Source: COMPACT MEMBRANE SYSTEMS, INC. submitted to NRP
ENHANCED COOL PROCESSING OF VALUE ADDED BEVERAGES
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0203097
Grant No.
2005-33610-15493
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2005-00262
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
May 1, 2005
Project End Date
Dec 31, 2007
Grant Year
2005
Program Code
[8.5]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
COMPACT MEMBRANE SYSTEMS, INC.
335 WATER STREET
WILMINGTON,DE 19804
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Osmotic distillation is an excellent method for highly concentrating thermally sensitive liquids at low temperatures. However, commercial success of this process has been limited due to lack of membrane stability during the processing of economically interesting liquids. We believe that our high flux, non-porous perfluoromembrane is an ideal candidate for OD in that it has high flux rates and will maintain stability by avoiding wet out and membrane fouling. We will use coffee to demonstrate the feasibility of a process that combines cold extraction with osmotic distillation to produce a coffee concentrate that has never seen high temperatures. We expect these cool concentrates to be superior in taste and convenience to conventionally brewed coffee. In so doing, we will introduce to the industry a novel food processing technique that enhances the value of beverage based food products.
Animal Health Component
30%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
30%
Developmental
70%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
5015310202070%
5022232202030%
Goals / Objectives
Our key objectives in Phase I are first to produce CMS membrane modules that maintain high fluxes and do not wet-out during the concentration via osmotic distillation of cold extracted coffee and second to produce a cool coffee concentrate that is superior in taste and convenience to conventionally brewed coffee. We will use coffee to demonstrate the feasibility of a process that combines cold extraction with osmotic distillation to produce a coffee concentrate that has never seen high temperatures. We expect these cool concentrates to be superior in taste and convenience to conventionally brewed coffee. In so doing, we will introduce to the industry a novel food processing technique that enhances the value of beverage based food products. During Phase I, coffee will be extracted from coffee beans at low temperature. This will result in an aqueous solution of coffee flavor components. After extracting the flavor components, we will expose the relatively dilute coffee solution to a concentration process called osmotic distillation, which can achieve concentration levels that are much higher than can efficiently be achieved by reverse osmosis or other concentration techniques. Osmotic distillation, or OD, is a process for concentration of solutions by removing the volatile solvent across a non wetted microporous membrane into a stripping solution, where the solvent passes in the gaseous phase. Most commonly, as in the case of coffee, the volatile solvent is water, and the stripping solution is most commonly a concentrated salt brine. The microporous membrane must be hydrophobic to prevent the solution from penetrating the pores. Possibly the most difficult aspect of the OD process is that the hydrophobic microporous membranes lose their hydrophobicity over time due to contamination and wetting out by the process fluids. In the case of most economically interesting fluids such as coffee, the fluid contains surface tension reducing agents, i.e., oils, that eventually migrate into the membrane pores. This initially reduces the rate of dewatering, since the pores of the membrane are being blocked by concentrated feed solution. Eventually, the brine and feed streams mix as the air filled pores no longer separate the two miscible liquids. Therefore, while there is great opportunity to service the beverage production industry with OD, this has not yet been commercially successful, due to relatively low flux and wetting out of the microporous membrane. We believe that our high flux, non-porous perfluoromembrane is an ideal candidate to establish high initial OD rates, and that the CMS membrane will be able to maintain those rates by avoiding wet out and membrane fouling. The coffee concentrate that will be produced from this cool extraction and concentration process will have never had bitter components extracted from the bean and will have never seen heat. The net result is a better tasting product that is also more convenient than having to fresh brew coffee. One can envision a machine similar to cold drink machines in fast food restaurants where when one pushes a button the cold coffee concentrate mixes with the hot water as it goes into your cup.
Project Methods
We will use coffee to demonstrate the feasibility of a process that combines cold extraction with osmotic distillation to produce a coffee concentrate that has never seen high temperatures. Coffee will be extracted from coffee beans at low temperature. After extracting the flavor components, we will expose the relatively dilute coffee solution to a concentration process called osmotic distillation, which can achieve concentration levels that are much higher than can efficiently be achieved by reverse osmosis or other techniques. We expect the resulting cool concentrate to be superior in taste and convenience to conventional brewed coffee. In so doing, we will introduce to the industry a novel food processing technique that enhances the value of beverage based food products. The CMS technology will be used to produce membrane modules that maintain high fluxes and do not wet out during the concentration via osmotic distillation of cold extracted coffee. We will prepare and test modules that have the CMS non-porous membrane coating on a microporous support of polypropylene hollow fiber. These modules will then be tested for performance and stability during osmotic distillation of coffee on a test rig that will be built by CMS personnel. The coffee used during OD will be cold extracted at CMS using Sivetz Coffee Inc. cold extraction equipment. Coffee beans will be purchased freshly roasted and will be ground just before extraction and concentration. To produce the coffee concentrate, osmotic distillation will be run at 25C and 40C until the rate of concentration, or water removal, starts to drop off from viscosity buildup. During the osmotic distillation processing we will measure the water vapor transport rate, monitor the membrane stability, and determine ease of cleaning the membrane system between uses. These key factors will be used to determine the overall economics of the concentration process. The quality of the concentrates will be evaluated by the Natick Army Labs. Samples will be tested for acidity, pH, specific gravity, and color quality. Flavor quality will be measured using HPLC and sensory testing. Prior to any taste testing, samples will be tested for microbiologically stability to ensure safe sampling. The control sample in these quality tests will be conventionally brewed coffee, brewed from the same freshly roasted and freshly ground coffee beans, and brewed just prior to sampling. The concentrated coffee product that we are proposing should remain stable at room temperature due to its high solids concentration and associated low water activity. We will determine microbiological activity and correlated shelf stability of the OD coffee concentrates at various levels of high concentration, i.e., 60, 65, 70, 75 percent solids and others if warranted. We will use standard plate count procedures to assess the microbial quality of our concentrates.

Progress 05/01/05 to 12/31/07

Outputs
OUTPUTS: This program demonstrates a novel food processing technique leading to broad utilization of value-added beverage concentrates. The key major advantages of the process are better taste and more convenient availability/usage of commercial beverages. There is much value in applying this technology to the broad area of food processing. This program will further enhance product value for domestic food processors, but not the foreign growers. CMS has excellent downstream alliances, and we are well positioned to bring these partners in for subsequent commercialization. Using coffee we will demonstrate the feasibility of a cool concentrate extraction/osmotic distillation process that produces cold coffee concentrates that are superior in taste and convenience to conventional brewed coffee. In so doing, we will introduce to the industry a novel value added food process that further enhances the value of beverage based food products. PARTICIPANTS: Not relevant to this project. TARGET AUDIENCES: Not relevant to this project. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: Not relevant to this project.

Impacts
In the Phase I program, commercial coffee concentrate was further concentrated by osmotic distillation (OD) cold processing at CMS. With this technique the coffee has never been exposed to high temperatures and therefore has never been degraded or had the bitter components extracted from the bean. The end result is thus a better tasting, more convenient product.Osmotic distillation is a practical, moderate-temperature process for concentrating food products, such as coffee, for maintaining flavor and convenience of use. In addition, the following conclusions can be drawn from the experimental procedures and results: 1. Compact Membrane Systems (CMS) perfluoro membranes are inert to many of the complex organic chemicals in coffee during osmotic distillation. 2. Coffee extracts produced by CMS osmotic distillation retain flavor with no loss of key constituents, such as caffeine. 3. Sensory testing shows that osmotic distillation coffee extracts achieve a high level of quality in flavor, odor, appearance and texture. 4. Incremental cost analysis show that the osmotic distillation process adds no more than $0.05-0.06 per cup of coffee to the consumer. 5. The osmotic distillation process can be applied to many other food products and agriculturally-derived beverages, such as tea, grape juice, orange juice, etc.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 05/01/05 to 05/01/06

Outputs
As described in the proposal, we are developing a system for in-line coating of hollow fibers and manufacturing them into membrane cartridges (using funds outside of this grant.) We are using this same system for manufacturing one of our gas-liquid contacting products, which was not anticipated at the time the proposal was written. While the opportunity to do this manufacturing in-house is a very positive one, it has tied up the system much of the year thus far. As such, we have not yet produced membrane modules that are suitable for use in this grant. We have, however, made encouraging progress towards this goal. Preliminary coating work on newly acquired PVDF HF has given encouraging results. We have designed and manufactured a membrane housing with a translucent shell that allows for visible inspection of flow path and assessment of fluid mixing, fluid channeling, and dead spots. It is entirely comprised of plastic to avoid corrosion from the brine. The system that will be used for performing the osmotic distillation testing is in place. Coffee extract that will be used during the OD runs is easily obtainable directly from Sivetz Coffee. We have already obtained and done some preliminary testing on this coffee extract. Once we have a membrane module available for the OD tasks, things should move smoothly since the necessary equipment, supplies, and personnel are in place for the downstream tasks. CMS anticipates shipping product samples to Natick Soldier Center prior to March 2007. Additional samples will be submitted as needed to allow testing of fresh product. Conclusion of testing is expected to occur in September 2007 followed by preparation of the Phase I Final Report before the end of December 2007 and Phase II proposal in February 2008.

Impacts
The coffee concentrate that will be produced from this cool extraction and concentration process will have never had bitter components extracted from the bean and will have never seen heat. The net result is a better tasting product that is more convenient than brewing fresh coffee. This can serve the beverage industry as well as the US armed forces where testing will occur before the end of the grant period.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period