Source: SHERLOCK BIOSCIENCES, INC. submitted to NRP
FIELD-DEPLOYABLE CRISPR-BASED DIAGNOSTICS FOR IMPROVED BIOSECURITY IN AQUACULTURE
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1030184
Grant No.
2023-33530-39561
Cumulative Award Amt.
$174,957.00
Proposal No.
2023-00996
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2023
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2024
Grant Year
2023
Program Code
[8.7]- Aquaculture
Recipient Organization
SHERLOCK BIOSCIENCES, INC.
200 TALCOTT AVE
WATERTOWN,MA 02472
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Rapid and accurate health assessment of farmed animals is critical to US aquaculture and agriculture. It is hindered by the cost, time, and technical expertise required for standard diagnostic methods, resulting in reduced capacity for disease control and production losses. Our goal is to transform US animal production by developing rapid, inexpensive, sensitive, field-deployable CRISPR-based diagnostics that enable farmers to effectively monitor and respond to disease outbreaks, validate pathogen-free status of broodstock, and screen imported materials for threats. The target pathogen for this Phase I project is White Spot Syndrome Virus (WSSV), a devastating virus that disrupts shrimp farm operations worldwide, resulting in billions of dollars in lost production. WSSV is highly virulent, leading to mass mortality such that early, rapid detection is critical to prevent catastrophic losses and mitigate spread. The specific objectives of this project are to (1) advance an established WSSV CRISPR-based diagnostic assay to be compatible with a cartridge-based diagnostic device ("PowerLite") developed by Sherlock Biosciences, (2) develop a simple field-based sample collection procedure compatible with the CRISPR detection cartridge (3) test the field deployable WSSV cartridge on the "PowerLite" prototype. This innovative technology would improve biomonitoring practices by enabling shrimp farmers to more rapidly and accurately screen for, and respond to, WSSV. It would provide a platform that could extend to other animal pathogens that impact US aquaculture and agriculture. This provides a unique business opportunity for Sherlock Biosciences to expand its technology platform beyond human health to domestic and global food security.
Animal Health Component
100%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
100%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
31137991040100%
Knowledge Area
311 - Animal Diseases;

Subject Of Investigation
3799 - Cultured aquatic animals, general/other;

Field Of Science
1040 - Molecular biology;
Goals / Objectives
Rapid and accurate health assessment of farmed animals is critical to US aquaculture and agriculture. It is hindered by the cost, time, and technical expertise required for standard diagnostic methods, resulting in reduced capacity for disease control and production losses. Our goal is to transform US animal production by developing rapid, inexpensive, sensitive, field-deployable CRISPR-based diagnostics that enable farmers to effectively monitor and respond to disease outbreaks, validate pathogen-free status of broodstock, and screen imported materials for threats. The target pathogen for this Phase I project is White Spot Syndrome Virus (WSSV), a devastating virus that disrupts shrimp farm operations worldwide, resulting in billions of dollars in lost production. WSSV is highly virulent, leading to mass mortality such that early, rapid detection is critical to prevent catastrophic losses and mitigate spread. The specific objectives of this project are to (1) advance an established WSSV CRISPR-based diagnostic assay to be compatible with a cartridge-based diagnostic device ("PowerLite") developed by Sherlock Biosciences, (2) develop a simple field-based sample collection procedure compatible with the CRISPR detection cartridge (3) test the field deployable WSSV cartridge on the "PowerLite" prototype. This innovative technology would improve biomonitoring practices by enabling shrimp farmers to more rapidly and accurately screen for, and respond to, WSSV. It would provide a platform that could extend to other animal pathogens that impact US aquaculture and agriculture. This provides a unique business opportunity for Sherlock Biosciences to expand its technology platform beyond human health to domestic and global food security.
Project Methods
The reaction chemistry will be converted to a mix that has already been optimized by Sherlock Biosciences for compatibility. Because LAMP is common between the WSSV SHERLOCKv2 fluorescent assay and the Sherlock Biosciences optimized chemistries, the same WSSV target and LAMP primer set will be used and GMGI will share these materials with Sherlock Biosciences. The LAMP primer set targets WSSV viral protein 28. Because the SherlockTM optimized mix uses a different Cas enzyme than the WSSV SHERLOCKv2 assay (Ssp Cas12a instead of Aap Cas12b), a new guide RNA will be commercially synthesized to contain the scaffold sequence compatible with Ssp Cas12a. Sherlock Biosciences routinely uses guide RNAs synthesized by IDT in assay development.After obtaining the Ssp Cas12a guide RNA containing the VP28 spacer sequence, collateral cleavage efficiency will be confirmed in one-pot LAMP + Cas12a reactions in microwell format. Preliminary evaluation will be done using synthetic WSSV DNA target as input, and collateral cleavage reporter fluorescence will be measured with a qPCR machine. A robust reaction will yield a fluorescent signal ≥ 10,000X above background in under 20 minutes when one million copies of target is present. Next, the same evaluation will be done using genomic DNA as input isolated from a shrimp sample infected with ≥ one million WSSV copies previously quantified by the WSSV SHERLOCKv2 assay and qPCR. GMGI will provide Sherlock Biosciences with this input material. Then, a 10-fold dilution series of both synthetic and genomic targets will be tested to assess the sensitivity of the new chemistry. Assay conversion will be considered successful if the assay can detect ≤ 100 copies and can show distinguishable differences between dilutions (with fluorescence showing a Pearson's correlation of ≥ 0.8 with viral copies). The sensitivity will also be compared with that of the lab-based WSSV SHERLOCKv2 assay, and a Pearson's correlation above 0.5 for commonly tested sample dilutions will be considered successful. Should any of the above evaluations not result in success, reaction mix optimizations will be made to increase sensitivity and reduce time-to-result. This may include addition of a chemical additive (e.g. 200mM glycine), altering guide RNA:Cas12a ratio, altering dNTP and magnesium concentrations, temperature, the sequence length of fluorescent reporter, and the addition of displacement primers. Sherlock Biosciences has found all of these to improve assay performance. If sensitivity and time-to-result needs to be increased further, we will evaluate the benefits of multiplexing another LAMP primer set and guide RNA to target a different but equally conserved and specific WSSV genomic region. Finally, specificity will be evaluated by checking for cross-reactivity with clinically relevant titers of common viruses (n = 5 for each EMS, EHP, IHHNV, IMNV and TSV - infected shrimp) as well as estimating the false positive rate from specific pathogen-free shrimp (n = 20).After confirming sensitivity and specificity comparable to existing technologies, we will convert the assay from liquid-based microwell format to cartridge-based format by lyophilizing reaction components to be compatible with the PowerLite. The same reaction mix formulation and lyophilization procedure that led to success will be attempted. The reaction mix includes 10% trehalose and 1% dextran in addition to the same reaction components used in the liquid format above. If needed, enzyme levels can be increased to maintain reaction efficiency. Prior to lyophilization and to facilitate cartridge assembly, the reaction mix is added to liquid nitrogen to freeze all components and generate Lyo-beads. Lyo-beads will be tested for successful lyophilization through rehydration and microwell plate testing using positive and negative control purified shrimp DNA as described in Objective 1.1. A successful lyophilization will show a fluorescence signal ≥ 10,000X above background in ≤ 20 minutes for a shrimp sample infected with ≥ one million WSSV copies compared to a specific pathogen-free shrimp sample.Lab-based diagnostics require nucleic acid input to be purified, which has time and cost constraints. To circumvent these, different field-deployable sample collection methods will be tested for compatibility with the PowerLite device. Current human diagnostics developed for the PowerLite device process total nucleic acids from saliva or nasal swabs that are immersed in TE buffer pH 8.0 and heated at 90°C for 3 minutes in the presence of a reducing agent to inhibit RNase activity. We will attempt to use a similar nucleic acid preparation methodology on samples collected from either swabbing shrimp tissue or a lysate created through crude mechanical disruption. If needed, a small mesh screen can be added to the device to prevent the lysate slurry from clogging downstream components. We will first attempt this on abdominal muscle tissue of WSSV-infected shrimp. If the yield is too low, we will experiment with other tissue types (e.g. pleopods, gills) and lysis additives (e.g. 15 mM NaOH to help dissolve cell membranes).The effects of different sample collection methods on reaction efficiency will be compared initially using the lab based microwell fluorescent assay. Samples collected from highly infected shrimp will be compared to purified genomic DNA from infected shrimp (positive control, n = 20) and from specific pathogen-free shrimp (negative control, n = 20). A sample collection method that shows a positive agreement of ≥95% and a negative agreement of 100% will be considered a success. Next, the effect of sample collection on assay sensitivity will be tested by collecting samples from the same infected individual using different sample collection methods. Samples will be diluted in a 10-fold dilution series and tested in the lab based microwell fluorescent assay. Limit of detection will be compared across sample collection methods and the method that enables detection of ≤100 copies per reaction will be considered successful.Lyophilized reaction components created in Objective 1 will be assembled onto the PowerLite-compatible plastic cartridges manually and sealed with pressure-sensitive adhesive film in a dry box. The device uses a sample analysis algorithm to give a binary readout ('positive' or 'negative'). This device will be calibrated using purified genomic DNA isolated from a shrimp sample with high viral load (>1 million copies per microliter) and from a pathogen-free shrimp sample. These samples will serve as positive and negative controls to train the sample analysis algorithm to make appropriate calls. Once calibrated, we will test a dilution series to continue to train the device to distinguish between negative and positive samples at the limit of detection. After device calibration is complete and the device is consistently making correct calls, we will then test positive (n = 20) and negative (n = 20) shrimp samples prepared using the sample collection method determined in Objective 2. If there is less than 95% positive agreement and 100% negative agreement, or if the method negatively impacts the fluidic movement within the cartridge, the sample preparation method will be determined not suitable for the cartridge. Method modifications and alternative sample collection methods will be tested for compatibility with the cartridge until ≥95% positive and 100% negative agreement are reached. Next, on-device sample preparation will be tested using the determined sample collection method. A variety of infected individuals ranging in viral load (n = 30; previously quantified by qPCR and WSSV SHERLOCKv2 assay) will be sampled and run to assess sensitivity of the cartridge-based assay. In this initial diagnostic performance evaluation, a diagnostic sensitivity of ≥98% will be acceptable.

Progress 07/01/23 to 08/30/24

Outputs
Target Audience:Target audiences reached by our efforts during the reporting period from November 2023 to August 2024 included over 3,000 attendees of the 2024 Plant Animal Genome conference, 500 attendees of the 2024 Shrimp Summit, 6 industry leaders through targeted interviews and 30 industry experts through our online survey, in addition to a presentation to representatives from Gorton's Seafood.? Changes/Problems: 1. The Sherlock "PowerLite" platform was supplanted by the Sherlock Veros device after Sherlock acquired Sense Biodectection in early 2023. 2. There were delays in lyophilized bead manufacturing that postponed on-device testing by approximately two months. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? 1. Merry Moore worked at Sherlock Biosciences as a post-bacc intern from July-October 2023 and carried out laboratory experiments for this project under the supervision of Dr. Mary Wilson and Scientist Kristen Shytle. She also received professional development mentorship from Dr. Wilson and Kristen. 2. Merry Moore worked at GMGI as a post-bacc intern from November 2023- February 2024 and carried out laboratory experiments for this project under the supervision of Dr. Shelly Trigg. She also received professional development mentorship from Dr. Shelly Trigg and Dr. Andrea Bodnar. 3. Dr. Shelly Trigg had the opportunity to attend a conference in India, 2024 Shrimp Summit where she was able to grow her professional network, and gain international visibility as aquaculture diagnostics expert. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Results have been disseminated through interviews with 6 internationally recognized industry leaders, presenting a pitch and networking at the 2024 Shrimp Summit in Chennai, India that had roughly 500 international attendees.? What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? We have completed the research proposed for our Phase I project resulting in a proof-of-concept demonstration of the end-to-end workflow on a commercially viable device. We accomplished Objective 1 of advancing a lab-based genetic WSSV CRISPR diagnostic assay developed at Gloucester Marine Genomics Institute (GMGI) to a rapid user-friendly, field-deployable assay using Sherlock Biosciences' Veros lateral flow device, removing technical challenges associated with laboratory diagnostics (e.g. PCR). We successfully converted the assay to Sherlock Biosciences' optimized chemistry and demonstrated that a simplified version of the assay with dehydrated reaction components worked with greater WSSV detection sensitivity than the original assay detecting as few as 10 copies in 25 minutes. We simultaneously developed internal control (targeting the shrimp gene EF1a) to use in tandem with our WSSV assay, and showed that both WSSV and EF1a dehydrated reaction components could be multiplexed during lateral flow. We accomplished Objective 2 by developing a simple field-based sample collection procedure compatible with the simplified assay. We tested a variety of lysis methods and identified the simplest, top-performing method, which involved pinching off a small piece of shrimp tissue (~10 mg), adding it to a soft plastic dropper tube containing alkaline lysis buffer, and squeezing the tube 10-30 seconds to release nucleic acid. We accomplished Objective 3 by assembling the dehydrated reaction components on the Veros lateral flow device and testing detection performance with synthetic DNA, genomic DNA, and a number of WSSV-infected and non-WSSV-infected shrimp samples. We found comparable WSSV detection of 10 copies in 25 minutes. With the assembled Veros lateral flow devices, we were able to detect WSSV in tissue from infected shrimp prepared using the crude lysis method described above. We tested 35 WSSV-infected, 15 pathogen-free, and 20 non-WSSV-infected shrimp samples and detected WSSV in 100% of the WSSV-infected samples (35/35, 100% positive agreement) and did not detect WSSV in the pathogen-free or non-WSSV-infected samples (35/35 100% negative agreement). In all other on-device tests with synthetic target, purified genomic DNA, and crude lysates, we never detected WSSV in samples that did not contain WSSV target sequence and we always detected WSSV when at least 10 copies of WSSV target sequence were present. We have no invention disclosures, patent considerations, or equipment purchased to report. Towards market research, we conducted a survey that received 30 responses to-date from the shrimp industry members, 6 interviews with internationally recognized industry leaders, and pitched the diagnostic to roughly 500 international attendees at the 2024 Shrimp Summit in Chennai, India. With feedback we have received, we plan to submit a Phase II proposal to continue R&D to build a multiplexed test and increase our test cases by partnering with hatcheries that have already offered to do comparative testing with both qPCR and our devices on their shrimp. The resulting product will enable industry workers to effectively monitor and respond to disease outbreaks, validate quality of exported and imported feed, post-larvae, and broodstock.

Publications


    Progress 07/01/23 to 06/30/24

    Outputs
    Target Audience:Target audiences reached by our efforts during the reporting period from November 2023 to August 2024 included over 3,000 attendees of the 2024 Plant Animal Genome conference, 500 attendees of the 2024 Shrimp Summit, 6 industry leaders through targeted interviews and 30 industry experts through our online survey, in addition to a presentation to representatives from Gorton's Seafood.? Changes/Problems: 1. The Sherlock "PowerLite" platform was supplanted by the Sherlock Veros device after Sherlock acquired Sense Biodectection in early 2023. ? 2. There were delays in lyophilized bead manufacturing that postponed on-device testing by approximately two months. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Merry Moore worked at GMGI as a post-bacc intern from November 2023- February 2024 and carried out laboratory experiments for this project under the supervision of Dr. Shelly Trigg. She also received professional development mentorship from Dr. Shelly Trigg and Dr. Andrea Bodnar. Dr. Shelly Trigg had the opportunity to attend a conference in India, 2024 Shrimp Summit where she was able to grow her professional network, and gain international visibility as aquaculture diagnostics expert.? How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Results have been disseminated through interviews with 6 internationally recognized industry leaders, presenting a pitch and networking at the 2024 Shrimp Summit in Chennai, India that had roughly 500 international attendees.? What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? We have completed the research proposed for our Phase I project resulting in a proof-of-concept demonstration of the end-to-end workflow on a commercially viable device. During this project period, we successfully accomplished Objective 2 by developing a simple field-based sample collection procedure compatible with the simplified assay. We tested a variety of lysis methods and identified the simplest, top-performing method, which involved pinching off a small piece of shrimp tissue (~10 mg), adding it to a soft plastic dropper tube containing alkaline lysis buffer, and squeezing the tube 10-30 seconds to release nucleic acid. We successfully accomplished Objective 3 by assembling the dehydrated reaction components on the Veros lateral flow device and testing detection performance with synthetic DNA, genomic DNA, and a number of WSSV-infected and non-WSSV-infected shrimp samples. We found comparable WSSV detection of 10 copies in 25 minutes. With the assembled Veros lateral flow devices, we were able to detect WSSV in tissue from infected shrimp prepared using the crude lysis method described above. We tested 35 WSSV-infected, 15 pathogen-free, and 20 non-WSSV-infected shrimp samples and detected WSSV in 100% of the WSSV-infected samples (35/35, 100% positive agreement) and did not detect WSSV in the pathogen-free or non-WSSV-infected samples (35/35 100% negative agreement). In all other on-device tests with synthetic target, purified genomic DNA, and crude lysates, we never detected WSSV in samples that did not contain WSSV target sequence and we always detected WSSV when at least 10 copies of WSSV target sequence were present. We have no invention disclosures, patent considerations, or equipment purchased to report. Towards market research, we conducted a survey that received 30 responses to-date from the shrimp industry members, 6 interviews with internationally recognized industry leaders, and pitched the diagnostic to roughly 500 international attendees at the 2024 Shrimp Summit in Chennai, India. With feedback we have received, we plan to submit a Phase II proposal to continue R&D to build a multiplexed test and increase our test cases by partnering with hatcheries that have already offered to do comparative testing with both qPCR and our devices on their shrimp. The resulting product will enable industry workers to effectively monitor and respond to disease outbreaks, validate quality of exported and imported feed, post-larvae, and broodstock.

    Publications

    • Type: Journal Articles Status: Other Year Published: 2024 Citation: Wanamaker SA, Shytle K, Moore MC, Bodnar AG, and Wilson M (2024) New LAMP-based portable diagnostic outperforms PCR for rapid viral detection in aquaculture. BioTechniques. (Manuscript in preparation for submission this Fall).