Source: IOWA STATE UNIVERSITY submitted to NRP
UNDERSTANDING RURAL QUALITY OF LIFE IN AN ERA OF DEMOGRAPHIC TRANSITION AND COVID-19 RECOVERY: 2024 WAVE OF THE ISTP
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
ACTIVE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1030030
Grant No.
2023-67023-39289
Cumulative Award Amt.
$644,595.00
Proposal No.
2022-10213
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2023
Project End Date
Jun 30, 2027
Grant Year
2023
Program Code
[A1661]- Innovation for Rural Entrepreneurs and Communities
Recipient Organization
IOWA STATE UNIVERSITY
2229 Lincoln Way
AMES,IA 50011
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
The rural Midwest has experienced dramatic changes in health and social well-being over the past decade. There is an immediate need to understand the socioeconomic, health, and emotional impacts of COVID-19 in understudied rural communities, especially in hard-hit meatpacking towns dominated by persons of color (PoC). There is also a need to better understand how rural quality of life (QoL) is maintained in the face of sizable population loss; and how small towns can promote social integration and cohesion between long-time residents and new PoC. The long-term goal of this integrated research and extension project is to identify and disseminate effective place-based strategies to maintain QoL in small towns impacted by demographic changes and COVID. Our project addresses rural priorities of providing essential services like health and mental health, retaining businesses for a robust local economy, and addressing labor shortages and skill gaps. Our project gives voice to often marginalized PoC in meatpacking towns to better inform rural policy. Improving QoL, integration, and COVID recovery will help small towns thrive in the 21st century. The five main objectives of the project are to: (1) establish a stakeholder advisory panel and engage with study communities; (2) conduct a large-scale social survey across 125 small communities for the 2024 wave of the longitudinal Iowa Small Towns Project using mixed-mode techniques to better engage PoC; (3) understand the impact of demographic transitions and COVID on rural QoL, especially in diverse meatpacking towns; (4) identify effective local responses to improve rural QoL and COVID recovery using interviews; and (5) develop and disseminate extension curricula to improve rural resiliency and recovery.
Animal Health Component
80%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
20%
Applied
80%
Developmental
(N/A)
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
8036010308040%
8056050308040%
6086199301020%
Goals / Objectives
The long term goal of this integrated research and extension project is to identify and disseminate effective place-based strategies to maintain quality of life in small towns impacted by demographic changes and COVID-19 in the rural Midwest. We view demographic transition and COVID-19 as community shocks, the former being a longer term press event and the latter an unforeseen pulse event (Collins et al. 2011). We argue these shocks have the potential to negatively impact rural quality of life, but that negative effects can be mitigated by collective community action. Our specific rural quality of life outcomes are to maintain essential community services, improve health and mental health, promote economic security, and foster greater social capital and community cohesion. In particular, we seek to understand how these outcomes differ for rural residents of color in agricultural production and processing communities.The five main objectives of the project are to:Establish a stakeholder advisory panel and engage with study communities, especially in diverse meatpacking towns.Conduct a social survey for the 2024 wave of the longitudinal Iowa Small Towns Project using mixed-mode techniques to better engage rural people of color.Understand the impact of demographic transitions and COVID-19 on rural quality of life,especially in diverse meatpacking towns.Identify effective local responses to improve rural quality of life and COVID recovery.Develop and disseminate extension curricula to improve rural resiliency and recovery.
Project Methods
Objective 1 - Stakeholder advisory panel. In order to ensure our project has a high probability of success, we will establish an advisory panel comprised of key stakeholders who will guide development of our engagement strategies, data collection efforts, analysis methods, and publications and extension curricula. The advisory panel will consist of 6 to 8 individuals including local community leaders, state advocacy groups for persons of color and meatpacking workers, extension educators, and academic faculty in rural sociology and public health. The advisory panel will be instrumental in guiding development of the community survey and engagement strategies to increase response rates among marginalized groups (objective 2); and in the development of extension curricula and policy reports using ISTP data (objective 5). Efforts: Convene a face-to-face pre-work meeting in year 1 to review project.Hold virtual panel meetings at least twice a year throughout the project. Convene a face-to-face post-work meeting to develop plans for disseminating products. Evaluation: Panel members will rate project activities yearly on their usefulness to stakeholders, whether it addresses a community need, timeliness, and how PDs communicate with communities and stakeholders.Objectve 2 - 2024 wave of the ISTP. We will draw a random sample of housing units across 125 small towns in Iowa, of which 99 are part of the original Sigma Study with data back to 1994. Sigma towns were chosen by randomly selecting one town between 500 and 9,999 peoplein each of Iowa's 99 counties. We include 24 additional towns that serve as regional trade centers; and two replacement towns because of floods. Our general sample will randomly select the larger of 200 of 15% of occupied housing units.We draw a random persons of color oversample in 11 towns where people of color account for 20% or more of the population.Next, we will implement the survey using four mixed-mode contact treatments outlined by Dillman et al. (2014), that also includes a$2 incentive. To address likely low response in 6 meatpacking communities, we conduct non-probability purposive samples in each community, workingwith local partners. In total, N=33,486 households will be sampled. Lastly, we will process and publish the ISTP data, including post-stratification weights. Efforts:Develop and pre-test questionnaire.Random sample and survey in 125 towns.Purposive sample and survey of people of color in 6 meatpacking towns.Process and publish ISTP data. Evaluation: Response rates of 50% or more in each town and for the oversample. Maintain positive working relationships with local partners. Tracking downloads of town profiles and data files. Calls for presentations from towns and stakeholders.Objective 3 -Understand the impact of demographic transitions and COVID-19 on rural quality of life.Understand how demographic transitions impact social conditions that, in turn, impact community QoL. Our general model posits that demographic change will likely reduce social capital and QoL. However, we also posit that strong social capital in prior years will increase current social capital, which will trigger a community response of increased civic participation among residents and increased shared leadership among local leadersthat will increase QoL ratings by residents. These effects are hypothesized to offset any QoL declines driven by demographic changes. Understand how COVID-19 has impacted the health, mental health, and financial situations of rural residents. We hypothesize that greater levels of social capital will increase the effectiveness of local organizations in responding to the pandemic, thereby reducing COVID harm. We also posit that social capital will result in greater adherence to COVID mitigation strategies among residents that also reducesharm. We will estimate statistical models for all 125 towns, but will also conduct separate analyses for towns of certain size classes and ethno-racial compositions. We will identify towns that did better-than-predicted at maintaining QoL and minimizing COVID harm to inform policy and practice. Data will be primarily analyzed using multilevel structural equation models. Efforts: Perform statistical analyses of demographic and COVID impacts on rural quality of life. Conduct analysis looking a different strata, such as town size, persons of color, and disadvantaged status. Produce conference papers, journal articles, and applied extension bulletins. Evaluation: Presentations at national professional conferences. Submission and publication of articles in peer-reviewed journals. Publication on extension bulletins. Write various articles for The Conversation.Objective 4 - Identify effective local responses to improve rural quality of life and COVIDrecovery.We seek to understand the responses and strategies undertaken by towns to promote QoL and reduce COVID harm. We will accomplish this by conducting key informant interviews in carefully selected towns. Based on the regression results, we will identify towns that had better-than-predicted (more effective) and worse-than-predicted (less effective) QoL and COVID impact scores. Next, we will select 10 towns from both the more effective and less effective groups using propensity score matching techniques.In each of the 20 towns, we will conduct key informant interviews. To ensure prolonged engagement, two project staff will spend four days in each community to conduct a minimum of 15 interviews. To identify effective strategies,we will use a modified variant of Grounded Theory method from a Glaserian paradigm to identify emergent themes. Efforts: Conduct interviews in selected towns. Transcribe and code data. Conduct additional interviews. Transcribe and re-code. Identify emergent themes that are credible to stakeholders. Present and publish results. Evaluation: High cooperation rate with key informants. High evaluations of interview process by participants and stakeholders. Consensus on effective strategies by stakeholders and research team. Presentation and publication of results.Objective 5 -Develop and disseminate extension curricula.We will develop 3 extension educational programs: Resiliency in Shrinking Small Towns, Welcoming People of Color to Revitalize Small Towns, and Recovering from COVID in Small Towns. The extension program will include presentation slides, facilitator guide, notes on the research, and discussion questions. We will work closely with the advisory panel, community partners, and extension professionals at all stages of the curriculum development process.We will distribute extension curriculavia the project website, eXtension, RDCs, USDA multistate projects, and other relevant channels as identified by the stakeholders.

Progress 07/01/23 to 06/30/24

Outputs
Target Audience:Target audience this period were state and local partners who will assist in the design of the questionnaire and implementation of the survey to households. This includes the the director and staff at the Iowa Farm Bureau Federation, staff at the Ethnic Minorities of Burma Resource Center, respresentatives from the League of Latin America Citizens that included chapters in 4 meatpacking towns, city officials who are member of the Iowa Council of Governments, and extension agents in rural counties who work for Iowa State Extension. Changes/Problems:The questionnaire data collection was meant to go out in late summer 2024 or fall 2024. This was delayed at the request of stakeholders, who had concerns about the 2024 presidential election. The first concern was that our stakeholders in meatpacking towns were busy with voter registeration efforts, and did not have time for the survey. The second concern from all stakholders was that the ISTP questionnaire would be seen as political if it were distributed close to the election, given it contained questions about COVID and ethnic diversity. We thought it would reduce response rates if residents thought the survey hada political dimension. To give our stakeholders more time to work on election tasks, and to minimize any perceived politicalization of the ISTP survey, we decided to hold teh survey back to spring 2025. What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?Published one peer-reviewed journal article in Journal of Rural Studies. Submitted one paper for review in South Dakota Law Review. Published 3 extension bulletins documenting population, economic, and farm trends for Iowa rural and micropolitan areas between 2013-2023. Gave 9 invited presentations on demographic change, increasing diversity, and impacts on rural quality of life across Iowa. Key groups included Iowa Farm Bureau, Iowa Institute of Cooperatives, Iowa Healthcare Association, Rural School Advocates of Iowa, and rural communities. Presented 3 papers at professional conferences, including Midwest Sociological Society and the European Society for Rural Sociology Congress. 15 unique media spots on state and national news, including newspapers, radio, and TV in Iowa, the Midwest, and nationally. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Implement the survey this spring 2025, as election concerns delayed 2024 implementation.

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? Objective 1 - Stakeholder Advisory Panel The stakeholder advisory panel of 16 persons were assembled. Panel included academics and extension educators at ISU, staff from Iowa Farm Bureau Federation, staff from Ethnic Minorities of Burma Advocacy Resource Center, chapter presidents of League of United Latin American Citizens, city officials from the Iowa Council of Governments, and citizens from 2 small towns. Panel meet 7 times as a group, however, meetings occured more often with a few stakeholders. Objective 2 - Conduct the 2024 ISTP Survey The questionnaire was designed, developed, and reviewed by PIs and stakeholder advisory members. The questionnaire was pretested. Currently in the process of translation. IRB / Human Subjects approval was obtained. The interview protocol for community site visits was developed and review by PIs and advisory panel.IRB / Human Subjects approval was obtained. The ISTP project office was established and equipped to process and store questionnaires. A secure 544 sq ft office was established, that has a locked outer door and located on a floor that has restricted access through a cardkey. The office is at 412 East Hall at Iowa State.We acquired 4 new desktop PCs for 5 workstations for data entry and analysis. The lab has a OCR scanner. The space also has locked file cabinents to store questionnaires. Acquired housing unit addresses for all 125 ISTP towns. A random sample was drawn for each town with a minimum of 250 housing units up to 15% of all housing units. This resulted in a random sample of 33,000 housing unit addresses. Produced 125 5x7 inch color postcard mailers to be used as prenotification for the questionnaire. Mailers have information about the 2024 ISTP on one side, and the other side has two charts of prior years data specific to that community. Mailers will be sent to all 33,000 households. Objective 3 - Understand Impacts of Demograhic Change and COVID-19 on Rural Quality of Life Built two longitudinal databases, one on quality of life measuresand the other on social capital / community attachment measures for the 1994, 2004, and 2014 waves. Individual data with poststratification weights were used to create town averages for all 100 towns in teh ISTP. Data by towns was disaggregated by sex (2 categories), age (3 categories), tenure (3 categories), and income (4 categories). Will be used for analysis and for a web database. Objective 4 - Identify Local Responses to Improve Rural Quality of Life Nothing to report. Objective 5 - Develop and Disseminate Information Established ISTP project website https://smalltowns.soc.iastate.edu Developed query-based website to make the quality of life and social capital databases available to the public. Program is in Python and will be hosted by Iowa State. 2024 data will be added in future.

Publications

  • Type: Peer Reviewed Journal Articles Status: Published Year Published: 2023 Citation: Matysiak, I., & Peters, D. 2023. Conditions Facilitating Aging in Place in Rural Communities: The Case of Smart Senior Towns in Iowa. Journal of Rural Studies 97:507-513.
  • Type: Peer Reviewed Journal Articles Status: Submitted Year Published: 2023 Citation: Peters, D., Bartling, E., & Meyer, E. Understanding Rural Legal Deserts to Inform Public Policy: Identifying and Describing Lawyer Gaps in Non-Metropolitan Counties. Under review in South Dakota Law Review.
  • Type: Other Status: Published Year Published: 2023 Citation: Peters, D. 2023. Rural Iowa At a Glance 2023, Population Trends. SOC 3104A, December. Iowa State University Extension.
  • Type: Other Status: Published Year Published: 2023 Citation: Peters, D. 2023. Rural Iowa At a Glance 2023, Economic Trends. SOC 3104B, December. Iowa State University Extension.
  • Type: Other Status: Published Year Published: 2023 Citation: Peters, D. 2023. Rural Iowa At a Glance 2023, Farm Trends. SOC 3104C, December. Iowa State University Extension.