Source: FLORIDA A&M UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
BIOTIC INTEGRITY INDEX DEVELOPMENT FOR FORESTED ECOSYSTEMS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0197125
Grant No.
2003-38814-13931
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2003-03905
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 15, 2003
Project End Date
Sep 14, 2007
Grant Year
2003
Program Code
[EQ.C2]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
FLORIDA A&M UNIVERSITY
(N/A)
TALLAHASSEE,FL 32307
Performing Department
AGRICULTURAL RESEARCH
Non Technical Summary
Reliable metrics are needed to assess effects natural resource management activities on biodiversity of forest ecosystems. The purpose of this study is to evaluate how forest ecosystem invertebrate communities vary naturally, and how they repond to different types of disturbance.
Animal Health Component
50%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
50%
Applied
50%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1230611113025%
1230621113025%
1350611113025%
1350621113025%
Goals / Objectives
1. We will conduct a general inventory of aquatic and terrestrial insect communities in GCPEP ecosystems using replicable collection methods. 2. Using Stream Condition Index and other suitable indicators, we will develop a water quality classification of the streams and rivers in GCPEP areas. 3. Using the terrestrial inventory results, we will identify possible indicator species which signal the presence of high-quality examples of the major natural communities. 4. We will analyze probable relationships of the spatial and temporal distribution patterns between vegetation, and terrestrial and aquatic insect communities using Geographic Information Systems (GIS).
Project Methods
The inventory of insect communities will be done by focused collecting in the Blackwater River State Forest, the Conecuh National Forest, and Eglin Air Force Base, with major emphasis on the natural communities of EAFB for reasons discussed below. Habitat types will include both aquatic and terrestrial; the former ranging from medium-sized rivers to very small steepheads, the latter covering the ten largest (in terms of area covered) upland forest communities in the GCPEP. Collecting methods in most cases will be semi-quantitative: malaise traps, pitfall traps, and flight-intercept traps. These devices, when left in place for standard periods of time, sample different fractions of the arthropod community in a given habitat. Aquatic collecting will be done with Hester-Dendy samplers and aquatic dip nets, as recommended by Hubbard and Swadling(1995). In developing biotic indices for natural communities, it is important to define clearly those communities. This is usually done on the basis of vegetation. In the GCPEP, the requisite natural community survey has been done only for EAFB (Kindell et al. 1996); for this reason, the bulk of the field work in this project will initially be done on Eglin. In the Eglin community survey, 34 different natural communities were identified. Since a detailed inventory of all 34 would be well beyond the scope of a three-year project, the nine largest community types (in terms of acreage) will be studied. These nine communities are all greater than 400 ha. (about 1,000 acres) and are as follows: Sandhill ~ 20,106 ha. Upland pine forest ~ 2,443 ha. Mesic flatwoods ~ 1,221 ha. Floodplain forest ~ 861 ha. Scrub ~ 837 ha. Upland hardwood forest ~ 697 ha. Baygall ~ 682 ha. Xeric hammock ~ 480 ha. Floodplain swamp ~ 478 ha. The sandhill community will be further subdivided into two parts: longleaf pine-wiregrass association, and longleaf pine-little bluestem association. Aquatic natural communities on EAFB include swamps, bogs, blackwater streams, seepage streams, spring-run streams, and alluvial streams (Kindell et al. 1996). Most of these have not been quantified in terms of area. Both aquatic and terrestrial sampling will be done twice a year during late spring and early fall. These are periods of peak insect activity. Although more frequent sampling would be desirable, the sampling methods we will use will generate very large numbers of specimens which must be processed and identified. Besides the cost considerations of more frequent trips to the study area, it is important to match specimen accumulation with the ability to process collections in a timely manner. By limiting collecting to spring and fall peak activity periods, we will generate sufficient material to accomplish our objectives, while avoiding the frequent pitfall of over-collection and becoming inundated with masses of specimens.

Progress 09/15/03 to 09/14/07

Outputs
OUTPUTS: Documented mayfly biodiversity by sampling nymphs and adults from upper and lower reaches of ravine streams located within several different major drainage basins and biogeographic regions in northern Florida. Specimens were identified to species level and abundance data were tabulated and then used to analyze mayfly community structure and environmental relationships. A cluster analysis of the sampling stations was performed using Unweighted Pair Group Mathematical Averaging (UPGMA) on a similarity matrix based on Spearman rank correlation coefficient. Thirty-nine species representing 25 genera and 11 families were recorded in the faunal survey. A total of 3,432 mayfly individuals were identified to species. Two new state records were recorded (Diphetor hageni and Ephemerella excrucians), both representing highly disjunct southern range-extensions. Also of note, a potential new species of Caenis was collected from steephead streams on Eglin Air Force Base, suggesting that these systems may harbor narrow-range endemic mayfly species. Species richness differences among stations appear to be largely a function of stream size. Ravine-head reaches had far fewer species (3-7 species) than did lower-reach stations, many of which had approximately 20 species. Habrophlebiodes brunneipennis is a particularly abundant species in upper-ravine springruns and can be considered a signature species of ravines in the Florida panhandle. The cluster analysis bears out that mayfly community structure among stations is controlled by both regional biogeographic differences and habitat differences related to stream size and type. PARTICIPANTS: Investigators: Manuel Pescador, Andrew Rasmussen, Barton Richard, Wills Flowers. Seton Bonney was trained by Andrew Rasmussen for water quality work on Eglin Air Force Base, one of the main study areas in this project. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: The original goal of developing indices to terrestrial invertebrates could not be met for this project. Preliminary sampling made it clear that the project budget and facilities at FAMU were inadequate for the extensive sampling that would be necessary to develop terrestrial indices. Changes in lodgistic at both Eglin AFB and within FAMU also made terrestrial sampling impractical. It was decided to concentrate on the aquatic sampling since this would lead to much more successful outcomes.

Impacts
The research conducted under this project has led to a better understanding of aquatic insect biodiversity in streams of northern Florida, particularly those on Eglin Air Force Base in the western Florida panhandle. As a result of our biotic survey, an inventory of aquatic insects is available as baseline data for biomonitoring activities being conducted by U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service personnel tasked with monitoring aquatic ecosystem health on the base. In fact, the data collected in this project has already been useful for the planning and implementation of an aquatic monitoring program on Eglin. Preliminary findings were shared with interested parties during a three-day biomonitoring workshop held at Eglin in March 2007. In October of 2007, a US Fish & Wildlife biologist (Mr. Seton Bonney) brought to our laboratory aquatic specimens he collected as part of stream bioassessment work being done on Eglin. During his week-long visit, he received instruction on taxonomic identification of the aquatic insects in his samples. The training was enhanced by the fact that he was able to compare specimens in his samples with specimens collected under this project. As a result of the training he received, he is better able to accurately identify specimens to lowest possible taxonomic level, thereby improving efficacy of the stream bioassessments he is conducting. This project has served as a spring-board for a new two-year project titled: Biotic Inventory and Conservation Status of Ephemeroptera (Mayflies), Plecoptera (Stoneflies), and Trichoptera (Caddisflies) on Eglin Air Force Base, Florida. A grant proposal to fund this project was submitted (November 2007) to the Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission under the State Wildlife Grant Program funded through the US Fish and Wildlife Service. Our research efforts have documented distributional records for many species of aquatic insects which can be considered to be rare or threatened in the state of Florida. These findings will continue to be of use in developing conservation plans to protect imperiled species and the habitats that support them.

Publications

  • Pescador, M.L. and B.A. Richard. 2006. A new species of Caenis (Ephemeroptera: Caenidae) from Florida, USA. Zootaxa 1355: 61-68.


Progress 01/01/06 to 12/31/06

Outputs
Due to the active hurricane season of 2005, two trips to Eglin Air Force Base for field sampling had to be cancelled. We resumed field work in 2006 and were able to collect aquatic insect samples at 14 stream monitoring stations during week-long sampling events in January, April, and October of 2006. In addition to benthic insect samples being collected, light trapping of adult Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera, and Trichoptera was also carried out during the April and October sampling periods. The majority of the monitoring stations chosen for this project have now been sampled on 5 separate occasions at different times of year. Having a temporal series of samples from each site will allow us to examine how the aquatic insect community structure at the sampling sites has changed throughout the course of the project. The repeated sampling also is necessary for developing a comprehensive taxonomic inventory. Specimen identifications are complete for all the benthic samples, and a preliminary list of aquatic insect taxa has been compiled based on the benthic data. Identifications of specimens from light trap samples are ongoing.

Impacts
The research conducted under this project has led to a better understanding of aquatic insect biodiversity in streams of northern Florida, particularly those on Eglin Air Force Base in the western Florida panhandle. As a result of our biotic survey, an inventory of aquatic insects has been produced which will provide critical baseline data for future biomonitoring activities conducted by U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service personnel tasked with monitoring aquatic ecosystem health on the base. Our preliminary findings were shared with interested parties during a three-day biomonitoring workshop held at Eglin in March 2007. Our research efforts have documented distributional records for many species of aquatic insects which can be considered to be rare or threatened in the state of Florida. These findings will be useful for developing conservation plans to protect key habitats that support multiple species. Listed below are recent scientific presentations and publications that were a direct outcome of this project.

Publications

  • Pescador, M.L. and B.A. Richard. 2006. A new species of Caenis (Ephemeroptera: Caenidae) from Florida, USA. Zootaxa 1355:61-68.
  • Rasmussen, A.K., M.L. Pescador, and B.A. Richard. 2006. Association of Research Directors, Inc. 14th Biennial Research Symposium, Atlanta, GA. Poster Presentation: Species Diversity and Community Structure of Ephemeroptera (Mayflies) in Northern Florida Ravine Ecosystems.
  • Rasmussen, A.K. and S.C. Harris. 2006. The 54th Annual Meeting of the Entomological Society of America, Indianapolis, Indiana. Poster Presentation: Review of the genus Beraea (Trichoptera: Beraeidae) in North America.


Progress 01/01/05 to 12/31/05

Outputs
For the aquatic component of the study, twelve sampling sites were established in streams that are associated with the various types of natural communities in the Eglin Air Force Base watershed. Benthic samples have been collected, and sampling is ongoing. Approximately six-man hours of benthic sampling are spent per collecting period. Standard aquatic dip net (D-Frame, 600 micron Nitex bag) and kick net/handscreen (meter, 600 micron mesh) are the method of choice to collect benthos sample for this study. These techniques allow us to qualitatively and to a certain quantitably sample a variety of habitats. Adults are mainly collected with portable light traps. Light trapping is useful for collecting not only a wide array of insect species but especially hard to-find species. Collected samples are currently being processed, sorted and identified. Identified taxa are entered in a database with GIS applications. Preliminary data indicate an interesting differences in the species composition and richness of aquatic insects particularly the EPT fauna (Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera, Trichoptera) of the streams associated with the various identified natural communities in the watershed. Moreover, occurrence of rare and threatened species of aquatic insects appear more in streams associated with Steephead Ravine Systems than those in Depression Wetlands or Floodplains. Analysis of insect biodiversity relative to the degree of land use in the watershed is continuing. The terrestrial biomonitoring component of this project has fallen behind, due in part to hurricanes disrupting several trips to select sample sites, and in part to the lack of facilities and technical assistance in FAMU for processing the huge numbers of specimens that our original collecting plan would generate. We have accordingly scaled back the terrestrial component to concentrate on a flatwoods sandhill comparison with ants and Orthoptera as the principle focal groups. Recent publication of identification keys to Floridas diverse and endemic grasshopper fauna, and the use of Orthoptera as indicator organisms in other grassland ecosystems make this a very appropriate group for North Floridas semisavanna habitats. We will also incorporate data from a previous invertebrate study of longleaf wiregrass flatwoods (many of these samples have not yet been sorted) from the Apalachicola National Forest which is 150 miles east of the Eglin area. This will give a broad regional dimension to our flatwoods data.

Impacts
The data from this project are a baseline of Florida Panhandle forest ecosystems, including associated aquatic ecosystems, in a relatively natural state, including a more or less natural fire regime. Natural ecosystems in this region outside of protected areas are under ever greater development pressure; at the same time there is increasing interest in managing both public and private lands to mimic as much as possible natural processes. Data on both terrestrial and aquatic invertebrate communities will be indispensable in detecting departures from natural processes and BMPs. Data on invertebrate communities will be extremely useful in evaluating impacts of climate change on Gulf Coast Ecosystems. The aquatic fauna in particular could be a sensitive indicator of climate change since the Florida Panhandle has a rich endemic fauna and many relict species living in geographically limited cool springs. The range and status of these species will change rapidly with changing climatic conditions.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 01/01/04 to 12/31/04

Outputs
For the aquatic component of the study, twelve sampling sites were established in streams that are associated with the various types of natural communities in the Eglin Air Force Base watershed. Benthic samples have been collected, and sampling is ongoing. Approximately three-man hours of benthic sampling are spent per collecting period. Standard aquatic dip net (D-Frame, 600 micron Nitex bag) and kick net/handscreen (meter, 600 micron mesh) are the method of choice to collect benthic samples for this study. These techniques allow us to qualitatively and to a certain extent quantitatively sample a wide variety of habitats. Adults are mainly collected with portable light traps. Light trapping is useful for collecting not only a wide array of insect species but especially hard to find species. Collected samples are currently being processed, sorted and identified. Identified taxa are being entered in a database with GIS applications. Preliminary data indicate an interesting correlations in the species composition and richness of aquatic, insects particularly the EPT fauna (Ephemeroptera-Plecoptera-Trichoptera) associated with the various identified natural communities in the watershed. Moreover, occurrences of rare and threatened species of aquatic insects appear more in streams associated with steephead/ravine systems than those in depression wetlands or floodplains. Analysis of insect biodiversity relative to the degree of land use in the watershed is continuing.

Impacts
The information generated by this project will enable land managers to assess the ecosystem health of forested land in the Florida Panhandle, to quickly detect changes, and to apply corrective measures if needed.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 01/01/03 to 12/31/03

Outputs
Budget clearance was received only last month (Nov. 2003). Field work will begin in the spring of 2004.

Impacts
None yet.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period