Source: MONTANA STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
PARAMETERS AFFECTING THE EFFICIENCY OF GENE TARGETING IN BOVINE CELLS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0194276
Grant No.
(N/A)
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Oct 1, 2002
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2006
Grant Year
(N/A)
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
MONTANA STATE UNIVERSITY
(N/A)
BOZEMAN,MT 59717
Performing Department
VETERINARY MOLECULAR BIOLOGY
Non Technical Summary
Genetic engineering of cattle is complicated by the very low efficiency at which genetic modifications can be made in bovine cells. This poject examines the parameters that limit the efficiency of creating targeted mutations in bovine cells, with the goal of being able to increase this efficiency.
Animal Health Component
25%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
50%
Applied
25%
Developmental
25%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
3083310100011%
3083310103011%
3083310108011%
3083410100011%
3083410103011%
3083410108011%
5113470100011%
5113470103011%
5113470108012%
Goals / Objectives
This study is aimed at developing an efficient system for targeted gene replacement in bovine cells. The rationale is as follows. First, cloning technology provides a means to produce lines of cattle having the genetic attributes obtained from a cultured fibroblast cell. Second, targeted gene replacement provides the best system by which one might design a transgene that will be precisely controlled in terms of the quality of the product, as well as the time and tissue of production. Moreover, unlike with other forms of transgenic animals, those produced by gene targeting will exhibit the same favorable characteristics in animals of subsequent generations that inherit the gene. The first report of gene targeting in livestock (sheep) was published two years ago. The process proved to be extremely arduous due to inefficiencies in performing the gene targeting event in cultured livestock cells. No published reports of gene targeting in cattle exist to date. We have extensive experience in gene targeting in mouse cell lines, and we propose to use this experience in the current phase of this project to increase the efficiency of gene targeting in bovine cells. Thus, although the current proposal involves no animal production or cloning, we are aiming to improve the most problematic phase in the production of livestock bearing targeted transgenes. In future years, we hope to advance the project into the phase of animal production. The production of recombinant human proteins in livestock is likely to become a completely new multi-billion dollar branch of agriculture in the near future. The current proposal is aimed at improving the technology by which these procedures are performed. Importantly, this work will ensure that as this new branch of agricultural production develops, Montana will be at the forefront of the technology and will be able to be a major player in this new industry. Montana has been a major agricultural producer for over a century. By assimilating pharmaceutical protein production into Montana's repertoire of agricultural products, we will further strengthen our agricultural economy and ensure that Montana partakes of the benefits of this new industry. In the next five year period, we are requesting USDA Animal Health Formula Funds to refine the system that we have produced based on a highly homozygous BEF cell line and matching library, and a genetically dissimilar BEF line. This system will then be used to make the first thorough analysis of how parameters based on target/targeting vector identity affect gene targeting in bovine cells by addressing the following Specific Aims. A. Establish conditions for clonal isolation of stably-transfected bovine fibroblasts. B. Design a new 5'tbp targeting vector that incorporates the double-selection system developed in Specific Aim A. C. Compare targeting efficiency between the isogenic cell line and the non-isogenic cell line.
Project Methods
A. Establish conditions for clonal isolation of stably-transfected bovine fibroblasts. We have designed and are in the process of developing a novel rapid double selection-based approach for targeting BEFs. The system is based on using a selectable marker cassette that incorporates both a n expressed short-lived fluorescent marker gene and a drug resistance marker. Fluorescent cells would be isolated and plated at a density of one cell per well in 96 well plates in selective medium. Since all cells from that parent would be confined to a single well, none would be lost to migration, and few generations would be needed to obtain enough cells for analysis. In preliminary work, we have created plasmid vectors that express both the Neo drug selection gene and different fluorescent markers. We are currently working on optimizing conditions for isolating and replating the fluorescent BEFs by FACS. We will then grow the isolated single cell clones in selective medium (containing the drug G418, for which the neo gene provides resistance), and assess our ability to obtain stable cell lines with random insertions of this double-selection vector. B. Design a new 5'tbp targeting vector that incorporates the double-selection system developed in Specific Aim A. We have isolated a new 18 kb tbp genomic clone from our American Holstein library that, based on Southern blotting and preliminary sequence analysis, contains a large amount of sequence that extends from 5' protein coding sequences to a region well upstream of the promoter. In the proposed granting period, we will continue mapping and sequencing analysis on this clone to allow design a targeting vector. This region of the gene was selected because, in previous studies producing targeting vectors for this same gene in mice, our 5' targeted vectors proved to be highly successful. Putative target regions will be assessed by PCR and Southern blot analyses to ensure that they will not contain repetitive sequences and that they will be compatible with subsequent genotypic analyses. The vector will be designed to be easily screened by PCR-based analyses, such that less genomic DNA will be required for subsequent analyses Finally, the targeting vector will be designed to express both neo and RFP-ODC, such that we can pre-select stably transfected cells at a very early time after electroporation, and then expand these selectively in G418-containing media, as described in Specific Aim A. C. Compare targeting efficiency between the isogenic cell line and the non-isogenic cell line. To begin to enumerate the effects of heterozygosity on targeting efficiency, we will compare the targeting efficiency using the isogenic TBP targeting vector that we have produced on either the isogenic American Holstein BEF line, whose sequences match those of the targeting vector exactly, or from the out-bred beef line that we produced with our USDA Animal Health Formula Funds last year.

Progress 10/01/02 to 09/30/06

Outputs
We previously produced a line of bovine embryonic fibroblast cells (BEF) from a 40 day-old Holstein fetus and a second line from an outbred free-range Montana beef fetus. From the Holstein fetus, we prepared a genomic DNA library in lambda phage. We expanded the BEF cell line to second passage, and froze several hundred vials of these early-passage cells in liquid nitrogen to provide an essentially permanent stock of BEFs that genetically match our genomic library perfectly. The primary library had over 10-fold coverage of the genome with an average insert size of over 22kb. We isolated 5 pure clones of the bovine tbp gene form the library, which have been used for making targeting vectors. We chose this gene as a representative paradigm largely because we have great experience in working with targeting this gene in mouse cells. Using several of these vectors, we initiated targeting of the matched Holstein cells and found that the locus could be effectively targeted, but cell migration precluded efficient clonal selection. We switched to a fluorescence-based double selection targeting method; however our studies using this failed to yield targeted clones. Analyses suggest that the fluorescence of single-copy transformed cells, as cells bearing targeted alleles should be, is too low to efficiently isolate, so only non-targeted multi-copy transfected cells are recovered by FACS. To surmount this problem, we switched to a strategy that is independent of fluorescent markers and will not exclude single-copy transformants. Cells are transfected with a targeting vector that contains only the drug selection marker (neo) and are being plated in 96-well dishes containing selective medium at densities that give 0.6 transfected cells per well. As such, most wells with cell growth are clonal derivatives of a single transfected founder, we eliminate pre-selection for high-expressers (i.e., multi-copy transformants), and all progeny of that founder are confined to a single well, thus precluding the previous complications due to unrestricted migration. We have also vastly improved our transfection efficiency by switching from electroporation of the cells (which gave only a small percentage of the cells transfected in analyses based on green fluorescent protein expression) to using the Amaxa Nucleofector II electro-transformation system. This modification, increased our transfection efficiency by roughly 10-fold. Using this approach,w we have now isolated genomic DNA from roughly 300 clones of G418-resistant Holstein (isogeneic) BEFS and a similar numer of Angus (mismatched) BEFS. We are currently optimizing protocols for measuring homologous gene targeting vs random insertion in these clones.

Impacts
Our goal is to measure how sequence identity parameters affect the efficiency of targeted mutagenesis in bovine cells. Were targeted mutagenesis to become tractable in cattle, it could both increase the value of existing cattle-based commodities and allow creation of countless more valuable cattle-based products. Thus, it could allow production of particularly disease resistant herds or herds exhibiting increased milk or beef production. It could also help create cattle lines custom fit to particular environments, for example, by altering their ability to use different feed sources, altering salt tolerance, or altering reproductive cycles.

Publications

  • Prigge JR, Schmidt EE. Interaction of protein inhibitor of activated STAT (PIAS) proteins with the TATA-binding protein, TBP. J Biol Chem. 2006 May 5;281(18):12260-9. PMID: 16522640.
  • Sansinena MJ, Taylor SA, Taylor PJ, Schmidt EE, Denniston RS, Godke RA. In vitro production of llama (Lama glama) embryos by intracytoplasmic sperm injection: Effect of chemical activation treatments and culture conditions. Anim Reprod Sci. 2006 Jul 15; [Epub ahead of print] PMID: 16846701.


Progress 01/01/05 to 12/31/05

Outputs
In founding work for this project, we produced a line of bovine embryonic fibroblasts (BEFs) from a Holstein fetus and a second line from an outbred free-range Montana beef fetus. From the Holstein fetus, we prepared a genomic DNA library in lambda phage. We expanded the line to second passage and froze vials in liquid nitrogen to provide a stock of BEFs that genetically match our genomic library perfectly. The primary library had over 10-fold coverage of the genome with an average insert size of over 22kb. We isolated 5 pure clones of the bovine tbp gene form the library, which have been used for making targeting vectors. Using these vectors, we initiated targeting of the matched Holstein cells and found that the locus could be effectively targeted, but cell migration precluded efficient clonal selection. In the past year, we improved our transfection efficiency in the past year by switching from electroporation of the cells (which gave only a small percentage of the cells transfected in analyses based on green fluorescent protein expression) to using the Amaxa Nucleofector II electro-transformation system. This modification, has increased our transfection efficiency by roughly 10-fold. We previously had been using a fluorescence-based double selection targeting method; however our studies using this failed to yield targeted clones. Analyses suggest that the fluorescence of single-copy transformed cells, as cells bearing targeted alleles should be, is too low to efficiently isolate, so only non-targeted multi-copy transfected cells are recovered by FACS. To surmount this problem, we switched to a strategy that is independent of fluorescent markers and will not exclude single-copy transformants. Cells are transfected with a vector that contains only the drug selection marker (neo) inserted into a non-disruptive region of the bovine tbp sequence to allow homologous gene targeting, and G418-resistant clones are being plated in 96-well dishes containing selective medium at densities that give 0.6 transfected cells per well. As such, most wells with cell growth will be clonal derivative of a single transfected founder, we will eliminate pre-selection for high-expressers (i.e., multi-copy transformants), and all progeny of that founder will be confined to a single well, thus precluding the previous complications due to unrestricted migration.

Impacts
Our goal is to measure how sequence identity parameters affect the efficiency of targeted mutagenesis in bovine cells. Were targeted mutagenesis to become tractable in cattle, it could both increase the value of existing cattle-based commodities and allow creation of countless more valuable cattle-based products. Thus, it could allow production of particularly disease resistant herds or herds exhibiting increased milk or beef production. It could also help create cattle lines custom fit to particular environments, for example, by altering their ability to use different feed sources, altering salt tolerance, or altering reproductive cycles.

Publications

  • TA Tucker, JA Kundert, AA Bondareva, and EE Schmidt (2005). Reproductive and neurological quaking(viable) phenotypes in a severe combined immune deficient mouse background. Immunogenetics, 57, 226-231.


Progress 01/01/04 to 12/31/04

Outputs
Our goal is to measure how critical it is to use isogeneic vectors for targeting mutations into bovine cells. Were targeted mutagenesis to become tractable in cattle, it could both increase the value of existing cattle-based commodities and allow creation of countless more valuable cattle-based products. Thus, it could allow production of particularly disease resistant herds or herds exhibiting increased milk or beef production. It could also help create cattle lines custom fit to particular environments, for example, by altering their ability to use different feed sources, altering salt tolerance, or altering reproductive cycles.

Impacts
Our goal is to measure how sequence identity parameters affect the efficiency of targeted mutagenesis in bovine cells. Were targeted mutagenesis to become tractable in cattle, it could both increase the value of existing cattle-based commodities and allow creation of countless more valuable cattle-based products. Thus, it could allow production of particularly disease resistant herds or herds exhibiting increased milk or beef production. It could also help create cattle lines custom fit to particular environments, for example, by altering their ability to use different feed sources, altering salt tolerance, or altering reproductive cycles.

Publications

  • Tucker, T.A., J.A. Kundert, A.A. Bondareva, and E.E. Schmidt (2005). Reproductive and neurological quakingviable phenotypes in a severe combined immune deficient mouse background. Immunogenetics, in press.


Progress 01/01/03 to 12/31/03

Outputs
Targeted mutagenesis can be used to create genetically modified animals; however, in species other than mice, there are very few reported successes (one sheep and one pig have been reported in peer reviewed papers) to date. The proposed research is aimed at increasing the efficiency of targeted mutagenesis in bovine cells, which could in turn be used to create animals by cloning. We produced bovine cell lines from a pure-bred breed of dairy cattle (American Holstein) and from an unrelated breed (free-range beef cattle from Montana). DNA from the Holstein cells has been used to produce vectors for targeted mutagenesis. Differences in targeting efficiency between the cell lines will be correlated to the number of DNA sequence differences between the two cell lines at the targeting site. We will then introduce mutations into the targeting vector and measure the effects of these on targeting efficiency in the two cell lines. As the first systematic study to analyze parameters affecting targeted mutagenesis in bovine cells, we have produced a line of bovine embryonic fibroblast cell (BEF) from a single 40 day-old bovine fetus that we harvested from a "pure-bred" American Holstein heifer inseminated with pure American Holstein semen. The rationale for this breed choice was to minimize heterozygosity in the resultant fetus. From the same fetus, we prepared a genomic DNA library in lambda phage. We expanded the BEF cell line to second passage, and froze several hundred vials of these early-passage cells in liquid nitrogen to provide an essentially permanent stock of BEFs that genetically match our genomic library perfectly. Characterization of the library indicate the primary library had over 10-fold coverage of the genome with an average insert size of over 22kb. We have screened this library and isolated 5 pure clones of the bovine tbp gene, which will form the target for our studies. We chose this gene as a representative paradigm largely because we have great experience in working with targeting this gene in mouse cells. Last year, we proposed that, since BEFs are highly migratory, they are poor colony formers, we would attempt to implement a rapid fluorescent marker/FACS-based method of identifying transfected clones. We have done this and it is working very well. Thus, a new vector design with both fluorescent and drug resistant markers is used for gene targeting. Several days after electroporation, fluorescent cells are isolated by FACS and plated at clonal densities in 96-well dishes. Conditions have been established to give only 0.66 transfected cells per well, so most colonies are clonal. In the next year, we will use this technology to isolate large numbers of transfected clones and use these to measure targeting efficiency.

Impacts
Our goal is to measure how critical it is to use isogeneic vectors for targeting mutations into bovine cells. Were targeted mutagenesis to become tractable in cattle, it could both increase the value of existing cattle-based commodities and allow creation of countless more valuable cattle-based products. Thus, it could allow production of particularly disease resistant herds or herds exhibiting increased milk or beef production. It could also help create cattle lines custom fit to particular environments, for example, by altering their ability to use different feed sources, altering salt tolerance, or altering reproductive cycles.

Publications

  • Schmidt, E.E. AA Bondareva, JR Radke, and MR Capecchi (2003). Fundamental cellular processes do not require vertebrate-specific sequences in the TATA-binding protein. J. Biol. Chem. 278; 6168-6174.
  • Bondareva, A.A., and E.E. Schmidt (2003). Early vertebrate evolution of the TATA-binding protein, TBP. Mol. Biol. Evol. 20; 1932-1939.