Source: CORNELL UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
ACTIVATION AND SUPPRESSION OF A BROAD-SPECTRUM NLR: TOWARD MECHANISM-INFORMED BIOENGINEERING
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1032574
Grant No.
2024-67011-42965
Cumulative Award Amt.
$180,000.00
Proposal No.
2023-11529
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Aug 15, 2024
Project End Date
Aug 14, 2027
Grant Year
2024
Program Code
[A7101]- AFRI Predoctoral Fellowships
Recipient Organization
CORNELL UNIVERSITY
(N/A)
ITHACA,NY 14853
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Rice is a staple for ~half of the world's population and is an important contributor to the U.S. economy. Bacterial leaf streak (BLS), caused by the bacteriumXanthomonas oryzaepv. oryzicola (Xoc), is a threat to rice production in most rice-growing regions of the world. Xoc has not yet been found in the U.S.and isa federal select agent or considered to be a threat to rice health in the U.S. Xoc, like most other bacteria in the same genus, carry proteins called transcription activator-like effectors (TALEs) that they inject into rice cells. TALEs can travel to the rice nucleus and activate rice genes beneficial for the bacteria. However, rice is not defenseless against TALE-carrying Xoc. A U.S. rice variety, Carolina Gold Select, carries an immune receptor called Xo1 that detects TALEs injected into rice cells and launches a defense response. If Xo1 is present in rice, it can stop the pathogen from causing BLS. Even more importantly, Xo1 can detect many types of TALEs, making it a promising source of broad-spectrum resistance against many types of Xoc strains, but also other Xanthomonas pathogens of crop plants. Interestingly, there are some TALEs from different species of Xanthomonas that evade detection by Xo1. Furthermore, a subset of Xoc strains have evolved a new type of shortened TALE (truncTALE) that, when injected into the rice cell, completely shuts down Xo1's ability to detect TALEs and defend against Xoc. Researchers don't yet know how Xo1 detects some but not all TALEs to trigger immunity, or how truncTALEs inhibit Xo1 to shut down immunity and facilitate disease. This project aims to uncover what is occurring between these proteins. Findings from this project will support the broader, future goal of engineering Xo1 to detect an even wider variety of TALEs from other agriculturally relevant Xanthomonas pathogens or to resist defense suppression by truncTALEs.To investigate how Xo1 detects TALEs and truncTALEs inhibit Xo1, we would like to know what components of the TALEs and truncTALEs are required for their respective activities. I will first perturb predicted regions of importance or swap regions between TALEs and truncTALEs. Xoc carrying each of these mutant proteins will be inoculated onto Carolina Gold Select rice to measure the level of disease or resistance. I will take a similar approach of perturbing predicted important regions of Xo1 and seeing whether those mutations impact Xo1's ability to detect TALEs or be inhibited by truncTALEs. In plants, I will also identify how Xo1 interacts with TALEs and truncTALEs. By identifying parts of TALE, truncTALE, and Xo1 proteins that are important for disease or immunity, and better understanding how each component might interact with each other, we can shed light on how Xo1 operates. Not only will these findings illuminate an uncharacterized immune receptor mechanism, but it will also allow us to conceptualize how we might engineer Xo1 for enhanced disease resistance against Xoc and other Xanthomonas pathogens.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
100%
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
21215301040100%
Knowledge Area
212 - Pathogens and Nematodes Affecting Plants;

Subject Of Investigation
1530 - Rice;

Field Of Science
1040 - Molecular biology;
Goals / Objectives
Preface: Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzicola (Xoc) causes bacterial leaf streak of rice. Xo1 is a rice immune receptor that confers resistance against Xoc. TALEs are effectors of Xoc that trigger Xo1 immunity. TruncTALEs are truncated variants of TALEs that inhibit Xo1 immunity.Goal [1]: to identify how Xo1 detects or is inhibited by pathogen effectors.- Objective [1.1]: Identify TALE and truncTALE regions required foractivation and inhibition of Xo1-mediated immunity.- Objective [1.2]: Determine whether TALEs interact with Xo1 and truncTALEs disrupt this interaction.- Objective [1.3]: Determine whether nuclear localization of TALEs and truncTALEs is required for Xo1 induction and inhibition.- Objective [1.4]: Determine whether TALE DNA-binding is required for Xo1 immunity.- Objective [1.5]: Determine importance of Xo1 regions in immunity.- Objective [1.6]: Determine importance of Xo1 nuclear localization on immunity.- Objective [1.7]: Collect disease specimens and isolate Xoc strains. Pathotype collected strains.Goal [2]: to support mentored research, collaboration, and professional development experiences to position the PD for a career in plant pathology.- Objective [2.1]: mentor REU students and undergraduate research assistants- Objective [2.2]: work with collaborators on structural characterization of the rice immune receptor and/or the pathogen effectors via cryo-EM- Objective [2.3]: present at conferences, publish manuscripts, and maintain collaborations
Project Methods
Methods:[1] test ability ofTALEs and theirvariants to trigger or inhibit Xo1- synthesize TALE variants with standard cloning techniques (Gibson assembly, Golden Gate, Gateway)and transform into pathogen- confirm TALE expression via Western blotting- inoculate Xoc carrying TALE variants on rice lines carrying Xo1 and test virulence- measure leaf lesion lengths caused by Xoc strains and analyze differencesvia ANOVA and Tukey HSDtest[2] test potential Xo1-TALE, Xo1-truncTALE, Xo1-TALE-truncTALEinteractions and determine Xo1 regions important for triggering immunity viatransgenicrice lines- standard rice transgenic development protocol- producelines carrying Xo1tagged with TurboID for proximity labeling approach- test function of transgene by inoculation with Xoc and leaf lesion measurements as above- identify any captured interactors with TurboID pipeline and LC/MS-MS-produce lines with tagged Xo1 deletion/swap mutants to identify regions important for immunity-test function of transgene by inoculation with Xoc and leaf lesion measurements as above[3]test Xo1-TALE,Xo1-truncTALE, and Xo1-TALE-truncTALEinteractions and determine Xo1 regions important for triggering immunity viatransient assay- transfect rice protoplasts with plasmids encoding TALE, truncTALE,and/or Xo1via standard rice protoplast protocol- detect/measure fluorescence forlocalization experiments in protoplasts- measure cell death for immune output assays in protoplasts[4] test DNA binding of the variant TALEs- EMSA to determine whether TALEs bind target DNA (established previously by lab)- quantify apparent dissociation constant betweenTALE variants and DNA via EMSAEvaluation:- mentorship milestones: mentor summer REU student, mentor honors thesis undergraduate student- professional development milestones: present in at least one conference per year, maintain new collaborations- communication milestones: publish at least two papers from research generated in project, present at student seminars and lab meetings

Progress 08/15/24 to 08/14/25

Outputs
Target Audience:The main target audience for the reporting period are undergraduate students that the PD mentored or is mentoring. These students have an interest in pursuing a career in the life sciences and were trained in skills important for becoming an independent researcher. The PD also shared results from the reporting period with an international audience of molecular plant pathologists at a major scientific conference. Changes/Problems:Objective [1.7] has been modified due to logistical concerns. Instead of traveling to Madagascar to assess Xo1 deployment potential, collect Xoc isolates and gain field experience, the PD has instead developed a collaboration with the Adachi Lab at Hokkaido University, where she will conduct a 3 month research stay to gain structural insights into Xo1 and its potential interactions with TALEs and truncTALEs. This work will lay the foundation for potential Xo1 engineering and a better understanding of how this NLR is activated and inhibited by Xoc TALEs and truncTALEs. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The PD presented a poster, "Activation of nuclear NLR Xo1 by TALEs and inhibition by truncTALEs depend on a repeat-for-repeat interface", at the 2025 International Society for Molecular Plant-Microbe Interactions Congress (~1,300 attendees). What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Objectives [1.2], [1.4], [1.6] and [2.2] are not yet met. Experiments to address all other objectives in Goal 1 are currently underway. Objectives [1.2] and [1.6] will be carried out as planned using the protoplast transient expression system that was successfully established during this reporting period. Objective [1.4] uses methods optimized previously in the lab and should also proceed as planned. Objective [1.7] has been modified as described in the Changes/Problems section. The travel budget under [1.7] will now be used for a 3-month research stay at Hokkaido University to expand Objective [2.2], to include structural characterization of Xo1 with TALEs or truncTALEs. The PD will be hosted by Hiroaki Adachi, whose lab has expertise in expressing plant immune receptors in Nicotiana benthamiana plants to analyze their biochemical and structural features.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? 1. Problem the project addresses: Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzicola (Xoc) causes bacterial leaf streak disease in rice. BLS occurs in most rice growing regions of the world and can impact yield. This project seeks to address this threat to food security by learning how a rice protein called Xo1, found in an American rice variety, defends the plant against the pathogen, and how some strains of the pathogen overcome Xo1. Xo1 is a rice immune receptor that confers disease resistance against Xoc by detecting transcription activator-like effector proteins (TALEs) Xoc secretes into rice cells. Some Xoc strains carry TALE variants called truncated TALEs (truncTALEs) that inhibit Xo1 immunity. How TALEs trigger and truncTALEs inhibit Xo1 immunity is largely unknown. 2. What work has been done in the project: Under Goal 1, the PD investigated how Xo1 detects TALEs and is inhibited by truncTALEs by testing mutated versions of the proteins in plant disease assays and protoplast (defense-associated) cell death assays. Under Goal 2, the PD mentored undergraduate research assistants and presented at a plant pathology conference. 3. What has resulted from the project: In alignment with Objective [1.1], the PD found that TALE C-term domain and truncTALE N-term domain are important for Xo1 activation and inhibition, respectively. Objective [1.3] was also accomplished and revealed that TALEs require their nuclear localization signals (NLS) to activate Xo1 but truncTALEs can still inhibit Xo1 without a functional NLS. TruncTALE inhibition of Xo1 is disrupted by fusion to a nuclear export signal and actively exclusion from the nucleus. Research on Objective [1.5] is ongoing and the PD has found that specific residues in the super-repeat domain and the zfBED domain of Xo1 are critical for triggering immunity against TALEs. This was accomplished by optimizing a protocol for a protoplast cell death assay. In alignment with the objectives under Goal 2, the PD mentored one graduating undergraduate student, preparing her for her career in the life sciences. The PD also disseminated knowledge gained from objectives under Goal 1 at the 2025 International Society for Molecular Plant-Microbe Interactions Congress. In addition, the PD established a new collaboration with the lab of Hiroaki Adachi at Hokkaido University towards a structural and biochemical characterization of Xo1 and TALEs/truncTALEs. 4. Why it matters: Data obtained under Goal 1 reveals new insights into how Xo1 detects TALEs and how it is inhibited by truncTALEs. The optimization of the protoplast cell death assay that was achieved will expedite further investigation of parts of Xo1 required for immunity. Understanding how TALE activation and truncTALE inhibition of Xo1 works at the molecular level can serve as a foundation for engineering Xo1 to better detect TALEs or be immune to truncTALE inhibition. Such engineering, in turn, may provide a new source of resistance to Xoc. The understanding gained by these data contribute to the plant health and production priority area and address questions relevant for NLR and effector biology, such as how an under characterized NLR with non-canonical domains detect its cognate effectors and how effector variants can subvert this defense mechanism.

Publications