Source: MICHIGAN STATE UNIV submitted to NRP
TOWARDS ENHANCING CLIMATE MITIGATION POTENTIAL OF SWITCHGRASS BIOENERGY CROPPING SYSTEMS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1032223
Grant No.
2024-67019-42336
Cumulative Award Amt.
$750,000.00
Proposal No.
2023-10217
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2024
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2028
Grant Year
2024
Program Code
[A1401]- Foundational Program: Soil Health
Recipient Organization
MICHIGAN STATE UNIV
(N/A)
EAST LANSING,MI 48824
Performing Department
PLANT SOIL MICROBIAL
Non Technical Summary
Development of new bioenergy crops has the potential to reduce consumption of fossil fuels while also enhancing environmental benefits, including through building belowground soil carbon stocks. Switchgrass, a member of North American tallgrass prairie, has become a promising feedstock for bioenergy production. Yet, it is notoriously slow in generating soil carbon gains. We envision two solutions to this problem: 1) breeding switchgrass to have higher capacity to build soil carbon, and 2) developing switchgrass cropping systems that include other plant species to enhance the stabilization of carbon in the soil. To explore the feasibility of these solutions, we need to gain a better understanding of how switchgrass root systems and soil microorganisms interact with soil pore structure, and how this interaction results in stabilization of the fixed carbon that switchgrass allocates belowground.We will perform an in-depth analysis of the root biomass and structure, microbial symbionts, soil pores, and resulting soil carbon accumulation in two experiments. In the first, we will collect data from 18 switchgrass genotypes grown in the field at three locations (in MI, MO, and TX). In the second, we will collect data from a field experiment in which switchgrass is grown with nine other species as neighbors, including native species of grasses, forbs, and legumes. This study will provide knowledge about how soil structure, which is critical for protection of carbon in soil, is affected by switchgrass roots and microbial symbionts. In addition, we will be able to assess the most promising traits for plant breeding, and the most promising additional plant species for a multi-species cropping system, with the goal of enhanced soil carbon sequestration. The results of this study will benefit society by providing knowledge needed to design bioenergy cropping systems that have both high productivity and can capture carbon from the atmosphere.
Animal Health Component
(N/A)
Research Effort Categories
Basic
100%
Applied
(N/A)
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
1020110107050%
2050780107050%
Goals / Objectives
Goal: Bioenergy cropping systems that produce sizeable belowground C inputs may have a beneficial impact on climate change mitigation. Yet, monoculture switchgrass, one of the promising bioenergy crops, is notorious for being slow in generating lasting soil C gains. Our goal is to investigate two potential solutions leading to increased soil C sequestration:1) Selection of particularly beneficial switchgrass genotypes. We will work with multiple switchgrass genotypes at three field sites in a latitudinal gradient across the U.S., representing highly contrasting soil and climatic conditions. Our aim is to identify the traits that are promising for future breeding to enhance soil C sequestration.2) Multicropping with other plant species. We will survey multiple native plant species (including grasses, forbs, and legumes) for potential inclusion in switchgrass stands. In a field experiment involving switchgrass paired with other species, we will use 13C to label switchgrass-derived C. Our aim is to identify plant species that result in enhanced soil C sequestration when planted into switchgrass stands, and the mechanisms through which this occurs.Objectives: Our specific objectives for both goals and experiments described above include measurement of:Aboveground biomass, root biomass, and root trait data (including in switchgrass genotypes and neighboring species)Mycorrhizal fungal colonization and community composition (including in switchgrass genotypes and neighboring species)Soil pore structure and its relationship with soil CSoil C levels and fractionsSwitchgrass-derived portion of each C fraction in the 13C-labeled multicropping experimentIn addition, we will use structural equation modeling and path analysis to address complex casual relationships between the effects of plant genotypes, root characteristics, neighboring species, mycorrhizal colonization, and inherent soil properties resulting in sequestration of soil C.
Project Methods
Methods for Goal 1.To assess the variability of switchgrass root characteristics and their associations with AMF, pore structure formation, and soil C we will work with a Switchgrass diversity panel experiment that is replicated at three field sites. Each site features 18 switchgrass genotypes, which vary widely in their aboveground characteristics, as well as in rhizosphere and microbiota. The experimental sites are located in Austin, TX; Columbia, MO; and KBS, MI, and are representative of, respectively, three major soil types of the contiguous US (Alfisols, Entisols, and Mollisols). To understand the magnitude of variation among switchgrass genotypes, we will examine belowground biomass and a suite of root and mycorrhizal traits that represent key controls over the mechanisms of deposition and stabilization of belowground plant C in soil. Because the experiment is replicated in three regions with contrasting soils and climates, we will begin to understand plasticity in these traits and the strength of genotypic versus environmental controls. Intact soil cores will be taken from genotypes at each site, with (i) intact cores for root analyses (10 cm diameter), (ii) disturbed soil samples for C measurements, and (iii) intact soil cores for μCT pore characterizations. Root and fungal tissue will be sampled intensively using a combination of approaches. We will isolate roots, rhizosphere soil, and bulk soil from intact soil cores and, using root sections from these samples, we will examine morphological, anatomical, and chemical traits in roots, separately by root orders where appropriate. AM fungal communities in roots and soil will be characterized by next-generation sequencing, which will also be leveraged to measure AM fungal abundance in roots and soil, complementing microscopy in roots. Soil carbon will be characterized by fractionation into various labile and recalcitrant pools. In addition, X-ray μCT scanning at 10-30 μm resolutions, image analyses, and soil pore structure characterization will be conducted.Methods for Goal 2.To assess the role of the plant neighbor identity on the switchgrass-derived soil C inputs we will work in the Switchgrass neighbor experiment (KBS, MI). Switchgrass (var. Cave-in-Rock) is grown there with neighbors of three functional plant groups: grasses, forbs, and legumes. Each group is represented by three species common in the prairie community of the Midwest; selected, when possible, based on previous evidence of positive contributions to soil C gains. Root biomass and traits and AM fungal communities will be characterized within intact soil cores (5 cm diameter) collected in the space between the switchgrass individuals and neighbor species. To detect carbon of switchgrass origin we will conduct 13C pulse labeling of the switchgrass in the experimental plots, followed by root and soil sampling, X-ray μCT scanning and analyses of the intact cores, as well as soil analyses. In addition, 13C will be measured in MBC, POM-C, POX-C, MAOM, and SOC.

Progress 07/01/24 to 06/30/25

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience during the first year of the grant was the larger scientific community and students. Our activities were focused on sample collection and beginning data collection. Scientists and students were made aware of the project through presentations, news articles, and discussions with colleagues and collaborators. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Our project provided training opportunities to two postdoctoral scholars (0.5 FTE each), five lab technicians (0.1-0.8 FTE each), and seven undergraduates (0.1-0.2 FTE each), who were all engaged in the research. Postdoctoral scholars were mentored in project design and team management, and led all aspects of data collection in close collaboration with the project PIs. Lab technicians were trained in sample collection and a variety of analytical lab techniques. Undergraduates participated in sample processing and subsequent data collection. Laboratory procedures that various individuals ereceived training in included DNA extraction, PCR, recording data and notes, soil tomography, root trait analysis, and microscopy. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?In this first year of the project, our focus was on sample collection and lab analyses. The project aims were described and communicated broadly through a news release produced by the Michigan State University agricultural experiment station, AgBioResearch. The research was also presented and discussed with ~170 undergraduate students taking an introductory ecology class (Plant Bio/Integrative Bio 355). What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?The next year of the project will be a period of intense data collection from the samples obtained in year 1. We will also continue the field experiments described for Aim 2, and these will be resampled because the plants and communities continue to mature. We also anticipate that we will have analyses completed for some aspects of the experiments, resulting in presentations and preparation of manuscript drafts in the following year.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Switchgrass has great potential as a crop for use in bioenergy cropping systems, but it does not induce gains in soil carbon that are important for soil health and ecosystem carbon budgets. The overarching aim of this project is to learn how soil carbon can be enhanced in switchgrass systems through selection of appropriate plant varieties, and the mechanisms behind that explain these effects. The project will be useful for scientists and agronomists, specifically those involved in switchgrass breeding programs and bioenergy cropping systems. The project has two aims, which involve different field experiments. In Aim 1, we are sampling switchgrass genotypes in replicated trials planted in Texas, Missouri, and Michigan. During this first year of the project, our team visited these sites and obtained deep soil cores (up to 100 cm). Approximately 120 cores have been collected From a subsample of the cores, the samples were divided by horizon, and roots have been extracted. Other analyses of these cores (including analysis of root traits, mycorrhizal and other fungi, soil carbon, and soil pore structure) are currently ongoing. In Aim 2, we established a field experiment in which switchgrass individuals are paired with one of ten species to examine the effects of differing plant neighbors. This experiment will enhance our understanding of the mechanisms by which other grassland species interact with switchgrass and result in greater soil carbon sequestration. The switchgrass in the experiment is being exposed to the stable isotope 13C in CO2, allowing us to determine the fate of carbon after it is fixed by switchgrass and allocated belowground. In the first year of the project, 13C labeling was performed, and soil cores were collected. The soil is in the process of being fractionated to determine the stability of switchgrass-derived soil carbon, as well as transport into neighboring plants. Other cores were collected for root and fungal analyses. Roots have been extracted from these cores, and microbial DNA has been extracted from roots and soil. Root trait analysis is currently ongoing, as well as molecular characterization of arbuscular mycorrhizal and other fungi that are important in determining soil nutrient acquisition and root turnover from infections. In addition, we have sampled a field-scale experiment in which grassland species are mixed in with switchgrass at varying proportions, and data collection from this project is also ongoing.

Publications