Source: FOREST PRODUCTS LABORATORY submitted to NRP
UNDERSTANDING WOOD ADHESIVE DURABILITY USING HMR COUPLING AGENT
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0190789
Grant No.
2001-35103-11191
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2001-02403
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Nov 1, 2001
Project End Date
Oct 31, 2004
Grant Year
2002
Program Code
[73.0]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
FOREST PRODUCTS LABORATORY
ONE GIFFORD PINCHOT DRIVE
MADISON,WI 53726
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Durability of wood adhesive bonds is a long-term problem of great importance to the wood composites industry. Bond durability problems can require the replacement of prematurely failing products and can impede the introduction of new products, such as wood-plastic hybrids. The Forest Products Laboratory has developed a coupling agent, hydroxymethyl resorcinol (HMR), that significantly improves the performance of many wood adhesive bonds. This is the most significant development in wood adhesion over the past decade, because improving the durability of composite wood products can lead to new products in the market place. Specific objectives of this study are to study the adhesion and chemical behavior of HMR coupling agent to better understand the mechanisms by which bond durability may be improved. The mechanism of HMR action will be investigated using complementary methods. Atomic force microscopy will be used to determine if HMR reinforces wood cells in the bondline. Solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance will be used to evaluate the molecular interaction of HMR with different wood components. Adhesive wettability studies will follow changes in HMR-treated wood and plastic surfaces. Bonding studies will determine the effect of specific formulations on bond strength and durability. This work affects adhesives for new engineered wood composites using nontraditional adhesives and preservative-treated wood. It may offer opportunities to improve adhesion to dense species like oak. The technique allows bonding to metal connectors used with wood beams to supplement or displace
Animal Health Component
80%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
20%
Applied
80%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
5110650200050%
8040650200050%
Goals / Objectives
Using the novolak-based version of hydroxymethylated resorcinol (HMR) coupling agent for wood, determine the importance of mechanical stabilization of wood cell walls to bond durability. Determine in what ways HMR molecularly interacts with major wood components and with epoxy adhesive. Determine the effects of the reaction time of HMR on wetting of both wood and vinyl ester resin surfaces. Determine the effects of HMR application variables on the mechanical properties of composites of wood bonded to reinforced vinyl ester resin. Compare the wood penetration of HMR relative to that of epoxy resin.
Project Methods
The effects of chemical modifications to change the stiffness of HMR, and thus its effect on bond durability, will be assessed by delamination tests. Solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance analysis will probe the molecular interactions of HMR with wood components and with epoxy adhesive. Contact angle analysis will be used to determine the effects of the reaction time of HMR on wetting of wood and of vinyl ester resin surfaces. Bond durability tests will quantify the effects of HMR application variables on the mechanical properties of composites of wood bonded to reinforced vinyl ester resin. Scanning electron microscopy with EDXA will be used to determine the relative wood penetration characteristics of HMR and of epoxy resin. Atomic force microscopy experiments will explore the time dependent changes that HMR imparts to wood surfaces.

Progress 11/01/01 to 10/31/04

Outputs
FPL: Substitution of resorcinol in HMR with progressively greater amounts of 2-methylresorcinol, to give lower crosslinking, decreased wood-epoxy bond durability. Thus, mechanical aspects of the primer are important. Storage of primed wood for long times or at elevated temperatures, to drive HMR's chemical reactions, had no effect on subsequent wood-epoxy bond durability. This appears to indicate that primer-epoxy chemical bonding is not a factor. Possibly, primer molecules at free, outer surfaces of the primer would be cured, with few active hydroxymethyl groups. Attempts to detect penetration of chlororesorcinol-tagged HMR into wood by electron diffraction have not been fruitful. Chromatography shows that 2-methyl resorcinol and 4-chlororesorcinol react at approximately the same rate as normal resorcinol. Time and money were unfortunately consumed by both a funding delay at the beginning, which forced intermittent hiring, and a several weeks of bonding problems caused by an unanticipated catalyst neutralization reaction. We did not cast films to assess relative stiffness differences of normal vs 2-methylresorcinol substituted HMR. VPI: Swelling and stress relaxation experiments suggest that HMR operates by altering the properties of the wood cell wall, reducing the initial swelling rate, but increasing the long-term equilibrium swelling. This suggests that crosslinking involving HMR inhibits polymer chain relaxations. Solid-state NMR results suggest that a relatively mobile population of wood polymers is affected, both in lignin and cellulose (the technique is not reliable for hemicellulose). Reactive methylol functionality remains up to 120 days after initial HMR treatment of wood, under very dry conditions. Preliminary NMR results show no evidence of epoxy resin chemically reacting with HMR-treated wood. Maine: Water uptake during 30-minute immersions of maple veneers was dramatically reduced by just 5- to 30-minute treatments in HMR. HMR treatment improves dimensional stability of wood compared to untreated samples after 24-hour immersion. Three-point bending of wood veneers showed that the stiffness of HMR-treated samples increased with treatment times, whereas those for water-soaked specimens decreased with soaking time. HMR was found to have a solubility parameter closer to that of lignin than to those of hemicellulose or cellulose. The stiffening effect of HMR in lignin is postulated to be due to antiplasticization, an uncommon effect that occurs in some glassy polymers. No AFM work was done, and reduced funding had eliminated most of it anyhow. Attempts to use vinyl ester resin as a thin layer adhesive in a bondline between wood substrates did not work, even with control samples: insufficient exotherm may be the problem. It was found that drying HMR-primed wood surfaces using infrared heat for 20 minutes to expedite subsequent bonding with epoxy adhesives gave at least equally durable bonds in water-soak tests compared to room-temperature drying requiring many hours.

Impacts
It was found that exterior durability of wood-adhesive bonds in exterior structural members seems to require dimensional stabilization of the wood surface by penetration and reinforcement of the wood cell substance. Manufacturers can now target this phenomenon to improve bonds to wood of many exterior or high moisture use structures. Production line bonding with epoxy (and likely other nonaqueous) adhesives is facilitated by using heat to dry the primed surface within minutes, without decreasing eventual bond durability.

Publications

  • Son J., and D.J. Gardner. 2004. Dimensional stability measurements of thin wood veneers using the Wilhelmy plate technique. Wood Fiber Sci. 36 (1):98-106.


Progress 11/01/01 to 10/31/02

Outputs
FPL: Substitution of progressively greater levels of 2-methylresorcinol for resorcinol in hydroxmethylated resorcinol primer is designed to lead to lower crosslinking densities. Such substitutions progressively decreased the ability of HMR primer to promote epoxy bonds to wood that resist delamination, as shown by stringent accelerated aging tests. Thus the crosslinked nature of the primer is an important aspect of action; that is, enhanced adhesive durability with the primer comes partly from its crosslinked nature, and not from a more linear polymeric structure. Three months of work were lost from unexpected effects of pH change during storage. VPI: Work was delayed for 7 months because of a hiring delay after funding was unexpectedly late. Swelling experiments measured by DMA have started. Swelling behavior of untreated yellow-poplar and most of the treated samples (HMR or individual components) follow the two-stage diffusion model proposed by Bagley and Long for absorption behavior of polymers. This seems to indicate that wood is following normal polymeric absorption behavior. Secondly, swelling history influences later swelling of samples. Thus, simple treatment of wood with HMR may influence later swelling partly because of simple exposure to water in the HMR, and caution must be used in interpreting results. Thirdly, the thermal history of the sample influences the swelling behavior of the samples. So, using thermal treatment to promote uniform cure of epoxy adhesives may affect the final swelling in itself. This provides another caution in interpreting results. Nuclear magnetic resonance experiments were delayed because of equipment factors but are now starting. U. Maine: The drying time of HMR-primed wood can reduced by changing from a schedule of overnight at room temperature to 20 minutes or less at 60 C, while the subsequent bonds of epoxy to wood were improved. This appears to indicate that an industrial process using HMR priming could be much more efficient, and therefore economic, than previously thought. Work on dynamic mechanical properties of HMR-treated wood has been progressing. It appears the overall time scale for the project (2 years) can still be adhered to, although some individual parts have been delayed.

Impacts
It seems that heating the HMR-primed wood can greatly accelerate its drying time before the wood can be bonded with epoxy resin. This would greatly speed operations such as making bonds between glass-reinforced tension laminations and glulam beams, which would improve the economics of production.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period