Source: School District of Philadelphia submitted to NRP
SAUL HIGH SCHOOL CURRICULUM ENHANCEMENT FOR AQUACULTURE (CEA) PROJECT
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0203351
Grant No.
2005-38414-15677
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2005-02735
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Aug 1, 2005
Project End Date
Jul 31, 2008
Grant Year
2005
Program Code
[OW]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
School District of Philadelphia
(N/A)
Philadelphia,PA 19103
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Agriculture is an ever-changing industry, with new concepts and practices being implemented all the time. Despite the fact that W.B. Saul, home to the biggest single-site FFA chapter, is one of the nation's most successful urban agricultural high schools, like many others its generally high-quality and engaging curriculum is not entirely aligned with the current admissions and performance expectations of both higher education and industry. There is a pressing need for the school to strengthen the scientific content of its agricultural classes, expect even more from its students, and provide additional opportunities for participation in challenging hands-on learning. This initiative is dedicated primarily to the development of 1) a comprehensive and rigorous aquaculture curriculum containing innovative elements that are likely to produce positive post-secondary student outcomes, and 2) a blueprint for both initial and on-going curriculum improvement across the agricultural spectrum that hinges on the establishment and maintenance of a local multi-disciplinary Core Science Enhancement Group. Through the national dissemination of these tangible, high-quality, and innovative products, both of which are sensitive to the unique circumstances of low-income youth from minority backgrounds, but can be readily utilized by other secondary-level programs irrespective of demographics, climate, or geography, project planners firmly believe that they are on the verge of taking high-school aquaculture education to the next level not only for the moment, but also on a continuing basis.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
90360993020100%
Goals / Objectives
In the process of pursuing the overall goal of improving agricultural education through curricular enhancements, the CEA Project planning team has been careful to design a program that is internally sustainable and scalable and capable of precipitating progress in the field on a regional or even national level. Consequently, the proposed array of project-related activities has been structured to lead directly to the achievement of the following two program objectives: 1. The development of an enhanced aquaculture curriculum that exposes students to advanced scientific subject matter and cutting-edge experimental techniques and technologies, and engages them in meaningful field-based learning opportunities; and 2. The development of a sustainable framework for professional skill-building that exposes a core faculty group to effective strategies for both augmenting their respective courses of study and conducting quality turn-around training related to curricular modification for other agriculture and science teachers throughout the school. While project personnel expect by the end of the grant award period to have accomplished the faithful and effective testing of the above-referenced products at Saul High School and the establishment of a reliable mechanism by which they can be broadly disseminated to other secondary-level agriculture programs, perhaps the most exciting feature of this ambitious curriculum enhancement project is its potential long-range impact on teaching and learning. As the scientific rigor and best practices that are first being more deeply embedded in the aquaculture and other advanced natural resources management and physical science classes begin their systematic cascade to the entry-level courses taught by core science enhancement group members and proliferation across the instructional activity of agriculture and content-area teachers outside of the core group, it is anticipated that the performance of the entire student body on the Science component of the Terra Nova standardized test will improve, and the rate at which Saul students receive their diploma in a timely manner will increase. These profound and pervasive improvements in academic achievement are expected not only to create positive changes in school climate, but also lead to opportunities that will increase the number of Saul students who actively pursue, are considered for, and ultimately succeed at postsecondary programming or career-track employment in aquaculture or other agriscience/business fields: additional and more sophisticated high-school internship placements being offered by local agriculture-related entities; a significant expansion in the range of undergraduate scholarships to regional higher-ed institutions for which students qualify; an increase in the amount of college-level coursework available to Saul students both on- and off-campus; and the structuring of course and fieldwork experiences in collaboration with professional organizations so that students may qualify for recognized industry certifications upon graduation from high school.
Project Methods
Project-related activities have been structured in a manner that supports a careful and comprehensive process of curriculum development during Project Year One, followed by pilot implementation and follow-up modification of the new curriculum during the second year of the project. During the first year, members of the Saul Core Science Enhancement Group (led by William Krill, aquaculture teacher, and including three other Natural Resources Management instructional staff, an animal science teacher, and a biology instructor) will participate in five (5) three-hour staff development sessions prepared and delivered by Dr. Steven Hughes of Cheyney University. In general, the first half of each session will provide the technical information and proven strategies necessary for conducting advanced project-based aquaculture education, while the second half will then demonstrate how the concepts/principles can be applied to other agricultural or scientific areas. Interspersed throughout will be opportunities for group members to review information on best instructional practices compiled by Dr. Hughes that encompasses high school, collegiate, governmental, and industrial domains and to provide input regarding the modification of the aquaculture curriculum based upon these data, past personal or professional experience, and project-funded trips to regional aquacultural research or business entities. Project Year One will also witness the purchase of cutting-edge equipment and materials (including sophisticated fish histology slide sets, LCD microscopes, and the highly-touted, interactive Fish Guts computer program) that will support the overall upgrading of aquaculture laboratory facilities and enhance teaching and learning during Year Two implementation of the revised curriculum. In the second year of the project, the focus of staff development will shift to supporting implementation of the new curriculum at the classroom level (led by Mr. Krill) and preparing the core group to conduct subsequent modifications/enhancements for other subject areas in a virtually autonomous manner. To the extent that experiential learning is a major component of the proposed revisions, all aquaculture students during Project Year Two will take four off-site instructional trips, including a full-day college/career exploration sponsored by Cheyney University and an overnight trip to the Freshwater Institute in Shepherdstown, WV. Dr. Hughes and Mr. Krill will be responsible for regularly reporting the progress of staff development and curriculum modification/implementation activities to the Natural Resources Management Advisory Committee, which will serve as an on-going steering group for the overall project. Saul Principal Thomas Scott (Project Director) and Education-to-Career Coordinator Jean Lonie (primary Project Co-Director) will be responsible for the day-to-day management of grant-funded activities, and will employ a Hoshin Plan to allow for color-coded tracking of program status and convenient modification when changes are deemed necessary and appropriate.

Progress 08/01/05 to 07/31/08

Outputs
The Curriculum Enhancement for Aquaculture at Saul High School for Agricultural Sciences program had two key objectives: (1) development of an enhanced aquaculture curriculum for exposing students to advanced scientific subject matter and cutting-edge experimental techniques and technologies, while engaging them in meaningful field-based learning opportunities; and (2) development of a sustainable framework for professional skill-building that exposes a core faculty group to effective strategies for both augmenting their respective courses of study and conducting quality turn-around training related to curricular modification for other agriculture and science teachers throughout the school. *Program Successes (Objective 1): Students had more opportunities to engage with cutting-edge technologies, and with equipment aligned with industry standards. The aquatics classroom and lab were upgraded with four (4) new laptop computers, an LCD computer projector, and additional tanks for raising a greater variety of species than before. The LCD computer projector supports class demonstrations, PowerPoint presentations, learning videos, and other multimedia activities. The laptops enhance the total complement of computers available in the classroom, and also are used for data entry in the lab; students now can record measurements, weights, temperatures, and observations, and then use for analyzing and presenting their data from lab activities. Students experienced field-based learning (in West Virginia) when visiting the Freshwater Institute and National Center for Cool & Cold Water Aquaculture and so drew explicit connections between classroom learning/industry standards & practices. Knowledge gained on the visits enriched Instructor Krill's lesson planning, classroom activities and student assessments. In November 2007, thirty (30) students visited Cheyney University campus and its Aquaculture & Hydroponics Lab and classrooms, getting a first-hand understanding of hydroponic facility operations, and observing college students work with rainbow trout. Saul High students reportedly enjoyed touring the dorms, meeting/speaking with Cheyney students about college life, and the opportunity to discuss internships, student housing, and financial aid with Cheyney faculty and staff. *Program Implementation Challenges: Objective 1: Although he continually updated his curriculum units with current information and materials, Mr. Krill and his students did not benefit from the enhanced curriculum that Consultant Dr. Steven Hughes (Director, Aquaculture Research & Education Center, Cheyney University) was slated to complete. Unforeseen circumstances delayed its development, and consequently no enhanced curriculum was ever implemented in W. B. Saul School's aquatics classes. Dr. Hughes did create an outline of curricular topics (advising Mr. Krill on materials necessary for implementation) but the anticipated curricular units were never delivered. Objective 2: Fostering strategic modification of curricula to better align with industry standards/technologies was a goal unmet; Dr. Hughes did not deliver any of the planned professional development sessions for teachers. PRODUCTS: *Student Experiential Learning: In May, 2006 twelve (12) students from Philadelphia's Walter Biddle Saul High School for Agricultural Sciences were accompanied by school personnel on a three-day field trip to West Virginia; students visited facilities that provided information to enhance their mastery of concepts and materials with which they were working in the Aquatics classroom. Students visited the Freshwater Institute in Shepherdstown, West Virginia, where they learned about alternative wastewater treatment technologies in the aquaculture industry, and the various types of equipment currently used to handle the wastewater resulting from working with fish. Students toured the facilities to gain a greater understanding of this technology. The high school students also learned about the role that aquaculture currently plays in such rural economic development in areas as Appalachia. In addition to learning about innovations in the field, students were also exposed to career opportunities. While in West Virginia, students also visited the USDA National Center for Cool & Cold Water Aquaculture, where they met with scientists and toured the facilities. Students were given an opportunity to observe the actual day-to-day workings of the Center, learned about the Center's research in aquatic animal health, and about their efforts to encourage economically and environmentally sustainable systems and practices in the industry. The tour of the Cheyney University classroom and laboratory facilities provided students with a first-hand understanding of the elaborate workings of a hydroponic facility, and also allowed them to observe the college students' work with rainbow trout. *Computer Technology: Approved materials/supplies has been purchased through grant funds to enhance the curricular content students are learning and materials they engage: an LCD Computer projector and four (4) laptop computers (iBook-G4) have been purchased for use in the classroom and laboratory. OUTCOMES: As a result of their visit to The Freshwater Institute and the National Center for Cool & Cold Water Aquaculture, students were able to draw explicit connections between classroom learning and industry standards and practices. Further, knowledge gained from these visits was later incorporated into Mr. Krill's lesson planning and student assessments. The LCD computer projector has been used for class demonstrations, including PowerPoint presentations, learning videos, and other multimedia activities. The four laptops have been added to the computers that were already available in the classroom, but have also been used for data entry in the lab. Students are able to record measurements, weights, temperatures, and observations that they can then use for analyzing and presenting their data from lab activities. DISSEMINATION ACTIVITIES: During the term of this grant-sponsored initiative, no project activities have been disseminated. However, future activities for sharing project results may include participation in FFA events and contests, science fair projects, and classroom presentations. FUTURE INITIATIVES: Continuing the program's underlying goals - to enhance Saul High School's aquaculture curriculum and offer expanded hands-on learning opportunities - some operating funds may (in future) be used to purchase additional materials and equipment, both for the classroom and the laboratory. Such purchases will supplement those improvements made to date, and may also utilize Perkins Grant funds, ultimately resulting in a lab setting that is more closely aligned with industry standards and innovative technologies.

Impacts
Project achievements/impacts appear in: student experiential learning, improved instruction delivery systems, and awareness of agriscience/agribusiness career information. While new curriculum units were never fully developed by Cheyney University's consultant, Saul High's Aquaculture teacher did incorporate up-to-date content knowledge/materials into his aquatics courses. **Project Director Wendy J. Shapiro Comments: Students were provided with such hands-on, real-life, learning experiences as are unavailable in classroom settings; key off-site instruction included field-trips to: The Freshwater Institute; National Center for Cool & Cold Water Aquaculture; Cheyney University Campus & Labs. Computer technology purchased for the Aquaculture Classroom will continue to enhance greatly student learning experience. A key barrier to full project implementation was inability of the university partner to deliver an enhanced curriculum, absent which professional development (and other) project components also proved impossible to conduct. A lesson was learned in project design/administration: future projects will seek outside expertise via partnerships with multiple entities rather than rely on a single university and a sole consultant. Saul Agricultural High remains committed (long-term) to developing an enhanced aquaculture curriculum, and to promoting careers and post-secondary study in aquaculture. We are grateful to USDA/CSREES for this SPEC grant award, and appreciative of lessons learned and impact/gains achieved, through the Curriculum Enhancement for Aquaculture initiative.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period