specimens from leaves in vials and 2) an indirect method, collecting whole plants in plastic bags from the field. Thrips were clarified and fixed for identification using taxonomic traits such as: number of pairs of elongate pronotal setae, metanotal campiniform sensilla and tergite VIII posteromarginal comb of micotrichia. Three Frankliniella species were identified associated with young emerging leaves in onions: F. occidentalis, F. schultzei and F. fusca. This is the first report of Frankiniella spp. affecting onions in Puerto Rico. Frankliniella fusca (41.1%) was the predominant species during the surveys. F. schultzei and F. occidentalis were uncommon during the Fall, comprising 6.6% and 7.6%, respectively. T. tabaci, the most important thrips of onions worldwide, was uncommon during Fall (3.0%). Others species under the genus Arorathrips were found associated to onions especially during the Fall. In addition, species of the Tubulifera suborder were observed. All F. occidentalis specimens collected were male. Population dynamics patterns of Frankliniella spp. were similar during the two seasons evaluated. Two field experiments were established to study the interactions between A. alli, thrips and Acidovorax avenae ss. citrulli. Data analysis is in progress.

Impacts
Three Frankliniella species were identified associated with young emerging leaves in onions: F. occidentalis, F. schultzei and F. fusca. This is the first report of Frankiniella spp. affecting onions in Puerto Rico. These findings are very important because of Frankiniella spp. potential to affect other vegetables cultivated in close proximity and their ability to transmit important plant viruses. Understanding the interaction of onion pathogens with insect pests in the tropics will allow us to develop better control management practices.

Publications

  • Feliciano M. and L. I. Rivera. 2006. First report of powdery mildew of onion caused by Leveillula taurica (Lev.) Arn. in Puerto Rico. Proceedings of the Caribbean Food Crop Society. San Juan, P.R.
  • Feliciano M. and L. I. Rivera. 2006. Frankliniella spp., new pest of onions in Puerto Rico. Proceedings of the Interamerican Society for Tropical Horticulture. San Juan. P.R.
  • Fernandez, J. and L. I. Rivera. 2006. First report of leaf spot of onion caused by Pleospora eturmiuna in Puerto Rico. Phytopathology 96:S35.