Source: HEARTLAND FIELDS, LLC submitted to NRP
REFINING AND EXPANDING THE USE OF LOW FAT SOY FLOUR IN TWIN-SCREW EXTRUSION TO PRODUCE HIGH PROTEIN TEXTURED SOY FOR FOOD APPLICATIONS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0200682
Grant No.
2004-33610-14704
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2004-02664
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2004
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2006
Grant Year
2004
Program Code
[8.5]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
HEARTLAND FIELDS, LLC
4200 CORPORATE DR., SUITE 106
WEST DES MOINES,IA 50266
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
There exists in the market an unmet demand for soy-based meat analogs to satisfy the North American consumer preferences for the texture and mouth-feel of the meats they grew up eating. Current commercial products derived from solvent extracted soybean flours do not meet market expectations. This project will advance the use of natural process soy flours that retain some (6-8%)oils to deliver great tasting meat analogs. The research will validate the twin-screw extruder for this process. A third purpose is to explore variations in piece size and shape, flour oil and protein contents, and flavors; to assess the process capability and deliver a range of products.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
50118201010100%
Goals / Objectives
The Research goal is to fine tune the Phase 1 discoveries in High Protein Textured soy (HPTS)production, using a twin-screw extruder and expand studies to broaden HPTS applications. HPTS contains a unique set of compositional factors plus the desireable combination of taste, texture and ease of rehydratioin. The uniqueness of HPTS begins with the low fat (6-8%), high protein (58-60%) soy flour, derived by a totally natural process and put through a twin-screw extruder, modified in assembly and die configuration. Exploring the commercial capacity is a key element of the project, along with testing variations of the size, shape, texture and flavor of the base technology to satisfy a broader range of market opportunities.
Project Methods
The studies in the Phase 2 research are (1) flour modification - stemming from new expelling methods that will provide 4-5 levels of oil content, and higher PDI values from new soy varieties; (2) die opening adjustments to deliver desired size and shape, such aas chicken breast sized pieces; (3) cutter types and sizes to provide new HPTS forms; (4)flavoring studies in both the final stage of extrusion and in post-extrusion processing with various sizes and shapes of HPTS; (5) shelf life and tensile strength studies of HPTS particles from different soy sources; and (6) cold press and CO2 extraction of oils to produce low fat, high protein flours with high PDI value for testing in the extruder.

Progress 09/01/04 to 08/31/06

Outputs
The product (commercialized as HPTS [TM], High Protein Textured Soy) is a dry, shelf stable textured soy chunk ideal for use as a meat analog when rehydrated and flavored. Other uses are being explored. The key benefits are improved texture and better flavor delivery that allow creation of excellent all-natural meat mimics. Material selection: A range of high protein all-natural soy flours (54-61% DB Protein) has been validated to work in the process. High protein is key to achieving the desired firm "meat-like" structure that is important when delivering a vegetarian meat analog that is familiar in the western diet. Residual oil (5-8%) and oleo-compounds, including the tocopherols and natural emulsifiers inherent to the flour by virtue of our expeller-press processing and air swept flour-milling process, have been identified as critical to the development of superior flavor and texture profiles of the HPTS. Structure/Flavoring: The dried, shelf stable product has an open cell, fibrous structure that facilitates easy rehydration. A low flavor profile allows for ease of topical flavoring. Flavoring of the product is best achieved in the rehydration step, as the flavor can easily penetrate through the entire matrix of the HPTS structure. Less flavor addition is required when added at rehydration, and the added flavor is subjected to very little heat. By contrast adding flavors in extrusion results in heat exposure and flashing of desirable volatiles. We also succeeded in coating of dry HPTS with liquid flavors as an alternate delivery form. Keeping Quality: Commercial interest in HPTS as a meat analog in frozen entrees led to keeping quality studies. We have passed the 15-month mark in an 18-month study and to date the meat analog and the entire entree have held up well with very little flavor or texture deterioration. The product meets and exceeds frozen food channel shelf life expectations. HPTS can be shaped and sized for a range of applications from flour/meal and granules to chunks as large as 2+ inch-long strips. Our focus has been on developing the larger pieces, as the market opportunity for larger pieces is largely unmet. Chunks are now used as beef and chicken flavored analogs in Heartland Field entrees sold at retail in California and the Midwest. Midsize pieces have also found commercial application as flavored pizza Vegan topping (e.g. Crumbled Italian sausage analog). This is in keeping with the ultimate goal of the USDA-SBIR program - the establishment of enterprises that benefit agriculture. The product is patent pending. The prior art has not shown any product to have the unique naturally inherent combinations of nutrients in a shelf stable product and we anticipate a late 2006 patent issue. In preparation for increased commercial demand we have validated the scaled up of the process to achieve rates of up to 1500lbs/hr. The process scaled well and product consistency appears to be improved with higher throughput. Some refinements of the extrusion die and forming assembly will be required to optimize specific product shape/size/texture attributes in preparation of commercial operation, driven by market needs.

Impacts
A simply better meat analog by virtue of its texture and flavor, the high protein textured soy will be a preferred meat analog for vegetarian foods, particularly when larger whole-muscle-like pieces are desired. The process used is all-natural (water, heat, and pressure only) and avoids any chemical solvents thus offering improved food safety for consumers and an environmentally better option to processors. The result is no special EPA or state environmental permitting is required in for production; and fewer allergenicity concerns for consumers with chemical sensitivities. Broad appeal of the high protein textured soy can increase the consumption of vegetable proteins.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 10/01/03 to 09/30/04

Outputs
The project is advancing well. The product (commercialized as HPTS [TM], High Protein Textured Soy) is a dry, shelf stable textured soy chunk ideal for use as a meat analog when rehydrated and flavored. Other uses are being explored. The key benefits are improved texture and better flavor delivery that allow creation of excellent meat mimics. We have completed most of the material trials and a number of the process and scale-up trials scoped in the Phase II solicitation. Heartland Fields, LLC has been fortunate to achieve some commercial business resulting in some added focus on application trials and support of commercialization, a directional change we have taken in keeping with the ultimate goal of the USDA-SBIR program, the establishment of enterprises that benefit agriculture. Material selection: A range of high protein soy varieties (48-52% DB in whole Soybeans, 56-61% in low fat flour from same) has been validated to work in the process. The high protein is key to achieving the desired firm meat-like structure that is important when delivering a vegetarian meat analog that is familiar in the western diet. Residual oil and oleo-compounds, including the tocopherols and natural emulsifiers inherent to the flour by virtue of our expeller-press processing and air swept flour-milling process, have been identified as critical to the development of flavor and texture profiles of the HPTS. Structure/Flavoring: The dried, shelf stable HPTS product has an open cell, fibrous structure that facilitates easy rehydration. Also, its low flavor profile allows for ease of topical flavoring. Its been determined that flavoring of the product is best achieved in the rehydration step, because the flavor can easily penetrate through the entire matrix of the HPTS structure. Less flavor addition is required when added at rehydration, and the added flavor is subjected to very little heat. By contrast adding flavors in extrusion results in heat exposure and flashing of desirable volatiles. Keeping Quality: Commercial interest in HPTS as a meat analog (chicken strips, beef tips) component in frozen rice-bowl and pasta-bowl entrees led us to initiate keeping quality studies. We have passed the halfway mark in this 18-month study and to date the meat analog and the entire entree have held up well with very little flavor or texture deterioration. We expect the products to have a shelf life equal to or greater than a meat-containing entree. HPTS can be shaped and sized for a range of applications from small meal and granules to chunks as large as 2+ inch long strips. Our focus has been on developing the larger pieces, as the market opportunity for larger pieces is largely unmet. Midsize pieces have also found commercial application as flavored pizza Vegan topping (e.g. Crumbled Italian sausage analog). The product is patent pending. The prior art has not shown any product to have the unique naturally inherent combinations of nutrients in a shelf stable product and we anticipate a 2006 patent issue. The progress to date and the planned year 2 refinements of the scaled up process will combine to enhance the product for wider commercialization.

Impacts
A simply better meat analog by virtue of its texture and flavor, the high protein textured soy will be a preferred meat analog for vegetarian foods, particularly when larger whole-muscle-like pieces are desired. The process used is all-natural (water, heat, and pressure only) and avoids any chemical solvents thus offering an environmentally better option to processors. The result is no special EPA or state environmental permitting is required in for production; and fewer allergenicity concerns for consumers with chemical sensitivities. Broad appeal of the high protein textured soy can increase the consumption of vegetable proteins.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period