Source: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, RIVERSIDE submitted to NRP
DECONTAMINATION OF CHLOROACETANILIDE HERBICIDES WITH THIOSULFATE SALTS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0189390
Grant No.
2001-35102-10861
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2001-01109
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Oct 15, 2001
Project End Date
Oct 14, 2005
Grant Year
2001
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, RIVERSIDE
(N/A)
RIVERSIDE,CA 92521
Performing Department
ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES
Non Technical Summary
Acetanilide herbicides such as alachlor, metolachlor and acetochlor are among the most heavily used herbicides in the U.S. Because of their widespread use, these herbicides are a ubiquitous source of contamination of soil and water resources. Contamination of groundwater by these herbicides is of particular concern because these compounds are potentially carcinogenic and exposure to them may cause serious health problems. We discovered a novel reaction, in which chloroacetanilide herbicides are dechlorinated and detoxified by thiosulfate salts. Addition of ammonium- or sodium thiosulfate to herbicide-contaminated sand columns reduced herbicide leaching by up to 99%. Because common thiosulfate salts are fertilizers or otherwise inexpensive products, this finding has great promise for practical implementation in many contaminant management scenarios, such as for wastewater treatment, spill cleanup, container decontamination, and remediation of polluted aquifers. The proposed research will evaluate the feasibility and conditions of using thiosulfate salts to decontaminate acetanilide herbicide residues from soil, water and aquifers. This research has a great probability of success because the hypothesis is based on an innovative but sound scientific approach. Development of this application will provide an effective tool for preventing and remediating environmental contamination of a number of heavily used herbicides, which can contribute greatly to the long-term partnership between agricultural sustainability and environmental protection.
Animal Health Component
90%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
10%
Applied
90%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
13302102000100%
Knowledge Area
133 - Pollution Prevention and Mitigation;

Subject Of Investigation
0210 - Water resources;

Field Of Science
2000 - Chemistry;
Goals / Objectives
The overall objective is to develop feasible risk-mitigation strategies for preventing and remediating soil and groundwater contamination by acetanilide herbicides, thus improving groundwater quality and helping to sustain the productivity of U.S. agriculture by assuring the availability of effective pest management tools. The specific objectives are to: 1). Understand the environmental compatibility of the herbicide- thiosulfate reaction by determining the degradation pathways of the initial products in soil and aquifer materials, and evaluating the adsorption and toxicological properties of the initial and metabolic products. 2). Through kinetics experiments and model simulation, identify the controlling variables and processes in herbicide residue removal from soil and water by thiosulfate, and construct protocols that are feasible and effective for implementation. 3). Conduct experiments under controlled conditions to test the effectiveness and applicability of using thiosulfate salts for treating herbicide-containing wastewater and aquifer phases contaminated with trace levels of herbicides. 4). Conduct active technology transfer activities to disseminate research results to interested parties such as agrichemical manufacturers, commercial applicators and dealerships, policy regulators, and environmental industries, and solicit input and effort for further development and implementation of this risk-mitigation strategy.
Project Methods
To achieve the proposed objectives, we intend to conduct experiments in a systematic manner. Our project will consist of four integrated phases. We will first conduct laboratory experiments to evaluate the environmental compatibility of using thiosulfate salts to detoxify chloroacetanilide herbicides. This will involve investigation of the degradative pathways of the reaction products in soil, water and sediments, and assessment for toxicity and mutagenicity assessment of major intermediates. During the second phase, we will develop working conditions for applying the thiosulfate-based approach under several different scenarios. This will involve understanding the stability of thiosulfate in soil, and quantifying the interaction of thiosulfate concentration, herbicide concentration, and herbicide adsorption in the removal of herbicides from the environmental matrices. The conditions established from the second-phase study will be employed and further optimized through the controlled experiments scheduled for the third phase. We will consider three scenarios relevant to the treatment of wastewater containing herbicides, soil that is grossly contaminated as at spilled sites, and aquifer phases that are polluted with herbicides at trace levels. The experiments will be small in scale and simulated n nature, and they are intended as pilot experiments that may provide guidelines for expanded-scale or field studies in the future. During the last phase and throughout the project, we will conduct active outreach to engage chemical companies, regulators, applicators, dealerships and environmental firms to develop transferable technology packages. Research results will be disseminated to these interested parties via various approaches, and guidelines for using research results will be made available through publication, web-site posting, meeting presentation, and other channels.

Progress 10/15/01 to 10/14/05

Outputs
Termination Report: We have completed this project after receiving one year no-cost extension from USDA-CSREES. Chloroacetanilide herbicides, including alachlor, metolachlor, propachlor, and acetochlor, are among the most heavily used herbicides in the United States. The combined annual use of these herbicides has remained at >100 million lbs each year in the United States. This use pattern clearly suggests that chloroacetanilide herbicides are vitally important for the productivity of U.S. agriculture. However, because of their widespread use, these herbicides are a ubiquitous source of contamination of soil and water resources. We discovered a novel reaction, in which chloroacetanilide herbicides are dechlorinated by thiosulfate, yielding initial products of little biological activity. Because common thiosulfate salts are fertilizers or otherwise inexpensive products, this finding has great promise for practical implementation in many contaminant management scenarios. We proposed to investigate the feasibility and conditions of using thiosulfate salts to decontaminate acetanilide herbicide residues from soil, water and aquifers, and to identify other susceptible contaminants or other nucleophiles.We have completed experiments to understand the kinetics of herbicide-thiosulfate reaction and to determine the fate of the initial reaction products. We further discovered that even more rapid dechlorination reaction occurs between chloroacetanilide herbicides and polysulfides, and the rate of reaction was about two orders of magnitude faster than that for thiosulfate under comparable conditions. We have completed experiments in aqueous phase to understand the kinetics of this reaction, and soil incubation experiments to evaluate the reaction kinetics in soil. The results show that polysulfides greatly enhanced the dissipation of these herbicides in soil, and the degree of enhancement was affected by the pesticide adsorption to the solid phase. We have also completed column leaching experiments to test the use of approach for removing pesticide residues present in soil. We are in the process of compiling data and preparing manuscripts for publication.

Impacts
Impact: Using thiosulfate salts to detoxify chloroacetanilide herbicides is a novel approach for environmental decontamination. There can be many scenarios to use this reaction. For example, this approach can be used for decontaminating spill sites, disposing wastes or waste water, and cleaning containers or equipment. The characteristics of this reaction also imply that many other halogenated environmental contaminants may be susceptible to this reaction. Our further finding that even faster reaction can occur with polysulfides suggests that using strong nucleophiles to dehalogenated certain organic contaminants may have general significance. Therefore, this line of research may lead to the development of inexpensive and safe remediation methods of general application.

Publications

  • Gan, J., Q. Wang, S.R. Yates, W.C. Koskinen, and W.A. Jury. 2002. Dechlorination of chloroacetanilide herbicides by thiosulfate salts. Proceedings of National Academy of Sciences (USA) 99: 5189-5194. Gan, J., P.C. Zhu, S.D. Aust, and A.T. Lemley. 2003. Pesticide Decontamination and Detoxification. ACS Symposium Series 863. ACS, Washington, DC. 266 p.
  • Gan, J., and S. Bondarenko. 2003. Detoxification of some halogenated pesticides by thiosulfate salts. In Gan J. et al. (Eds) Pesticide Decontamination and Detoxification. ACS Symposium Series 863. ACS, Washington, DC. pp. 51-65.
  • Bondarenko, S., and J. Gan. 2005. Dehalogenation of halogenated fumigants by polysulfide salts. Journal of Agricultural & Food Chemistry (submitted


Progress 01/01/04 to 12/31/04

Outputs
We have requested and received one year no-cost extension on this project. Chloroacetanilide herbicides, including alachlor, metolachlor, propachlor, and acetochlor, are among the most heavily used herbicides in the United States. The combined annual use of these herbicides has remained at >100 million lbs each year in the United States. This use pattern clearly suggests that chloroacetanilide herbicides are vitally important for the productivity of U.S. agriculture. Because of their widespread use, these herbicides are a ubiquitous source of contamination of soil and water resources. We discovered a novel reaction, in which chloroacetanilide herbicides are dechlorinated by thiosulfate, yielding initial products of little biological activity. Because common thiosulfate salts are fertilizers or otherwise inexpensive products, this finding has great promise for practical implementation in many contaminant management scenarios. We proposed to investigate the feasibility and conditions of using thiosulfate salts to decontaminate acetanilide herbicide residues from soil, water and aquifers, and to identify other susceptible contaminants or other nucleophiles. We have completed experiments to understand the kinetics of herbicide-thiosulfate reaction and to determine the fate of the initial reaction products. We further discovered that even more rapid dechlorination reaction occurs between chloroacetanilide herbicides and polysulfides, and the rate of reaction was about two orders of magnitude faster that for thiosulfate under comparable conditions. We have completed experiments in aqueous phase to understand the kinetics of this reaction, and incubation experiments to evaluate the reaction kinetics in soil. The results show that polysulfides greatly enhanced the dissipation of these herbicides in soil, and the degree of enhancement was affected by the pesticide's adsorption to the solid phase. We are currently conducting column leaching experiments to test the use of approach for removing pesticide residues present in soil. These experiments will provide information on the feasibility of use on remediation of contaminated soil sites.

Impacts
Using thiosulfate salts to detoxify chloroacetanilide herbicides is a novel approach for environmental decontamination. There can be many scenarios to use this reaction. For example, this approach can be used for decontaminating spill sites, disposing wastes or waste water, and cleaning containers or equipment. The characteristics of this reaction also imply that many other halogenated environmental contaminants may be susceptible to this reaction. Our further finding that even faster reaction can occur with polysulfides suggests that using strong nucleophiles to dehalogenated certain organic contaminants may have general significance. Therefore, this line of research may lead to the development of inexpensive and safe remediation methods of general application.

Publications

  • Yang, W.C., J. Gan, S. Bondarenko, and W.P. Liu. 2004. Nucleophilic radical substitution reaction of triazine herbicides with polysulfides. Journal of Agricultural & Food Chemistry 54, 7051-7055.


Progress 01/01/03 to 12/31/03

Outputs
Chloroacetanilide herbicides, including alachlor, metolachlor, propachlor, and acetochlor, are among the most heavily used herbicides in the United States. The combined annual use of these herbicides has remained at >100 million lbs each year in the United States. This use pattern clearly suggests that chloroacetanilide herbicides are vitally important for the productivity of U.S. agriculture. Because of their widespread use, these herbicides are a ubiquitous source of contamination of soil and water resources. We discovered a novel reaction, in which chloroacetanilide herbicides are dechlorinated by thiosulfate, yielding initial products of little biological activity. Because common thiosulfate salts are fertilizers or otherwise inexpensive products, this finding has great promise for practical implementation in many contaminant management scenarios. We proposed to investigate the feasibility and conditions of using thiosulfate salts to decontaminate acetanilide herbicide residues from soil, water and aquifers, and to identify other susceptible contaminants or other nucleophiles. We have completed experiments to understand the kinetics of herbicide-thiosulfate reaction and to determine the fate of the initial reaction products. The reaction rate between alachlor, acetochlor, propachlor, and metolachlor with thiosulfate was measured as a function of the initial thiosulfate concentration. To understand the fate of the reaction products, in a separate study, 14C-labelled metolachlor was reacted with thiosulfate and then used to treat soil samples. The treated soils were incubated at the ambient temperature, and evolution of 14CO2 was collected and monitored. This analysis will show the mineralization of thiosulfate-metolachlor product in soil, and formation of intermediates. We further discovered that very fast reaction also occurs between chloroacetanilide herbicides and polysulfides, and the rate of reaction was about two orders of magnitude faster that for thiosulfate. We have completed experiments in aqueous phase to understand the kinetics of this reaction, and will further design experiments to evaluate the reaction in soil. We anticipate that there could be wide applications of this reaction for pollution prevention and remediation of point source contamination.

Impacts
Using thiosulfate salts to detoxify chloroacetanilide herbicides is a novel approach for environmental decontamination. There can be many scenarios to use this reaction. For example, this approach can be used for decontaminating spill sites, disposing wastes or waste water, and cleaning containers or equipment. The characteristics of this reaction also imply that many other halogenated environmental contaminants may be susceptible to this reaction. Our further finding that even faster reaction can occur with polysulfides suggests that using strong nucleophiles to dehalogenated certain organic contaminants may have general significance. Therefore, this line of research may lead to the development of inexpensive and safe remediation methods of general application.

Publications

  • Gan, J., Q. Wang, S.R. Yates, W.C. Koskinen, and W.A. Jury. Dechlorination of chloroacetanilide herbicides by thiosulfate salts. Proceedings of National Academy of Sciences (USA) 99: 5189-5194, 2002. Gan, J., P.C. Zhu, S.D. Aust, and A.T. Lemley. 2003. Pesticide Decontamination and Detoxification. ACS Symposium Series 863. ACS, Washington, DC. 266 p.
  • Gan, J., and S. Bondarenko. 2003. Detoxification of some halogenated pesticides by thiosulfate salts. In Gan J. et al. (Eds) Pesticide Decontamination and Detoxification. ACS Symposium Series 863. ACS, Washington, DC. pp. 51-65.


Progress 01/01/02 to 12/31/02

Outputs
Chloroacetanilide herbicides, including alachlor, metolachlor, propachlor, and acetochlor, are among the most heavily used herbicides in the United States. The combined annual use of these herbicides has remained at greater than100 million lbs each year in the United States. This use pattern clearly suggests that chloroacetanilide herbicides are vitally important for the productivity of U.S. agriculture. Because of their widespread use, these herbicides are a ubiquitous source of contamination of soil and water resources. We discovered a novel reaction, in which chloroacetanilide herbicides are dechlorinated by thiosulfate, yielding initial products of little biological activity. Because common thiosulfate salts are fertilizers or otherwise inexpensive products, this finding has great promise for practical implementation in many contaminant management scenarios. We started to evaluate the feasibility and conditions of using thiosulfate salts to decontaminate acetanilide herbicide residues from soil, water and aquifers, and to identify other susceptible contaminants or other even stronger nucleophiles. We have carried out studies to understand the kinetics of herbicide-thiosulfate reaction and to determine the fate of the initial reaction products. The reaction rate between alachlor, acetochlor, propachlor, and metolachlor with thiosulfate was measured as a function of the initial thiosulfate concentration and temperature. Information on temperature independence is critical for understanding the mechanism of this reaction. In another experiment, carbon 14-labelled metolachlor was reacted with thiosulfate and then used to treat soil samples. The treated soils were incubated at the ambient temperature, and evolution of carbon 14 of carbon dioxide was collected. This analysis will show the mineralization of thiosulfate-metolachlor product in soil, and formation of intermediates. In our recent study, we discovered that very fast reaction also occurs between chloroacetanilide herbicides and polysulfides, and the rate of reaction was two orders of magnitude as rapid as with thiosulfate under comparable conditions. We are currently conducting kinetics experiments to quantitatively describe this reaction, and to understand the mechanisms of this reaction. We further found that the reaction with polysulfides also happen with a number of chlorinated hydrocarbons that are typically resistant to chemical or microbial transformations in the environment. We anticipate that there could be wide applications of this reaction for pollution prevention and remediation of point source contamination.

Impacts
Using thiosulfate salts to detoxify chloroacetanilide herbicides is a novel approach for environmental decontamination. There can be many scenarios to exploit this reaction. For example, this approach can be used for decontaminating spill sites, disposing wastes or waste water, and cleaning containers or equipment. The characteristics of this reaction also imply that many other halogenated environmental contaminants may be susceptible to this reaction. Our further finding that even faster reaction can occur with polysulfides suggests that using strong nucleophiles to dehalogenated certain organic contaminants may have s=general significance. Therefore, this line of research may lead to the development of inexpensive and safe remediation methods of general application.

Publications

  • Gan, J., Q. Wang, S.R. Yates, W.C. Koskinen, and W.A. Jury. Dechlorination of chloroacetanilide herbicides by thiosulfate salts. Proceedings of National Academy of Sciences (USA) 99: 5189-5194, 2002


Progress 01/01/01 to 12/31/01

Outputs
Chloroacetanilide herbicides, including alachlor, metolachlor, propachlor, and acetochlor, are among the most heavily used herbicides in the United States. The combined annual use of these herbicides has remained at greater than 100 million lbs each year in the United States. This use pattern clearly suggests that chloroacetanilide herbicides are vitally important for the productivity of U.S. agriculture. Because of their widespread use, these herbicides are a ubiquitous source of contamination of soil and water resources. We discovered a novel reaction, in which chloroacetanilide herbicides are dechlorinated by thiosulfate, yielding initial products of little biological activity. Because common thiosulfate salts are fertilizers or otherwise inexpensive products, this finding has great promise for practical implementation in many contaminant management scenarios. In this project, we will evaluate the feasibility and conditions of using thiosulfate salts to decontaminate acetanilide herbicide residues from soil, water and aquifers. We are currently carrying out experiments to understand the kinetics of herbicide-thiosulfate reaction and to determine the fate of the initial reaction products. In one on-going experiment, reaction rates between alachlor, acetochlor, propachlor, and metolachlor with thiosulfate are measured as a function of temperature. Information on temperature independence is critical for understanding the mechanism of this reaction. In another on-going experiment, 14C-labelled metolachlor was reacted with thiosulfate and then used to treat soil samples. The treated soils are being incubated at the ambient temperature, and evolution of 14CO2 is collected. This analysis will show the mineralization of thiosulfate-metolachlor product in soil, and formation of intermediates. Studies on reaction between these herbicides with glutathione and thiosulfate with other halogenated compounds are being planned for this year.

Impacts
Using thiosulfate salts to detoxify chloroacetanilide herbicides is a novel approach for environmental decontamination. There can be many scenarios to exploit this reaction. For example, this approach can be used for decontaminating spill sites, disposing wastes or waste water, and cleaning containers or equipment. The characteristics of this reaction also imply that many other halogenated environmental contaminants may be susceptible to this reaction. Therefore, this line of research may lead to the development of an inexpensive and safe remediation method of general application.

Publications

  • Gan, Q. Wang, S.R. Yates, W.C. Koskinen, and W.A. Jury. 2002. Dechlorination of chloroacetanilide herbicides by thiosulfate salts. Submitted to Proc. National Academy of Science (USA).