Source: MALAMA KAUAI submitted to
KALO TO KULA: CONNECTING OUR KEIKI TO KALO FOR A SUSTAINABLE KAUA‘I
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1031156
Grant No.
2023-70026-40840
Cumulative Award Amt.
$220,476.00
Proposal No.
2023-01892
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Sep 1, 2023
Project End Date
Aug 31, 2025
Grant Year
2023
Program Code
[FASLP]- Food and Agriculture Service Learning Program
Project Director
Soza, S.
Recipient Organization
MALAMA KAUAI
4900 KUAWA RD
KILAUEA,HI 967545507
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Kalo to Kula will ensure that cultural food staple kalo (taro) continues to reclaim its rightful place in our daily island food culture, by developing appreciation by young kalo consumers and bringing kalo into schools through field trips, student-led projects, USDA compliant recipes, and cafeteria staff trainings. Though Kaua'i imports upwards of 85% of their food, it produces 2/3 of the taro in Hawai'i - most of which is sold off-island. Kaua'i kalo farmers will be supported through a needs assessment, processing supplies distribution, and purchasing of kalo products.Our goal is to center kalo in the local farm to school movement, with increased access to, and consumption of, kalo in Kaua'i schools. Our project will include poi and other kalo products, increasing its adaptation into meals. Youth will lead the project through taste tests and recipe feedback, and execution of student-led kalo projects and huaka'i (excursions/field trips) to kalo farms. These opportunities connect across Hawai?i's traditional cultural practices and are powerful focal points for strengthening our youth's self awareness, self-sufficiency, and health. This is especially true for Native Hawaiians who struggle with self identity and cultural pride due to historical erasure or misinformation of Hawaiian people.To ensure an authentic and equitable approach when focusing on an important cultural crop, all project staff and paid consultants are Native Hawaiian. Kalo to Kula will bring together kalo farmers, cultural practitioners, community-based nonprofits, cafeteria staff, teachers, and students to connect our keiki to kalo for a sustainable Kaua'i.
Animal Health Component
10%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
10%
Applied
10%
Developmental
80%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
50214541010100%
Knowledge Area
502 - New and Improved Food Products;

Subject Of Investigation
1454 - Taro;

Field Of Science
1010 - Nutrition and metabolism;
Goals / Objectives
Kalo to Kula complements and builds upon our island's farm to school work to date, while centering and grounding it in Hawaiian culture, and supporting increased food access and health through kalo's incorporation into school meal programs. The project brings together stakeholders from various parts of our food system, including farmers, a food hub/distributor, school cafeteria staff, teachers, and students. Students are the end consumer and will have extensive agency and voice in recipe development and project designs for their school-based activities. Direct connections to Part 1B of the RFA include aligning with the primary goals of FASLP:Purpose: to increase knowledge of agriculture and improve the nutritional health of children.FASLP Primary GoalsProject Connection1. Increase capacity for food, garden, and nutrition education within host organizations orentities and school cafeterias and in the classroom;Provides educational opportunities through cafeteria worker trainings and student-led projects, such as kalo tasting activities field trips2. Complement and build on the efforts of the farm to school programs implemented undersection 18(g) of the Richard B. Russell National School Lunch Act [(42 U.S.C. 1769(g)]Follows several successful Kaua'i based farm to school projects including a USDA-funded Farm to ECE effort, and County-funded farm to school credits for schools; makes programming more culturally responsive3. Complement efforts by the Department and school food authorities to implement the schoollunch programs established under the Richard B. Russell National School Lunch Act (42U.S.C. 1751 et seq,) and the school breakfast program established by section 4 of the ChildNutrition Act of 1966 (42 U.S.C. 1773);Supports efforts to incorporate kalo into school lunch and breakfast programs, and works directly with school food authorities on compliant recipe development, product creation, and training4. Carry out activities that advance the nutritional health of children and nutrition education in elementary schools and secondary schools (as those terms are defined in section 9101 of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C 7801); andProvides education and direct food access that encourages healthy carbohydrate and grain intake that is more suitable to those of Native Hawaiian and Pacific Islander descent - and generally healthier for all students than their grain-based alternatives5. Foster higher levels of community engagement and support the expansion of national service and volunteer opportunities.Engages a wide variety of kalo farmers, processors, cultural practitioners, a food hub, cafeteria workers, and students
Project Methods
MK's PD will manage project timeline, deliverables, and project evaluation alongside a third-party evaluator, Kelea Levy of Kanaka Economic Development Alliance (KEDA). Approximately 4.6% of the budget is allocated for evaluation services, although the PM will also spend significant time supporting. PD has also completed complex evaluations for federal projects in the last three years including evaluation for our USDA-funded Farm to ECE project. See attached Logic Model for details on the overall strategy.Process evaluations will determine whether program activities have been implemented as intended and resulted in certain outputs. The PD will conduct process evaluation on a monthly basis throughout the life of the project by matching the work plan/timeline to steps achieved, and by reviewing the activities and output components of the logic model (i.e., the left side) and the indicators detailed in the below table (comparing targets to actuals). The Evaluator will perform quarterly check-ins to ensure the project is on target in relation to processes, activities, outputs, and timeline.Outcome evaluations will be monitored and measured to determine how well the strategies and activities employed by the project supported the project goals and objectives. The outcome evaluations will include taste testing focus group in-person and survey feedback from youth and cafeteria workers, increases in sales of kalo during the project, kalo farmer needs identification and how well the project helped meet the identified needs, cafeteria worker behavioral changes related to using kalo, and student behavioral outcomes related to eating kalo. Evaluator will assist in the development of all evaluation tools during Q1 of the project and follow through on the implementation, collection, and analysis of the data gathered from the tools throughout the project.

Progress 09/01/23 to 08/31/24

Outputs
Target Audience:Community Individuals living on Kaua?i including youth, primarily those attending school, as well as the adults that care for, feed, and educate them including teachers, teacher aids, school administration, cafeteria staff, parents, and guardians. The community was also involved in a kalo recipe contest ti hep crowd-source kid-friendly recipes for our guidebook. Schools Schools on Kaua?i including public, public charter, private, and home schools. We also include pre-schools/ECEs, after-school programs and organizations that host youth programs during summer, fall, winter, and spring school breaks. Teachers, cafeteria staff, and administration have all been key audiences that have received outreach and education about the program. Kalo Farmers Farmers residing on Kaua?i that grow kalo (taro). Government School Food Service Branch, DOE Farm to School Coordinator, and government representatives have been informed and updated on project progress. Technical Assistance Providers UH-CTAHR Extension Agents Our work matters to these various groups for a number of reasons. First, the remote island of Kaua?i has just a 5-day supply of food (which is upwards of 85% imported). Yet, Kaua'i is the number one producer of kalo (taro) in Hawai'i, producing two-thirds of our state's crop of this culturally important food source. Most of this kalo is shipped off-island to poi mills, but local kalo farmers aim to keep the food on Kaua'i to feed our people. Formerly a daily staple in the Native Hawaiian diet, kalo was cultivated in a 100 different varieties, eaten as the main dish at almost every meal and enjoyed by the entire population. In the ancient creation stories of the Hawaiian people, kalo is not just food - kalo or H?loa is the elder brother to the Hawaiian people who trace their genealogies back to this plant and continue to live in a reciprocal relationship of stewardship and nourishment to this day. Rightfully, kalo is one of the few cultural starches grown in Hawai?i that is approved for use as a grain alternative in child nutrition programs by USDA, and is also typically a baby's first food in Polynesian and Oceania cultures due to its easy digestibility, high nutrition, and because it is hypoallergenic. MK has collaborated with individual kalo farmers and fiscally sponsored grants for kalo farmer hui (groups) and throughout this work we've heard many of their challenges as well as what motivates them to continue farming taro. Kalo farmers are truly the fabric of our island's culture and history, and a key to our food sustainability as a remote and vulnerable community where we have the 2nd highest child food insecurity in the country where one in four children faces food insecurity - in a place with a year round growing season no less. The majority of kalo farmers are Native Hawaiian, carrying with them decades of ancestral practices of culturally-based food production. The Kaua'i Complex Area of the Department of Education hosts 21 schools serving 8,500+ keiki (children). Much of the food being distributed and consumed at the schools has little cultural importance due to lack of familiarity and preparation knowledge. As we move forward in this work, we continue to hear confirmation and support from the various groups that make up our target audience, all of whom have acknowledged that kalo deserves to reclaim its rightful place in our everyday food culture. Changes/Problems:The only major change was the staffing change, which left us without a coordinator/Kalo Specialist to help support the program for several months - significantly delaying kalo product development and production. We were finally able to hire a replacement in the summer, which has helped to get the program back on track to complete our goals by the end of Year 2. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?Our first set of workshops for cafeteria staff and teachers was hosted on September 21, 2024 and September 28, 2024 with a total of 18 attendees, 3 MK staff, 3 guest speakers, and 3 host site staff. ? How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?We have been developing and releasing social media and newsletter content to our communities of interest. This included the development and release of our first year's Kalo Farmer Needs Assessment results, which was also directly shared with industry technical assistance professionals, and later published in a Civil Beat article on taro production in Hawai'i that was published in October. We have a Farm to School webinar scheduled for October 14, 2024 to share details about our Kalo Kredit and Kalo Farm Field Trip grants along with information about our Food Trees for Schools program. We will also be attending both the Schools of the Future and Hawai'i Ag Conference in November 2024 to disseminate some results with both the education and agriculture industries. We will be making a presentation at the Dept. of Education's Schools of the Future Conference, where many staff from across Hawai'i attend to learn about innovations and new programs in schools, and our Executive Director also mentioned the program in her Hawai'i Ag Conference presentation about our food hub facility. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?In the next year of the project, some of our key activities and milestones include: Gain approval from Dept. of Education School Food Services Branch for our Kalo Fries and Pre-Steamed L?'au Leaf for trial in DOE schools and potential inclusion in meals using a recipe from the Kalo to Kula Recipe Guidebook Complete farmer supply purchasing, food hub equipment purchases, and kalo product production at scale to supply schools and institutional markets Conduct year 2 Kalo Farmer Needs Assessment and host a 2nd Kalo Farmer Dinner, with feedback from farmers designing future and ongoing program support Host 2nd Kalo to Kula workshop with teachers and cafeteria workers Complete Kalo Kredit and Kalo Farm Field Trip programs with schools

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? 1. Our first official Kalo to Kula training was held September 2024, with 5 attendees. Participants spent the day at the farm of partner organization Iwikua at Waimea High School. Our second Kalo to Kula training, also in September 2024, was held in Anahola at K?kula Kumuhana o Anahola farm and garden. 13 attendees including teachers from 1 Hawaiian preschool, multiple homeschools, DOE schools, and 1 cafeteria staff were present. Attendees participated in a number of activities including time in the garden assisting with weed maintenance and learning how kalo grows. Then we heard from generational taro farmers who shared about their farming experience and expertise. The group also learned how to use our recipe guidebook by breaking up into groups and preparing 3 different kalo recipes. They enjoyed a catered lunch that featured 3 other kalo recipes from the guidebook and were given leftovers to share with friends and family. MK staff went over the 2 grant opportunities open to schools, field trip grants and Kalo Kredits. Each participant received a recipe guidebook, printed kalo resources and curriculum, along with Kalo Kits filled with the recipe-ready ingredients available in the Kalo Kredit grant so that they can experiment with them on their own time. Our workshops highlighted the release of our Kalo to Kula Recipe Guidebook, which features 19 kalo recipes compliant to USDA National School Lunch and School Breakfast programs. In Year 2 of the project we will be promoting the guidebook, and also beginning the field trip and kalo product grants (Kalo Kredits) to schools across the island to assist in implementing hands-on activities with keiki. The 2nd Kalo to Kula training sessions for teachers and cafeteria staff is scheduled for March 2025. 2. This work is expanding on our previous farm to school programs and also goes deeper into specific cultural food items in a unique way. It touches both hands-on education and food service in school environments, while supporting the taro industry to better engage with the schools in meaningful ways. 3. Begin batch testing kalo products: our first Kalo Specialist began batch testing 2 of our 4 main kalo products; kalo pa?a and l??au while identifying needed processing and packaging equipment. After he resigned, the position was vacant for 6 months while we searched for a qualified candidate. Batch testing continued, albeit at a much slower rate then was planned, with temporary assistance from other MK staff to continue progress on production. In August, the position was finally filled. Both the kalo pa?a and l??au products are being distributed to restaurants and schools for testing and feedback. Progress on our other kalo products is being made, including kalo flour and kalo fries. Poi was initially on our list of products but after farmer needs assessments and many 1:1 conversations with farmers, this is one product many of them would like to focus on and provide for the community. We will be focusing on kalo fries and l??au production while supporting established poi mills and these farmers who are looking to expand into value added production. Finalize kalo recipe Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs): Final SOPs will be completed in the coming months. The loss of our Kalo Specialist created delays in production and SOP development that were compounded by kitchen construction and permitting delays. We have since met with a local legend, Tammy Smith who is an expert in preparing cultural foods on a mass scale for both schools and elderly homes. She has agreed to visit our kitchen facility and help us finalize our SOPs while troubleshooting any underlying production issues. Purchase kalo processing and packaging equipment for food hub: our team has spent a significant amount of time researching and testing various processing and packaging equipment for efficient production. MK staff have also visited commercial kitchens at Waip? Foundation and K?ko?o ??iwi to gain more in depth knowledge for medium to large scale production of value-added kalo products. PD Soza is set to visit Maui Innovation Center and Ala Kukui in H?n?, both of which host a wide variety of industrial kitchen equipment. Kalo Recipe Guidebook: this guidebook hosts a wide variety of family recipes that have been adapted to fit into the USDA?s National School Lunch and School Breakfast programs. There are recipes for breakfast, lunch and snack and all feature either the kalo corm or taro leaves or a combination of the two, as well as, poi - a staple Hawaiian dish of cooked kalo mashed and mixed with water. It was imperative to our team to include recipes that our community is familiar with and enjoys eating to ensure that the food would not be wasted when served in the cafeteria. Each recipe was tested multiple times and shared with various school aged children and adults for feedback and, if needed, recipe adjustments. Extensive analysis of the entire guidebook along with each recipe to verify compliance was done with the help of a former local Hawaii Child Nutrition Program auditor. Upon completion of taste testings and this final review, a nutrition analysis was completed for all 19 recipes and nutrition labels were created and included in the book. This guidebook also breaks down how to credit kalo, lau, and poi as different meal components in both breakfast and lunch dishes, as well as, how to locate them in the Food Buying Guide because both kalo and lau are listed under different names, Malanga (Taro) and Spinach, respectively. It also shares guidance on how much cafeterias should buy and cites the Food Buying Guide app and online tip sheets where cafeteria managers can seek further guidance. 4. Our student-led projects using kalo products was pushed to year 2 due to our staffing shortage, which delayed the kalo product production. We plan to still reach our end outcomes in year 2. This is also when the field trips are scheduled to occur. 5. We began engagement with the community, kalo farmers, and schools in the first year of the project. We hosted a Kalo Recipe Contest in December 2023, which resulted in 8 winning community-submitted recipes that were incorporated into our Kalo Recipe Guidebook. Leading up to our Kalo Farmer Dinner we conducted a needs assessment with 21 unique farms participation. From there we analyzed the data and prepared a snapshot to share back with farmers. Our dinner was held in December 2023 at Kawaikini Charter School which is centrally located on the island and has participated in various Farm to School programs and projects with MK for many years. The agenda for the evening was tailored around our kalo farmers to give them all an opportunity to gather, and in some cases meet for the first time, and enjoy a delicious meal together. We then shared details about Kalo to Kula and reserved the remaining portion of the evening for farmers to fill out evaluations. We specifically wanted to know if they were in support of the program, whether or not they were able to participate in this first year. 100% of the 19 farmers in attendance are in support of the program. Extensive outreach sharing promotional flyers via email, e-newsletters, and social media has been shared with schools and the broader community. PD Soza and M?lama Kaua?i Kaua?i ED are both deeply connected with schools throughout a number of years of Farm to School related projects. PD Soza has also fostered many personal relationships with teachers and school administrators at many schools across the island. Through these 1:1 opportunities, outreach has been on-going throughout the entirety of the project thus far.

Publications