Source: BioProdex, Inc., Sid Martin Biotechnology Development Incubator submitted to NRP
DEVELOPMENT OF TOBACCO MILD GREEN MOSAIC TOBAMOVIRUS AS A BIOHERBICIDE FOR THE INVASIVE WEED TROPICAL SODA APPLE
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0203303
Grant No.
2005-33610-15548
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2005-00042
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
May 1, 2005
Project End Date
Dec 31, 2006
Grant Year
2005
Program Code
[8.2]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
BioProdex, Inc., Sid Martin Biotechnology Development Incubator
(N/A)
Alachua,FL 32612
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Tropical soda apple is an invasive weed that imposes a severe economic constraint on the livestock industry, threatens pristine natural areas, and imminently menaces croplands in the Southeast. The technology described herein will spur the development of an innovative, effective, environmentally beneficial, nonchemical control for this noxious weed. This research will promote the development of the world's first virus-based commercial bioherbicide that will help control this weed and provide for the economic viability of livestock production. Reduction in the use of chemical herbicides and the alleviation of the weed's encroachment into natural areas and croplands are other benefits.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2132300110140%
2132300114060%
Knowledge Area
213 - Weeds Affecting Plants;

Subject Of Investigation
2300 - Weeds;

Field Of Science
1101 - Virology; 1140 - Weed science;
Goals / Objectives
The overall objective of this project is to establish the feasibility of developing Tobacco mild green mosaic tobamovirus (TMGMV) as an EPA-registered bioherbicide to control Solanum viarum (tropical soda apple; TSA), an economically and ecologically damaging invasive weed. TMGMV is a naturally occurring (i.e., not genetically altered), economically insignificant plant virus, which is found in Florida, several other states in the USA, and in many other countries. We have demonstrated that TMGMV is capable of killing TSA plants. We have also shown that this virus can be used as a bioherbicide to control TSA infestations in the field. The virus can be easily produced on a laboratory-scale in susceptible tobacco plants, extracted from tobacco leaves, and applied in the field with readily available tools to control TSA In small areas (1 to 10 m2). These studies indicate that it should be possible to produce the virus on an industrial scale, but the scientific and technical feasibility of such production needs to be established. It is also unknown whether the virus could be made into a stable, standard formulation for use to meet the market needs, i.e., to treat several thousands of acres on demand. To answer these questions, we will examine the feasibility of producing TMGMV in quantities of 250 to 500 grams of active ingredient per production batch, establish efficacy, handling, and application criteria, thereby assessing the feasibility of transitioning the prototype into to a first-generation product. In summary, we will determine the technical and practical realities of implementing the bioherbicide under commercial, user-driven TSA-management programs. The specific objectives are to: 1) develop and validate methods to produce TMGMV in a 3-acre field-grown tobacco crop and maximize the virus yield through optimization of plant inoculation, plant production, leaf age-harvest relationships, and leaf harvest and processing; 2) set standards for a commercial prototype bioherbicide by determining the optimum active-ingredient (a.i.) concentration, formulation type, handling, storability, application, and disinfestations; 3) develop and validate field-application parameters for the prototype bioherbicide including the amount of the bioherbicide that will treat an acre, best methods of application for spot treatment and large-area treatment, application volume in GPA, and the practicability of using TMGMV in state-wide TSA-management programs in Florida; 4) determine the possibility of movement of TMGMV from experimental and production plants (tobacco) to two susceptible species planted as sentinels near the experimental/production plants; and 5) determine the possible persistence of TMGMV at the experimental/production site. A final report will be prepared which will set the stage to develop a Phase II Proposal.
Project Methods
A 3-acre field will be set up at the University of Florida Plant Science Research and Education Unit (PSREU, a subcontractor), to grow irrigated tobacco crops. Tobacco plants will be grown from seed in a greenhouse and inoculated when the seedlings are at 4- to 6-leaf stage by spraying TMGMV inoculum evenly over the foliage with an air-brush. Plants will be transplanted, grown, and managed according to the recommended production and crop protection practices. The optimum leaf age for harvest, number of harvests per plant per growth-cycle, and the effect of flowering on virus yield will be determined. Using the best conditions for maximum virus yield, the leaf-biomass yield per harvest, total leaf yield per acre, virus yield per acre of tobacco, total materials, time, and labor required for harvest; and the cost of production will be estimated. The harvested leaves will be transported to the subcontractor laboratories in the Plant Pathology Department and stored in a cool, dry place until processed. The virus will be extracted from the leaf tissue and processed into a wettable powder. This virus preparation will be packaged in a plastic satchel that will be storable at ambient conditions inside air-conditioned buildings. As a precaution, it may be stored in a refrigerator for prolonged storage. The material will be applied with high-pressure, hand-held sprayers (for spot application) or tractor-mounted spray booms (for large areas) or wiper applicators. Unused material will be destroyed by inactivating the virus by adding laundry detergent or bleach (e.g., Clorox) in sufficient amount of water. The product will be standardized with respect to units of active ingredients per gallon or per acre. Application volume and practical tools needed to obtain best levels of control will be established. The bioherbicide's efficacy will be determined from the level of TSA kill under field conditions, with 95-100% as the target. The possibility of TMGMV spreading to nontarget plants at the production sites will be monitored by planting two TMGMV-susceptible species, Capsicum annuum and Petunia x hybrida, as sentinel species. The experimental and production plots will be surrounded by narrow bands of these sentinel species and the possible movement of TMGMV from inoculated tobacco plants to the sentinels will be monitored for symptom development over the entire duration of the study. If symptoms develop, the plant tissues will be assayed for TMGMV by ELISA and back inoculation to TSA and tobacco plants. If no symptoms develop during of this study, a sampling of the sentinel plants will be subject to ELISA test at the conclusion of the study to confirm the lack of TMGMV's spread. The possibility of persistence and survival of TMGMV at the production site will be determined at the conclusion of the study by assaying soil samples from several locations within the site. ELISA and plant inoculations (on TSA and tobacco) will be used. If the virus is detected at significantly high levels (e.g., high proportions of positive samples), the soil will be tilled once or several times at 1- or 2-month intervals until no traces of the virus are found.

Progress 05/01/05 to 12/31/06

Outputs
Tropical soda apple (TSA; Solanum viarum) is an invasive noxious weed that imposes a severe economic burden on the livestock industry, threatens biodiversity in natural areas, and is starting to invade some croplands (e.g., citrus). An effective control is urgently needed to stop the spread of TSA and the threat it poses to the sustainability of the livestock industry in Florida and the neighboring states. The current control methods, namely repeated mowing and chemical herbicide applications, are costly, provide only temporary relief, and/or not suitable for all sites. BioProdex is developing and testing the feasibility of using a naturally occurring plant virus, Tobacco mild green mosaic tobamovirus (TMGMV), as a bioherbicide. TMGMV kills TSA consistently, completely, and quickly and is nontoxic to humans and other animals. It is as effective as or more effective than the chemical herbicides currently approved for TSA control. The ability of TMGMV to replicate in TSA and amplify the bioherbicidal activity allows for a very low concentration of the active ingredient to be used for TSA control. TMGMV can be readily applied by high-pressure sprayers and other methods such as low-pressure spray combined with moderate plant tissue abrasion, wipers, and abrade-and-spray. The overall objective of the Phase I SBIR project was to demonstrate the feasibility of large-scale production of TMGMV for use as a bioherbicide. To this end, we proposed to: 1) determine the scientific and technical feasibility of mass-production of TMGMV in a susceptible tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) cultivar grown as a field crop; 2) extract and concentrate the virus from tobacco biomass; 3) test the infectivity and bioherbicidal efficacy of the purified virus; 4) develop a prototype bioherbicide product; and 5) establish the practicability of the use of the bioherbicide for TSA management. At the completion of this Phase I program, as described herein, we have successfully demonstrated the feasibility of commercial production of TMGMV for use as a bioherbicide product. We have also confirmed that the industrial process we have developed is an efficient and practical means to produce sufficient amounts of the bioherbicide for commercial sales. In addition to these studies related to the Phase I objectives, we have completed a comprehensive nontarget plant risk assessment based on a host-range study and concluded that the potential risks from the use of TMGMV as a bioherbicide are negligible and manageable. BioProdex has submitted a data package to the EPA with petitions for an Experimental Use Permit (EUP) and a Section 3 Registration (registration). The proposed name for the commercial bioherbicide will be SolviNix, derived from SOLVI, the Bayer code for Solanum viarum, tropical soda apple, and Nix, as in: to put a stop to. The EUP is anticipated in the fall of 2006 and the registration by the fall 2007 (provided no new and additional data are required by the EPA).

Impacts
The principal outcome of this project will be the development and marketing of SolviNix as a biological herbicide for the highly invasive noxious weed tropical soda apple (TSA). The research results and the technology developed through this project will enable BioProdex, Inc. to register and market SolviNix as the first virus-based bioherbicide in the world. A green herbicide, SolviNix will provide an effective and environmentally safe alternative to biotoxic chemical herbicides used for TSA control in cattle production. In addition to the economic benefits to livestock producers in Florida and the South, SolviNix will help to slow the spread of TSA into natural areas and thereby preserve natural biodiversity.

Publications

  • Charudattan, R., Pettersen, M.S., and Hiebert, E. 2004. Use of Tobacco mild green mosaic virus (TMGMV)-mediated lethal hypersensitive response (HR) as a novel method of weed control. U.S. Patent No. 6,689,718 B2. February 10, 2004.
  • Charudattan, R., Hiebert, E., Elliott, M., DeValerio, J., and Horrell, J. 2005. A Highly Effective Biological Herbicide for Tropical Soda Apple. Florida Cattlemen, in press.
  • Charudattan, R., Hiebert, E., Elliott, M., DeValerio, J., and Horrell, J. 2005. SolviNix, A Bioherbicide for Tropical Soda apple - An Update. Florida Weed Sci. Soc. Abstract.