Source: APL SCIENCES, INC. submitted to NRP
DEVELOPMENT OF A PCR-BASED IDENTIFICATION SYSTEM FOR DISTINGUISHING TUNA SPECIES
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0202939
Grant No.
2005-33610-15491
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2005-00267
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
May 1, 2005
Project End Date
Oct 31, 2005
Grant Year
2005
Program Code
[8.5]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
APL SCIENCES, INC.
3610 NW 42ND TERRACE
GAINESVILLE,FL 32606
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Global market demands for fresh tuna products have resulted in increased pressure on tuna fisheries worldwide. As a result, consumer driven market pressures have created significant commercial importance in the U.S. market for certain high-value tuna species. Domestic tuna harvests and harvests by foreign sources determine the supply of raw tuna available to U.S. vendors. In fact, the U.S. is largely dependent on imported fresh tuna to meet market demand. Declines in tuna fisheries, tighter catch quotas, and increased competition in global raw-tuna markets create a special and immediate concern for quality control, product security, and supply chain continuity. These issues have implications for the consumer, who is completely dependent on producers to maintain product integrity and quality especially when shortfalls in supply occur. The purpose of this study is to develop a reliable DNA-based diagnostic that will allow for the unambiguous identification of the four most commercially valuable fresh tuna species. This diagnostic is necessary in order to insure accurate species identification, proper product labeling and traceability, and to aid in the monitoring of catch quotas and suspect and/or seized product.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
50308101040100%
Goals / Objectives
Our long-term goal is to develop a reproducible, high throughput, cost-effective, qualitative molecular diagnostic that will definitely distinguish the four most popular Thunnus species and will serve as a basis for establishing a more comprehensive set of DNA-based markers requisite in building a tuna species data base. While the initial target samples will primarily focus on the fresh forms of tuna, the molecular diagnostic markers will be applicable in distinguishing species in value-added tuna products that include heat processed albacore. Successful development and implementation of these diagnostics will provide discriminating PCR-based tests for species authentication. In providing a much needed evaluation tool and database for tuna producers and regulators, it also has potential to serve as the platform technology for developing diagnostics for other niche markets in the food industry dealing with issues of fraudulent labeling, traceability, species substitution as well as stock assessment and species conservation. In Phase I, we will procure authentic tuna samples from established and reliable sources and establish appropriate isolation protocols for tuna meat DNA suitable for its amplification by polymerase chain reaction (PCR). These DNA templates will be amplified with gene-specific primers designed to differentiate the four major Thunnus species in the fresh form. Discriminating and reliable species identifying nuclear DNA markers will be designed and tested on this PCR-platform. Finally, this PCR-based diagnostics will be tested in a multiplex configuration to analyze the four tuna species thereby giving us the power to assay multiple species in a single reaction. Such a format will provide a user-friendly diagnostic with output that is easily interpreted.
Project Methods
The DNA from each species of fresh tuna will be isolated utilizing commercially available extraction kits to identify the optimal protocol that yields DNA template of quality and quantity sufficient for reproducible downstream amplification. Efforts will be made to design the most streamlined protocol that is compatible with efficient, cost-effective screening for large numbers of samples. Utilizing publicly available sequence databases, nuclear gene-specific primers identifying the four major Thunnus species will be designed and tested in a PCR analysis. A universal PCR marker set will be developed inclusive for the Thunnus genus as an internal control. These primer sets will provide key tools for the benchmark diagnostic in the certification of each tuna species. Central to streamlining this diagnostic test is the rigorous assessment and optimization of the PCR conditions for running multiple species-specific primers in a single reaction. A primer set capable of universally recognizing the Thunnus genus will be tested in multiplex reaction with each species-selective primer set. The performance and selectivity of the species-specific primers identified in Objective II will likewise be assessed within a multiplex format to determine appropriate compatibility in a diagnostic PCR. An initial validation study of the diagnostic will be preformed in this Objective. Double blind, authentic tuna samples will be prepared and randomly analyzed to verify the working conditions of the diagnostic. A more defined and extensive validation will be included in Phase II of this work and will be based on results obtained in this Phase I.

Progress 05/01/05 to 10/31/05

Outputs
Our long-term goal is to develop a reproducible, cost-effective DNA-based diagnostic that will definitely distinguish four major high market-value tuna species. In this Phase I project, we performed the foundational work that supports our long term objective. Furthermore, we anticipated that this feasibility study will provide the platform for developing diagnostics for other niche markets in the food industry experiencing similar issues of fraudulent labeling and in need of species verification. While DNA is a robust target molecule, it can be susceptible to degradation under certain extraction conditions. Thus, it is important that we optimize a DNA extraction protocol that will increase the yield for recovery of DNA. The development of a diagnostic for tuna authentication necessitates addressing a series of issues including: 1). optimizing a procedure for DNA template capture that has utility for fresh meat samples suitable for its amplification by PCR, 2). testing the reliability and reproducibility of a PCR-based diagnostic for tuna meat samples, 3). simplifying the diagnostic pattern by identifying gene-specific, species-discriminating primers for establishing four species of tuna authentication. We successfully addressed all the technical objectives put forth in this SBIR Phase I research proposal. In addition to identifying an effective DNA extraction method for tuna meat that yields high quality template for PCR analysis, we have optimized a streamlined process for tuna sample collection that provides a more rapid and facile DNA template isolation procedure while generating comparable quality DNA template for PCR-based analyses. We have demonstrated that our isolation procedure for tuna meat genomic DNA provides suitable template for PCR with our newly identified species discriminating gene-targeted primers. We identified new gene sequences from which primers were designed and used to demonstrate the feasibility and utility of a DNA-based diagnostic. These primers are powerful new tools for species discrimination of fresh tuna products. In summary, we have developed a DNA-based method for species identification of the four major tuna species: blue fin, yellow fin, albacore, and big eye. This method can be run fee-for-service at APL Sciences for species validation. In addition, the proprietary components can be put in a kit format for public, private and government laboratories to purchase and run samples for the industry. The technology developed in this research can be extended to numerous other applications where DNA-based diagnostics are needed.

Impacts
Tuna is one of the worlds most valuable commercial seafoods. Albacore, bigeye, bluefin, and yellowfin are considered the most popular of the Thunnus species that are collectively fished in over 70 countries worldwide. Due to the exceptionally high value of bluefin, albacore, yellowfin and bigeye tuna and their diminishing stocks, there are increasing concerns regarding species substitution with lower value, lower quality species. Currently in the U.S. tuna industry, regulatory action cannot be taken to verify fresh fish species or processed products because there is no reliable test available to analytically distinguish species at the DNA level. The results of this project satisfy a critical need for the industry and the tests developed have significant value to both State and Federal regulators, other researchers and the commercial sector. Quality control issues, catch quota violations, and species substitution of tuna are viewed as emerging problems and an effective DNA-based diagnostic for reliable species identification will provide regulators and the industry the necessary tools to take pro-active measures and enforce regulatory mandates.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period