Source: UNIVERSITY OF MAINE submitted to NRP
LEVERAGING THE CULTURAL AND ARTS AMENITIES OF RURAL COMMUNITIES TO PROMOTE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT/PROSPERITY AND SUPPORT HUMAN DIVERSITY
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1030172
Grant No.
2023-67023-39501
Cumulative Award Amt.
$224,809.00
Proposal No.
2022-10204
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2023
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2025
Grant Year
2023
Program Code
[A1661]- Innovation for Rural Entrepreneurs and Communities
Recipient Organization
UNIVERSITY OF MAINE
(N/A)
ORONO,ME 04469
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Many U.S. rural communities have economic development strategies that promote cultural amenities and performing arts to attract tourists and residents, and to improve community wellbeing. Despite the widespread use of cultural amenity and performing arts-based strategies, there is little research-based information about the ethnic and racial character of these place-making assets across U.S. regions. Also, there's a lack of understanding about their effects on rural economic development and prosperity.This project will fill these gaps with an assessment of the cultural amenities and performing arts activities of U.S. counties, with an emphasis on their ethnic and racial character, along with an analysis of their impacts on the economic development of regions. The study will use a new measure of the urban influence of U.S. counties to examine how the types of cultural amenities and performing arts activities vary across the rural-urban hierarchy, and to learn how the impacts of amenities and arts might differ across places.The project will generate two large publicly available databases: a county-level inventory of about 250,000 place-based assets (e.g., cultural amenities, performing arts) and county-level indicators of urban influence, which will complement existing indicators such as the USDA Urban Influence codes. Policymakers and rural development practitioners will use this information in local arts and economic development planning and benchmarking exercises, and other researchers will use this information in studies of rural economic development. Near the completion of our study, we will visit and share our results with economic development policymakers and practitioners, and leaders of local arts-based organizations. The project's ultimate goal is increased diversity of (and inclusion in) local culture and arts, and improved rural economic development.
Animal Health Component
60%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
20%
Applied
60%
Developmental
20%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
6096110301050%
6086050301050%
Goals / Objectives
The purpose of this study and future efforts that build from this seed grant-funded project is to leverage the place-making assets of rural areas to promote economic development/prosperity and support human diversity. Our objectives are to: (1) build a large-scale database of the cultural amenities and performing arts activities of U.S. counties, with an emphasis on their ethnic and racial character, (2) develop and implement a new continuous measure of urban influence for U.S. counties, (3) construct a wide variety of county-level indicators of economic development/prosperity and human diversity, (4) characterize the ethnic and racial diversity of community cultural amenities and performing arts activities, (5) explore the role of urban influence in explaining differences in cultural amenities and performing arts activities (and the ethnic and racial diversity of these place-making assets) across rural areas, and (6) analyze the effects of the "amount" and "diversity" of cultural amenities and performing arts activities on the economic development/prosperity and human diversity of rural communities.Based on the lessons learned while addressing these six objectives, a seventh objective is to assemble a project team of collaborators and partner organizations, identify sites for case studies and surveys, and set priorities for future research and outreach.
Project Methods
Techniques to be Employed: We will use standard data collection and cleaning techniques to build the database of cultural amenities and performing arts activities, and will match the addresses of these place-based assets to their counties of location using (for example) the HUD U.S. Postal Service Zip Code Crosswalk. To build the county-level measure of urban influence, we will use a VAR model and novel method for decomposing error variances into respective components. In the analysis of the diversity of cultural amenities and performing arts activities, we will use entropy measures of diversification and comparisons to a U.S. benchmark. The techniques used to examine the geographic distribution of cultural amenities and performing arts activities across the rural-urban continuum include descriptive analyses such as scatterplots and maps. To identify counties with an abundance (or lack) of place-making assets, we will analyze the residual of the amount of place-making assets relative to the amount predicted by a regression analysis. Finally, we will use the techniques of factor analysis and regression analysis to examine the importance of cultural amenities and performing arts activities to rural economic development/prosperity and human diversity. Factor analysis will be used to reduce the number of variables measuring cultural amenities and performing arts activities into a manageable number prior to conducting the regression analysis. The regression analysis techniques will include, where appropriate, spatial econometrics and methods to account for the potential endogeneity between the measures of regional economic development and prosperity, and the amount and diversity of cultural amenities and performing arts activities.Expected Results: We expect the project to generate a substantial amount of new information about the amount and diversity of cultural amenities and performing arts activities in U.S. rural areas. We expect to find large differences in these place-making assets across regions, with some clusters of communities having similar types of amenities. These differences are likely to be explained--at least in part--by a region's urban influence, heritage and history, and characteristics of the local population (including its diversity). We expect some of the cultural amenities and performing arts activities to be associated with some of the indicators of rural economic development/prosperity and human diversity. Finally, we expect to identify many communities and organizations that will make ideal partners for future research and outreach. How Data will be Analyzed or Interpreted: Data analysis will involve a variety of descriptive and econometric techniques. Given that results from this project will inform the selection of future case studies and survey research, the interpretation of some results will be "preliminary."Efforts to Cause Changes in Knowledge, Actions or Conditions: Results will be communicated using technical reports and data briefs, and via social media and YouTube videos. In year 2, we will present results at meetings and submit journal articles. In addition, we plan to visit 5 to 7 communities and/or organizations during year 2 of the project. During these visits, we will share results of the study and gather new information and feedback about cultural amenities and arts. The database of place-based assets and other county-level variables will be stored in a data repository and made available to others.The main project outputs are the seven activities (e.g., building the large-scale database of cultural amenities, meeting with community development and arts-based organizations) and the two products (e.g., publicly available database of amenities and arts, publicly available database of county-level urban influence). We will evaluate the impacts of the two products by monitoring the count of downloads and use by others. We will evaluate the impacts of the seven activities by monitoring feedback received from the stakeholder groups that we visit, and feedback received from our dissemination (e.g., social media posts, YouTube videos, technical reports) of project results.

Progress 07/01/23 to 06/30/24

Outputs
Target Audience:The target audience for this research project includes economic development professionals, state and local decisionmakers, individuals and organizations involved in cultural amenities and performing arts, and other researchers. During this review period, which covers the first year of the project, our efforts reached other researchers through a presentation at an academic conference. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided?The project provided training and professional development opportunities to three graduate students in UMaine's School of Economics. These students received training in a statistical technique used to measure econometric connectedness, and they applied this training to an analysis of the econometric connectedness of U.S. counties relative to selected U.S. metropolitan areas. The econometric connectedness "score" for each of the U.S. counties is a novel measure of urban influence.Two of the three graduate students gained experience in the communication of scientific results when they presented the research at an academic conference. How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Our results related to urban influence were disseminated to other researchers in a presentation at an academic conference. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?During the next reporting period, which is the second year of the project, we expect to conduct the research and analysis related to objectives 3 to 6 of the project. We have an undergraduate student working on the project this summer (2024) along with the funded graduate student, who willremain on the project through the summer of 2025. We will also use the information obtained on the cultural amenities and performing arts activities of U.S. counties, along with their level of urban influence, to identify sites for future case studies and/or surveys and set priorities for additional research and outreach. This will involve interacting with members of the target audience for this research project such as economic development professionals, state and local decisionmakers, individuals and organizations involved in cultural amenities and performing arts, and other researchers.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? During this review period, which covers the first year of the project, we made substantial progress toward meeting the first two project objectives. Related to objective 1, we built a large-scale database of over 225,000 cultural amenities and performing arts activities and, for a subset of these entries, we have compiled information on their ethnic and racial character. Related to objective 2, we have developed a new continuous measure of urban influence for U.S. counties. One version of this measure analyzes urban influence relative to New York, Los Angeles, and Chicago, which are the three largest U.S. metropolitan areas. A second version of this measure analyzes urban influence for U.S. counties relative to U.S. metropolitan areas with 5 million or more residents, which includes additional areas such as Atlanta, Dallas, Washington DC, and others.

Publications