Source: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY submitted to NRP
GENETIC COMPONENTS REQUIRED FOR PARAMUTATION AT THE MAIZE PL LOCUS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
0189057
Grant No.
2001-35301-10641
Cumulative Award Amt.
(N/A)
Proposal No.
2001-01595
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2001
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2004
Grant Year
2001
Program Code
[(N/A)]- (N/A)
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY
(N/A)
BERKELEY,CA 94720
Performing Department
PLANT BIOLOGY
Non Technical Summary
This project will define the molecular mechanism(s) responsible for a type of heritable gene inactivation called paramutation. Inactivation, or "silencing," mechanisms directly impact modern agriculture by limiting the effectiveness of genetic modifications using recombinant DNA (transgene technology) and by potentially playing a role in the production of high yielding hybrids through conventional breeding programs. Certain examples of silenced transgene DNA can become reactivated in several of our corn lines defective in paramutation. Mutations in at least eight different components, encoded by required to maintain repression (rmr) genes, can disrupt the paramutation process occurring at the purple plant1 (pl1) gene. The pl1 gene directly regulates the production of purple anthocyanin plant pigments and thus silencing of pl1 is manifest as visible losses of plant color. Using standard molecular cloning techniques we will physically isolate and analyze the rmr2 and rmr6 genes to identify the proteins they encode. We will also use genetic and molecular genetic techniques to test a hypothesized role for RNA transcripts produced from the pl1 gene in pl1 paramutation. Finally, we will examine the broader roles of RMR functions in maintaining the inactivation of mobile genetic elements ("jumping genes") throughout the corn genome. A detailed understanding of the paramutation mechanism, how is it triggered, and what mediates this process, should lead to practical solutions and novel strategies for future plant improvement programs.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
100%
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
2011510108040%
2011510104060%
Goals / Objectives
This research addresses epigenetic mechanisms of gene silencing that cause heritable changes in gene regulation. Mutational analyses have identified at least eight genetic components required for one such gene-silencing mechanism in Zea mays. Initial analyses indicate that these genetic components are broadly used for genetic repression required for proper growth, development, and homeostasis. The objectives of this project are to clarify the role of post-transcriptional mechanisms in this type of gene-silencing, define the involvement of these silencing mechanisms on the regulation of Maize transposable element, proceed with molecular cloning of two genes that are required for this heritable gene-silencing, and genetically map five other genes identified by mutations.
Project Methods
Our mutational analyses have identified at least eight genetic loci (required to maintain repression 1, 2, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11, and mediator of paramutation 1) whose functions are required to maintain repressed gene activity following an initial gene-silencing event at the maize purple plant 1 (pl1) locus. The RMR1 function(s) appears to mediate a post-transcriptional regulatory event. We will use a combination of mutational-analyses, standard genetics, genetic mosaic analysis, RNase-protection and nuclease-sensitivity assays to test several predictions of this hypothesized post-transcriptional control. Using mutable derivative alleles, we will proceed with molecular cloning of the rmr2 and rmr6 genes using molecular and phenotypic co-segregation analysis. We will also concurrently pursue candidate gene approaches for molecular cloning. A combination of genetic crosses, molecular genotyping and phenotypic analyses will be used to test the effects of recessive rmr mutations on the transposition activity of four distinct Maize transposable element systems. As a prelude to future cloning efforts, the remaining rmr loci will be genetically mapped using a combination of cytogenetic and molecular genetic techniques.

Progress 07/01/01 to 06/30/04

Outputs
The goal of this multi-award project was to identify genetic components required for an unusual plant genetic mechanism, known as paramutation, causing heritable changes in gene regulation. A model system affecting pigment production was identified in maize operating on a specific allele of the purple plant 1 locus (pl1) and a half-saturation mutational screen was conducted to identify relevant genes encoding components required for paramutation. Nine distinct required to maintain repression (rmr) genes were identified by mutational analysis and breeding stocks were created to understand their specific functions at the pl1 locus and, in a broader context, their roles in genome-wide regulation. Potential commercial importance of these materials in relation to amelioration of transgene silencing was disclosed and is currently under review in the US Patent filing: 2001 09/972,805 Genetic Functions Required for Gene Silencing in Maize. Chandler, V.L., Hollick, J.B., Dorweiler, J.E., Lisch, D., Kubo, K. and C. Carey. Molecular expression studies of pl1 transcriptional regulation in rmr mutant plants led to a working model to explain the paramutation mechanism operating at pl1. Tests of this model highlight important differences with seemingly similar mechanisms in other eukaryotes. We used mutational analysis, genetic segregation, pl1 RNA measurements, and genetic mosaic analysis to test a post-transcriptional component of pl1 paramutation. Specific mutant pl1 alleles, selected for pigment defects, were found to be deficient in paramutational properties thus genetically defining specific DNA sequences involved in the process. These materials formed the basis of a project currently funded by NSF to functionally identify these DNA sequences. Mosaic analysis showed that paramutation is a progressive process occurring throughout plant development and also reveals the process is clonal in nature without systemic spread of the paramutation behavior. Molecular and genetic tests further identified additional genomic targets of Rmr action including specific transposons families and developmental regulators thus providing additional experimental systems for future study. As further progess in understanding the paramutation mechanism requires identifying the molecular nature of rmr genes, we employed high-throughput technologies to identify rmr2 and rmr6 candidate genes. Based on highly refined genetic map position and subsequent comparisons with NSF-funded maize genomics resources, we identified a gene encoding a putative histone methyltransferase enzyme which could be involved in chromatin-level changes associated with the paramutation mechanism. Consistent with the behavior of these proteins, we found diagnostic patterns of cytosine methylation altered in rmr2 mutant plants. We also refined the map position of rmr6 and found organization of this region to be highly conserved with that of the sequenced rice genome. Based on these comparisons, there are several likely candidate genes to consider. Thus we made significant strides towards identifying the molecular nature of the paramutation process through candidate identification of at least one rmr gene.

Impacts
Our research progress suggests that the genesis and maintenance of heritable epigenetic variation in plants can be mediated by RNA interactions that affect the heritable transcriptional regulatory status of affected genes. Although key aspects of this mechanism are still unknown, it is expected that a molecular understanding of this RNA-based mechanism will lead to improvements in transgene vector designs and molecular screening techniques for transgenic approaches to crop improvement. Similarly, novel approaches for targeting heritable epigenetic silencing of specific loci may be developed as tools for studying gene structure and function. Further, manipulation of RMR functions through transgenic or traditional breeding may allow reliable control of traits governed by genetic modifications.

Publications

  • Hollick, J.B. (2003) Paramutation in plants, in Encyclopedia of Life Sciences, Macmillan Reference Ltd., London.
  • Hollick, J.B. and Chandler, V.L. 2001 Genetic factors required to maintain repression of a paramutagenic maize pl1 allele. Genetics 157: 369-378.
  • Dorweiler, J.D., Carey, C.C., Kubo, K.M., Hollick, J.B., Kermicle, J., Chandler, V.L. 2000 Mediator of paramutation 1 (mop1) is required for the establishment and maintenance of paramutation at multiple maize loci. The Plant Cell 12 (11): 2101-2118.
  • Hollick, J.B., Patterson, G.P., Asmundsson, I.M., Chandler, V.L. 2000 Paramutation alters regulatory control of the maize pl locus. Genetics 154: 1827-1838.
  • Hollick, J.B. and Chandler, V.L. 1998 Epigenetic allelic states of a transcriptional regulatory locus exhibit overdominant gene action. Genetics 150: 891-897.


Progress 01/01/03 to 12/31/03

Outputs
Our working model for pl1 paramutation remains intact, yet results from the prior year have served to highlight important differences with seemingly similar mechanisms in other eukaryotic organisms. We used mutational analysis, genetic segregation, pl1 RNA measurements, and a genetic mosaic analysis to test a post-transcriptional component of pl1 paramutation. Specific mutant pl1 alleles, selected for pigment defects, were found to be deficient in paramutational properties thus genetically defining specific DNA sequences involved in the process. The fact that subsequent molecular analyses indicate pl1 RNA is still produced at low levels in these defective alleles modifies our current working hypothesis concerning the functional role of pl1 RNAs in this process. A completed genetic mosaic analysis shows that paramutation is a progressive process occurring throughout plant development. This analysis also reveals that the process is clonal in nature without any systemic spread of the silencing behavior. We also employed high-throughput technologies to identify candidate genes for both rmr2 and rmr6. Based on a highly refined genetic map position and subsequent comparisons with NSF-funded maize genomics resources, we have focused our attention to a gene encoding a putative histone methyltransferase enzyme which could be involved in chromatin-level changes associated with the paramutation mechanism. DNA sequence analysis of our rmr2 mutant alleles will serve to confirm or potentially discount this candidate gene assignment. Consistent with the behavior of these proteins, we found diagnostic patterns of cytosine methylation altered in rmr2 mutant plants. Tests are now being formulated to functionally assess this assignment. We also refined the map position of rmr6 and found the organization of this region to be highly conserved with that of the sequenced rice genome. Based on these comparisons, there are several candidate genes currently under consideration. Thus we have made significant strides towards identifying the molecular nature of the paramutation process through candidate identification of at least one rmr gene. Previous analyses indicating rmr-based effect on Mutator transposons motivated our experiments to test whether or not the movement of maize transposons, like Activator (Ac), were affected. We completed stock constructions and phenotypic analyses showing that transpositions of Ac from a reporter locus were unaffected by RMR functions. These data indicate that RMR functions are not generally involved in specifying transposon regulation per se. We also made progress in genetically mapping other rmr loci. We positioned rmr7 to the short arm of chromosome 2, rmr1 to the long arm of chromosome 9, and rmr11 to about a 20% region of the genome not covered by our series of BA translocation stocks. With these crude positions, we can now employ high-throughput mapping to help identify candidate genes.

Impacts
Our research progress suggests that the genesis and maintenance of heritable epigenetic variation in plants can be mediated by RNA interactions that affect the heritable transcriptional regulatory status of affected genes. Although key aspects of this mechanism are still unknown, it is expected that a molecular understanding of this RNA-based mechanism will lead to improvements in transgene vector designs and molecular screening techniques for transgenic approaches to crop improvement. Similarly, novel approaches for targeting heritable epigenetic silencing of specific loci may be developed as tools for studying gene structure and function. Further, manipulation of RMR functions through transgenic or traditional breeding may allow reliable control of traits governed by genetic modifications.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 01/01/02 to 12/31/02

Outputs
We are investigating the regulation of color production in maize to understand chromosome-based gene control mechanisms in higher plants. Visual pigment levels are a simple indicator of quantitative gene expression from the purple plant 1 (pl1) locus. One particular form of the pl1 gene is subject to epigenetic switching from high expression states (lots of pigment) to low expression states (very little pigment). The low expression state is very stable and invariably causes a highly expressed partner to switch to the low expression form. This unusual type of gene silencing is known as "paramutation." During the initial phase of this project, we identified 8 novel genetic loci whose functions are required to maintain repression of the particular pl1 gene; they are responsible for maintaining the low expression state. We also had hints that RNA transcripts from the pl1 gene were needed to cause paramutation. This gene silencing mechanism appears to be of broad significance to proper genome function. Mutations in various RMR components lead to molecular changes at transposable elements and cause developmental abnormalities. The goals of the current project are to investigate the potential role of an RNA-based mechanism in mediating paramutation, proceed with molecular cloning of the rmr2 and rmr6 genes, assess the role of RMR1, RMR2, and RMR6 functions on the regulation of various maize transposons, and to genetically map new rmr loci. We determined that pl1 RNAs, but not functional PL protein, are required to establish paramutation silencing. Mutant analyses indicate that both transcriptional and post-transcriptional mechanisms are need to effect heritable gene silencing. We are currently using molecular tests to decipher the difference between an inducing pl1 RNA versus a normal, non-inducing, pl1 RNA. Molecular cloning of the rmr6 gene is progressing by two strategies; transposon-based co-segregation analyses and position-based candidate gene approach. We have two candidate genes identified from a map-based cloning strategy for rmr2. Stock constructions have been completed for the tests of RMR functions in the regulation of two maize transposons and results will be known by next month. As a prelude to eventual molecular cloning, we have mapped two new rmr loci using both cytogenetic tools and standard genetic linkage analyses. Excellent progress has been made on all specific aims of this project during the last year. Molecular identification of the rmr6 and rmr2 gene products is currently our top priority.

Impacts
Progress on this project suggests that the genesis and maintenance of heritable epigenetic variation in plants can be mediated by RNA interactions that affect the heritable transcriptional regulatory status of affected genes. Although key aspects of this mechanism are still unknown, it is expected that a molecular understanding of this RNA-based mechanism will lead to improvements in transgene vector designs and molecular screening techniques for transgenic approaches to crop improvement. Similarly, novel approaches for targeting heritable epigenetic silencing of specific loci may be developed as tools for studying gene structure and function.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period


Progress 01/01/01 to 12/31/01

Outputs
We are beginning to clarify the role of a post-transcriptional regulation in a gene-silencing mechanism operating at the Maize pl1 locus. Research completed during the initial phase of this project continues to support the hypothesized role of pl1 RNA as a mediator of trans-silencing interactions occurring at pl1. This evidence is derived from a combination of genetic and molecular expression experiments. Standard genetic crosses with specific cytogenetically-defined chromosomes demonstrate that certain derivative alleles of the pl1 locus displaying a "loss-of-function" phenotype fail to cause trans-silencing of specific pl1 alleles. Measurement of pl1 RNA using RNase-protection assays indicate that all derivative pl1 alleles of this type fail to produce full-length pl1 RNA transcripts, thus implicating a functional role for pl1 RNA in the trans-silencing mechanism. This evidence complements previous findings in which derivative pl1 alleles presumed to make non-functional PL proteins still retain the ability to cause trans-silencing of specific pl1 alleles. We have made progress towards understanding the role of this gene-silencing mechanism in the control of Maize transposable elements by advancing stock constructions for specific genetic tests of the requirement for RMR functions for transposition behaviors. We have also made progress towards identifying the molecular nature of several genetically-defined components required for this type of gene-silencing. The genetic map positions of the rmr2, rmr6, and rmr7 loci have now been identified and refined using special cytogenetic mapping tools and ongoing genetic linkage studies. Candidate gene approaches for molecular cloning are routinely being evaluated as mapping information from NSF-funded projects continues to be deposited in the public domain. In a complementary approach, we are currently pursuing "transposon-tagging" methodologies using mutable alleles of rmr6 and rmr2. We have generated segregating populations and collected tissues needed for the type of standard co-segregation analyses used to molecularly clone Maize genes.

Impacts
Initial progress on this project suggests that the genesis and maintenance of heritable epigenetic variation in plants can be mediated by RNA interactions that affect the heritable transcriptional regulatory status of affected genes. Although key aspects of this mechanism are still unknown, it is expected that a molecular understanding of this RNA-based mechanism will lead to improvements in transgene vector designs and molecular screening techniques for transgenic approaches to crop improvement. Similarly, novel approaches for targeting heritable epigenetic silencing of specific loci may be developed as tools for studying gene structure and function.

Publications

  • No publications reported this period