Source: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY submitted to
TRANSGENES IN CONTEXT: USING MICROBIAL ECOLOGY TO UNDERSTAND THE DYNAMICS OF ARTIFICIAL DNA CONSTRUCTS AT THE AGRICULTURAL INTERFACE
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
TERMINATED
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0190437
Grant No.
(N/A)
Project No.
CA-B*-ECO-6899-H
Proposal No.
(N/A)
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Program Code
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Oct 1, 2001
Project End Date
Sep 30, 2007
Grant Year
(N/A)
Project Director
Chapela, I. H.
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
(N/A)
BERKELEY,CA 94720
Performing Department
ECOSYSTEM SCIENCES
Non Technical Summary
(N/A)
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
75%
Applied
25%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1330850107034%
1350850106033%
2020850110333%
Goals / Objectives
Over 100 million acres of transgenic crops have been planted every year worldwide for the last 5 years. One of the consequences of transgenic crop release into the environment is the spread of the transgenic constructs into non-target organisms, including non-transgenic crops, crop relatives, other plants and potentially a wide-variety of other prokaryotic and eukaryotic organisms. The unintended presence of transgenic seed recently evidenced in corn in the American Mid-West can be attributed to such biopollution. So far, however, transgene monitoring has been focused on the commodity crops themselves and on the expression of the transgene through the expected DNA-encoded protein and their corresponding traits. Little research has been focused on non-target, non-crop biological species and populations, or on the intrinsic ecological properties of the transgenic DNA itself, independently of the traits it might encode at a specific time. This problem is particularly critical, given that most presumed environmental effects of introduced transgenic DNA should be expected to occur through non-target organisms and through unintended effects of the transgenic DNA, either due to epistatic genomic effects or because of the secondary expression of novel traits. This is an area where neither traditional molecular biology nor traditional ecology have proven suited to effectively apply concepts or methods to detect and follow the movement of transgenic DNA constructs. This proposal aims at using concepts of microbial ecology to provide a novel database and conceptual framework to study and understand the movement of transgenic DNA in the environment. Accordingly, the objectives of this proposal are: 1. To establish DNA-based methods to detect the presence of transgenic constructs in non-target organisms. 2. To establish methods to determine the genomic context in which these constructs are contained. 3. To establish the extent and dynamics of introgression of transgenic constructs into local fields and varieties of agricultural crops. 4. To establish the extent and dynamics of introgression of transgenic constructs in non-crop organisms, including plants and microbes. 5. To establish a conceptual framework to understand the dynamic change in abundance, distribution and effects of transgenic DNA in the wider context of the agricultural interface and the environment beyond.
Project Methods
This proposal takes advantage of the fact that practically all commerical varieties of transgenic crops deployed to date, independently of their host genome, contain DNA sequences in common, particularly those of vectors and promotors. These common transgenic sequences can be used as beacons not only to determine presence/absence data, but also to anchor a chromosome-walking effort to determine the genomic context of the transgenic insertion. Transgenes will be sought in a phylogenetic radiating pattern, from varieties of the crop plant, through wild relatives and out specifically into the microbial community (fungi and bacteria). DNA extraction, amplification through polymerase chain reaction (PCR), sequencing and establishment of genomic context through inverse PCR have all been tested in the PIs laboratory. We have found that a nested-PCR approach increases the sensitivity and reliability of our detection methods, and this approach will be expanded. Using these methods we have been already able to detect transgenes in cultivated relatives of industrial maize. Two mapping efforts will be undertaken from this initial detection stage. First, presence absence data for transgenic occurrence will be mapped at a geographical scale. Second, coarse genomic mapping will allow for the identification of the genomic context within which the detected transgene was found. Mapping efforts will be extended over a three year period in order to determine change in diversity and/or abundance in transgenic populations over time. These observations might enable some predictive power and modelling of transgenic distributions. The crop chosen for this study will be corn, given its predominance in the market, the large acreaged planted to transgenic lines, as well as its social and economic importance. As a baseline, corn samples will be systematically obtained for the 2001 harvest year from industrial and subsistence fields in California, the Mid-West and from Mesoamerica, the known region of diversification of this crop. Draft geographical and genomic maps will be elaborated establishing the extent of distribution of transgenic constructs in non-transgenic plants. The same sites and adjacent areas will be sampled directly for DNA, as well as for culturable microorganisms. The DNA and culture collection thus obtained will be screened using the same nested amplification approaches as for the plant samples.

Progress 10/01/01 to 09/30/07

Outputs
OUTPUTS: The reporting period includes a year of sabbatical work at the National Center for Biosafety in Norway. Prior approaches, which highlighted the specific removal of PCR inhibitors through protease treatment were discarded when we realized that this could not be utilized widely. Instead, a new approach was established, a non-specific, alkali-based pretreatment of individual particles from air samples which rendered both extraction and inhibition problems a moot point. Thus in Norway we succeeded in performing single-particle PCR amplifications which were enough to provide a clean and bright signal using standard and low-cost reagents. This method was further developed to the point where we now have a preliminary publication, through a patent, under discussion with the University of California's Office of Intellectual Property (IPIRA) and their Norwegian counterpart. Further elements of a possible device are now in draft and word description and will be submitted pending discussions on the patents. Meanwhile we continue to perform field sampling using standard air sampling methods across various transects. We consider this important to lay down baseline data for future mapping since the development of the method has taken such a long time. One graduate student successfully defended the concepts behind this effort in his preliminary exam, and another student was accepted in Berkeley to undertake the mapping and database mathematical aspects of the project. PARTICIPANTS: In addition to Ignacio Chapela, PI, the project included for this reporting period Dr. Terje Traavik, Director of the Center for Biosafety, Norway -who is also cited as co-inventor in a forthcoming patent application- and Ali B Tonak, graduate student at the Chapela lab and for a semester in Norway. TARGET AUDIENCES: An unexpected new "audience" can be identified in this reporting period, the audience of technology transfer and patent office specialists. This new group of readers comes in addition to the expected audience of farmers, city-managers, etc. as described before for this project. PROJECT MODIFICATIONS: We took a major new technical approach which allowed the non-specific, single-particle amplification of specific DNA sequences through PCR.

Impacts
A patent application is in discussion between the IPIRA office at the University of California and the Technology Transfer office in its Norwegian counterpart at the Norwegian Center for Biosafety. A PhD student successfully defended the concepts behind this effort in his preliminary exam, and another student was accepted in Berkeley to undertake the mapping and database mathematical aspects of the project.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 01/01/05 to 12/31/05

Outputs
In this period, the research laboratory went through major reconfiguration and reorganizing. Research was continued to establish an in-situ PCR protocol to enable the use of sequence-specific visualization of DNA on individual particles (spores, pollen). No publications to report.

Impacts
The expected impact continues to be highly promising. In contrast to current methods of identification, which require each sample to be processed separately in test-tubes, the protocols devised under this project will allow each individual particle to operate, in practice, as an individual test. This will be useful not only for transgenic and biosafety research, but also for other fields.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 01/01/04 to 12/31/04

Outputs
No progress to report for this period.

Impacts
This research should lead to a fast, comprehensive method for the direct detection of transgenic DNA in the environment. The level of detection, and the equipment being used should make it possible to process 2-4 orders of magnitude more individual genomes than it is possible to date. In addition, this method should allow for the detection of transgenic DNA by local individuals or communities, allowing for generalized, low cost, extensive monitoring urgently needed but not available today.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 01/01/02 to 12/31/02

Outputs
New primers were designed to allow for the fluorescence-detection of transgenic DNA in various microscopic particulates. A method was established to collect, fix and process particulates for visualization of fluroescent probe for detection. A first run was tested using the new COPAS particle fluorescence analyser. Conditions were established for the amplification of DNA within particles using polymerase chain reaction (PCR). A collection of particles from environmental samples was initiated to test age effect on the detection method. Relatively high background fluorescence was identified as a potential problem, although new tests using fluorochromes in a different spectral range promise to ameliorate this problem. In optimizing the direct amplification from particles, an in-vitro set of experiments identified a heat-stable, protease-sensitive, factor in pollen extracts that inhibits DNA polymerase activity in a dose-dependent fashion. We postulate that this factor represents a protein in these particles that could potentially preclude the possibility of amplification using PCR. New fixation and pre-incubation methods are being tested to eliminate this inhibition ifor the field-based assays

Impacts
This research should lead to a fast, comprehensive method for the direct detection of transgenic DNA in the environment. The level of detection, and the equipment being used should make it possible to process 2-4 orders of magnitude more individual genomes than it is possible to date. In addition, this method should allow for the detection of transgenic DNA by local individuals or communities, allowing for generalized, low cost, extensive monitoring urgently needed but not available today.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period