Source: Micronic Technologies, Inc. submitted to NRP
TORNADIC WATER PURIFICATION FOR ABANDONED MINE SITES ON FEDERAL LAND
Sponsoring Institution
National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Project Status
COMPLETE
Funding Source
Reporting Frequency
Annual
Accession No.
1029996
Grant No.
2023-33530-39236
Cumulative Award Amt.
$181,500.00
Proposal No.
2023-00735
Multistate No.
(N/A)
Project Start Date
Jul 1, 2023
Project End Date
Feb 28, 2025
Grant Year
2023
Program Code
[8.1]- Forests & Related Resources
Recipient Organization
Micronic Technologies, Inc.
201 Davis Drive, Unit E
Reston,VA 20164
Performing Department
(N/A)
Non Technical Summary
Under prior funding from the USDA, Micronic has developed a prototype engineering design for processing cheese manufacturing wastewater in a controlled manufacturing environment. Anticipated results of the Phase I program effort will build off this core technology and develop a proof-of-concept demonstration for application to federal forest land abandoned mine sites. Given the considerable differences between the controlled environment of a manufacturing facility and the remote, corrosive, field environment of an abandoned mine site, the effort will require not only the demonstration of the technology when run against wastewater streams but also the identification of a system layout which incorporates significant innovations. In the USDA-NIFA-SBIR-009301 funding opportunity Topic Area 8.1, Forests and Related Resources, Subtopic 3. Reducing Ecological Damage by Forest Operations, the USDA identified a need for new and innovative technologies focused on reducing water degradation located on federal lands and reducing impacts to the ecological structure of the operational area. In response to this need, Micronic Technologies will develop a water purification system based on the company's tornadic water purification technology for application to abandoned mines and associated mining-influenced waters and acid mine drainage (MIW/AMD) on federal land. Work to accomplish this goal is structured around four technical objectives; identify abandoned mine sample sites and acquire wastewater samples, process and analyze samples, identify a preliminary Phase II demonstration system layout, and conduct a market study of the technology for MIW/AMD remediation on federal lands.Ultimately, the successful implementation of the system which doesn't use filters, membranes, or chemicals will be transformative for water purification technology. Potential commercial application and market impacts of such a commercialization effort would be significant and can be applied to a broad range of wastewater treatment solutions. The value proposition of the technology is found in an increase in water reuse, a reduction in water treatment costs, and increased responsiveness to environmental regulation. Improvements are realized in a range of areas including water reclamation from non-traditional sources and water reuse. This will lower water usage expenses, provide more clean water, and create potential ancillary revenue from the reuse of recovered clean water, and the monetization of a proactive approach to federal, local, and state environmental regulatory compliance with an associated reduction in regulatory noncompliance.
Animal Health Component
50%
Research Effort Categories
Basic
(N/A)
Applied
50%
Developmental
50%
Classification

Knowledge Area (KA)Subject of Investigation (SOI)Field of Science (FOS)Percent
11202102050100%
Knowledge Area
112 - Watershed Protection and Management;

Subject Of Investigation
0210 - Water resources;

Field Of Science
2050 - Hydrology;
Goals / Objectives
In the USDA-NIFA-SBIR-009301 funding opportunity Topic Area 8.1, Forests and Related Resources, Subtopic 3. Reducing Ecological Damage by Forest Operations, the USDA identified a need for new and innovative technologies focused on reducing water degradation located on federal lands and reducing impacts to the ecological structure of the operational area. In response to this need, Micronic Technologies is investigating the development of a water purification system based on the company's tornadic evaporation technology with the goal of environmental remediation of mining-influenced water (MIW) and acid mine drainage (AMD) at abandoned mines on federal land.Under prior funding from the USDA, Micronic has developed a prototype engineering design for processing cheese manufacturing wastewater in a controlled manufacturing environment. Anticipated results of the Phase I program effort will build off this core technology with the goal of developing a proof-of-concept demonstration for application to federal forest land operations. Given the considerable differences between the controlled environment of a manufacturing facility and the remote, corrosive, field environment of an abandoned mine site, the effort will require not only the demonstration of the technology when run against wastewater streams but also the identification of a system layout which incorporates significant innovations to the technology.Work to accomplish the program goals is structured around four Technical Objectives (TO's) as follows.TO 1. Identify mine sample sites and acquire wastewater samplesWorking with the USDA, Micronic and TRC, the Consultant to the Program, will identify at least two problematic closed mine sites under USDA stewardship for MIW/AMD sampling. TRC will provide Micronic with samples from the selected sites. Questions to be addressed will focus on developing a sample set which is representative of a range of constituent profiles for abandoned mine sites on federal lands.TO 2. Process and analyze samplesWastewater samples from each of the mine sites identified in TO 1 will be processed by the Micronic laboratory proof-of-concept demonstrator. Questions to be addressed will examine the resulting clean product water and collected waste to provide insight on the system performance in the various identified MIW/AMD wastewater applications.TO 3. Identify a preliminary Phase II demonstration system layoutUtilizing data gathered in TO 1 and TO 2, a preliminary Phase II layout will be identified. The layout will be based on the core tornadic evaporation technology supported by a range of enhancements to assess field installation issues related to abandoned mine site environments. Questions to be addressed will be directed toward layout functionality (e.g., volatile fume mitigation, self-contained heat exchanger cooling, design of a corrosion-resistant process path, etc.) and supporting site structures (e.g., access, power, wastewater, and clean water handling, etc.).TO 4. Conduct market study of the technology for MIW/AMD remediation on federal landsMicronic Technologies in collaboration with the selected Technical and Business Assistance (TABA) vendor, RTI International Research Institute, will develop a market study to assess the commercial viability of the technology for purification of MIW/AMD. In addition, Return-on-Investment analyses will be conducted using operational and capital expenses for each of the mine site scenarios identified in TO 1. Questions to be addressed will consider the economic feasibility of the technology for application to abandoned mine sites on federal land.
Project Methods
It is intended the work to be conducted on the program be based on an overall research approach structured to achieve goals of the technical objectives. To accomplish this, the Phase I Work Plan consists of four main tasking elements with methods directly correlating to the four program technical objectives (TO's).TO 1. Identify mine sample sites and acquire wastewater samplesTo accomplish this objective, working with the USDA Forest Service, Micronic and TRC, the Consultant to the Program, will identify at least two problematic closed mine sites under Forest Service stewardship for mining-influenced water and acid mine drainage (MIW/AMD) sampling. TRC will be the lead on this work and will utilize their mine site expertise to select potential candidate sites based on impaired water profiles and disposal processes. The site reviews will consider a range of physical, economic, and regulatory variables. The reviews will investigate constituent profiles and concentrations, drainage flow volumes, current cost of remediation efforts, regulatory constraints, etc. The goal is to acquire an understanding of the geology, chemistry, management procedures and costs, and regulatory drivers defining the structure and management of each site. Understanding the "inner workings" of a specific site will be key to the successful remediation at that site. Accordingly, the review process will strive to define a top-level conceptual site model (CSM) from existing documentation such as geologic and hydrologic surveys. In many cases, detailed CSM's will already exist. In addition, detailed chemical analyses providing a constituent profile of the sites are probably already available. TRC will collect samples from each of the candidate sites and deliver the samples to Micronic's facility in Bristol, Virginia for processing. TRC will work with Micronic to determine appropriate engineering and safety protocols for handling and treating wastewater samples. TO 2. Processing and analysis of samplesTo accomplish this technical objective, wastewater samples from each of the selected sites identified in TO 1 will be collected by TRC and processed by Micronic in the company's facility in Bristol, Virginia. Micronic will be responsible for sample processing and operation of the laboratory processing equipment while TRC will be responsible for sample transport and the analysis of clean water product and waste concentrate in their laboratories or by third party vendors. Micronic will report processing metrics including, purge times, flow rates, and times of operation while TRC will be responsible for reporting the chemical characteristics of the AMD wastewater influent, clean water product, and concentrate of the testing process. The goal of this effort will be to assess system performance against MIW/AMD waste streams.TO 3. Identify a preliminary Phase II demonstration system layout To accomplish TO 3, data gathered in TO 1 and TO 2 will be used to identify a preliminary Phase II system layout. The system will be based on the core Micronic technology supported by a range of enhancements to assess field installation issues related to abandoned mine site environments. The preliminary layout will include unit-specific details such as volatile fume mitigation, self-contained heat exchanger cooling, and layout of a corrosion-resistant process path. The second part of the preliminary layout will address supporting site-specific structures. To accomplish this, Micronic will collaborate with TRC. Preliminary site layout elements will consider access infrastructure for influent handling (e.g., piping, holding tanks, etc.) and the handling of the clean water product and the wastewater concentrate (e.g., discharge piping, holding tanks, transportation or other disposal methods, transport facilities, etc.). In Phase II of the program, a complete design will be developed including civil and mechanical information for installation at a selected site.TO 4. Market study of the technology for wastewater remediation at MIW/AMD sites on federal landsThe accomplishment of TO 4 will entail conducting a market study to assess commercial viability of the technology for mitigation of water degradation and reduction of environmental impact at MIW/AMD sites on federal lands and the completion of Return-on-Investment (ROI) analyses using operational (OPEX) and capital expenses (CAPEX) for each of the sites identified in TO 1. TRC will provide current and future cost information about each of the selected TO 1 sites. This assessment will be conducted by Micronic Technologies in collaboration with the selected Technical and Business Assistance (TABA) vendor, RTI International Research Institute (RTI), who will develop a market study to assess the commercial viability of the technology for purification of MIW/AMD. Micronic will compare CAPEX and OPEX of current site remediation against CAPEX and OPEX of a Micronic installation at the site and generate a break-even analysis for installation of the technology.The program milestones closely correlate to the program technical objectives.September 2023 - Acquisition of MIW/AMD samples from SAMS'sDecember 2023 - Complete processing/analysis of samplesFebruary 2024 - Complete preliminary system layout and market study

Progress 07/01/23 to 02/28/25

Outputs
Target Audience:The initial audience for this technology will be the U.S. Forest Service for use at abandoned mine sites on federal land. Once demonstrated and commercialized, the potential audience widens to mining sites across the U.S. The issue of mining influenced water/acid mine drainage (MIW/AMD) from closed mines hits close to home for Micronic. Micronic's home is in the Appalachian region of Southwest Virginia, where MIW/AMD leaches into watersheds and eventually into local aquifers. Such sites have long-term health hazards to aquatic and other life requiring increasingly advanced solutions to keep our waters clean. In the Central Appalachian coalfields near mine sites there are elevated concentrations of major chemical ions in streams, degraded water quality levels that are acutely lethal to standard laboratory test organisms, and levels of selenium concentrations which are toxic in fish and birds. These environmental water issues are the direct result of MIW/AMD at shuttered mine sites. These man-made environmental degradations are legacy years in the making. MIW/AMD have impaired thousands of miles of streams in Appalachia, transforming them into metal-rich, acidic waters and sediments which, in turn, have poisoned the aquatic habitat with potentially hazardous toxin levels and created conditions of severe nutrient limitations. Ultimately, the potential audience for this revolutionary technology is as broad as there are uses of water. Because water is such a ubiquitous presence in everyday life, there's a temptation to consider applications far too broadly for successful commercialization. Micronic is confident its validated technology can remove high concentrations of impurities from a wide range of contaminated water but clearly understands there are numerous other technologies already in the water treatment marketplace. Rather than seek entry where other technologies and treatment infrastructures are already firmly entrenched, Micronic has narrowed its target commercial entry point to very specific markets to which it is particularly well suited. It is anticipated one of the viable markets will be remediation of MIW/AMD and the resulting conversion of waste streams into non-traditional clean water sources. It is anticipated the technology will concentrate a "waste liquid" by a factor 20x thus reducing the waste volumes to be managed and, subsequently reducing operational costs. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?The Phase I research results have been made known to the consultants on the program; RTI and TRC. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals? Nothing Reported

Impacts
What was accomplished under these goals? All technical objectives were successfully realized. In the Phase I program, Micronic pursued four key technical objectives (TO's). In TO 1, the focus was on identifying abandoned mine sample sites and acquiring wastewater samples. TO 2 focused on upgrading and optimizing our laboratory system for application to mining influenced water/acid mine drainage (MIW/AMD) remediation. This unit was then used to process the wastewater samples collected in TO 1 to demonstrate the technology's effectiveness in treating MIW/AMD. TO 3 focused on developing a preliminary demonstration system layout, and, finally in TO 4 a comprehensive market study was conducted to assess the viability and impact of the technology for MIW/AMD remediation. Work on TO 1 focused on the identification of candidate MIW/AMD sites. After a review of several sites, TRC provided Micronic with samples from three selected sites for testing (i.e., Letcher County, Kentucky, Knott County, Kentucky, and Perry County, Kentucky). TO 2 involved a dual-pronged approach. Initially, efforts were directed toward upgrading and optimizing the laboratory proof of concept demonstration system in readiness for processing MIW/AMD samples. This optimization encompassed a series of upgrades including; the replacement of the original diesel engine which powered the system with an electric motor, installation of an advanced control system tuned to the advanced performance of the upgraded system, installation of a ruggedized coated blower, replacement of the air-driven water pump for the concentration tanks with an electric pump, and the design, fabrication and installation of an advanced separator. Subsequently, wastewater samples from the three selected sites were processed by Micronic at its Bristol, Virginia facility. This was followed by a third party laboratory analysis of the influent, the clean water product and the waste concentrate by Enthalpy Analytical in Richmond, Virginia. The analytical testing performed by Enthalpy evaluated key water quality parameters including metal concentrations, total dissolved solids (TDS), pH levels, sulfate concentrations, and other site-specific contaminants of concern. The results from these analyses provided quantitative evidence of the system's effectiveness in treating MIW/AMD from multiple sources with varying contaminant profiles. The main constituents in samples from the Letcher County, KY site were significantly reduced by the following percentages; Calcium 98.36%, Iron 100.00%, Potassium 100.00%, Magnesium 98.27%, Sodium 89.68%, Sulfate 100.00%, and TDS 94.58%. The main constituents in samples from the Knott County, KY site were significantly reduced by the following percentages; Calcium 98.02%, Potassium 100.00%, Magnesium 97.31%, Sodium 99.71%, Chloride 99.59%, Sulfate 99.59%, and TDS 99.33%. The main constituents in samples from the Perry County, KY site were significantly reduced by the following percentages; Calcium 99.11%, Iron 100.00%, Magnesium 99.60%, Manganese 99.80%, Zinc 99.15%, Chloride 100.00%, Sulfate 99.55%, and TDS 99.16%, A preliminary demonstration system layout was developed in TO 3. The top level design drew on data and insights gathered during TO 1 and TO 2. The design is centered on the tornadic process while incorporating supporting systems for field operations. The core design philosophy emphasizes modularity and transportability through a dual-trailer configuration. This will ensure rapid deployment and operational flexibility across diverse field environments. The first trailer serves as the primary processing unit, housing the tornadic purification unit and associated control systems. This trailer includes an integrated influent holding tank sized to maintain continuous operation while accommodating typical flow rate variations. The second trailer functions as the water management center, containing separate storage systems for processed clean water and concentrated waste. This trailer also houses an electric generator system, providing power generation capability when grid power is unavailable. Future design refinement will focus on optimizing the system layout through detailed civil and mechanical engineering specifications. A market study of the tornadic water purification technology was conducted by the Technical and Business Assistance vendor, RTI International, during TO 4 to assess commercial viability of the technology for mitigation of MIW/AMD and recovery of critical minerals from the waste concentrate. A summary of the main conclusions of the study follows. • The U.S. Federal government has made domestic production of rare earth elements (REE's) and critical minerals (CM's) a strategic priority, creating a significant driver for adoption of new technologies that can economically produce them. • AMD is a significant source of domestic raw material with high concentrations of REE's and CM's. Flows of AMD streams range from 20 to 200 gallons per minute. To penetrate the market, Micronic must develop a system on the order of 50,000 GPD (35 GPM) to match capacity of a significant number of streams. • There are many options for treating AMD, including options very low in cost when neutralization with lime is sufficient to restore water quality. • When AMD streams contain high levels of nitrates or selenium, additional treatment steps are required. Micronic Technologies' tornadic water purification process has the potential to treat these streams in a single step, avoiding multi-step, complex treatment systems and, accordingly, offers the potential to reduce cost. • The concentrate produced by the tornadic process is potentially less costly to process than concentrated AMD sludge from retention ponds, which are currently used as feedstock for REE processing operations because it is expected to be higher in REE/CM content. • The total cost of ownership (TCO) for tornadic processing was compared to the state of the art in AMD treatment in 2 cases: 1) low flow (50,000 GPD), as a stand-alone treatment option and 2) high flow (750,000 GPD RO reject) as a replacement for the brine concentration step. • In the low-flow case, capital cost and energy cost were higher for the tornadic system than for a treatment train consisting of clarification, precipitation, and reverse osmosis steps to treat AMD with high concentration of nitrates. However, the ability to deliver a self-contained, mobile solution could make the tornadic system an attractive alternative where land suitable for a multi-process train is not available. • In the high-flow case, the tornadic system offers potential for significant savings by replacing brine concentrators and crystallizers, evaporative systems with high CAPEX and OPEX, due to the need for treatment chemicals and use of high-cost materials. The large scale of the high-flow case means this use case represents a long-term opportunity for Micronic. Micronic's tornadic water purification technology demonstrates significant potential for remediation of MIW/AMD, offering substantial benefits to mining communities, environmental agencies, and society at large. For primary stakeholders, including mining operators and federal land managers, this translates to more efficient compliance with environmental regulations, reduced treatment complexity, and potential recovery of valuable critical minerals and rare earth elements from waste concentrate which aligns with U.S. strategic priorities for domestic mineral production. For surrounding communities and ecosystems, the technology promises cleaner water resources, reduced environmental contamination, and improved public health outcomes, while its mobile, modular design enables treatment in remote locations where traditional infrastructure is impractical.

Publications


    Progress 07/01/23 to 06/30/24

    Outputs
    Target Audience:The initial audience for this technology will be the U.S. Forest Service for use at abandoned mine sites on federal land. Once demonstrated, the potential audience widens to mining sites across the U.S. The issue of mining-influenced water and acid mine drainage (MIW/AMD) from closed mines hits close to home for Micronic. The company is located in the Appalachian region of Southwest Virginia, where MIW/AMD leaches into watersheds and eventually into local aquifers. Such sites have long-term health hazards to aquatic and other life requiring increasingly advanced solutions to provide optimal remediation. In the Central Appalachian coalfields near mine sites there are elevated concentrations of major chemical ions in streams, degraded water quality levels that are acutely lethal to standard laboratory test organisms, and levels of selenium concentrations which are toxic in fish and birds. These environmental water issues are the direct result of MIW/AMD at shutdown mine sites. These man-made environmental degradations are a legacy years in the making. MIW/AMD have impaired thousands of miles of streams in Appalachia, transforming them into metal-rich, acidic water and sediments which, in turn, have impaired the aquatic habitat with nutrient limitations and potentially hazardous levels of toxins. Ultimately, the potential audience for this revolutionary technology is as broad as there are uses of water. Because water is such a ubiquitous presence in everyday life, there's a temptation to consider applications far too broad for successful commercialization. Micronic is has demonstratedits validated technology can remove high concentrations of impurities from a wide range of contaminated water, but clearly understands there are numerous other technologies already in the water treatment marketplace. Rather than seek entry where other technologies and treatment infrastructures are already firmly entrenched, Micronic has carefully narrowed its target commercial entry point to very specific markets to which it is particularly well suited. It is anticipated that one viable market may be remediation of MIW/AMD and the resulting conversion of waste streams into non-traditional clean water sources. The technology canconcentrate a "waste liquid " into a concentrate by a factor 20x and hence facilitate the recovery downstream, as the volumes to be managed are reduced thus reducing operational costs. Changes/Problems: Nothing Reported What opportunities for training and professional development has the project provided? Nothing Reported How have the results been disseminated to communities of interest?At this point in the program effort, the research results have been made known to the Consultants on the Program, RTI and TRC. What do you plan to do during the next reporting period to accomplish the goals?Work to be conducted during the next reporting period includes the following. TO 2: Process and analyze samples Micronic will process and analyze the samples collected in TO 1. TO 3: Identify a preliminary Phase II demonstration system layout Micronic and TRC will complete a preliminary Phase II demonstration system layout. TO 4: Conduct market study of TOPTM technology for MIW/AMD remediation RTI will complete the Phase I market study.

    Impacts
    What was accomplished under these goals? Progress to date on the Phase I research and development effort has entailed continuing work on Technical Objectives (TO's) as follows. TO 1: The identification of mine sample sites and acquisition of wastewater samples As noted in the previous Interim Technical Report (ITR), work on this objective was led by the Consultant to the Program, TRC who has extensive experience in mine site geology and hydrology. In the last ITR, TRC was evaluating a series of possible sample sites. Each of those locations had been rejected as potential sampling sites and the search was continuing for candidate locations. During this reporting period, work on TO 1 continued to identifycandidate MIW/AMD sites. As a result of this effort, Micronic and TRC selected three sites for Phase I sample testing. TRC provided Micronic with samples from the selected sites as listed below. Sample Site 1 (Letcher County, Kentucky) 37°7'24.78"N 82°44'38.1"W 37.12355, -82.74391667 The site is located at the end of Baker Branch Road which is off of Rt. 1862, approximately 2 miles east of Mayking, KY. In March 2024, TRC personnel traveled to Letcher County, Kentucky in order to conduct a site reconnaissance and collect samples. The site was suggested by TRC's records review and conversations with the Kentucky Energy and Environment Cabinet. The site, which is a detention pond is near reclaimed coal mining activities. Temperature (15.8 C) and pH (7.73) measurements were collected as well as 15 gallons of water. All samples were collected and taken to Micronic Technologies, Inc., in Bristol, VA. Sample Site 2 (Knott County, Kentucky) 37°12'31.0"N 82°58'29.0"W 37.20861111, -82.97472222 The site is located approximately 3 miles east of Redfox, KY, south of Rt. 15 and along the eastern side of Defeated Creek Rd. In March 2024, TRC personnel traveled to Knott County, Kentucky to conduct a site reconnaissance and collect samples. The site was suggested by TRC's records review and conversations with the Kentucky Energy and Environment Cabinet. The site is near an active coal mine. Temperature (14.4 C) and pH (7.29) measurements were collected along with 15 gallons of water. The water samples were taken to Micronic Technologies, Inc. in Bristol, VA. The site is located at a detention pond adjacent to the coal yard. Sample Site 3 (Perry County, Kentucky) 37°17'3.9"N 83°30'37.00"W 37.2844444444, -83.51027778 The site is located at the end of Dusty Fork Road, west off of Rt 484, approximately 1.3 miles northwest of Saul, Perry County, KY. In March 2024, TRC personnel traveled to Perry County, Kentucky in order to conduct a site reconnaissance and collect samples. The site was suggested by TRC's records review and conversations with the Kentucky Energy and Environment Cabinet. The site is near reclaimed coal mining activities. The site consists of a detention pond. Temperature (16.2 C) and pH (2.99) measurements were collected as well as 15 gallons of water. All samples were collected and taken to Micronic Technologies, Inc., in Bristol, VA. TO 2: Process and analyze samples As reported in the previous Interim Technical Report (ITR), work which was being conducted on TO 2 was focused on upgrading the laboratory concept demonstration system in preparation for MIW/AMD sample processing. The upgrade work was completed during this reporting period including; the replacement of the original diesel engine which powered the system with an electric motor, the installation of an advanced control system tuned to the performance of the upgraded system, the installation of a ruggedized coated blower, the replacement of the air-driven water pump for the concentration tanks with an electric pump, and the design, development, fabrication, and installation of an advanced separator. TO 3: Identify a preliminary Phase II demonstration system layout During this reporting period, TRC completed site selection and sample acquisition and has begun work on TO 3, the preliminary identification of support structure and structure layout needed to implement an on-site Phase II demonstration unit. Preliminary site layout elements will include access infrastructure for influent handling(e.g., piping, holding tanks, etc.) and the handling of the clean water product and the wastewater concentrate (e.g., discharge piping, holding tanks), and the capability to transport the unit to the site. This work includes placement of the unit and support systems on a potential demonstration site map, identification of influent, clean product water, and brine tanks, associated piping, and an electrical generator. The work is currently on-going. TO 4: Conduct market study of TOPTM technology for MIW/AMD remediation During this reporting period, work continued on TO 4, a market assessment of the TOPTM technology for MIW/AMD remediation. The analysis is being conducted by Micronic Technologies in collaboration with the selected Technical and Business Assistance (TABA) vendor, RTI International Research Institute (RTI), who is developing a market study to evaluate the commercial viability of the TOPTM technology for purification of MIW/AMD. The work is currently on-going.

    Publications