Source: UNIV OF IDAHO submitted to NRP
STIMULATING 4-H YOUTH FOR FUTURE WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT THROUGH HANDS-ON NON-FORMAL STEM LEARNING IN RURAL SETTINGS
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1031213
Grant No.
2023-69018-41016
Cumulative Award Amt.
$748,965.00
Proposal No.
2022-12195
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2023
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2026
Grant Year
2023
Program Code
[A7801]- Food and Agricultural Non-formal Education
Recipient Organization
UNIV OF IDAHO
875 PERIMETER DRIVE
MOSCOW,ID 83844-9803
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
The goal of this project is to empower Idaho 4-H youth to enter STEM professions for their future careers through an innovative STEM education program titled "The Idaho Drone League for 4-H leadership (iDrone 4-H)". As a new initiative, the iDrone 4-H program will consist of a week-long online curriculum development and design (Phase 1) plus two-day hands-on in-person training (Phase 2) during the Idaho 4-H State Teen Association Convention (STAC). This hybrid (online + offline) future workforce activity will build and fly drones, learn about safety regulations, drone technology, and develop research questions. To accomplish the overarching goal of the program, the project team will focus on four primary objectives; 1) increase students' knowledge in STEM-related areas (non-formal learning), 2) improve students' attitudes toward STEM (non-formal learning), 3) increase students' motivation to be an ag scientist or engineer, and 4) increase students' self-efficacy and self-confidence related to leadership skills and STEM. We will recruit students across Idaho via the 4-H network, with a recruitment focus on STEM minorities in rural settings. Although a first-come, first-served principal is applied, 15-20 seats will be reserved for students in rural homes where internet service is unavailable. About 450 (150 students/yr x 3 years) highly motivated Idaho youth will impact their communities by increasing the number of talented students in rural settings through iDrone-4H, ultimately enhancing the nation's STEM competitiveness.
Animal Health Component
90%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
90%
Developmental
10%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
80602102050100%
Knowledge Area
806 - Youth Development;

Subject Of Investigation
0210 - Water resources;

Field Of Science
2050 - Hydrology;
Goals / Objectives
The goal of this project, therefore, is to empower Idaho 4-H youth to enter STEM professions for their future careers through an innovative STEM education program titled "The Idaho Drone League for 4-H leadership (iDrone 4-H)". As a new initiative, the iDrone 4-H program will consist of a week-long online curriculum development and design (Phase 1) plus two-day hands-on in-person training (Phase 2) during the Idaho 4-H State Teen Association Convention (STAC). This hybrid (online + offline) future workforce activity will build and fly drones, learn about safety regulations, drone technology, and develop research questions. To accomplish the overarching goal of the program, the project team will focus on four primary objectives; Obj 1) increase students' knowledge in STEM-related areas (non-formal learning), Obj 2) improve students' attitudes toward STEM (non-formal learning), Obj 3) increase students' motivation to be an ag scientist or engineer, and Obj 4) increase students' self-efficacy and self-confidence related to leadership skills and STEM.
Project Methods
iDrone 4-H Online camp (Phase 1): We will recruit students across Idaho via 4-H network, with a targeted recruitment focus on STEM minorities in rural settings (See the collaboration letters). Although a first-come, first-served principal is applied, 15 - 20 seats will be reserved for students in rural homes, where no internet service is available. We will work with remote/rural school districts to accommodate them for Phase I (sprig break) and Phase 2 (summer break) while they can participate in the iDrone 4-H as an option by travelling. Recruitment will take place as soon as the proposal is funded and our advisory board will provide insight and assistance in recruitment. We will advertise through local school districts and community-based organizations and ask educators and program facilitators to identify students and promote the iDrone 4-H during 4-H STAC in summer 2023. Because the project is designed to encourage 4-H youth, we will leverage connections with preexisting programs, such as the 4-H Extension program (see attached letter), the UI Drone Summit, faculty classroom, the existing STEM education network, e.g., Idaho STEM Action Center (Idaho STEM AC, 2020), and the tribes. Students (about 105 online students) will be recruited for iDrone 4-H Online during spring break (Phase 1)Each youth participant from the iDrone 4-H Online will explore their own research questions with support from our team (including USDA-funded staff). They will bring those questions to the workshop where they will learn to fly drones, collect data, analyze data/image processing, and learn federal regulations for safe flight (e.g., FAA Part 107 license). After recruitment, participating students will be asked to complete a pre-workshop survey to assess their current level of understanding related to iDrone concepts and provided with an informational video to introduce them to drones and guide them to develop a research question and brainstorm techniques. Examples such as drone-based insect sampling for precision agriculture, environmental water sampling, wildfire monitoring, and salmon habitat research will be provided as context. Examples will vary based on target region and population, so they are culturally relevant to participants' socio-cultural experiences at their location. They will then be asked to brainstorm their own drone-based research ideas and bring those to the iDrone 4-H to share with their peers. If brainstormed ideas are not a good fit for team project areas, teams can use the examples above. We will use survey findings from Phase 1 to refine and improve Phase 2 curricular design to sustain the iDrone 4-H program. The iDrone 4-H team will work collaboratively to tailor Phase 2 iDrone training workshops adjust the curriculum to include a basis for where participants are in their understanding of general experimental design and self-efficacy as assessed in the pre-workshop survey. Although the general STEM content will stay consistent, alterations will be made in the planning stage of each phase to infuse culturally relevant topics and maximize the potential benefit for youth. With a wide age range of 6th-12th graders, the team will consider whether there is a need to tailor programming to age-specific tracks based on survey findings. Note that the broad age group mingled well in past iDrone events with older students often taking on the role of leading their team, especially during coding, developing a mission plan, and the poster session (Ryu et al., 2020; Ryu et al., 2021).iDrone 4-H Offline Training (Phase 2): During the 4-H STAC, the iDrone 4-H youth will begin with a 2-day hands-on training scheduled for each summer. Participating students will complete a brief survey that will capture demographic information, STEM interests, and motivation for participating in a drone workshop (as well as interest in participating in a drone league near future). The iDrone training module during the 4-H STAC is described below. Teams will be formed in subsequent stages. The first groups will be formed based on participants' topics of preference (e.g., precision ag, environment, and public safety). Within these groups, secondary groups will be formed based on the level of participants' STEM skillsets (e.g., beginner, intermediate, and expert). Final teams (3-5 students in each group) will be formed utilizing both topics of preference and STEM skillsets based on the recommendations by the iDrone project team. Each team will be assigned an advisor (mentor) who represents a diverse population of STEM professionals. Advisors will include women, Hispanics, Native Americans, and first-generation college students, to provide role models who correspond to participants' gender and ethnicity make-up. These advisors will be recruited as a guest speaker after the selection of youth to be representative to the corresponding participants through the previously described networks for recruitment of participants. Advisors will be expected to support their assigned team through the development of their iDrone 4-H project. Additionally, these advisors will be asked to share about their current careers and their journey towards their career. Throughout Indigenous Knowledge for Effective Education Program (IKEEP), Co-PI Wargo will develop an advising or mentoring guide and conduct a training session to provide advisors with the necessary knowledge to be successful assisting with iDrone projects.Team building activities will include cooperative learning strategies and leadership sessions. Participants will engage in ongoing "sharing" and "processing," where they will work in cooperative learning groups to refine their ideas. This trial-and-error time allows youth to reflect on successes and opportunities for growth while working toward a better solution. At the end of the workshop, they will share their projects with all workshop participants and engage in a full group reflection.Working with local iDrone 4-H coordinators (USDA-funded staff), the project team will also provide basic instructions on methods to investigate specific aspects of participants' identified real-world problems, such as 1) how advanced drone technology can minimize fire potential in Idaho (e.g., Soda fires) via drone-based remote sensing, 2) how to improve net revenue using drone-mounted spot spray for precision agriculture, 3) how to identify salmon spawning areas using drone-mounted sensors to advance river restoration projects for salmon returns in the northwest, 4) what conditions, constraints, and risks can make it possible to provide drone-based delivery service (e.g., ag equipment part delivery in rural settings, or 5) how to protect privacy from nearby drone flights using anti-drone and/or drone jamming technology. These examples will be altered during the hands-on training to be culturally relevant to participating youth. This portion of the workshop will aid in the generalization of learned knowledge and transferability of content to various contexts. Although they are not expected to compete in any way, they will be instructed and guided in collaborative data collection with the methods they have been taught at this stage (Phase 2).Group discussions will revolve around what students learned from the "scripted" approach and the data they gathered. Learning objectives will include: understanding what a research question is, methods of answering questions with data, technical data collection skills, and content knowledge gains in areas specific to the science of the questions and aligned to American Science and Math Education standards. Additionally, youth participants will be challenged to generalize their knowledge and derive new opportunities for application in their futures.

Progress 09/01/24 to 08/31/25

Outputs
Target Audience:During the second year (YR2), from September 1, 2024, to August 31, 2025, we successfully hosted an online drone camp that engaged approximately 80 young participants. Conducted via the Zoom platform, this virtual experience provided students with hands-on opportunities to build and code drones, culminating in indoor flight activities. This interactive approach not only enhanced their technical skills but also deepened their interest in STEM disciplines. In addition to the virtual camp, an in-person drone camp was held in late June 2025 to further expand these learning opportunities to approximately 80 4-H students in northern Idaho. Two separate sessions took place--one at Washington State University in Pullman, WA, and another at the Plummer Public Library in Idaho. These in-person camps were designed to strengthen STEM engagement and leadership development among youth across rural communities. By offering both virtual and in-person formats, this blended approach effectively addressed the diverse needs of our target audience, ensuring greater accessibility and a broader impact on youth in underserved areas. Changes/Problems:During the reporting period, one of the project collaborators retired. This retirement has not impacted the overall goals or accomplishments of the project. Principal Investigator Dr. Ryu will work with the Office of Sponsored Programs to update project personnel accordingly in the coming months. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Although the iDrone 4-H program is currently designed for 6th-12th grade students, the long-term vision includes expanding the curriculum to STEM educators, particularly high school teachers. Next summer, Dr. Ryu's team plans to host a hands-on professional development workshop for K-12 teachers. This workshop will guide teachers in building, coding, and flying drones in compliance with federal safety regulations for the national airspace. Additionally, teachers will learn to develop project-based research questions tailored to their classroom environments. This initiative will allow the project team to assess the impact of the iDrone 4-H program on teachers' interest, knowledge, and confidence in incorporating drone education into their teaching practices in the near future. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Principal Investigator Dr. Ryu is actively disseminating project updates and outcomes through professional social media platforms, including LinkedIn and Facebook, to engage a broad audience. Additionally, the team plans to publish findings in the Journal of Rural Education to further contribute to academic discourse. To amplify the program's reach and impact, the team is also initiating collaborations with peer institutions--such as Washington State University and Montana State University--to co-develop grant proposals and implement similar STEM education programs across rural communities in America. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?To further advance the overarching goals of the iDrone 4-H program, we plan to continue offering the annual online drone camp to reach a broader population of rural youth across Idaho. In addition, we aim to expand the number of in-person drone camps held throughout the state, with a particular focus on serving Title I school districts and underserved rural communities. These efforts will enhance access to hands-on STEM learning opportunities, support continued growth in student knowledge and interest in STEM careers, and further develop leadership and self-efficacy among Idaho 4-H youth.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? To achieve the overarching goal of empowering Idaho 4-H youth to pursue STEM careers, the iDrone 4-H program successfully implemented a hybrid learning model consisting of both online and in-person components. A four-day online drone camp was conducted via the Zoom platform, engaging over 80 participants in hands-on activities such as building drones from scratch, coding flight paths, and conducting indoor flights using educational drones. This non-formal learning environment enhanced students' knowledge in STEM-related areas (Objective 1) and improved their attitudes toward STEM (Objective 2). Beyond the virtual experience, students learned how to operate drones within the National Airspace System, incorporating federal safety guidelines and FAA regulations--providing practical insights into real-world STEM applications. Phase 2 of the program included in-person drone workshops held at Washington State University during the Idaho/Washington 4-H Teen Association Convention (STAC) on June 24, 2024. An additional in-person drone camp (June 25 - 27, 2024) was hosted at the Plummer Public Library to further engage rural youth and spark interest in STEM disciplines. To assess program effectiveness, survey instruments were used to collect feedback from participants. Preliminary results indicate increased student motivation to pursue STEM careers (Objective 3), along with measurable gains in self-efficacy and leadership confidence (Objective 4). These findings are being compiled for dissemination and publication in the coming year.

Publications


    Progress 09/01/23 to 08/31/24

    Outputs
    Target Audience:The project officially commenced in the later months of fall 2023, despite a scheduled start date of September 1, 2023. This delay was primarily due to administrative processes and the completion of necessary paperwork. In the first year (YR1) of the initiative, we successfully hosted an online camp that attracted approximately 100 young participants. This virtual experience, conducted via the Zoom meeting platform, offered these youths an engaging opportunity to build and code drones, followed by conducting indoor flights. This practical approach not only enriched their technical skills but also heightened their interest in STEM disciplines. Furthermore, in addition to the online drone camp, an in-person camp is slated for mid-July 2024, aimed at extending these enriching experiences to more 4-H students (approximately 80 students) in the Treasure Valley areas of Southern Idaho. This blend of online and physical camps is specifically designed to cater to the diverse needs of our target audience, ensuring broader accessibility and impact among the youth in these communities. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Although the iDrone 4-H program is currently targeted to 6th - 12th grade students, eventually STEM educators, such as high school teachers will implement drone curriculum into their classrooms. During this summer, Dr. Ryu's team also hosted an hands-on workshop for K-12 teachers to help them to build, code, and fly drones by meeting federal regulations and safety guidelines at the national airspace and develop their own project-based research questions for their classroom settings. Basically, this activity helps the team examine the effects of iDrone 4-H program on teachers' interest, knowledge, and confidence in the context of drone education in their classrooms. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?PI, Ryu is actively communicating with a broader audience via social media platforms, such as LinkedIn and Facebook. Additionally, the project outcomes will be presented in the upcoming conferences (ASABE, July 28-31, 2024) while the project team will collaborate with interested institutions (e.g., Washington State University) in writing grants and to plan and implements similar STEM educational programs. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?We will continue to host an annual online drone camp to benefit more rural youth across Idaho. We also plan to host in-person drone camp in rural communities, especially focusing on Title 1 School districts in Idaho.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? A 4-day drone online camp was held via Zoom platform and more than 100 people joined and enjoyed drone building from scratch, coding, and indoor flights with small education drones. In addition to nonformal STEM experience in online formats, students also learn how to fly drones at the national airspace by meeting federal safety and regulations set by Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). In person drone workshops also took place in Moscow during the Idaho 4-H Teen Association Convention (STAC), June 25 - 26, 2024. We have collected comments and feedback through survey activities to measure students' motivation to enter STEM career by increasing their self-efficacy and self-confidence

    Publications

    • Type: Conference Papers and Presentations Status: Accepted Year Published: 2024 Citation: Stimulating 4-H youth for future workforce development through hands-on nonformal STEM learning in rural settings