Source: UNIVERSITY OF VERMONT submitted to
COMPANION CROPPING STROPHARIA MUSHROOMS WITH HEMP FOR NUTRIENT RECOVERY AND ECONOMIC RETURN
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1030586
Grant No.
2023-67024-40294
Cumulative Award Amt.
$298,338.00
Proposal No.
2022-10355
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 15, 2023
Project End Date
Jul 14, 2025
Grant Year
2023
Program Code
[A1601]- Agriculture Economics and Rural Communities: Small and Medium-Sized Farms
Project Director
Neher, D.
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF VERMONT
(N/A)
BURLINGTON,VT 05405
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Sustainable waste management strategies are often overlooked as a method to reduce dependency on agricultural inputs and increase profitability of small- and medium-sized farms. Processing medical hemp for human consumption uses mostly dried floral material and disregards the rest of the plant as waste accumulating to 600 pounds per acre. Using hemp waste as mulch for hemp plants and substrate to grow gourmet Stropharia mushrooms would allow smallholder farmers to restore fertility directly while generating an added source of income. The overall goal of this project is to build an integrated waste management approach that provides economic and environmental returns to farmers by improving soil health, increasing plant productivity, and building soils suppressive to disease. The objectives are four-fold: 1) quantify medical hemp waste streams, 2) evaluate the effectiveness of mushrooms to reduce or replace external synthetic fertilizer inputs, 3) assess the impact on plant disease and yield, and 4) perform a cost-benefit analysis to assess feasibility. We plan to compare three organics recycling techniques (i.e., mushroom companions, microbial digestion, raw waste mulch) with a synthetic fertilizer control at multiple locations and years. If successful, the proposed work will offer novel solutions for on-farm organics recycling and address two USDA Strategic Plan Goals: 4) facilitate rural prosperity and economic development, and 5) strengthen the stewardship of private lands through technology and research. The proposed study is proof-of-concept for future studies that would be a first of their kind to formulate farm-specific waste management plans using mushroom companions.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
0%
Applied
100%
Developmental
0%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
4031730301030%
4031470301025%
1020110106015%
1021730106015%
2120110112015%
Goals / Objectives
The long-term goal of the proposed project is to build a working knowledge of the waste stream generated by medical hemp farmers and identify waste management strategies that provide economic and environmental returns to small and medium-sized farms. The goal is approached with four specific objectives: (1) Quantify waste streams produced by medical hemp at partner farms, (2) Evaluate the effectiveness of SRA for nutrient recycling and availability to plants, (3) Assess the impact of each recycling strategy on plant disease and yield, and (4) Perform a cost-benefit analysis to assess the feasibility of mushroom companions as an economically viable option compared to other fertility and recycling strategies.
Project Methods
Multiple locationsThe on-farm experiment will be conducted at 2 locations in Vermont and 1 location in Minnesota. Vermont sites include Four Clover Farm (Eden) and Borderview Farm (Alburgh), and the Minnesota site will be Minny Grown (Cannon Falls).Plot Design and Field Preparation At each of three sites, four treatments will be organized as a randomized complete block design with five replications for a total of 60 experimental units (4 treats x 5 reps x 3 sites). Hemp plant treatments will receive one of four treatments: 1) hemp chips as mulch inoculated with Stropharia rugosoannula mushrooms (SRA), 2) hemp mulch treated with purchased inoculum (commercial control), 3) hemp chips as mulch (true control), and 4) synthetic fertilizer without mulch (negative control). Plots will be 8 x 20' with a 5' buffer between plots to avoid interplot interference. Inoculated plots will be separated using a plastic barrier to prevent mycelium from spreading into the uninoculated treatments. The field will be cultivated in early spring before plots are demarcated. Each plot will be planted with 10 hemp transplants spaced 4' apart to allow ample space for growth. Inoculation of SRA at the rate of 5 lbs per 16 ft2 will occur immediately after the mulch has been applied to allow time for the mushroom mycelium to colonize the hemp chips before planting. This experiment will be repeated over the course of two growing seasons to ensure adequate time for mushroom establishment.Objective 1) Quantify waste streams produced by medical hemp at partner farmsWe plan to keep detailed records of total plant dry biomass and total plant dry floral yield after post-harvest processing is complete.Objective 2) Evaluate the effectiveness of SRA for nutrient recycling and availability to plantsWe plan to quantify hemp degradation two ways: 1) Oxidative enzyme activity of the mulch/soil using microplate assays, and 2) nutrients in soil and plant tissues. By taking samples before planting, mid-season and at harvest we can assess SRA's ability to restore soil fertility. Both soil and plant tissue will be analyzed for nutrition, focusing on nitrogen, potassium and phosphorous availability.Objective 3) Assess the impact of each recycling strategy on plant disease and yieldPresence and severity of any disease on hemp will be assessed in the field to determine whether it varies by treatment. Specific attention will be given to plant pathogenic soil nematodes such as lesion and root knot nematodes (Pratylenchus, Meloidogyne hapla). We will measure yield by harvesting hemp plants in the fall according to standard industrial practices where flowering buds are removed from stalks and dried to 10% moisture. Dried flowers will be weighed to compare among treatments. Mushrooms will also be harvested periodically through the growing season and weighed to assess total yield and marketable biomass for the cost-benefit analysis.Objective 4) Perform a cost-benefit analysis to assess the feasibility of implementing each recycling strategy and if mushroom companions are an economically viable option We will evaluate the cost and returns of each recycling strategy outlined above. For strategy 1 (mushroom companions), the cost of spawn, maintenance, and labor requirements of mushroom companions will be measured. The benefit return on nutrient savings and farm gate and direct to consumer market value of mushrooms will be estimated. For strategy 2 (microbial digestion), the cost of inoculant by volume and labor requirements will be measured. The return on nutrient savings will be estimated. For strategy 3 (raw waste mulch), the cost of fertilizer will be determined. For strategy 4 (synthetic fertilizer), the costs associated with waste hauling will be evaluated.

Progress 07/15/23 to 07/14/24

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience is small and medium-sized farms. Changes/Problems:Weed pressure. Mowing and weed trimmers were insufficient in managing weeds. Weed pressure was a major issue in the treatment plots mulched with hemp biomass in the Vermont Farms, and likely responsible for reduced hemp yields. Control plots covered in landscape fabric had little to no weed pressure which correlates with greater yield in plots with fabric (controls) than without fabric. Adjustments to be implemented in year 2 (2024) are the following: Apply weed mat to all treatment plots two weeks prior to spreading mulch and inoculating beds to smother weeds before they can establish. Apply hemp mulch and inoculate beds earlier in the season (mid-May) to further smother weeds. Fertility Differences/Plant Stunting. Despite attempts to apply the equivalent of 100 lbs/N per acre, there were nutrient deficiencies observed for plants in mulched plots. Plants in control plots without mulch showed no signs of stunting and produced the greatest yields. We hypothesize that application of carbon-rich biomass tied up the soil nitrogen. Adjustments to be implemented in 2024 are the following: Rake away mulch in May and rototill nutrients into plots for deeper placement than in 2023. Deeper placement places more fertility in contact with plant roots than the microbial communities in the mulch layer. Apply nutrient requirement in two stages, i.e., spread half of nutrient requirement into rototilled lanes and the other half at planting (spread fertilizer into planting hole). Disease Pressure. Extensive prevalence of Septoria leaf spot likely reduced yields at the Vermont farms. Rain and wet conditions experienced in Vermont the summer of 2023 likely exacerbated this issue. Adjustments to be implemented in 2024 are the following: Record disease incidence and severity early in the grow season (mid-June/early July) and periodically thereafter to assess disease progress. Prune lower leaves of plants in July to reduce disease spread (if needed). Flower yield was less than commercial standards. Plant stunting, disease pressure, and competition of weeds negatively affected yield in treatment plots. Moreover, farms were hot and dry at the start of the season in Vermont, and throughout the season in Minnesota. We installed drip tape and sprinkler irrigation systems to even out moisture among farms. However, installation was weeks after planting and the drought damage had a lasting impact. Adjustments to be implemented in 2024 are the following: Install drip irrigation before planting at each farm. Adjust fertility application regime, weed management, and disease pressure as outlined above. Changes to fertility, weed, and disease management may alleviate some of these pressures. Disparate Mushroom Yield among farms. Mushroom production was unequal across the three farms. Eden outperformed all other sites with ~57 pounds of fresh mushrooms. Alburgh was second with ~8 pounds while Minnesota produced about a pound. Differences between the VT and MN sites were likely due to unequal precipitation (VT had more than typical; MN had less than typical). Despite differences in yield and rain, we were successful in getting mushroom beds established at all experimental locations. Adjustments to be implemented in 2024 are the following: Irrigation systems will be established after applying mushroom spawn to insure establishment of mushroom treatments. Reduce labor and increase accuracy of mushroom harvest by counting mushrooms rather than picking and weighing them individually. A subset of mushrooms will be harvested at the beginning of each flush and a mean weight per mushroom determined. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?For professional development, a graduate student Attended a webinar "From bud to blend: Compost opportunities in Cannabis cultivation" sponsored by the U.S. Composting Council on 22 April 2024. The webinar explored best practices and technology in processing cannabis waste, uncovering potential opportunities in this flourishing field, and learn about successful marketing strategies. Additionally, you will hear experts discuss current regulatory frameworks around cannabis waste disposal, particularly in key states like Colorado and California. Attended and participated in the Vermont Organic Recycling Summit in Waterbury, 29 April 2024 How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Invited presentation to direct stakeholder audience at Annual Field Day at Borderview Farm (Alburgh, VT) on 27 July 2023 What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?The field experiment will be repeated at the same three farms. Additional measures will be taken to better manage weed pressure, more efficient and accurate estimates of mushroom yield, and quantify plant pathogens and disease progress. A greenhouse experiment will be conducted to quantify the relationship between depth of hemp mulch with mushroom yield. Aspects of Objectives 3 and 4 will be addressed, including quantification of aboveground disease severity, plant-parasitic and free-living nematodes in the soil, and estimating economic value of mushrooms and hemp flowers. The economist who was an original co-PI (School of Business, Western Colorado University) left the university at the outset of the project.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Year 1 of 2 of a field experiment were conducted on three farms, two in Vermont and one in Minnesota. Two undergraduate students gained research experience with this project. Using hemp waste as mulch for hemp plants and substrate to grow gourmet Stropharia mushrooms would allow smallholder farmers to restore fertility directly while generating an added source of income. Methods and year 1 (2023) results are presented below: Objective 1. Waste streams produced by medical hemp were quantified by weighing fresh and dry mass from flowers, stems and leaves. Flowers are the harvestable product while the remainder is considered waste. Objective 2. Effectiveness of SRA for nutrient recycling and availability to plants was measured through enzymatic activity that reflects lignin decomposition by soil microorganisms, percent mass loss in litter bags, and nutrient content of soil and plant tissue. Enzymes were quantified monthly and measures of decomposition, and nutrient content were measured in spring and fall. Nutrient content in soil was similar among treatments. Enzyme activity varied by sampling time and farm location without any consistent pattern among treatments. Decomposition was fastest in plots inoculated with mushroom spawn when compared to the other treatments. Objective 3. Aboveground Septoria leaf spot disease was extensive at one farm and less at the remaining two farms. Septoria leaf spot was the most prevalent pathogen at our Vermont sites which might have affected plant performance. Rain and wet conditions experienced in Vermont during the summer of 2023 likely exacerbated this issue. Objective 4. Yields of mushroom and hemp flowers were quantified by mass. The yield of medicinal hemp plants was measured as weight of flowers harvested, and mushroom yield quantified by fresh weight when picked and weighed. At the Vermont sites, hemp yield tended to be greater in the control plots covered with landscape fabric (negative control) when compared to plants grown in mushroom/microbially treated hemp mulch. The opposite effect was observed at the Minnesota site where plants grown in treated biomass yielded more than the control plots. Mushroom yield varied greatly by location. Stropharia treatment beds at Eden (VT) yielded the most mushrooms throughout the 2023 season followed by the beds at Alburgh (VT). Beds at the Minnesota site did not fruit until late fall and total mushroom production was significantly less compared to the Vermont sites.

Publications