Progress 10/01/04 to 09/30/09
Outputs OUTPUTS: I worked with the multistate team to develop a research base containing performance and benchmark financial information on farms and their lenders, and rural and non-traditional capital markets. I also developed a dataset of social capital measurement from several different sources. Under the project, I trained 3 MS students and one PhD student. Research was disseminated through publications in over 15 refereed journals, and more than 30 professional conferences. Noteworthy are two special meetings on microfinance and rural finance that I organized: one at the Tri-annual Meetings of the International Agricultural Economics Association in Beijing, China and one at the Annual Meetings of the Allied Social Sciences Association which includes the Agricultural and Applied Economics Association. I was asked to consult the World Bank on the effectiveness of ratings for improving efficiency in MFIs, and received external funds for part of the work from a prestigious grant by the Center for Financial Research at the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, where I also presented the work at a special workshop. PARTICIPANTS: Not relevant to this project. TARGET AUDIENCES: Not relevant to this project. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: In 2009 this project was under review for renewal and was renewed as NC1177. The new project goals are 1. Examine the impact of recent fluctuations in capital and commodity markets on the performance, management, and regulation of agricultural financial institutions 2. Evaluate the management strategies, capital needs, and policy impacting the financial performance and long-term sustainability of firms in the food and agribusiness sector 3. Identify financial institutions and services that benefit agricultural producers and rural communities and expand agricultural markets, especially those producers that are beginning, young, from socially disadvantaged groups, and/or involved in producing specialty crops 4. Investigate capital structure, financial performance, and investment strategies of firms producing renewable energy in context of long term climate change. Implications of these findings for agriculture and rural communities will be delineated
Impacts Since traditional agricultural financial institutions, set up to support agricultural production, are playing a diminishing role due to globalization and transition of financial markets, new players such as mainstream financial institutions, specialized microfinance and community development financial institutions, now provide essential services to rural households and farmers in the domestic and international rural finance markets. My research helped understand the objectives and drivers of performance of the new players in the rural financial markets as well as the factors improve performance and risk-management of domestic and international financial institutions. An important sub-area of my research was on governance and performance in financial institutions. Governance includes internal governance involving board-management interaction and ownership, and external governance involving rating, regulation, auditing and other institutions of market discipline. To correctly study the link between governance and performance, it is important to develop and use appropriate measurement of performance, especially in multi-task financial institutions such as microfinance and community development financial institutions because they strive to serve 1/many marginal clients (achieve outreach) in 2/ a profitable manner (sustainability). Measuring the efficiently of these FIs matters as well, so I have studied FIs efficiency with innovative stochastic frontier methods. Mastering these methods has permitted me to collaborate with colleagues and students and apply the methods to other sectors such as nursery greenhouses and peanut production. The success and failure of a financial institution depends on its ability to understand its clients, namely firms and households. My research shows that alternative lending practices and technologies such as credit counseling, group loans, and the use of social capital as collateral are important and can successfully be used by both lenders and their clients. I also study investment in firms and farms and their dependence on external funds and changes in producer support policies and show to what extent financial markets and institutions are able to meet the financial needs of their clients in a changing environment.
Publications
- Hartarska, Valentina; C. Parmeter, and D. Nadolnyak (2010) Economies of Scope of Lending and Mobilizing Deposits in Rural MFIs: a Semiparametric Analysis, American Journal of Agricultural Economics.
- Hartarska V., and R. Mersland, (2010), What governance mechanisms promote efficiency in reaching poor clients Evidence from rated MFIs, European Financial Management.
- Caudill, S, Gropper D, and Hartarska V. (2009), Which Microfinance Institutions Are Becoming More Cost-Effective With Time Evidence from a Mixture Model, Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking, 41(4), p.651-672.
- Hartarska V., (2009)review of Swinnen, J.F.M. ed. (2007) Global Supply Chains, Standards and the Poor: How the Globalization of Food Systems and Standards Affects Rural Development and Poverty, Cambridge, MA: CABI., American Journal of Agricultural Economics 91(4):1154-1155 .
- Hartarska V. (2009), The Impact of Outside Control in Microfinance, Managerial Finance, 35(12), p 975-989.
- Hartarska, V., and Nadolnyak, D. (2008) Does rating help microfinance institutions raise funds Cross-country evidence. International Review of Economics and Finance, 17, p 558 571
- Hartarska V. and D. Nadolnyak (2007), Do Regulated Microfinance Institutions Achieve Better Sustainability and Outreach Cross-Country Evidence, Applied Economics 39(10-12):1207-1222.
- Nadolnyak D., S. Fletcher, and V. Hartarska (2006), Peanut Cost-Efficiency and Producer Characteristics in the Southeast: Implications for the Farm-Level Impact of the 2002 Farm Act, Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics 38(1), p. 213-224.
- Hartarska V. and M. Holtmann (2006), An Overview of Recent Developments in the Microfinance Literature, Agricultural Finance Review, 66(2): 147-165.
- Hartarska V. and C. Gonzalez-Vega (2006), Evidence on the Effect of Credit Counseling and Mortgage Loan Default by Low-Income Households, Journal of Housing Economics, 15 (1): 63-79.
- Hartarska V. and C. Gonzalez-Vega (2006), What Affects New and Established Firms Investment: Evidence from Small Firms in Russia, Small Business Economics Journal, 27(2&3): 195-206.
- Ellinger P., V. Hartarska, and C. Wilson (2005), Structure, Performance, and Risk Management of Financial Institutions, special issue of Agricultural Finance Review,35(2):183-200.
- Hartarska, V. and C. Gonzalez-Vega (2005), Credit Counseling and Mortgage Termination by Low-Income Households, Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 30(3):227-243.
- Hartarska, V. (2005) Governance and Performance of Microfinance Institutions in Central and Eastern Europe and the Newly Independent States, World Development Vol. 33(10):1627-1643.
- Hartarska, V. (2004), Community Development Financial Institutions in the Southeast: Board Size and Diversity as Governance Mechanisms, Southern Business and Economics Journal, 27 (1&2):102-110.
- Hartarska V., Nadolnyak D. (2010)What external control mechanisms help Microfinance Institutions meet the financial needs of marginal clientele (forthcoming 2009) in Handbook of Microfinance edited by Marc Labie and Beatriz Armedariaz
- Barth, J., M. Burtus, V. Hartarska, Hai Jasob Jiang, and T. Phumiwasana (2007), A Cross-Country Analysis of Bank Performance: The Role of External Governance pp151-153 Corporate Governance in Banking: A Global Perspective. Benton Gup (ed.), Edward Elgar Publishing
- Barth, J., V. Hartarska, D. Noelle, and T. Phumiwasana (2005), A Cross-Country Analysis of External Governance and Bank Profitability in Regulation of Financial Intermediaries in Emerging Markets, edited by T. Mohan, R. Nitsure and M. Joseph, A Sage Publications, New Delhi: India, pp. 46-86.
- Elliot V., V. Hartarska, C. Bailey, (2007) Economic Growth and Resource Allocation in Alabama: Is there a Dutch Disease, proceedings from the PAWC Annual Meeting, Dec. 4-6, 2006.
- Kennealy, P., V. Hartarska, C. Bailey and M. Dubois, 2006 Correlation Between Forestland Ownership and Poverty in the Non-Metro South, proceedings from the at the PAWC Annual Meeting, Dec. 4-6. 2005.
- Hartarska, V. (2005) Community Development Financial Institutions: Issues of Performance and Governance, Online Proceedings of the Center for Financial Research Workshop, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Washington D.C. September 20-21, 2005.
- Hartarska, V. (2005)Community Development Financial Institutions in Rural Areas: Efficiency and Governance, Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of NC 1014, Rural Financial Markets in Transition, Minnesota, October 4-5, 2005.
- Barth, J., D. Gropper, V. Hartarska, S. Nolle, and T. Phumiwasana, 2005 External Governance and Bank Performance: A Cross-Country Analysis, Dolibois Seminar Series Miami University Oxford, Ohio. April 2005.
- Nadolnyak D., V. Hartarska, and S. (2004) Fletcher Cost Efficiency of U.S. Peanut Producers and Welfare Effects of Substitution of Quota with Marketing Assistance Loan Program, published abstract in Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, 2004.
- Hartarska, V., (2004) The Portfolio of Family Farms, abstract in Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, 2004.
- Ellinger P., V. Hartarska, and C. Wilson, 2005 Structure, Performance, and Risk Management of Financial Institutions, Organized Pre-Conference Seminar, American Agricultural Economics Association Annual Meetings in Rhode Island, 2005, Session CD publication.
- Bellenger M., D. Fields, and V. Hartaska. 2005 Technical Efficiency in Alabama Nursery and Greenhouse Sectors. Southern Nursery Association Research Conference Proceedings. Volume 50, 2005.
- Hartarska V., and C. Gonzalez-Vega, (2005) The Impact of Credit-Counseling on Mortgage Prepayment and Default by Underserved Low-Income Households, Conference Proceedings, Federal Reserve System's Fourth Community Affairs Research Conference Promises & Pitfalls: As Consumer Finance Options Multiply, Who Is Being Served and at What Cost, April 2005.
- Mai C., Hartarska,V. (2008) Financing Constraints and the Family Farm: How do Families React published abstract in Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics, 2008.
- Elliott II V., V Hartarska, and C. Bailey, (2008), Natural Resources Endowment and Economic Growth in the Southeastern United States, published abstract in Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics, 2008.
- Hartarska V. 2005 Ratings in Microfinance, abstract published in Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, December, 2005.
- Hartarska, V. (2004) Governance and Performance of Microfinance Organizations in Central and Eastern Europe and the Newly Independent States, abstract published in Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics, 2004.
|
Progress 01/01/05 to 12/31/05
Outputs A major effort during the year was undertaken to map the current state of the field and to develop strategies for further research including identifying specific collaborative research efforts. I collaborated with Christine Wilson at Purdue University and Paul Ellinger at University of Illinois in a research project that summarized accomplishments of the discipline in the area of Structure, Performance and Risk Management of Financial Institutions in Agriculture and identify emerging issues that need to be addressed by the discipline. Outputs included conference paper presentations and a refereed article. Non-traditional financial services are becoming important source of funds in rural areas as traditional financial institutions streamline their operations to be relevant in a global world. Focusing on lending practices, I study whether innovative lending practices such as use the applicants social capital can help lenders to make a better decision. In addition
focusing on Community Development Financial Institutions, I analyze governance practices their impact on institutions performance. Outputs include funding to leverage resources and a fellowship with the Center for Financial Service Research, FDIC, one conference and one workshop presentations and published proceedings, one paper on social capital under review and two working papers. This work attracted the attention of the editor of Journal of Agricultural Finance Review who asked me to submit my work for peer review and possible publications in AFR as well as to write and a lead invited paper on microfinance to broaden the field AFR. Another area of my research focused on evaluating the impact of changes in the 2002 Farm Act, on efficiency of the Southeastern peanut producers and specifically whether the substitution of the peanut quota system with a marketing loan program affects efficiency, and whether the policy changes will hurt former quota owners. Outputs include a journal
article, a conference paper and a published abstract. I also made progress in the developing of modeling strategy on farm household portfolios. A graduate student was recruited to develop a thesis proposal on the topic and to assemble the experimental station farm management data. Review of the literature on off-farm income, household bargaining and farm investment began. In addition, a grant proposal with Dr. Duffy was submitted to leverage finds for the program but was not funded.
Impacts 1. Identified plan for further research on Risk Management of Financial Institutions for NC10140 2. Investment and off farm income of Alabama farm households are strongly correlated suggesting employment opportunities outside the farm will affect the future of the family farm. 3. Substitution of peanuts quota system with marketing loan program is not expected to put at disadvantage former quota owners. 4. Credit counseling and social capital affect loan repayment and default. 5. CDFIs with more diversified boards are less efficient.
Publications
- Hartarska, V. (2005), Community Development Financial Institutions: Issues of Performance and Governance, Online proceedings of the Center for Financial Research Workshop, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Wahsington D.C. September 20-21.
- Hartarska, V., and C. Gonzalez-Vega,(2005).Credit Counseling and Mortgage Termination by Low-Income Households, Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 30(3) 227-243.
- Ellinger P., V. Hartarska, and C. Wilson, (2006).(forthcoming) Structure, Performance, and Risk Measurement of Financial Institutions, special issue of Agricultural Finance Review.
- Nadolnyak, D. A., S. M. Fletcher, and V. M. Hartarska, (2006). Peanut Production Cost Efficiency and Producer Characteristics in the Southeast: Implications for the Farm-Level Impacts of the 2002 Farm Act, Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics.
- Nadolnyak, D. A and V.M. Hartarska, and Fletcher, S.M., (2005). Producer Characteristics and Peanut Cost Efficiency in the Southeast: Implications for the Farm-Level Impacts of the 2002 Farm Act, Abstract published in JAAE.
- Hartarska, V.(2005). Community Development Financial Institutions in Rural Areas: Efficiency and Governance, Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of NC 1014, Rural Financial Markets in Transition, Minnesota, October 4-5.
- Ellinger P., V. Hartarska, and C. Wilson (2006), forthcoming), Structure, Performance, and Risk Measurement of Financial Institutions, special issue of Agricultural Finance Review.
- Hartarska, V., and C. Gonzalez-Vega (2005), Credit Counseling and Mortgage Termination by Low-Income Households Proceedings of from invited presentation at the Federal Reserve System Fourth Community Affairs Research Conference Promises and Pitfalls: As Consumer Finance Options Multiply, Who Is Being Served and at What Cost? April.
- Bellenger, M., D. Fields, Valentina Hartaska, (2005). Technical Efficiency in Alabama Nursery and Greenhouse Sectors. Southern Nursery Association Research Conference Proceedings. Volume 50, 2005.
|